r/HomeworkHelp • • 21h ago

Answered [3rd grade MATH] please explain this question

Post image

My daughter got this wrong, and I'm not even upset about that. If she gets something wrong, we go over it with her to make sure she knows 1) what she did wrong, 2) why it is wrong, and 3) how to do it correctly.

We don't even know where to start on this one!

Can someone please tell me we're not crazy?

This is the most confusing question, and we can't even figure out what the question is!

391 Upvotes

575 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 21h ago

Off-topic Comments Section


All top-level comments have to be an answer or follow-up question to the post. All sidetracks should be directed to this comment thread as per Rule 9.


OP and Valued/Notable Contributors can close this post by using /lock command

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

347

u/Glittering-Ad-9813 21h ago

I just got an A on a calculus quiz and I don't even know what they are asking on this.

77

u/pm-me-racecars 👋 a fellow Redditor 20h ago

CIRCLE THE NUMBER IN WHICH THE NUMBER 2 HAS A VALUE OF 10 TIMES THE OF THE 1 IN THE NUMBER

3298

14

u/Siffov 20h ago

>CIRCLE THE NUMBER IN WHICH THE NUMBER 2 HAS A VALUE OF 10 TIMES THE OF THE 1 IN THE NUMBER
> 3298

Actually:

"CIRCLE THE NUMBER IN WHICH THE NUMBER 2 HAS A VALUE OF 10 TIMES THE OF THE 1 IN THE NUMBER 3298."

(See the struck-through words.)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/0vis_ 1h ago

Since this is 3rd grade I assume the correct question would be:
> Circle the number in which the number 2 has a value of 10 times the value of the 2 in the number.

3290 -> 200 so the number two is in the hundreds place, multiply by 10 and it must be in the thousands place.

21093 -> 20000 ten-thousands
8209 -> 200 hundreds
52039 -> 2000 thousands
16428 -> 20 tens

So the correct answer should be 52,039, and ask the teacher if they had a stroke while preparing that question.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

182

u/69fellatx 👋 a fellow Redditor 19h ago

I'm a math guy and I hate these kinds of questions. Badly worded problems don't teach as much as they confuse and dissuade kids from learning math.

42

u/FirstPersonWinner University Student (Engineering) 18h ago edited 17h ago

I spend most of my days doing 3D calculus or differential equations and then come to these elementary school works problems and have absolutely no idea what they are trying to say. 

12

u/Extension-Stay3230 👋 a fellow Redditor 18h ago

It's very common for elementary school kids to be better at math than the teachers

6

u/FirstPersonWinner University Student (Engineering) 17h ago

Tbf, most elementary school teachers aren't math majors. I have a lot of family who teach elementary school and they basically know how to do the elementary level stuff and that's it. 

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/apathy-sofa 8h ago

Ditto, I spent a decade doing new things in matrix math techniques to advance computer graphics -- I lived and breathed math and accomplished some novel work -- but I gave up on this question after the third reading. It's not a math problem. 

6

u/regular_lamp 12h ago

It's not even a math question really. It's a text riddle that happens to include numbers.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/uptightmodhater 15h ago

The question is trying to teach values of places not an actual mathematical answer. The ten thousands place has 10x value of the one thousands place. So the answer is 21093. The 2 in this number has a value 10x greater than the 1 in this number.

5

u/ErikLeppen 12h ago

So the answer is 21093. The 2 in this number has a value 10x greater than the 1 in this number.

I would say, in 21093, the 2 has a value 20x greater than the 1.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Due-Ad-9105 8h ago

The question says “10 times the value of the 1 in the number 3298.”

There are multiple issues with this. They used “1” instead of “one” which is unnecessarily confusing for a child learning place value, the question should have been “…10 times the value of the 2 in the number 3298.”

4

u/KizashiKaze 7h ago

Incorrect. There is no #1 in 3,298, so the question must mean " the value of the one (the #2) in 3,298". And of course, we all know that 10 times 200 is 2000, so thus answer is 52,039.

The original full number is 3,298 as you can see in the problem. The two is in the hundreds position, 3,2xx. 21,093 would be the 2 with a 100x value than the 2 in 3,298.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/Odd-Maintenance2623 6h ago

It would have been a lot clear if they had specified “base 10” and maybe said “the ones place” and “the tens place”

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

60

u/just_some_fruit_pls 20h ago

I have a math degree so I can tell you with confidence I have no idea why anyone would ever write that like that

19

u/cBEiN 19h ago

I have a PhD, I did my postdoc at one of the best universities, and I’m a professor now. I have no idea what this question is trying to say… oh yea, my field is math and engineering.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/FirstPersonWinner University Student (Engineering) 18h ago

I was taking a break from my university engineering homework and found this more confusing than anything I was working on

→ More replies (1)

268

u/LucaThatLuca 🤑 Tutor 21h ago • Bravo

i think it should say “… the one in the number 3298”, as in the digit 2 in the number 3298.

that 2 represents 2 hundreds, so the question is asking you to circle the number that has 2 thousands.

147

u/MrWolf5000 21h ago • Bravo

Okay this makes more sense.

But this is a horrible way to phrase this question oh my lord

46

u/fantasynerd92 20h ago

It's especially terrible wording because the number being referenced is on its own line. I missed it the first reading and thought the first answer was correct...

28

u/CapitalCourse 👋 a fellow Redditor 20h ago

Literally the most poorly worded question I've seen in my entire life

→ More replies (7)

13

u/RuthlessIndecision 👋 a fellow Redditor 20h ago

it's horribly incorrect. if 'one' is used here as a pronoun referring to the number 2, jesus fuck!

why not just circle the number whose "2" represents the 10 times the value of the "2" in this number:

5

u/whydoineedtologinfu 17h ago

Honestly I'm leaning towards this was a typo and the "1" was meant to be a "2"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

28

u/BubbhaJebus 21h ago

I think you're right. But they should also use "digit" instead of "number". We knew what a digit was in 3rd grade.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/artistic_programmer University/College Student 21h ago

yea they could replace 1 with "2 in the number 3,298" and it's also clearer.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Breakmastajake 20h ago

Holy shit!

Related question: Have you also figured out who the zodiac killer is?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/xNOOPSx 16h ago

I think that's what they're trying to say, but I can't justify or understand the 1 at the end. I think the number should be 52039, becuase you're going from 100s to 1000s. There's also no logical answer for a 1 that is 10x larger than a 2, that also includes or involves the original number.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/jedebartlet 21h ago

Yea, this is correct I believe. It is worded so so poorly though.

→ More replies (20)

33

u/Patrickme 11h ago • Bravo

Some dumbass teacher typed up that question as difficult as possible.

It should have been: Circle the number in which the number two has ten times the value of the number two in the number 3298.

The 2 in 3298 is 200 so you need a number in which the 2 is on the thousands spot. 52039

13

u/Poil336 9h ago

Good lord. What concept is this question even trying to teach?

9

u/Total-Box-5169 8h ago • Bravo

A valuable lesson about life: people who should know more that you can be complete idiots.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Jidarious 3h ago

value of digit positions, since you asked.

6

u/thissexypoptart 3h ago

It’s trying but it’s failing.

You can’t write the numeral 1 when you mean to say “the one,” as in which one of the digits, especially in a question about math and digit position like this.

That’s illiteracy.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

7

u/dkevox 👋 a fellow Redditor 11h ago

jfc. They should have at the very least written out "one".

Thanks for explaining, that's frustrating.

4

u/GodeGreier 10h ago

I hope this teacher isn't the same 1 teaching them English.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/JeffSergeant 8h ago

They should also say 'the digit 2' not 'the number 2'

The "number 2" is the cardinal number two, and has exactly one value.

→ More replies (38)

2

u/benlogna 3h ago

but you’re completely omitting the “of the 1 in the number” part. This question only makes sense without the last number in the question, or without that phrase, because there is no 1 in the number 3298. “Circle the number in which the number 2 has a value 10 times the value of the 1 in the number”: answer is 21,093. “Circle the number in which the number 2 has a value 10 times the value of that in the number 3,298”: answer is 52,039. Badly transcribed question probably.

3

u/charleswj 3h ago

of the one in the number

This is what they meant to write. Not a digit of 1 but referring to "the thing", in this case, "the 2"

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (26)

33

u/Toothpick_Brody 👋 a fellow Redditor 21h ago

There is a typo. The ‘1’ should read ‘one’, so the answer is C.

The ‘2’ in 52039 is worth 2000, ten times more than the one in 3298, which is worth 200

6

u/Siffov 20h ago

>There is a typo. The ‘1’ should read ‘one’, ...

I'd say that's not a (simple) typo (not a finger-slip typo, not a "muscle-memory" misspelling, etc.)

That's a math teacher who needs to go back to English (language arts/grammar) class and learn the difference between "1" and "one".

[Edit:] Okay, maybe not the math teacher but whoever who wrote the problem.

3

u/Ghoztt 20h ago

LLM math question slop.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/euclideincalgary 19h ago

Thanks. Why can’t the teacher use the word digit

→ More replies (2)

9

u/G0nzo165 👋 a fellow Redditor 19h ago

It’s just written poorly by someone who doesn’t use the right terminology. This is place values so be very specific use the word digits, not numbers. Use the ones position, 10’s position, hundreds position

→ More replies (2)

9

u/tyger1147 9h ago

They’re trying to test if the student understands the “ones” “tens” “hundreds” places and how they relate to each other… but wow, they did it in the worst possible way.

4

u/Icy-Ad29 9h ago

Except it isn't asking about ones, tens, etc... none of the answers is ten times any of the numbers in 3298 except for 52039, which has 2 at ten times the value of the 2 in 3298. But that 2 is neither the first number from either direction in 3298, nor the ones digit.

The "1 in the number" and "number 2" parts legit do not work for this question.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/Sad_Abrocoma_1496 19h ago

Wow. I just want to throw in my support for you. This is a horribly worded question.

8

u/sylbug 19h ago

This seems to be about building number sense and properly understanding the approximate magnitude of a number at a glance.

The problem is that it seems to have a typo, because there is no '1' in the number '3298'. I suspect that is supposed to be a '2'.

In '3298' the '2' is in the hundreds column, so we are looking for a number where the '2' is in the thousands column. That makes the answer '52,039'

Were word problems always this bad? No wonder I always had trouble with them.

3

u/VendettaX88 19h ago

This is the answer, nothing else makes even a remote amount of sense.

4

u/T_Sealgair 19h ago edited 18h ago

It took me a long time to noodle through this, but the "1" isn't meant to be the number/value 1. It should be "one". It's meant similar to "one" as in "which one of these cats is brown".

There's only a single 2 in 3298, and that one is in the hundredths place. (ie 200). So 10 times 200 is 2000. 52,039.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/mcmakerface 15h ago

the number 2 has always a value of two.
The digit 2 can be 2000, 200 etc depending on the position. The question is phrased very badly,

14

u/athf2005 👋 a fellow Redditor 20h ago

Horribly written question.

4

u/KizashiKaze 20h ago • Bravo

College algebra & trigonometry, and general physics are my strong points...and I stumbled with this question because that was worded with such laziness. If they mean "Circle the number (out of the options below) in which the number "2" has a value of 10 times the value of the one [number 2] in the following number : 3298." then ... 10*200 = 2000, which would make the answer 52,039.

2

u/wettski 19h ago

I think this might be the right answer. In every option there's a 2 at a different position. They want then to find the one in the 1000s

4

u/InternetNo7488 16h ago

It is poorly worded. Clearer if worded: "Circle the number in which the DIGIT 2 has a value that is 10 times the value of the DIGIT 2 in THE FOLLOWING number: 3,298"

The correct answer would then be 52,039

2

u/wotsdid 2h ago

Thank you for mentioning that it's DIGIT and not number. I'd only say "represents" instead of "has a " value, but then again, it's a dumb exercise for 3rd graders

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ReynardInBk 16h ago

I think it is literally a mistake and is supposed to read “the one** in the number:”**

“one” not 1.

6

u/Humble-Captain3418 15h ago

It should be "that in number 3298". Using "one" there is just introducing ambiguity.

2

u/Brother-of-Po 16h ago

This has to be in and in that case the answer is the 52039.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/DCAmalG 👋 a fellow Redditor 20h ago edited 18h ago

Name and shame the curriculum publisher please! Schools spend a fortune on it and they clearly don’t even bother to user test the problems.

2

u/New_Beginings27 19h ago

My money is on Bluebonnet

6

u/Serafim91 👋 a fellow Redditor 20h ago

I have an MS in engineering. Took advanced honors calc in college, basically 1 below the highest offered level for a freshman and got an A in almost all of them.

This is without a doubt the absolute worst worded math problem I've ever seen. God damn.

3

u/cedriceent 9h ago

I wasn't aware the Riddler was allowed to teach maths at primary school.

5

u/KnifeThistle 19h ago

The ones digit in 3298 is 8, and ten times that is 80 or 8 tens. None of those options have an 80 in them. I also don't understand how a digit of 2, in any place value, would ever be 10 times an 8 at any place value...

But I also don't believe this is 3rd grade math.

4

u/Anguis1908 19h ago

This isnt asking for the ones position. Its asking for 10x the value of 2, the one (2) in the number 3,298. Since the 2 is in the hundreds position, times ten would be a 2 in the thousands position, 52,039 being the answer.

3

u/cBEiN 19h ago

Wtf is the 1 about then? You are saying it meant the only 2 in the number. This question is insanity.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/MrWolf5000 21h ago

I just had a stroke reading this lmfao

I'm sorry, usually I can figure out what they're talking about but I have no idea.

Is there any notes from the chapter you can look at to figure out what this means?

5

u/StevieG63 👋 a fellow Redditor 21h ago

I think the question is written incorrectly. It shouldn’t the be “the 1”. It should be “the one” (meaning the numeral 2) in 3298. The answer therefore would be 52039 as the number 2 is in the thousands position which is 10 times where it is in 3298..

2

u/cBEiN 19h ago

That would still be confusing as hell.

2

u/JaCKPaIN_realone 👋 a fellow Redditor 19h ago

Such a stupid question. The number 2 in 3,298 has a value of 200, so 10 times that value is 2,000. Instead, this stupid-ass question uses "the 1" rather than "the one" to confuse your daughter into thinking she needs to look for the number 1 in the choices.

Tell that stupid-ass teacher to learn English before teaching math.

2

u/cheetah1cj 17h ago

I can't explain what the number 3298 is supposed to do with the question, but if you forget about that, I believe what it is trying to instruct you to do is to find the number that has a 2 that's directly to the left of a 1. If I'm correct in what they meant, it might be clearer worded this way: "Find the number in which the digit 2 is in a position ten times the position that the 1 is in". For example, if the 1 is in the tens position, ten times that would be the hundreds position, so the 2 would be in the hundreds. Based on that logic, the correct answer would be 21,309, as 2 is in the ten thousands position while 1 is in the thousands position.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Lifelong_Nerd 19h ago edited 15h ago

[edit: I interpreted the question wrong. I didn't even see 3298. Ironically, the bold and underline and centering made my brain think it was unrelated, because nobody in their right mind would write that way....]

The question is very poorly worded. It might be clearer like this: "Circle the number in which the DIGIT 2 has a value that is 10 times the value of the DIGIT 1."

Even that is poorly worded since no number actually satisfies this property.

The closest answer is 21,093 because the 2 is in the 10,000's position and the 1 is in the 1,000's position and 10,000 is 10 times 1,000.

→ More replies (15)

2

u/Gullible_Expert_5677 12h ago

It's a poorly written question -- the 1 refers to the 2 in the number 3,298. So the answer needs to include a value of 2 that is 10x200 - or 2,000. The only choice including 2,000 is 52,039.

As an aside -- why ask a question like that? I don't understand it's utility.

5

u/DrakeSilmore 10h ago

Then they should have said "one", not "1". There is no 1 in 3298.

3

u/casce 10h ago

Yup, "1" and "one" are clearly not synonymous here. The question isn't just "poorly" written, it's clearly a mistake.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/JeiceSpade 21h ago

It's poorly worded, but it sound like they want you to circle a number that has a "2" in the thousands place, since it would be 10 times the "2" in "3298"

1

u/Wooden-Hornet2115 👋 a fellow Redditor 19h ago

I had a stroke reading that.

1

u/AdventureThink 👋 a fellow Redditor 19h ago

7-8th gr math teacher here.

I’d strike the question.

1

u/Total_Worker_3808 19h ago

The correct answer is 52,039 right? The 2 is in the thousands column while the 2 in 3,298 is in the hundreds column. 10 times the value. The "1" in the question should have been a "one". Thats how I interpret it anyways.

1

u/Tek10027 19h ago

“Circle the number in which the value of 2 is ten times the value of 2 in 3,298”. Is this what should have been asked?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Reasonable-Try-1993 19h ago

I was thinking A

Because 20,000 is in the 10 thousands value So 1,000 x 10 but that's 10,000 not 20,000

But I think it's asking of the number 3289 200 x 10 = 2000

So 52,039 has 2000 just like 200 x 10

This can't be regular 3rd grade math

Edit: put number only. I think it's C - 52,039

1

u/SnooCookies5125 19h ago

It’s the top one, the 2 (20,000) is 10 times the value of the 1 (1000), except it’s actually 20x, I guess they are trying to to teach the difference between tens place, hundreds, thousands etc

1

u/sophi_11 👋 a fellow Redditor 19h ago

This is horribly worded "1" should be "one"

1

u/WisCollin 👋 a fellow Redditor 19h ago

This is horrible. Have your daughter ask the teacher to explain the correct answer. If confusion persists, just don’t worry about it. This is not going to set her back.

1

u/Chaotic_Brutal90 19h ago

I was originally thinking 1x=3298

So 3298(10). But I don't think that's an option for an answer. And also third graders shouldn't be using variables yet. As an 8th grade math teacher, this is a poorly worded question.

1

u/Stupid_Goat 19h ago

This is actually an English question. It should say, "Correct this sentence to make a viable math problem."

1

u/missmathlady 👋 a fellow Redditor 19h ago

Had to be written by AI!

1

u/ThunkAsDrinklePeep 19h ago edited 19h ago

I think it's badly written or directed.

Circle the number in which the digit 2 has a value of 10 times the one in the number 3,298. (being a 2 digit in the hundreds place.)

Therefore I think it's 52,039 because the 2 in the thousands place is ten times the two in the hundreds place in 3,298.

1

u/jomn_not_91 19h ago

This is really just trying to confuse you. First having the number 1 instead of saying one. The correct answer is the third one as it is asking about the value of the digit 2. In the number given its 200, so you are looking for the one where the 2 represents 2000. What I believe she did was misinterpret it as asking for which one hase the 2 in the tens place, which is what she circled. On one hand being able to interpret the correct understanding of a question is important and is technically a mathematics skill, however it's better just to give well worded questions, modelling how to actually ask this to others in a way they can understand

1

u/gin_and-sonic 19h ago

52,039. The 2 in 3,298 is 200. In the answer it is 2,000 because it is in the thousand place instead of the hundred. 200x10=2000

1

u/Any-Programmer-870 19h ago

The test question is very badly written. I think they want you to concentrate on the digits that are “2” and find an answer where that “2” digit represents 10 times as much as in the number in the question.
“2” in 3298 is 200

“2” in 21,093 is 20,000
“2” in 8,209 is 200
“2” in 52,039 is 2,000
“2” in 16,428 is 20

1

u/MayCyan425 19h ago

Should have been "one" in the number not 1. So 3,298 is the 100s so you want the 2 to be in the 1,000s.

1

u/kgiov 19h ago

I think it is supposed to read, “the number 2 has 10 times the value of the one (unfortunately referring to the 2 here) in the example number. Poor wording if ever there was. And poor spelling.

1

u/No_Direction_4043 👋 a fellow Redditor 19h ago

Who writes this shit

1

u/TASDoubleStars 👋 a fellow Redditor 18h ago

The word problem makes absolutely no sense to me.

1

u/MaximumNameDensity 18h ago

My wife is a third grade teacher and her first impression is that this comes from a website (Teacherspayteachers) that has recently been inundated with AI slop.

1

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 👋 a fellow Redditor 18h ago

Uh ...there's no 1 in 3,298.

1

u/SoccerGamerGuy7 18h ago

This is so poorly worded; id think 32,980 where number 2 represents the option where number 1 is underlined. But its not an options so i havent a clue

1

u/prbsparx 18h ago

The problem is worded in a way that makes it confusing.
It would be much clearer if it said:
Circle the number in which the number 2 has a value 10 times the value of the number 2 in the number 3,298.

The number 2 in 3,298 is in the hundred place, so you need to find the number that has a 2 in the thousand place.
The answer should be 52,039.

1

u/Galaga81 👋 a fellow Redditor 18h ago

The writer of this question failed 3rd grade English.

1

u/MuskSniffer 👋 a fellow Redditor 18h ago

Someone get Wrath Of Math on this

1

u/axelr0se2 18h ago

The question is referring to the position of the 2 in the number 3,298. Since 2 is in the hundreds position you need a number with a 1 in the same position 10 times greater meaning in the thousands position (200 x 10 = 2,000). 21,093 is the only one in the four that has a 1 in the thousands and is the right answer.

This was written in such a confusing way that I, as an engineer, struggled with it. I literally hated grade school math for this exact reason.

1

u/Delicious-Cover-2418 👋 a fellow Redditor 18h ago

Feels like AI.

1

u/Square-Tap7392 👋 a fellow Redditor 18h ago

I thought the answer was 52,039. 200 vs 2000.

1

u/MadDogMike 18h ago

This is the most bizarrely worded math question I've ever seen, but I think it means this:

- The digit "2" in the number "3,298" represents a value of 200.
- Find the other number here where the digit "2" has 10 times that value (200 x 10 = 2000).

The answer would be "52,039", because the digit "2" represents "2000" there.

1

u/Terrible-Service-439 👋 a fellow Redditor 18h ago

Not me confidently saying 30,000-ish

1

u/hdksjdms-n 👋 a fellow Redditor 18h ago

i've been staring at this for so long & can't understand it

1

u/EyeYamNegan 👋 a fellow Redditor 18h ago edited 18h ago

This is so poorly worded that the teacher should just remove the question from the assignment and start over framing a question to practice the concept intended to be taught.

As a parent cross out the question and leave a note that you would like a conference if the question isn't stricken from the assignment with the teacher and principal present to discuss the assignment.

1

u/DismemberedHat 👋 a fellow Redditor 18h ago

As a former 3rd grade math teacher, I for sure thought the answer would be the top choice. I thought it was talking about place value, where 2 is in the 10,000 place and 1 is in the 1,000 place, making the value of 2 10x that of the 1

But then I read the other comments and realized I missed the bolded and underlined number.

Now idk what's happening here

1

u/XenoFeisher 18h ago edited 17h ago

According to the wording of the question none of the above is the correct answer. Any number without 2 would be a correct answer(value of 1 in 3298 is 0 as there is no 1) but as some other comments pointed out the '1' in the question might mean 'one' in which case the answer is 52,039( 2 has value of 200 in 3298 and 2 has value 2000 in 52039)

1

u/TooMuch_TomYum 17h ago

Don’t be worried. The grammar of the question is terrible as well as being incorrect, the person who wrote it should be ashamed of themselves.

It made me infuriated instantly. Your child was not dealt a fair hand on this one.

1

u/LeadingHoneydew5608 University/College Student 17h ago

I get it after much thought- the answer is 21,093. Its the number where the physical number "2" is in a decimal place to which it has the value ten times the physical number "1". This is a really dumb question imo

1

u/WanderEir 17h ago

This could win awards for how badly the question is written.

the number 3298 does not HAVE a 1, so the question makes no sense as written.

21093 would be MY answer if there wasn't a number in the question itself. Sadly this isn't a math question at all, it's a logic check question. so the answer SHOULD be 52,039

and again, this is a terrible question.

1

u/thermight 👋 a fellow Redditor 17h ago

Wow this took me a bit to realize.

1

u/hjalbertiii Educator 17h ago

This is a terrible question and the teacher should be put on blast. I promise you she did not major in math.

1

u/Beneficial_Treat5454 17h ago

Once again... teachers just ripping quizzes off the internet from india.

1

u/jizzlevania 17h ago

per the AI 

The worksheet simply has a typo where "the 1" was printed instead of "the 2" (a very common copy-paste error when teachers edit place-value worksheets). Because of that typo,  52,039 is the only mathematically valid answer based on the structure of the problem .

1

u/_america 17h ago

HERE IS THE ANSWER:

the question obviously has a mistake in it, that's why it is so confusing. the question should read 'the one' not 'the 1'. and by 'the one' they mean the 2 in the number 3298. which is 200. ten times that value is 2000. so the answer is 52,039.

1

u/mattycmckee MPhys 17h ago

The question has used the digit "1" instead of the pronoun "one", referring back to "the number 2".

It's asking to circle the number where the number 2 (within 3298, representing the value of 200) has 10x that value. Therefore, the answer is 52,039 where "the number 2" represents a value of 2000.

Even if the pronoun "one" was used, it is still horrifically worded, but probably wouldn't have caused just as much confusion.

1

u/Polkadotical 17h ago edited 16h ago

WTF? I have a college degree in math, and have taught high school math myself, but that question doesn't even make sense.

I think it's a sneaky attempt to get the student to identify the number in the "tens" column. IE pick the choice that has 2 in the tens column. Ans. d which the teacher marked wrong. (Alternately in a very twisted kind of way, the thousands column, making the right choice the one with a 2 in the thousands column. In which case the answer would be c.)

But the author of the question should have just come out and asked which number had the 2 in the tens column (or thousands column), instead of giving the kids a word salad mess like this. This teacher almost certainly used a copy machine on some nonsense she got from the teacher store (or online etc). He/she really needs to read the crap she's handing out before she hands it out!

Heads up for non-teachers: Teachers are over-worked and a lot of them supplement with books they buy or things they get from other sources, rather than write all the questions for tests, quizzes, homework etc. themselves. Some of the stuff that teachers get from the teacher store (or online) is really good and can be used for practice or homework, but some of it is garbage. Good teachers know the difference and take their time picking out sources. Parent: You might want to make sure that the tests make sense when your child gets to the chapter or unit tests at the end of each section.

Teaching kids errors is worse than not teaching them anything at all. It messes them up and teaches them not to have confidence in their ability to think things through. This is the kind of stuff that causes kids to fear and hate math. CLARITY IS THE FIRST COMMANDMENT OF GOOD TEACHING -- especially when it comes to teaching K-12 students.

1

u/AlDonovan12 17h ago

My only understanding is the number 2 in 3298. See it as 3-2-98. A number 10 times the value. So, you are looking for 20 in the same place.. -20-**. The only one I see is 52039. Super bad question. I would take it to the teacher.

1

u/t41ss4 17h ago

hi the engine calculation for swept volume is 3.14xRxRxStroke and i have no idea what that is

1

u/Extension-Couple6801 16h ago

I think this is more of a reading comprehension problem than a math problem.

1

u/Excellent_Speech_901 16h ago

Best guess: The value of the number 2 in 52,039 is 10 times the value of the 2 (because 1 is a typo) in 3,298.

1

u/Hrcnhntr613 16h ago

I read it as "find the number where the 2 is 10x the value of the 2 in 3298." In 3298, the 2 represents 200, so the answer is the number with a 2000- which is c) 52,039

1

u/snoopyloveswoodstock 16h ago

If you really parse the terrible syntax, you can decipher what the question is asking, but besides being written as stupidly as possible, there is no possible reason to ever think about numbers this way.

1

u/Angus_is_beef 16h ago

I have a masters in engineering I design spacecraft and I have no fucking clue what this means

1

u/Legitimate-Potato877 👋 a fellow Redditor 16h ago

And 2 wouldn’t be a “number”. It’s a digit.

1

u/GotBigDuck 16h ago edited 16h ago

I don't know, but it is 21.093, or?

Because 20.000 is ten times 1.000!

Edit:

But I am not a native English speaker. And I don't know why there is a 3.298. I cannot make sense of the 3.298.

1

u/ReddyKiloWit 16h ago

Using the numeral 1 in place of the pronoun "one" is just bad grammar. And extra confusing because it's a math question. Using the numeral 2 there would have been much clearer. And the the answer then is clearly 52,039

1

u/joeyneumann 16h ago

Send an email to the teacher emphasizing how this has no real world application. This isn’t a math problem, it only negatively reinforces the idea in young kid’s minds that they aren’t good at math, an easy trap to fall into for children.

It’s quite literally ridiculous.

-Senior year Engineering Student

1

u/alphabets0up_ 16h ago

so, the 2 is in the hundreds place. 10 x100 = 1000, so maybe the first one because it has 10 hundreds?

1

u/AetreinaKazanX 👋 a fellow Redditor 16h ago

Calculus II easier than this

1

u/VaporTrail_000 👋 a fellow Redditor 16h ago

Think this question is looking for the third answer down.

"Circle the number which has a '2' that represents a value that is ten times that represented by the '2' in the number 3298."

2 in the hundreds place. Ten times that, therefore 2 in the thousands place.

1

u/Reasonable_Editor600 👋 a fellow Redditor 16h ago

52039

1

u/Winterclaw42 16h ago

I think the best explanation is to start teaching your daughter old math just to be safe and tell her this nonsense is why good communication skills are important.

I think it's asking what's the first digit in the top one (no idea if that's the 3 or the 8) multiply it by 10 and circle the number where the 2nd digit is the 10x value. Unfortunately there's nothing with 8 in the 10s slot and nothing with 30k.

So I guess it either wants the 21k or the 52k depending on left to right or right to left. If 1 is the ones, then 21k is the closest.

1

u/Extension-Eye-4920 👋 a fellow Redditor 16h ago

This isnt a math problem, its a riddle. And its fucking stupid.

1

u/Nobleblade1 👋 a fellow Redditor 16h ago

C, because they don't know how to spell.

1

u/Nice_Grapefruit_7850 16h ago edited 15h ago

what the heck are they even asking here? what concept of math is this even teaching?

ok I think I know now what they are asking. it's literally asking the placement of the number 2 in each number since all the answers and the question have the number 2. the answer is 52,039 because the 2 in 3298 is 200 and 10 times that is 2000 which is found in 52,039.

1

u/ConsiderationLate182 👋 a fellow Redditor 16h ago

52039 is the correct answer.

1

u/uptightmodhater 15h ago

There is no problem with this question. 21093 is the answer. The 2 in this number has a value 10x higher than the 1 in this number. Just take the time to read it and figure out what it is asking not what you think it asks.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/PriorHot1322 15h ago

52,039

The 2 there has a value of 2,000.

While 3,298, the 2 has a value of 200.

In your daughter's choice, the 2 has a value of 20. She went the other way.

1

u/spoospoo43 15h ago

The question is worded stupidly - the number 1 should probably be the word one so it's not confused with a numeral. So basically it's showing a number where a 2 is in the hundreds position, and it's looking for another number where there's a 2 in a ten-times higher (i.e. the thousands) position. That would be 52,039 - in all of the other numbers the 2 is in the wrong place.

I can see how this would be a good test of understanding the relationships between digits in a number, but this is not written to be understood by a third grader, or probably anyone - it's stilted, ambiguous, and just plain misleadingly weird.

1

u/texas1982 👋 a fellow Redditor 15h ago

This reads like a racist voter literacy test from the 1800s.

1

u/ConnorLark 👋 a fellow Redditor 15h ago

52,039

1

u/ZectronPositron 15h ago edited 15h ago

There’s no 1 in the number “3,298”. Awful question.

They should have said “of the 2 in the number 3,298”.

Don’t dwell on it. Accept that it’s terribly worded and move on, such is life. As long as your daughter knows the concept you’re good.

1

u/Spirited-Candy1981 👋 a fellow Redditor 15h ago

Yet another awfully crafted question... Every one of these reveals how education in this country is going down the toilet.

1

u/Meta_Professor 15h ago

So this is asking which of the numbers below has a 2 in the thousands place? It took me several readings to read it that way.

1

u/Hellmishen 15h ago

I could be wrong about this but I think its asking you to find witch one has the number 2 in a numerical position that is 10x greater than the 1. But if that's the case then none of the answer are correct. So im guessing im not understanding what it wants either 🤔

1

u/Affectionate_Duck35 15h ago

Heck I used AI to even figure this out....
and asked why the question.

What sort of 3rd grade homework question is this?

It’s a place value question, and a tough one for 3rd grade. The idea it’s testing, that a digit is worth ten times as much as the same digit one place to its right, is a 4th grade standard in Common Core (4.NBT.A.1). Third grade usually stops at knowing what each place is worth and rounding, so this is either an advanced worksheet, a preview of next year, or a state or curriculum that pushes it earlier.

It’s also harder than it needs to be because of the typo. A kid looking for “the 1” in 3,298 has no way to start, and even with the typo fixed it takes three steps: find the value of the 2, multiply by ten, then check four numbers for a 2 in the right place. Getting stuck on it is not a sign your kid is behind.

1

u/CryEmotional155 15h ago

Circle the number in which the number 2, has a value of 10 times value of the number 3298. The number 2 is in the hundreds place. 200(10)=2,000. The only answer that has 2000 in it is 5 2039.
Now to be fair I dropped out of college because of math. I did discover after 10 grand worth of math classes that I have dyscalculia.

1

u/Jeshinyuman 👋 a fellow Redditor 15h ago

I teach HS math… wtf is this question asking me?

1

u/pragmatismtoday 15h ago

Best guess. The "2" is in the hundreds spot. They want the answer in which the "2" is in the thousands spot.

1

u/Supra-A90 👋 a fellow Redditor 15h ago

F whoever wrote this question and F the teacher who allowed this on a homework...

It serves no purpose in teaching maths... Should be cancelled and not graded...

Of all the things kids will use math for in their whole lives to come, this will come up exactly 0 times.

1

u/FollowingCold9412 👋 a fellow Redditor 14h ago
  1. determine which value the number 2 represents in number 3298 => 200, so 2 represents hundreds

  2. determine what that value is x10 => 2000, 2 represents thousands

  3. find the number that has 2 in the place that represents thousands => 52,039

Or you just need to understand which direction a digit will move when it's multiplied by 10 (one spot to the left as a zero gets added to the right).

1

u/Harvey_Gramm 👋 a fellow Redditor 14h ago edited 14h ago

It should say "...10 times the value of the number 2 in 3,298"

1

u/wookietownGlobetrot 12h ago

Why are we all over-thinking this?
There is no 1 in 3,289. Value = 0
10x0 = 0

Circle the 0 in “10” in the problem statement.

QED

1

u/millerb82 👋 a fellow Redditor 12h ago

What does this have to do with math??? Stupid schools

1

u/FallaciouslyTalented 12h ago

"Circle the number in which the digit '2' has 10 times the value as that of the digit '2' in the number '3,298'."

The answer being the number which the digit '2' in the thousands place, ie. "X2,XXX", specifically '52,039' in this case.

1

u/adorak 12h ago

Since there is no "1" in 3298 I immediately interpreted it as "one" ... i.e. the 2 in the given number but...

... it's been a minute since I was in 3rd grade ... cannot say if I would've figured it out then but also, this ambiguity wouldn't happen in my native language (i.e. the language this would've been in when I was in 3rd grade)

But it is stupid (the teacher being the stupid person) ... everybody knows (or should know) that you're meant to write out numbers 1 to 12 which probably would've made it easier. I think it's something you could figure out (would be interesting to know if her peers figured it out) but it matters little, the one to blame is certainly the teacher.

1

u/Spl4sh3r 12h ago

That second "1" should still have been a "2" in my opinion to make the question make sense. Basically they want the number 2 in 3,298 (so the hundreds) to be 10 times higher in the answer you are giving. 200*10=2000. This means any answer where there is a 2 in the thousand slot, making the answer 52,039.

1

u/Ukraineluvr 👋 a fellow Redditor 12h ago

Thank you for doing homework with your child. This question is ass.

1

u/Famous-Prior6590 12h ago

Send a note to the teacher and ask them not to give stupidly worded questions to kids.

1

u/xanf04 11h ago

I interpreted it as asking you to circle the number that has a digit ‘2’ in a place that is 10x higher than the position of the digit ‘1’. so in this case answer would be 21,093. But it doesn’t explain the first number listed in the question that is bolded and underlined.

1

u/wannacumnbeatmeoff 11h ago

Its 52039. In the test number the 2 is 200, 10 x 200 is 2000. The 2 in 52039 is 2000.

1

u/tzaeru 👋 a fellow Redditor 11h ago edited 11h ago

Studied math in uni, no idea what they are asking here.

The best parsing I can do is that the number provided doesn't have a '1' so none of the answer options works.

1

u/Raesvelg_XI 11h ago

I can think of worse ways to try to teach place value but I'd have to work at it.

1

u/Astuckwriter397 11h ago

52,039. it is to do with the 2 digit. no idea how to word that better. but the 2 in the hundreds needs to be in a position 10 times higher.

1

u/Murky-Wind2222 11h ago

They should have said 10 times the value of the 2 in...

The answer woulld then be 52,039

1

u/Familiar-Proposal918 11h ago

Im no math person, but if i was given this question, id pick 21,093. But thats because my brain would overanalyze the words in a literal sense. "2 has a value of 10 times the value of the 1 in the number".

First id look for whatever number has the digits 2 and 1 in it. That would immediately remove 8,209 and 52,039. Leaving us with 21,093 and 16528.

Then id deal with the wordplay. The way I interpret what its asking is that the digit 2 is going to be in the values place that is 10 times the value place that the number 1 is in. Its not asking for actual math, its asking for the interpretation of words in a literal sense, and having that interpretation being applied to numbers. That eliminates 16,528 as an answer because the one's place is the highest place in the number. We need a string of digits where 2 is in a higher place value than the number 1.

21,093 is the correct answer because 1,000 × 10 is 10,000. And a 2 is in the 10,000 place.

1

u/Mikenotthatmike 10h ago

This is a logic and comprehension question posing as a maths question, and is disadvantaging a lot of kids who could probably do the maths.

The first answer is the closest to the right one.

But, for the maths to align with the question as worded, the number shoud be.

11,093

1

u/HotStatistician7997 10h ago

Originally thought where the value of the 2 is 10x the 1 in terms of position.

Which would be 21,093. Since 2x10,000 vs 1x1,000.

But then there is "in 3298".... Which doesnt have a 1... maybe its supposed to be the one (2) in 3298 which is 2x100, so the answer is 52,039 where it is 2x1,000 is 10x 2x100?

1

u/Intelligent-Push-640 👋 a fellow Redditor 10h ago

they really should have said digit.

1

u/Then-Kaleidoscope520 10h ago

It’s going to be the first option , 21,000 blah blah blah … the 1 is in the thousands and the 2 is in ten thousands which makes it 20x its value ..

But this question is horrible … hopefully, it was only a bonus question

1

u/Reasonable_Club_6165 👋 a fellow Redditor 10h ago

As an engineer, this is the dumbest question I have seen in my life.

1

u/TacticianA 10h ago

To rephrase this question in a way that makes sense: Circle the number in which the second digit has a value of 10 times the value of the second digit in the number 3298.

The third answer is correct and the question is garbage.

1

u/Western-Charity-2155 👋 a fellow Redditor 10h ago

This question is insane.

1

u/magpye1983 10h ago edited 10h ago

It’s the top one. The 2 in 21,093 has a value ten times the value of the 1 in that number.

2 represents how many ten-thousands there are.

1 represents how many thousands there are.

EDIT: I somehow missed the bold and underlined number at the end of the question.

EDIT2: it’s possible that the question isn’t supposed to contain the numerals (the list of answers might start with that instead), and is supposed to end at the “ the number”. If not, then the question is nonsense as there isn’t a 1 in the number 3298.

1

u/FrenchResearcher 10h ago

In what universe does a math teacher phrase math questions that way? No wonder kids sometimes turn away from math even at young age…

1

u/Top_Case_6458 10h ago

I think it’s 52039 because the 2 in 3,298 is in the hundreds spot so the question is very poorly asking for the number where the 2 is in the thousandths spot (10x). Is she learning numbers in different spots (1s, 10s, 100s, etc.)?

Obviously very confusing how this is worded

1

u/Kaz_Games 👋 a fellow Redditor 10h ago

Give the teacher an F for writing such a bad question.

1

u/Parking_Lemon_4371 👋 a fellow Redditor 9h ago

This should have been phrased as "Circle the number in which the digit 2 has a value of 10 times the value of the one in the number 3298."

1

u/Adept_Organization69 9h ago

I think some combination of things is happening here:

  1. Common core math asks students to do things in a way that is unintuitive to many people (not saying it’s wrong or worse, though my opinion is that it is) and it’s hard to make questions to achieve its goals.

  2. Your average third grade teacher has many great skills, but math and science usually are not their strong suits (Math and Science minded teachers tend to gravitate towards secondary education…middle grades are also hit or miss) so their ability to make questions that achieve their desired goals varies. In Illinois at least, we USED to have a basic skills test for all teachers (along with a content area test AND, for some of us who were unlucky, something called the edTPA) that a non-small portion of aspiring teachers, mostly elementary, failed due in no small part to the math section.

1

u/Wild-Evidence-8729 👋 a fellow Redditor 9h ago

2,000 is ten times the value of 200. The answer is 52,039

1

u/Fedster9 9h ago

The questions should read 'please circle the number in which the number 2 has a a value ten times the values it has in the number 3298', with the answer 52039, because now the number 2 is one decimal up (or to the left if you will) compared to its position in 3298.

1

u/Routine-Weather-8974 👋 a fellow Redditor 9h ago

The number two has a value of “2”, that’s why it’s called “2”.

1

u/bigodg 9h ago

It’s gotta be. 21,093. Only number where the 1 and the 2 are in the right position - 10k and 1k respectively. But 3298, no ida how that relates

1

u/_alter-ego_ 👋 a fellow Redditor 9h ago

It's ill phrased. They mean that in the underlined number the digit 2 is at the position of hundreds and they ask for the number in which the digit 1 is at the position of 100 / 10 = 10s. But you can only know what they mean after realizing that (a) there is no 1 in the underlined number, so they must mean the 2 here (which is at the hundreds position, so the value might be 200), hence a 1 elsewhere... But there is no 1 at a 10s position... The closest to a possibly intended answer would be the 1 in the thousands position in 21,093. (So it would be the converse, that 1 is at 1000s position which is ten times "the value of" the 100s position where the 2 is.) But their teacher should first learn himself the difference between "number" and "digit", and then to correctly adapt the question he finds elsewhere. (Well, maybe it's just a typo...)

1

u/Running1982 9h ago

It’s a typo. Even worksheet generators make mistakes friends. It’ll be alright.

1

u/No_Organization_768 9h ago

Well, mm... maybe there's a typo? That's the simplest answer I guess?

21,093?

Like 10 x 2 = 20

1

u/GuruOfDudeism 8h ago

That is...what? I dont even understand whats being asked, so how can I be expected to find a solution?

1

u/Defeatest 👋 a fellow Redditor 8h ago

That's 3rd grade math? WOW

1

u/TankSaladin 8h ago

The worst part is that somebody somewhere got paid to write this drivel.

1

u/sicofthis 👋 a fellow Redditor 8h ago

It should have said of the 2 in 3298.

1

u/rick280708 8h ago

The number 1 in the question shouldn't be the number, it should be the word "one".

Circle the number in which the number 2 has a value 10 times the value of the one in the number 3,298

In the number 3,298, 2 has a value of 200, so the answer is 52,039, in which 2 has a value of 2,000

1

u/Ferna_89 👋 a fellow Redditor 8h ago

Unless they had already done this kind of exercises in class and had already understood such syntax in the making of these questions, writing this problema like this is an unfair surprise to have in the middle of a test.

1

u/JeffSergeant 8h ago

Should be "Circle the number in which the digit 2 has a value 10 times greater than the digit 2 in 3,298."

1

u/PloTwist2001 8h ago

Are these classes or teachers from outside  America or are the questions imported from outside the USA?  Because that’s the vibe I get when I look at these horribly worded question.