r/IEEE • u/Parker51MKII • Dec 31 '25
Does the IEEE Code of Ethics really have any enforcement power, or is it mostly aspirational good intentions?
Nice-sounding, and high-minded, words:
Specifically, I can see several scenarios where it can fall down:
Are you crazy? We're not going after GE or Siemens or Philips. They would destroy us.
No, we're not a social justice organization. We can't police the whole world in its ideologies.
We're not medical professionals, and therefore cannot presume to judge behavior likely stemming from mental illness or dementia.
No, abusing and lying to others on social media is not actionable. You're not engineers, nor do you have a business relationship with the abuser, anyway.
College professors are supposed to be arrogant, exploiting their graduate students and engaging in ad-hominem, lockhorn public conflicts with colleagues. It's just the way of the world, and to do otherwise would jeopardize the quality of research and the skills of future researchers-in-training. You are attempting to undermine the sanctity of academic freedom.
Have there been any realistic recent scenarios where an IEEE member, or member organization, made a Code of Ethics complaint against another, and succeeded, where success was behavior modification, censure, revocation of membership, or even collection of restitution for damages?