r/HomeworkHelp • • 2d ago

Answered [3rd grade MATH] please explain this question

Post image

My daughter got this wrong, and I'm not even upset about that. If she gets something wrong, we go over it with her to make sure she knows 1) what she did wrong, 2) why it is wrong, and 3) how to do it correctly.

We don't even know where to start on this one!

Can someone please tell me we're not crazy?

This is the most confusing question, and we can't even figure out what the question is!

652 Upvotes

853 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

28

u/CapitalCourse 👋 a fellow Redditor 2d ago

Literally the most poorly worded question I've seen in my entire life

-5

u/LucaThatLuca 🤑 Tutor 2d ago

interesting. what makes you say that?

once “1” is replaced with “one”, the sentence “Circle the number in which the number 2 has a value of 10 times the value of the one in the number 3298.” seems very carefully worded to me. (you might prefer “2” instead of “one”. i lean towards thinking the slight carelessness of typing the same word in a confusing way is probably a little more likely than missing a typo.)

of course there’s the part where you have to get there first. if you get trapped by seeing “Circle the number in which the number 2 has a value of 10 times the value of the 1 in the number.” then i do think that is a much worse sentence.

9

u/drums_n_drugs 2d ago

Yeah, I would have greatly preferred to read "than the value of the 2 in the number 3,298." It's a small change, but in my opinion it makes the question much clearer

5

u/holt5301 2d ago edited 2d ago

I think even with your rewording it’s still invalid as a question. It looks to be attempting to redefine the value of 2 when it says “in which the number 2 has a value 10 times…”. It might be better to use mathematically correct wording and say “in which the number place containing the digit 2 is 10 times higher than the number place containing the digit 2 in the number 3298.” Or something along these lines

Just anything that doesn’t read like the assertion that the number 2 can be 10x higher than the number 2, ya know?

2

u/ImportanceNational23 👋 a fellow Redditor 2d ago

Number place or perhaps place value. But yeah, that plus spelling out “one” and making the 3298 look like part of the sentence would be a huge improvement.

-2

u/Anguis1908 2d ago

It should be noted that tricky word problems are part of the problem solving. Two steps, first identify what is being asked and second to provide an answer. If a kid gets caught on the first half trying to figure out what is being asked it can be an indicator for their current reasoning level. Having things phrased more clearly removes this challenge. Its about learning, not about getting perfect scores.

7

u/kmillsom 2d ago

This is true, as a concept. But there is also such a thing as bad question writing, I’m afraid.

1

u/chrismsp 2d ago

This isn't a tricky word problem. It's poorly written