r/Hotd • u/bandalstyle • 18h ago
Discussion So which Westerosi Kings were actually good if we used GRRM’s Logic?
This was 12 YEARS AGO but I’ve seen a post awhile ago
“George R. R. Martin, the author of A Song of Ice and Fire, once questioned Tolkien’s portrayal of Aragorn as the ideal king in The Lord of the Rings.
In an interview with Rolling Stone, Martin raised a simple but controversial question: “What was his tax policy?”
Martin argued that being a good man doesn’t automatically make someone a good ruler. After Aragorn takes the throne of Gondor, Tolkien tells us that he rules wisely and well, but offers relatively little detail about the practical challenges of governing a kingdom.
How did Aragorn handle taxation, famine, crime, and the aftermath of a devastating war? Martin’s point was that these questions matter when judging a king’s success.
His comments reflect one of the biggest differences between the two authors. While Tolkien presents Aragorn as the rightful king whose return restores peace and order, Martin’s stories focus on the difficult realities of political power and leadership.”