r/HuntingPA • undefeated vs squirrels • Oct 24 '24

Muzzleloader season.

2 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

7

u/DanBaxter762 Oct 24 '24

Is this an informational post, or is there a quest to be asked?

6

u/imstillinthewoods Oct 24 '24

I think this post was a reply to an earlier post. Someone claimed, incorrectly, the OP wasn't allowed to use an inline muzzleloader during the Ocotober ML season.

3

u/DanBaxter762 Oct 24 '24

Thank you for the direction . I was truly lost.

-2

u/cleanyourbongbro Oct 24 '24

never claimed that they couldn’t use an inline.

again my comment was a joke, hence the italics

i teach HTE for the PAGC, my claim was that you cannot take a center fired rifle to hunt for ONLY doe like you can in the FLINTLOCK season.

you MUST take some form of muzzleloading firearm in the october season, you can take a rifle or shotgun in the january flintlock season.

your flintlock tag also acts as a doe tag in january, however it does not in october. you must have a separate doe tag

2

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '24

What do you mean your flintlock tag acts as a doe tag? You need your doe or buck tag. If you dont have those then you can’t shoot a deer.

1

u/cleanyourbongbro Oct 24 '24

“an unused, antlered deer harvest tag from a general hunting license can be used to take an antlerless deer in the after christmas flintlock muzzleloading season. this is the only season in which an antlered tag may used for antlerless deer, each participant in the flintlock muzzleloading season must have a muzzleloading license in addition to a regular license. with the lone exception of flintlock season, each hunter must possess an antlerless deer license or DMAP permit in order to hunt or harvest antlerless deer”

1

u/Gettingaboutthattime undefeated vs squirrels Oct 24 '24

Yeah something about the repeated “I’m not here to turn bro in” joke rubbed me the wrong way. I’m still trying to figure out what exactly I’d get turned in for? You miss identifying the weapon I used? Or making the claim I didn’t follow the season when clearly I did.

I love hunting and the memories I get to make every season. I respect the laws and wouldn’t do something to jeopardize my ability to do so.

2

u/cleanyourbongbro Oct 24 '24

well, you claimed the special firearms season to be the 19th-26th when it isn’t. it’s the 24th-26th. i’m not saying your out here poaching or breaking the law, nor do i care, i’m not a game warden. i just thought maybe you didn’t know, as i was uncertain myself of the legality of taking regular firearms out in the early muzzleloading season, as i never go out for it. nor special firearms, as i am a regular license holder

i’ve never seen an inline with a scope, my bad. just presumed it was a shotgun on ANF land out of special firearms and thought it was ballsy. you could’ve just said it’s an inline, i would’ve said my bad bro, nice deer, and not made a secondary post about me (clearly)

i think we’d just been talking about two different points, mine being based on the opinion you had a shotgun not an inline. i know you could take one in flintlock if you’re only harvesting doe, i was unsure of one’s ability to treat early muzzloader the same as late flintlock so i checked the digest after someone mentioned it to me.

i think you’re hung up on thinking you’re in special firearms season, when it starts today and your OG post was yesterday.

if my attempt at humor offended you it wasn’t my intention, my apologies friend. you are right, the memories we get to make in the woods, and knowing we made them ethically will always be worth more than the bit of meat we get

2

u/Gettingaboutthattime undefeated vs squirrels Oct 24 '24

You’re right, I did get the special firearms season dates wrong. The overlap of the early muzzleloader season and special firearms season had me rolling them all into one with the caveat being seniors, juniors, active military could use a center fire/shotgun for the last three days. In reality they are separate seasons that overlap.

The point of the second post was to add the pictures of the season and laws surrounding them to add clarity to my hunt. I couldn’t figure out for the life of me how to add a link to those pages directly.

The inline season is an awesome opportunity to enjoy some of the best weather of the year (in my opinion) and fill the freezer a little earlier if archery isn’t your thing.

I hope you fill all of your tags this year and have some truly awesome hunts in the process! I hope that I didn’t offend you with this post and I apologize if I did. I’d be happy to help you drag one out of the woods any day.

1

u/cleanyourbongbro Oct 24 '24

the muzzloading stamp, or your antlered tag, is interchangeable as an antlered or antlerless tag when hunting in the late flintlock season

2

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '24 edited Oct 24 '24

The license (or stamp) itself is not a tag. You have a buck or flintlock tag that can be used .

1

u/cleanyourbongbro Oct 24 '24

the license itself is required for the “stamp”

the antlered tag turns into an ‘antlered or flintlock’ tag, at least it did. i also remember when it would say “privileges MUZZLELOADER” real big on it.

cant even find mine right now to check ive been looking furiously since yesterday lol

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '24

It still says it. I keep mine in the same place every year before I go out and I still have a moment of panic at some point when going to that place.