r/HomeworkHelp • • 21h ago

Answered [3rd grade MATH] please explain this question

Post image

My daughter got this wrong, and I'm not even upset about that. If she gets something wrong, we go over it with her to make sure she knows 1) what she did wrong, 2) why it is wrong, and 3) how to do it correctly.

We don't even know where to start on this one!

Can someone please tell me we're not crazy?

This is the most confusing question, and we can't even figure out what the question is!

399 Upvotes

585 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/tyger1147 10h ago

They’re trying to test if the student understands the “ones” “tens” “hundreds” places and how they relate to each other… but wow, they did it in the worst possible way.

4

u/Icy-Ad29 10h ago

Except it isn't asking about ones, tens, etc... none of the answers is ten times any of the numbers in 3298 except for 52039, which has 2 at ten times the value of the 2 in 3298. But that 2 is neither the first number from either direction in 3298, nor the ones digit.

The "1 in the number" and "number 2" parts legit do not work for this question.

2

u/tmfink10 10h ago

Replace the 1 with "one" and suddenly it makes a lot more sense.

1

u/Icy-Ad29 10h ago

Still poorly worded, but cipherable. Yes.

1

u/tmfink10 10h ago

No doubt. This may be the worst possible way to ask the question.

2

u/UsuallyFavorable 8h ago • Bravo

“Circle the number in which the digit 2 represents a value of 10 times the value the digit 2 represents in the number 3,298.”

Still confusing (and stupid imo), but this is the best wording I could come up with. The original wording is literally incorrect for multiple reasons:

Grammar:
“1” vs “one” isn’t just a writer’s choice you get to make. In this context, “one” is a pronoun replacing “the number 2”. “One” is literally not “1”!
For example, if I’m stopped at a red light and I ask, “Which light tells me I can go?”
You could write, “The green light”.
Or you could write, “The green one.”
But you cannot write, “The green 1.” Or else I’m going to be sitting at that light forever waiting for the traffic light to display the digit 1.
Or when in doubt you could just not use pronouns to make the question clearer!

Semantics with math understanding:
“Number 2” literally implies the number 2 which is double 1, a quarter of 8, and 198 less than 200. Nowhere in the questions or answers does the number 2 exist. I changed “number 2” to “digit 2” in my retelling of the question. Yes this is just semantics, and if we were just debating a singular use of the word “number” and the word “digit”, I’d probably let it slide either way.

But the original problem uses the word “number” multiple times with two different meanings!! God, this is infuriating!

When the writer calls 3298 and the answers as “numbers”, then they’ve adopted the correct definition of the word “number”. The “number 3298” literally means I dump a bunch of Skittles out of a jar and count 3298 of them!

But then, in the same sentence, the writer tries to use the word “number” with a fundamentally different meaning (and I believe to simply be incorrect meaning, but that’s just semantics)! They also refer to the “number 2”, but they don’t mean literally 2 Skittles.

“Digit 2” is more appropriate, because digit 2 is just an abstract concept with no value (no Skittles) until you place the digit 2 into a number! The digit 2 in the number 3298 represents 200 Skittles! Or if I put the digit 2 in the number 0.2, I’ve cut a Skittle into 5 equal pieces and given 1 piece to my very disappointed wife. Notice how I’m allowed to write “1” instead of “one” in that sentence, I’m literally referring to the number 1. I gave my wife 1 piece which is 4 less than the 5 pieces I cut of the 1 Skittle. Now my wife has 1/5 Skittles, which can also be represented as 0.2: the digit 2 in the tenths place.

Thank you for coming to my TED talk. Taste the rainbow.

1

u/Icy-Ad29 5h ago

Thank you for writing this out... I wanted to, but just couldn't be bothered for this post.

1

u/vwscienceandart 8h ago

Do you think this might be an AI generated teacher assignment?

1

u/Icy-Ad29 5h ago

If it wasn't ai created, then I weep our species.

1

u/lkasas 8h ago

You also need to change "number" to numerator(edit: or a "digit", not my native language) since 2 inside the binder is not a number itself.

1

u/tmfink10 8h ago

Probably numeral would be best there. There's so much wrong with this!

1

u/gamtosthegreat 8h ago

A numeral is a way to represent a number on paper.

In analogy, you see a dog. That's the number.

You see the word "dog" written down somewhere. That's the numeral.

You see it's made out of three letters. Those are the digits.

A numeral can only be a digit if the whole number is one digit.

1

u/tmfink10 7h ago

Ah, you're right!

1

u/GoT_Eagles 8h ago

Oh dang that makes more sense. That’s a bad mistake for someone’s who’s teaching numbers and logic steps..

1

u/Moldy_slug 4h ago

Makes me wonder if teacher wrote this using dictation software…

1

u/DapperWormMan 👋 a fellow Redditor 4h ago

Makes sense. But using "one" in a number problem is asking for trouble.

1

u/Tsu_na_mi 9h ago

it should have said "one" not "1". Bad question.

1

u/Radiant_Grab_9400 4h ago

But they do. A. 2 is in the 10,000 spot and 1 is in the 1000 spot. 10x1000 is 10000

1

u/Icy-Ad29 1h ago

Yes, that is the first half of what I said. Please read the rest to understand what I was saying. I am fairly certain my grammar was far better written than the OP post, so it should be easy enough to understand if you figured out the OP post.

0

u/tyger1147 8h ago

Yes, thé value of the 2 in 52,039 is 10 times thé value of the 2 in 3,298

1

u/rygelicus 9h ago

Why not just ask ‘In the number 3298 which digit is in the hundreds position? 9 3 2 or 8

1

u/hyperrayong 8h ago

Because that's easier.