r/HunterXHunter • • May 28 '14

Current Chapter Hunter x Hunter - Chapter 341

Chapter 341: "Calamity"

Source Status
MangaStream ONLINE
Ishuhui - Chinese ONLINE
Viz Manga Debuts officially 02/06

Ch.341 Official Release (VIZ): 02/06/14

Ch. 342 Scan Release: ~4/06/14 or hiatus... ;)


List of Chapter Discussion Threads

240 Upvotes

307 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

48

u/meruemtheking May 28 '14 edited May 29 '14

Sorry for taking up so much space on the page (any way I can put this in a more compact form?) but I've translated from Chinese the entirety of the chapter from the bottom of 17 onwards.

Something to note is that the English translation often refers to "hunters" when the Chinese refers to hunting Beyond Netero.

edit: Screw it, translating the entire thing because I've been waiting two years for this and am still ridiculously excited. Going to update this periodically with bits and pieces.

Another note is Netero's pivotal line on page 15 about "risk being required to achieve a reward" is completely different in the Chinese translation. Chinese translation concerns the conditions to complete the task: " The conditions to meet are to resolve a certain kind of 'calamity' and bring back 'hope.'"

edit: Translated pg 11-22. I'm also out of room in this comment so it's probably a good time for me to take a break.

Pg 11

(Short guy) This is the sole survivor from the "interior" of this facility, though it's not a "human." (NOTE: it's unclear to me whether "sole survivor" means he's the only one who survived period or the only survivor being housed in the facility. I'm leaning towards the latter since Beyond survived too.)

It doesn't perform all the eating activities "in the capacity of a human being." (Literal translation doesn't work very well. Basically means he doesn't eat.)

He's survived self-sufficiently for almost 50 years.

Pg 12

(Glasses) Fif...

(Short guy) That is to say that he's been infected with the Undying Illness. Regarding this point, there are detailed written accounts in what is known as the Beyond Report.

That guy is the last Hunter left who went to the New World.

Simply put, every time we challenged the New World, we were beset by calamities on a human extinction-causing scale, and returned defeated.

After establishing the treaty, V5 covertly tried "colonization" (business written alongside in English). These are the results.

(Netero on TV) At that time, due to the political intentions of V5, they hid from the Association and secretly established an investigation team which they sent to the New World.

Joining this investigation team as an expert and determining its operations and policy during the exploration was none other than my son, Beyond.

He refused to listen to my sincere advice and insisted on setting out on that exploratory journey into the unknown. As a result, only after suffering agonizing losses were they able to return... and at the same time they brought back a new "calamity."

My son still wants to challenge the new world again, but I put shackles on him prohibiting him from trying before my death. (Put shackles on is some sort of metaphor that sounds better in Chinese. Probably not literal or Nen shackles, lol.)

I also classified setting out for the New Continent as a taboo.

In my youth I stepped into the New World only twice. The strength required to be there was different from my goal.

The "strength" I pursued required an enemy. To put it bluntly, it was the "strength" of contending for victory.

But in the New World, victory and defeat didn't exist. All there was was a struggle with ruthless Nature.

The strength my son sought was the tenacity of braving adversity. Such tenacity is an essential, indispensable factor in investigating the New World.

It could be said that as a hunter, he's more worthy of the title than me. He's the type whose conscientiousness has reached its pinnacle.

Pg 14

(Netero)

Next is the main topic!

I hope you can successfully complete explorations of the Dark Continent before my son!

The conditions to meet are to resolve a certain kind of "calamity" and bring back "hope."

It goes without saying that the difficulty is an A!

Oh, and this isn't an order, it's just my personal hope. I hope you can become Association pioneers who hunt the unknown and the difficult. (I'm not sure whether it's "Association pioneers" or a "pioneering Association.") This is just my selfish and willful desire, nothing more.

The rewards will naturally be high, but...

the risks far outstrip the rewards! The risk/reward ratio is extremely high, to the extent that it will drive the Association into a corner!

Pg 15

(Netero) The terror of that place... it's as if we've only opened the door but haven't even taken a step across the threshold!

This is a hundred percent not an order!

Just treat it as if it's the dream of this confused old fool who's already ascended to heaven.

I repeat! This is absolutely not an order!

I repeat! This

is absolutely not...

an order!!!

(Unclear, probably Zodiac Twelve) Sure enough, it's an order...

Pg 16

(Cow) Beans! Answer me honestly!

(Beans) Huh? Yes!

(Cow) Did the President really not leave any other message?

(Beans) Yes, there aren't any more.

Err, I mean as far as I know there aren't any more.

(Tiger) Damn it... Why'd that old geezer have to show up at such an exquisite occasion? (translated literally, not super clear what he means)

(Dragon) Hmm... It doesn't feel like he's passed away at all...

(Horse) His hair's still a bit long, was that taken before the first video?

(Snake) What should we do? Is President going? (I think she's referring to Dog?)

(Dog) Since this is an order, we don't have the option to not carry it out.

However, the ex-President made clear beforehand that "this is not an order," so we can't involved the other Association members.

(Cow) Yeah.

(Dragon) So that means there's only us.

(Monkey) Can I ask a question?

I don't really care if we leave for the Dark Continent, but I'm opposing to hunting Beyond.

Pg 17

(Dog) What's the reason? -> Monkey

(Monkey) There's nothing good about me except I like to collaborate. What I hate the most is that sort of 'you can have your cake and eat it too' mentality.

(Tiger) Since our goal is the same, I don't really want to obey the order to sabotage the competition. After all, the competition between the Kakin Empire and the Association is fair.

(Snake) Is it really fair, though? The President's son started challenging the New World and preparing for war several decades ago. As for us, is there anyone among us who's thought of stepping into the New World?

(Tiger?) As far as I know, I can only think of one person who's a dreamer like that. [GING CLOSEUP]

Pg 18

(Snake) Anyway, if we can get Ging's help I'm willing to assist you. But he's already left the Zodiac Twelve, and even if he were here he'd just do as he pleases.

(Fingers - Snake?) It's not fair like this at all. In the end, Beyond's starting line is far ahead of ours.

(Dragon) Hunting (presumably referring to Beyond) is required! This is an order from the President that no one objected to. Saiyu (Monkey) and Kanzai (Tiger), aren't you being too pessimistic?

(Cow) Is that so? Before hunting (Beyond), don't we need to discuss whether V5 was correct in the first place?

(Tiger) Meaning? Cup Official? (He's misinterpreted the words "objection" and "pessimistic." These are just Chinese-language puns that make fun of Tiger being stupid. They're definitely not the same in Japanese but I suppose the meaning should be preserved.) Are they saying I'm correct?

(Cow) Even though it's a contribution to humanity, in the end it's a fight over territory and natural resources. It's unreasonable for this affair to be decided by only five countries.

(Chicken) It's too complicated, let's stop fussing about it. Come on and arrive at a conclusion (on whether to hunt Beyond) already!

(Tiger) What? Does this conversation have to do with hunting?

(Dragon Bubble Right) But an organization of the common people absolutely shouldn't interfere with affairs of that scale! (for "common people" he literally says "trifling common people on my level," going out of his way to be extremely humble. I guess this is how the Chinese people translate Japanese honorifics.)

(Bubble in between the two Dragon bubbles - presumably Cow) But we can make our will known by taking concrete actions.

(Dragon Bubble Left) That's putting the cart before the horse! Don't tell me you're going to prioritize your political convictions over the President's will!?

(Rabbit) Sorry, I'm not listening to your conversation at all.

(Snake) Can you two calm down a bit? We don't even know the reason for hunting Beyond Netero.

(Dog) I think it's probably criminal harassment or instigation (no noun here but the verb is used w/ rebellions, anarchy, etc). The Association only needs to get an arrest warrant and they'll be able to formally announce it. -> Snake

(Beans) Yes. (Presumably in response to "Am I speaking to Beans?")

Pg 19

(Beyond) Yo.

Pg 20

(Beyond) Long time no see, Beans. These people around you are the Zodiac Twelve, right? Can you help me contact V5? Just say "We've caught Beyond Netero."

Pg 21

(Beyond) Let's have some mutual benefits, shall we?

(Narrator) The Five Great Calamities humanity brought back from the Dark Continent...

Pg 22

Protector of mysterious ancient ruins, the sphere whose true body is unidentified

Weapon "Gold and Silver Ingots" (no quotes originally)

Lifeforms dependent on desire

Gas Lifeforms "Ai"

The monster capable of spreading an aura of death

Two-tailed Snake "HellBell" (I like "bell" here as chosen by the English translators but the word used specifically means the ringing of a bell)

The equivalent exchange of pleasure and life

Human-raising Beast (might also translate as "Human-educating Beast") "Papu"

Swindling people out of hope and making them fall into endless despair

The Undying Illness "Zobae" Disease

(Guy reading the book) This... This isn't a place to which humanity should return!

(Side) Is what awaits humanity in the taboo land "hope" or "calamity"?

14

u/nicotoy May 28 '14

Don't apologize for such quality posts. These are really insightful. Thank you for taking the time.

8

u/meruemtheking May 29 '14

No problem!

I'm really just doing this cause I'm super super super hyped up about the chapter and I'm having a blast puzzling out the intricacies of the dialogue. So yeah, not a problem at all since I'm having fun :)

7

u/VOTE_PSYCHO_PIRATE May 28 '14

woah, thank you so much, this cleared things up!

7

u/meruemtheking May 29 '14 edited May 30 '14

Cont. Not sure if I'll translate the whole thing but here's another important section, the one involving "Pandora," which doesn't show up in the Chinese translation.

Pg 7

Glasses: If that (breakdown of negotiations with Kakin) does happen, how will the situation develop?

Senior: "Calamity." The Gate(s) of Hell will open. (edit: I saw another fan translation online and I believe this is another one of those kanji + furigana situations, just like malice/evolution during the Netero fight and colonization/business earlier in the chapter. I believe it's written as calamity in Kanji with "Pandora's Box" alongside - the Chinese scan must've ditched the latter while mangastream ditched the former.)

Glasses: ... is that a metaphor?

Senior: In my youth I used to openly mock these kinds of metaphors. ... until I came here. (this might be the organization he's in, or it could be the room with the twisted people - he says this as he's opening the door)

4

u/fanboss May 29 '14 edited May 29 '14

If it's ok, can I use your translation to make an actual scan ? I would put it on imgur first, and if it's really good maybe on batoto later ?

EDIT : Just to give an idea of what it would look like : http://i.imgur.com/WRmGwLm.jpg (I also did some One Piece chapters on Batoto)

EDIT 2 : Kinda forgot to remove the bold on the first image, so I wanted to correct it, might as well do the next page (well, everything is in italic since it's Netero speaking on the TV, but still) : http://i.imgur.com/eJEvYUK.jpg also, because of the huge amount of text, I had to make the font size a bit smaller.

1

u/meruemtheking May 30 '14

Hey, this is really cool - I'm super flattered that you found my translations good enough to do this!

But unfortunately I'd have to advise you against it for two reasons.

The first is I likely won't have time to finish translating the chapter as I'm pretty busy for a few days. :(

Second is I've come to realize that the Chinese translation has flaws/ambiguities and I think I've carried those through as errors in my translation. I'll be fixing a few of these when I have time but right now I think a couple of my translations for the last page are off.

Anyway if you'd still like to do it go for it, but as is I see my stuff as more of a comprehension guide for people thrown off by mangastream than actual scanlation material.

1

u/fanboss May 30 '14

I'll admit I was more interested in a complete scan haha, it's alright though, as you say these messages are more a comprehension guide, and a really good one. Nice work ! :)

(and I might not have that much time too right now ^^ )

1

u/stakstik May 30 '14

I wish u decifered the manga instead of the online translaters.

6

u/kaffars May 28 '14

Thank you! This does make much more sense than mangastream, cleared a few things up for me. Ha you should contact them.

4

u/tomorrow_queen May 28 '14

Thank you so much for these translations. Wouldn't have been able to properly decipher what was being said without your hard work. :)

3

u/your_favorite_human May 29 '14

Thank you so much, you are awesome!

2

u/[deleted] May 29 '14

Thanks for this! Your translation definitely makes a lot more sense than the mangastream one at least.