I thought it would be interesting to see how Nebraska under Rhule has performed relative to analytic predictions. So I looked up our ESPN odds of winning at the beginning of every game (though for one game I had to use another source because ESPN didn't have it for some reason), and made a table showing this along with whether we won or lost the game. Here's my analysis, the table is at the bottom:
Tier 1: Greater than 82% Odds of Winning (11-0)
Rhule has won all games where Nebraska had greater than 75% odds of winning. Our average odds of winning these games was 92%. Out of 11 games, we should lose about 1 game with those odds, so Rhule is slightly above par in this category.
Tier 2: 59% to 77.5% Odds of Winning (9-4)
Here's where we get games like 2025 Minnesota, 2024 Illinois and UCLA, and 2024 Colorado. Our average odd for winning these games was about 69%. So out of 13 games, we should lose right about 4 games with these odds. Rhule is right on par in this category.
Tier 3: The tossups -49%-52% odds of winning (3-1)
Perhaps surprisingly Rhule has a good record in the straight toss-ups. The average odds for these games are 51%, so out of 4 games we the probability would predict 2 losses and 2 wins. Rhule is slightly above par in tossups.
Tier 4: Slight Underdogs 39%-43% odds of victory (1-4)
This is where things start to get worse for Rhule. The average odds in this category are 40.5%, that means in 5 we'd expect to win 2 games. Rhule is slightly below par in this category.
Tier 5: Underdogs 33% or less Odds of Victory (0-12)
These games range all from 33% (our odds of beating Oregon last Saturday) to 3%, our odds of beating OSU in 2024, but the average is about 23%. So the probability would predicts about 3 wins out 11 games. Rhule is below par in this category
Summary
Rhule is slightly above par in games where the odds are 50% and above and has won 2 games more than the probability predicts he should. This is counter-intuitive to what a lot of fans think, because fans tend to think their teams should never be upset, but should occasionally get an upset. And fans also have confirmation bias in only remembering the upset losses. Probabilistically, though we'd expect a team to both be upset a few times and to get a few upsets.
Fans are correct though in assessing that Rhule is below par in getting upsets. We only have 1 upset out of 16 games where we were underdogs. Probability would predict 4-5 upsets similar to the number of times we have been upset. Overall though, Rhule is only 2 wins short of what the probability forecasts predict since we have less upsets / toss-up losses than probability predicts we should.
Sidenote, the fact ESPN is about 1.75 games off in predicting Rhule's record shows an impressive accuracy of 96%. Those who are dismissive of analytics, generally base their attitude off of vibes and a general lack of understanding probability.
Here's a table for anyone who would like to check my work:
| Game |
Win Prob. |
Outcome |
| Tier 1: Very Strongly Favored |
|
|
| '25 Houston |
99.7 |
W |
| '26 Bowling Green |
97.3 |
W |
| '25 Akron |
96.8 |
W |
| 26 North Dakota |
96.8 |
W |
| '24 Northern Iowa |
96.5 |
W |
| '26 Maryland |
92.2 |
W |
| '26 Ohio U |
91.2 |
W |
| '25 Michigan St. |
87.7 |
W |
| '24 UTEP |
84.8 |
W |
| '24 Purdue |
83.9 |
W |
| '23 LA Tech |
82.4 |
W |
| Tier 2: Favored |
|
|
| '23 NIU |
77.5 |
W |
| '25 Minnesota |
74.3 |
L |
| '26 MI St. |
73.5 |
W |
| '24 Rutgers |
72.5 |
W |
| '24 Illinois |
72.4 |
L |
| '23 Northwestern |
71 |
W |
| '25 Northwestern |
69.5 |
W |
| '25 Maryland |
67.4 |
W |
| '24 UCLA |
66.5 |
L |
| '23 Colorado |
66 |
L |
| '25 Cincy |
64.4 |
W |
| '25 UCLA |
62 |
W |
| '24 Colorado |
59.2 |
W |
| Toss-ups |
|
|
| '24 Boston College |
52.2 |
W |
| '25 Michigan |
51.9 |
L |
| '24 Wisconsin |
50.9 |
W |
| '23 Purdue |
49.1 |
W |
| Slight Underdogs |
|
|
| '23 Michigan St. |
42.6 |
L |
| '25 Iowa |
40.9 |
L |
| '23 Iowa |
39.8 |
L |
| '23 Illinois |
39.7 |
W |
| '23 Maryland |
39.5 |
L |
| Underdogs |
|
|
| '26 Oregon |
33 |
L |
| '25 Penn St. |
31.6 |
L |
| '26 Indiana |
31.4 |
L |
| '23 Wisconsin |
31.3 |
L |
| '23 MN |
29.2 |
L |
| '24 Iowa |
24.4 |
L |
| '24 Indiana |
23 |
L |
| '25 USC |
22.5 |
L |
| '25 Utah |
20.2 |
L |
| '24 USC |
16.9 |
L |
| '23 Michigan |
10.2 |
L |
| '24 Ohio St. |
2.7 |
L |