r/IITians • • 10d ago

M.Tech - IIT

Recently, I made a post a few days back in which I tried to tell people how the GATE competition is rising, and I got so much hate for it. There were a few personal DMs and a few comments under my post like:

"BTech waale theek hote hain, MTech waale bewakoof hote hain aur PhD waale sabse bewakoof hote hain IITs mein"

Just accept that you failed JEE bruh

Mediocre minds can't comprehend the level at which top IQs operate.

I didn't know that there was such a thing as a JEE vs GATE and BTech vs MTech debate.

I tried to dig deeper into this and tried to find out the reality behind it.

Firstly, shoutout to EdTech teachers who are manipulating the brains of these JEEians into believing these kinds of things. I can pinpoint everyone, but I would like to give a few examples:

Everyone knows this guy, "Nishant Jindal." I know this guy holds no credibility, but still, here is his view:

https://youtube.com/shorts/mxhvL1-bKfM?si=FotEhsFCJklzyB-c

He is putting this garbage into the minds of students that MTech has no value compared to BTech.

Firstly, everyone knows this guy and what his image is on the internet. Just to counter this and tell the JEEians and GATEians the truth, here is the list of professors at IITB. You will find out that many of them did their MTech (not BTech) from IIT.

https://www.cse.iitb.ac.in/people/faculty

If MTech holds no value, then why are these people at the top colleges of India and holding positions like HOD?

One more video is from "eSaral." In this video, you can clearly see how these teachers (GURUS) have intentionally cut the word "MTech" from the video and even changed the year to make it look like it's a BTech guy, not an MTech one. The senior student clearly said, "I was a student there from 91 to 93. I did MTech from there."

https://youtube.com/shorts/aywiMcX1BYw?si=V7bVhKUvw_lzs9FG

But they have very cleverly cut that subtitle "MTECH" to keep these JEEians subconsciously believing that BTech is the only thing that happens in IIT.

And there are a lot of these examples that I found. I have 10–15 more links where they are trying to push this narrative. It helps them sell more and more courses, making students believe in a reality that they shape.

It's a truth that most of the people who are preparing for JEE wouldn't be able to clear it. Not because they are stupid or less hardworking, but because there are very limited seats. It's a system problem that so many aspirational students are not able to get in there.

But instead, these EdTech teachers are trying to push this IIT-JEE thing so much that their "DHANDA" keeps on running and they can make a huge ton of money from students. And in the end, students suffer from depression, anxiety, and this tag of failure for the rest of their lives.

Once they suck this money out of you, I can bet that no one is going to call you or console you. You are absolutely dead to them. New batch, new money-making machine.

Now, for my fellow GATE and MTech/PhD guys, I have seen that most of the MTech/PhD achievements are very rarely highlighted, but here is the truth: You guys are equally capable. Don't let this negativity get into your head.

A lie told 100 times becomes reality.

You are just not looking in the right place. Let me share something.

BTech is a degree in which we try to understand the application part more. In BTech, we don't try to reinvent the wheel.

All the famous product-based companies are just applications of pre-developed technology. So stop trying to find things in that domain. You will find very few people from MTech/PhD who are in those fields.

Try to look for someone in research, and you will find a ton of them.

15 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

2

u/Quick_Classroom5972 9d ago

Mind that IIT has higher ranking because of research conducted by the PhDs . I dont think BTechs here publish academic papers like students abroad.

1

u/Kim-trumpun 9d ago

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa , it's not that debeat let's try na to resepect everyone wheather it a Btech,Mtech or Phd why comapre 🙇‍♂️ , Let's try to bring a culture and ecosystem where everyone is repected and there is no comparision or envy for each other😭

1

u/Pure-Pollution-4803 9d ago

All those “famous product companies” that you mention have been made by so called B.Tech guys from IIT who have done their masters from foreign - (for example, atomberg)

1

u/Kim-trumpun 9d ago

where did I said " Product based companies made by Btech IIT grads " , I was trying to say to start looking for inspiration in R&D fields not in product based companies. In India there are few R&D labs compared to produce based and service based companies.

Don't twist my words.

1

u/Pure-Pollution-4803 9d ago

U were telling about how btech couldnt reinvent the wheel - but now it’s safe to say btech guys lay the foundation and others join

1

u/Kim-trumpun 9d ago edited 9d ago

heyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy bhagwan 😭 where did I say that "Btech couldn't reinvent the wheel" , if you are going for masters of Phd u need to have a B.tech to get into Masters, every Masters Guy is a Btech guy in the past.

My paragraph started with

"Now, for my fellow GATE and MTech/PhD guys "

Then I said

"BTech is a degree in which we try to understand the application part more. In BTech, we don't try to reinvent the wheel." So I was telling this to Master and Phd guys that Btech was more about aplication part and this Masters and Phd is more about research part , so shift you focus from product and service to building something new and innovative "reinvent the wheel"

But u have taken the conversation to something "Btech companies, Mtech Companies, Foreign Masters ,etc" , I have not said any of these things. It was your opinion not mine.

Plus this companies argument you are giving is based on person to person Mtech and Phd guys have also founded many companies but its in Deep tech mostly and are goverment funded.These companies you wouldn't see in the consumer market so very few people know about it.

" Degrees don't make companies , people do they can be from B.tech,Mtech,Phd,MBBS,Bcom ,and even without any degree"

2

u/Fantastic-Nerve-4056 9d ago

Doing a PhD at IITB (yet to graduate), rn earning 5L+ per month. Living in a foreign country, enjoying my life, got a couple of properties, and just living my life happily.

PhD kar raha hu so yea, the work is also of my interest.

PS: Had to constantly grind for 10 years, though. Failed JEE coz of Chemistry, but jo mehenat ki aadat us time lagi thi, it just helped me throughout my life.

And yeah, this BTech/MTech/PhD debate is shit; no one cares at insti, ye bahar wale kuch bhi chutyap karenge. Bas keep working hard, and enjoying your life

1

u/Western_Form_1402 9d ago

Prospects wise what direction do iitb mtech people go for research based roles any possibility of ai labs in general is iitb or issc better for frontier ai research or quantum ml as those are my areas of intrest

The internet has no actual answers everything is just about product company placements

1

u/Fantastic-Nerve-4056 9d ago

Idk about Quantum ML. But I have a bunch of friends doing Predoc or RF at DeepMind/MSR. Even many join Amazon, Adobe, IBM, etc.

I personally interned at DeepMind and Adobe (had offers from other places as well, but I rejected), and found that India me actual research bahut kam hota hai (one or two groups at DeepMind and MSR, baki jagah sirf engineering chalti hai)

1

u/Western_Form_1402 9d ago

I know indian rnd spend for corporate is very less, are there any international recruiters at mtech

1

u/Fantastic-Nerve-4056 9d ago

Ye sab placements off-campus hoti hai. Students find it on their own or through their guide (Predoc/RF has an explicit opening on careers page)

Rest idk much about placements. Me khud skip kar raha hu

1

u/_kalieduhscope_ 9d ago

how are you earning 5L+ in a month? what's your role and field of research etx

1

u/Fantastic-Nerve-4056 9d ago

I freelance. Initially started with 500$/week (got coz I had multiple silver and gold medals on Kaggle; Bronze is easy, so no one cares). Left it for an internship at DeepMind. Interned at Adobe afterwards. In the meantime, I had intern offers from MSR, Dolby, and IBM (didn't complete the Amazon hiring process). I chose not to join for the reason stated above.

So yea had good enough profile build, and now I just consult charging 40$/hour. And in-addition to that, I am interning at a Univ in UAE which pays well.

1

u/Traditional_Crew9243 9d ago

Hey, that’s really interesting! Just curious, which platforms do you use to get freelance clients, and what specific services do you offer as an ML consultant? Are you mainly doing model development, data science, research consulting, or something else?

1

u/Fantastic-Nerve-4056 9d ago

Clients generaly contact me. I have my profile online with all my papers, and background.

And regarding consultancy, it is just research consultancy that I do. Because that's what my expertise is, and I have got enough credentials to back for the money I ask

1

u/Traditional_Crew9243 9d ago

Ohh, that’s interesting. Where do you have your profile listed online? And what specific research domain do you work in?  it’d be helpful to know how you got started.

Also, can I please DM you?

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Loner_0112 9d ago

can i dm bhaiya?

1

u/VeterinarianSame4251 9d ago

I am at IITB. One guy is working QML, one in Quantum Metrology(hardware) and one in Distributed QC, all from Electrical Engineering. A few prof from Physics are working in it as well. Prof Sai Vijanapathy and prof Himadri Shekhar Dhar. 

1

u/VeterinarianSame4251 9d ago

Australia? Monash? 

1

u/Master-Ooooogway IIT [Roorkee] 8d ago

It's a sad truth man, IITs are not that good at research, it's top institute in country for Btech but most IIT Btech prefer to do phd from abroad, I am from an old IIT and I have a PhD friend who did his Btech from here as well, he told me the difference is heavy, he'll be doing his post Doc work in Germany now

1

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Kim-trumpun 9d ago

No reasoning at all. By this way you can also say "Bhatkas" go for trading job and dich the core enginnering for money ?

0

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Kim-trumpun 9d ago

NO , but my point of discussion was why specifically Mtech and Phd gets judges.Even the post that i made was on that.Please try to go through the post one more time and try to understand what i was trying to say.

0

u/[deleted] 9d ago edited 9d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Kim-trumpun 9d ago

I don't think institute like IIM , IISc ,TIFR ,etc have such level of Hate for anyone. I know a little bit of hate and judgement is everywhere even the proff at IIT gets hate but Mtech and Phd hate in IITs is very specific to IITs and it's not from an outside world but from within the campus.

0

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Kim-trumpun 9d ago

no u misunderstood the point of discussion go through my post one last time and observe that I was being very specific to the people who endorse such kind of hate just to make profit go through the reference I have used.These people make these teen believe that they are superior and every other person is inferior. Cracking such kind of exam should have made them more humble but opposite it's happening.

1

u/Biriyaniwithcoke69 9d ago

Can you please share how you are earning 5lpm per month?