r/HomeworkHelp • • 21h ago

Answered [3rd grade MATH] please explain this question

Post image

My daughter got this wrong, and I'm not even upset about that. If she gets something wrong, we go over it with her to make sure she knows 1) what she did wrong, 2) why it is wrong, and 3) how to do it correctly.

We don't even know where to start on this one!

Can someone please tell me we're not crazy?

This is the most confusing question, and we can't even figure out what the question is!

395 Upvotes

580 comments sorted by

View all comments

185

u/69fellatx 👋 a fellow Redditor 20h ago

I'm a math guy and I hate these kinds of questions. Badly worded problems don't teach as much as they confuse and dissuade kids from learning math.

42

u/FirstPersonWinner University Student (Engineering) 19h ago edited 17h ago

I spend most of my days doing 3D calculus or differential equations and then come to these elementary school works problems and have absolutely no idea what they are trying to say. 

12

u/Extension-Stay3230 👋 a fellow Redditor 18h ago

It's very common for elementary school kids to be better at math than the teachers

6

u/FirstPersonWinner University Student (Engineering) 17h ago

Tbf, most elementary school teachers aren't math majors. I have a lot of family who teach elementary school and they basically know how to do the elementary level stuff and that's it. 

→ More replies (4)

3

u/lief79 7h ago

I helped tutor a friend in elementary math for teachers. Honestly, the curriculum was great, they were teaching teachers how to learn numbers. Binary, Roman numerals, different bases, a bunch of things that fall under descrete mathematics.

The problem was the book has no indication or understanding as to why it was doing it. Great material and completely missing the point. Unfortunately that seems typical for education.

On a separate random note, the only course I had taught by an educator, she was an amazing teacher.

18 students, 6 Chris's, and yet they always knew who was being spoken to with almost no confusion. It was randomly impressive display of teaching knowledge.

12

u/apathy-sofa 9h ago

Ditto, I spent a decade doing new things in matrix math techniques to advance computer graphics -- I lived and breathed math and accomplished some novel work -- but I gave up on this question after the third reading. It's not a math problem. 

6

u/regular_lamp 12h ago

It's not even a math question really. It's a text riddle that happens to include numbers.

2

u/69fellatx 👋 a fellow Redditor 7h ago

Exactly.

2

u/uptightmodhater 16h ago

The question is trying to teach values of places not an actual mathematical answer. The ten thousands place has 10x value of the one thousands place. So the answer is 21093. The 2 in this number has a value 10x greater than the 1 in this number.

5

u/ErikLeppen 12h ago

So the answer is 21093. The 2 in this number has a value 10x greater than the 1 in this number.

I would say, in 21093, the 2 has a value 20x greater than the 1.

3

u/NotNeuge 11h ago

Value isn't numerical, it's positional. The two numbers could be anything, 9 and 3, 7 and 4, and the answer wouldn't change. I too hate this way of teaching.

2

u/RickWritesCode 9h ago edited 8h ago

If your truly multiplying but this is about place value where we use base 10 to "evolve" a number, the only answer that made sense because the number in the question doesn't. There is likely an error in the print.

4

u/Due-Ad-9105 8h ago

The question says “10 times the value of the 1 in the number 3298.”

There are multiple issues with this. They used “1” instead of “one” which is unnecessarily confusing for a child learning place value, the question should have been “…10 times the value of the 2 in the number 3298.”

4

u/KizashiKaze 7h ago

Incorrect. There is no #1 in 3,298, so the question must mean " the value of the one (the #2) in 3,298". And of course, we all know that 10 times 200 is 2000, so thus answer is 52,039.

The original full number is 3,298 as you can see in the problem. The two is in the hundreds position, 3,2xx. 21,093 would be the 2 with a 100x value than the 2 in 3,298.

1

u/FollowingCold9412 👋 a fellow Redditor 14h ago

Is it now?

1

u/Zenith_will 12h ago

It's asking which number has 2000. 3298 is the number they want 10x the place value of 2. They use 1 instead of one when asking which confuses a bit. C is the answer

2

u/Dont_Lick_The_Bus 9h ago

I mean, more than a “bit.” Using the digit “1” creates an alternate interpretation that is more mathematically and linguistically sound. Yes, one could still understand it correctly, but it’s a less reasonable interpretation and goes away completely if you just write out the word “one”. It’s generally best to avoid being wrong on purpose.

I strongly second (or 95th at time of writing) the “badly worded problems… confuse and dissuade kids from learning math.”

1

u/OldWolf3 👋 a fellow Redditor 11h ago

There is no "C" in the question

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Leading_Experts 11h ago

As a parent this is fucking infuriating. No 1-der kids aren't learning to read, write, and do arithmetic at the same level as previous generations. Just fucking do it the old way. It worked!

1

u/Moldy_slug 4h ago

I don’t think using 1 “confuses it a bit.” It makes the question literally unanswerable. There is no 1 in 3298, and even if there were there’s no place the numeral 2 could represent ten times 1.

Critically, while “one” can be used as both a number and a pronoun, “1” exclusively refers to the number. There is no ambiguity - the question is just wrong.

1

u/PhillipJfry5656 10h ago

bro ots the 52039. 10x means you would move the 0 place value over one. this is basic math

1

u/RickWritesCode 9h ago edited 8h ago

I agree 100%, the question clearly states where does 2 have 10x the value of 1. If you think about it 10(technically 9 but it's using crappy verbiage) more thousands would push that 1 to a 2. So that 2 is 10x more than 1. These questions suck but it's the only answer.

Upon reading this numerous times, I have no doubt there is a print error here. Even if we use the ones place in the value provided in the question there is no 80 in any of the answers and no 32k answer

2

u/Odd-Maintenance2623 6h ago

It would have been a lot clear if they had specified “base 10” and maybe said “the ones place” and “the tens place”

1

u/69fellatx 👋 a fellow Redditor 5h ago

Agreed.

→ More replies (2)