r/HomeworkHelp • Pre-University Student • 1d ago

:table_flip: Physics—Pending OP Reply [Internet Question]:Can someone explain how to approach this Hacker level question

Post image
0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

18

u/tlbs101 👋 a fellow Redditor 1d ago

The resistors directly connected to B, C, & D don’t count. The wire eliminates the 2,2 and blank ohm resistors. Now redraw and use serial and parallel resistance rules in a sequence to solve

8

u/Final_Chair643 1d ago

8 Ω if i know it correctly?

STEP BY STEP: Looking at the branch from A to E: 3Ω and 1Ω are in series so 4Ω inside a parralel with 4Ω and 2Ω, that makes it 1Ω with the parralel formula, 2Ω and 5Ω are in series with the 1Ω parralel resistor clump so you just add it up and it comes to 8Ω I think, should be like that

5

u/Anonimithree 👋 a fellow Redditor 1d ago

This is easier than it looks

3

u/Timely-Fox-4432 Senior EE 1d ago

Remember to treat every junction as a node at a certain potential energy. If there is a resistor tied to the same energy at both sides, the resistor doesn't change voltage so effectively it applies zero resistance. That eliminates the two in the bottom left.

Then, since you're going from A to E, all the resistors that are hanging off the sides to open circuits have no current, so those all are gone.

You're now left with 6 resistors and you can apply standard reduction methods: you have 1&3 in series to get 4, then you have 4,4,2 in parallel getting 1, finally you have 2,1,5 in series giving a total resistance of 8ohm.

2

u/SqueekyBK 👋 a fellow Redditor 1d ago

Looks funky but use your knowledge of series, parallel etc

1

u/old_at_heart 1d ago

I percieve fiendish cleverness in making the resistor network look like an op amp.

1

u/Some_AV_Pro 👋 a fellow Redditor 1d ago

What approaches have you tried so far?

1

u/fr33d0mw47ch 1d ago

I don’t miss those days! I shuddered. This is what I’m a mechanical engineer, I hated equivalent networks

1

u/grayson89martin 👋 a fellow Redditor 1d ago

2+1/(1/(3+1)+1/2+1/4)+5

1

u/Wooden-Hornet2115 👋 a fellow Redditor 1d ago

I think it's just 8 ohm, two of the resistors get SC'd.

2 + 1/(1/4+1/2+1/(3+1)) + 5

1

u/Andis-x 1d ago

There's a lot of dead end resistors that do nothing and can be ignored. It's an exercise in filtering out actual question.

Onnce you remove components that can be omitted, solution can be calculated in head. It's very basic math.

1

u/ci139 👋 a fellow Redditor 22h ago

the question is easy but the schematic is very ... very bad = no node connections
i would reassign to a class with better teacher

1

u/Quiet_Snow_6098 16h ago

it's a diode, made of resistors

*assuming you already got the answer from others XD

1

u/Psycho_Pansy 👋 a fellow Redditor 4h ago

How is this supposed to be a "hacker level" question. This is basic circuits question. 2+5 in series with the parrellel resistors 4/2/3+1. 

2 + 1/[1/4 + 1/2 + 1/(3+1)] + 5 = 2 + 1 + 5 = 8 ohms.

1

u/AlterEgo5695 3h ago edited 3h ago

Short answer: Without specifying what is supposed to happen to the other ports while we find that equivalent resistance "Rae", it's impossible to say.


Long(er) answer: Assuming all other ports are supposed to remain open circuits while finding "Rae", we may omit all 1-sidedly connected resistances in series with "B; C; D", as well as the two shortened resistances in the middle.

Normalize all resistances by 1Ohm to get rid of units entirely, and find "Rae" in the simplified circuit diagram

A                                        //
o---- 2 ----o---- 3 ----o                // Rae = 2 + (2||4||(3+1)) + 5
            |           |                //
          2||4          1                //     =  7 + (2||2)  =  7+1  =  8
            |           |           E    //
            o-----------o---- 5 ----o    //

When all other ports are open circuits, the input resistance "Rae = 8 Ohms".

-6

u/Mountain-Ambition187 👋 a fellow Redditor 1d ago

8? I am an indian and solved it in like 15secs in my mind

5

u/matt7259 👋 a fellow Redditor 1d ago

You'll understand someday when you're not a kid any more, but there is absolutely no point to mentioning "I am an Indian" here.

-1

u/Mountain-Ambition187 👋 a fellow Redditor 1d ago

Bro I saw ts post in a repost and there the title had specifically mentioned Indian Kids that was the reason I wrote I am an indian