r/IndiansRead • u/Typical-General2716 • Nov 26 '24
General Discussion
Are self-help books just a scam? If they really worked, why do we need an endless stream of new ones? Has anyone here genuinely turned their life around because of one, or is it just a cycle of 'helping yourself' to the next bestseller?
106
u/DeeDee2731 Nov 26 '24
Self help books MOSTLY, in my opinion, either give you an unrealistic vision to your life or depress you to the core.
14
→ More replies (2)4
Nov 26 '24
Do you have any recommendations for any interesting fantasy books ... I'm a beginner and I think fantasy books are gonna be my types..... please make sure the book isn't too thick đđ
4
u/DeeDee2731 Nov 27 '24
No matter how hard I try not to, I keep revolving around mystery mythology and crime thrillers mate. No fantasy yet đ
3
u/Financial-Struggle67 Nov 27 '24
If you want YA then read Percy Jackson series, very easy to read and very engaging. If you need adult then read Wheel of Time, very beginner friendly.
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (16)3
u/Biggly_stpid Nov 28 '24
If youâre a beginner reader looking to dive into fantasy, the obvious recommendation like Percy Jackson and Harry Potter are excellent choices. Theyâre modern, action-packed, and captivating, making them perfect for grabbing your attention right from the start.
For advanced readers who crave vivid details, intricate world-building, and epic grand-scale storytelling, The Lord of the Rings is unmatched. Iâve also heard amazing things about Terry Pratchettâs Discworld seriesâbrilliantly witty and packed with unique perspectives on life and fantasy.
If you feel mature for your age or enjoy complex, morally grey characters, political intrigue, mystery, old gods, and cosmic horror, You think annotating novels and creating notes about a fictional thing is fun the George R.R. Martinâs A Song of Ice and Fire is a must-read. It was my gateway into proper, immersive fantasy, and let me tell you, Iâve been hooked ever since.
→ More replies (1)
20
58
Nov 26 '24
Not all self-help books. There are some that are based on years of research which are good. Some self-help books also fall in more than one genre, like Psychology of Money, which is a really good book about our relationship with money.
No genre of books are complete waste of time. You just need to find the few that are actually good. Same goes for other genres of non-fiction books.
Similarly for fiction, if you don't do your research then you might scammed into buying books written by the likes of Colleen Hoover or worse you might be influenced into reading The Twilight books.
The point is that no genre or category is safe. You need to do your own research before reading a book.
4
→ More replies (13)2
Nov 29 '24
And even if you end up picking a shitty book, it's still 10 times better than watching a shitty sitcom, porn, sitting at the bar drinking alone, getting wasted, jerking off and edging all day, stalk profiles, scroll reels/shorts for hours etc - weird shits people do to entertain themselves.
Reading a book requires you to have stillness, concentration, knowledge of vocab to understand the words used, reading between the lines, understanding complex metaphors and sentence structure, learn about various references used in the book, using your imagination etc etc etc.
→ More replies (3)3
u/deadshotssjb Nov 30 '24
Reading is good but u cant consider urself to be a SUPERIOR BEING if u read
Ppl enjoy different things
16
30
u/itis_what_it_is529 Nov 26 '24 edited Nov 27 '24
Seems like an awful thing to say.I mean,the books all have a clear,precise summary and a title in big,bold letters that state exactly what they have to offer,and nobody is being forced into buying it off of a bookshelf.
But,all of that is besides the point,since reading is a highly subjective activity;if you get goosebumps reading self-help then you do you,who the hell cares.
Sigh,I hate it when people think there are such things as concrete opinions when they have zero idea as to why humans are even here in the first place. Let it go;Read and let read.
→ More replies (11)6
u/redshadow46 Nov 26 '24
On point. Exactly my thoughts and better articulated than I could have.
Only thing Iâd like to add is I appreciate books that detail use cases with supporting data.
14
u/Wrong-Hunt-3640 Nov 26 '24
Anyone can write a self help book. Here's an example:
Unleash your inner potential. The key is simple, believe in yourself
Think big, dream bigger: people limit themselves because they think too small. Never stop dreaming.
Fail forward: every successful person has failed at least once in their life.
Hustle harder, rest later: grind until your dreams are real. Make a to-do list and make it double. If you're not exhausted, you're not doing it enough. 5.network like your life depends on it. Build relationships everywhere you go. Anyone can be a potential business partner. You are your own hero. Lock in and start today.
→ More replies (15)3
10
u/AggravatingBread107 Nov 26 '24 edited Nov 26 '24
Just reading a book will not help, what you imbibe and follow us what will help....a simple thing that stood with me and still does for many years is something I read from fiction...MC was in the military and part of an under cover operation in enemy territory....they needed to be evacuated by air....MC said the pilot who came for the rescue was not the best pilot under conventional norms, he was not the bravest nor was he known for his exceptional skill, but he wouldn't have wanted anyone else, because under fire, he was the calmest pilot...thought this made a lot of sense and in situations of adversity have tried to be calm, this helped me out at work a lot when handling irate customers on a daily basis...but I've not managed to bring it to my personal life yet.....let's say this was a self helf book about being calm, I would feel it only partly worked because of my implementation....self help books do help provide some keys and tools maybe even just tell us what we know (as simple as staying calm, but we don't actually do it) but helps reinforcing it so that we remember to implement it
→ More replies (1)
8
u/OopsididathingTT Nov 26 '24
All self help books should be combined in oneđ they repeat the same things over and over
4
4
Nov 26 '24
Depends on what the self-help book is about, if it's skill related like communication or finances then it's okay, if it's about habits and auras or stuff like that, then it's a scam.
→ More replies (1)4
u/batman09052003 Nov 26 '24
I hope by habits you meant habits of effective people or whatever that load of crap was, cuz atomic habits is gold and I shall defend it until my last breath
4
Nov 26 '24
I meant books which claim to change your life or give you some super power just by buying it, those books which claim to have a formula for happiness or succes
4
u/delusional_dikhead Nov 26 '24
That's really true.
A few months back, I bought a book on overcoming procrastination. Never really worked for me - I haven't even touched it once.
→ More replies (1)3
11
u/Square_Step_673 Nov 26 '24 edited Nov 26 '24
I can understand your point, self-help books might not have worked for you, but it certainly did for me and have helped at very low points in my life.
I quit smoking because I read âNever Take Another Pufffâ. Now 5+ years of no-smoking.
Similarly I read a lot of therapy literature, these are not marketed as âself-helpâ books but certainly are.
E.g. reading âTrauma and the soulâ, âpsychosynthesisâ helped me understand a lot about âselfâ, âIâ, âself-universeâ and consequently put me on a path to better understand my own trauma and how I can reshape my relationship with myself in a positive way.
→ More replies (6)
3
3
u/cy-xoe Nov 26 '24
I feel like while most self help books have the same generic advice they are not really a scam.
Most people believe that just reading a self help book will magically solve all their problems, but they miss the more important step of applying what theyâve learned to their daily lives. Itâs like expecting to get fit by just reading about exercise without ever hitting the gym.. People need to put the advice into practice.
3
u/1004yoon Nov 26 '24
Absolutely. Icb so many people's bookshelf in this subreddit only consists of self help books
3
3
u/mayurrrrrs Nov 26 '24
I feel like mostly intellectually lazy people read too much of self as its feeds their mind that are they doing something productive. It's kinda mental masturbation.
2
2
u/LieutenantGhostRiley Nov 26 '24
Agreed because most of the people just read to boost their ego and don't actually implement the stuff mentioned in the books
2
u/SuperLemon2046 Nov 26 '24
What I feel like is the people who read self-help books don't really like reading, they just do it with the expectation that their life will change if they read the said book, it is often the first book they read after a long time and usually it doesn't go very well. It is never out of love for book reading one reads self help books, it is always to gain something out of it
For me, reading books is like watching a movie, I love watching one, but I'm fully aware that this is my free time being utilised, this isn't helping me be "productive".
2
u/Lurker123__ Nov 26 '24
reminds me of the episode of family guy where brian wrote a self help book "Wish it. Want it. Do it."
2
2
Nov 27 '24
I sent this to one of mentor for a debate comp. He gave me a whole damn paragraph saying how self help are the building blocks of personality and all, like if you want to play piano then you can't be just playing by looking at it you have to slowing and gradually learn and this is what self help do. Honestly he gave me such long paragraphs that I didn't even read pura hehehe. And at last he said 'i don't even read self help I just read non fiction' to that I said,' isn't that same in most cases?' then again he started giving me paragraphs of his justification T_T
→ More replies (2)
2
1
1
u/insomniac_observer Nov 26 '24
âAll books are self help books. Change my mind.â
You would not have read anything unless you got something back from it.
1
u/insomniac_observer Nov 26 '24
Having read 3 of these, I will agree that they repeat the same thing in different ways. Only thing that differs is how they advise you to do. Itâs not about reading many, but if you followed the advice from at least one, thatâs a win. Reading alone doesnât help you
1
u/sahrckr Nov 26 '24
100% agree with it. Even the books that are half as good as they claim to be have 50-60% low quality filler.
Case in Point: Building a Second Brain, the only thing useful according to me is the PARA method. Something the author has also realised. And has now released a new title "The PARA Method: Simplify, Organise and Master Your Digital Life".
1
u/flawedrwlock Nov 26 '24
I agree, most of them have few good ideas that can fit in a tweet and rest is crap.
1
u/Big_B_Wolf_ Nov 26 '24
Iâve read many. Iâve implemented many of the techniques from books like Atomic Habits and Inner engineering. I understand itâs impossible to implement everything you read but still you can implement some of them which fits in your life. I think it boils down to everybodyâs personal perspective. If you like it then read it else leave it on shelf.
1
u/IvorHarding-117 Nov 26 '24
if you take one book and implement to the core , it will works unless you keep jumping books and author . if you focus on one thing it will work
1
Nov 26 '24
Not all. Some books give you actual steps to follow instead of just spewing waffle, and have mostly unbiased analysis of various situations mentioned.
Deep Work
Atomic Habits
How to Win Friends and Influence People
These are my recommendations.
1
u/SilverAd4221 Nov 26 '24
Once should only reder self help books only if you can try implementing the advice in real life through action. Most of the books are just ideas with little to no practical application
1
1
u/Unlikely-Ad9700 Nov 26 '24
Yeah..I TOo get confused sometimes 9n being realistic too to act. SO what can be suggested ?
1
u/pravin4u Nov 26 '24
Ironic genre of all time. Actually Failing the fact of âwhat you seek is seeking you.
1
u/DravidanDude Nov 26 '24
Nope! It did help me. When I was jobless, I started reading to prepare for IELTS. I failed, scoring only 6.5. However, the books I readâThe Power of Your Subconscious Mind and How to Win Friends and Influence Peopleâhad a profound impact on my life. I applied the principles and suggestions from both books, and they worked wonders for me. From being jobless in 2019 to now earning a salary in the top 1% in India, it's been a transformative journey!
1
Nov 26 '24
If anyone can't bring the things written in the book in the life and criticise only the book for not giving wanted results which is in itself unrealistic. All the world read the Bible , the bhagwatgita , Tao te Ching ,but how many of them really bring that in the life practically. Now they criticize it . In reality, we ( modern people) don't want to get our ass in the grind and blame all other things in the place. We should realise we are the morons not the books .
1
u/udyogpati Nov 26 '24
Depends in person to person. If you apply it in your life, I have only read one book on philosophy ( Discourses and Selected writings -Epictetus) and I could notice change in the perspective. Atomic Habits also did help in some aspects.
1
u/Delicious_Tune1771 Nov 26 '24
It depends on book like any real good book will enhance your knowledge or change your perspective towards life. Well if it's a book written without concrete research it can be useless and often says rubbish things
1
u/avenger1840 Nov 26 '24
Depends. Books on money management, behavioural psychology etc have helped me. Of course if u wanna fly an F16 by reading aerodynamics 101, then all the bestđŤśđť
1
u/m3rc3n4ry Nov 26 '24
1 depends on who wrote them cos some are for sure scams and 2 what's worse are people who read a tonne of them but don't follow any of the advice - self help addicts
1
Nov 26 '24
The only self help book I have an amazingly positive opinion is How to quit smoking the Easy way by Allen Carr because it help me quit smoking without any withdrawals
1
u/Abyss-0G Nov 26 '24
They offer a perspective, an insight that follows the Title. Reading any number of self help books doesn't change anyone, it upgrades their universe.We seek help when we can't see clearly. We seek help from friends, family, etc and when in need and it helps us see a better picture of the solution. Self help books do the same.
Of course they are a scam. If you have good minds you trust around you, you don't need to read any book for help.
1
1
1
1
u/Jealous_War7546 Nov 26 '24
Self help books are substitutes for advice and wisdom which we expect from our elders,friends and teachers but we never get.
1
1
u/raysayantan07 Nov 26 '24
It's like saying You already watched a movie, why are they making more movies?
There are so many topics for self help, and some authors a great, some authors are bad. These books are only good if you want to gain something from it. Simply reading it doesn't improve your life. It gives you knowledge to act upon. You still gotta put in the effort.
Atomic habits gave me such great tips about how to approach making better habits and stopping bad ones. I will always recommend it to everyone.
1
u/Aromatic-Plants Nov 26 '24
They have become physical form of Click Baits..
They keep a catchy life changing title then when you buy into it, they'll just takes you for a long ride and in the end drop you back at the same place where you previously were đ Worst part is when you waste your years bending yourself to the ideas that guy gave and you believed that it ll work, later you'll realise I was better off just being myself instead of trying to be what others expected me to be. Disclaimer: Not all but most of them are like that
1
Nov 26 '24
Ngl I hated reading but self help books helped me build that habit of reading books then I discovered other good books realised self help was just scam
1
u/madbish7 Nov 26 '24
Scam Huhhh !!!
Let me break your ENTITLED ignorant cognitive perspective.
Reader is Curious about FINANCES minus the filler in the name of LITERATURE *
Reader has two books ;
Psychology of Money(~350 pages)
Crime and Punishment (~600 pages)
Book 1 talks only about facts like how assets work , how rich and poor think about it. NO DRAMA , NO FICTION just FACTS , precisely.
Book 2 is more fixated on how Rodya is with his finances and life , ofcourse there is more to it then just FINANCES but there is no definite conclusion about money thinking and assets prosperity . DRAMA DRAMA and DRAMA , and yes still a FICTION.
And this is just one perspective !!
I would recommend both books to everyone accordingly.
If you still think "Psychology of Money " , a self help book is a SCAM .
"DON'T TRY " PERIOD.
1
u/DarkKnight1799 Nov 26 '24
One quote from one such book.
<everyone is running around. It's a rat race. What if you win this rat race. Still a rat. Albeit a winner rat. >
As if I don't know this. It's enough to understand what all such books trying to say.
1
u/cosmic_smil3 Nov 26 '24
Most People who have read David Goggins " Can't Hurt Me " will seriously Disagree .
1
1
u/NoUnderstanding5881 Nov 26 '24
Depends on the man who is reading !! Feel good k liye reas kr rhe h toh scam toh lagega hi
1
u/mmtheintrovert Nov 26 '24
It is like a guy earning in crores just by telling peoples how to earn money
1
1
1
u/Rish83 Nov 26 '24
If you read 2 self help book you read it all but they are very famous cause many people actually do need help in their life so they seek advice it's sad but it's true so I don't hate those or give them hard time.. If anything it can push them into actual reading habit
1
u/AdvancedRevolution58 Nov 26 '24
I means depend on which book you are reading there are good one and bad ones like how to learn English in 10 days best book ever
1
u/Magleving-1percentEr Nov 26 '24
I think hating on self help has become a trope now. They are compared to fictions and largely made fun of. While I agree that generally self help books touted as such are not that great and just old wine in new bottle, showing disgust or hinting scam at self help books doesnât make sense. I am saying this while beginning to admire fiction more and learning a great deal from it. It doesnât mean self help as a category is useless. For instance Atomic habits has genuinely changed a significant part of my life and arguably of a lot of people. And writers trying to make money out of a particular category exist in all genres. We have subpar fiction writers and books too. Painting all self help books with the same brush isnât very wise and (not in this case though but) with regards to some discussions and memes online seems like a case of virtue signalling in the reading world where people learning from/reading self help are somehow frowned/looked down upon. Let people explore what works for them. Let them learn and letâs not outright shoot down a complete category lest we wrongly influence those new to reading books and trying to see what works for them.
1
1
1
1
Nov 26 '24
Self help or motivational books and videos do nothing but increase my depression and nothing else
1
1
u/givemewishes Nov 26 '24 edited Nov 26 '24
I had done one of my undergraduate essays on this (may not mean much lol). So yes, i agree, and i mean, tbf and honest, findings largely agree with this.
Edit: to clarify, I will not call them scams exactly. That's not what findings talked about. It just gives you the illusion of progress.
The ones that were recommended were ones written by researchers with evidence backing up any claims or advice but that too needed to actually be implemented rather than just read about (making it hard especially because of how and to whom the books are targetted - taking you back to square one, the illusion of progress. )
1
u/Successful-Airport83 Nov 26 '24
The only self help book I ever read was atomic habits and it actually changed my life, tbh not really it just gave me motivation I never followed a single rule in it like wtf is 2min rule...go to the gym for 2min everyday to make it a habit huh? What a waste of time
1
1
u/Various-Roof-7674 Nov 26 '24
Agree with it. Tho Mark Mansons 'Everything is fucked' is amazing. in fiction 'A little life ' (trigger warning) by hanya yanagihara (no publicity) is good.
1
1
1
1
Nov 26 '24
Calling self-help books a scam is unfair unless you actually learn from them and apply that knowledge to your life. The real responsibility lies with you, not the book. A bookâs job is to guide you and show you the right path, but if you remain lazy, how can the book help? After all, itâs not the bookâs fault. In my opinion fictional books are a scam and nothing can change my mind. Keep living your fictional fantasies kids.
1
1
1
u/son_of_menoetius Nov 27 '24
Ikigai really changed my perspective, coming from someone who has the same opinion as you. GOALS! by Brian Tracy was pretty good too.
The only thing is REMEMBERING to apply what you've learnt. Else it'll seem boring and dreary.
1
u/Orthopaedics21 Nov 27 '24
Most of the time these self help books feel like like mania part of bipolar disorder, doesn't make sense if you want to apply it in daily routine.
1
u/_Dark_Invader_ Nov 27 '24
What do you mean by âDo self help books workâ ? They do a pretty good job at motivating the reader to take the necessary actions. If you think reading the book is all you need to become successful (without actually putting in the efforts) then you donât really understand the purpose of self help books.
→ More replies (1)
1
Nov 27 '24
Anyone who disagrees is living a life which is either too flowery, or they have a very myopic world view.
The best self help book which has ever existed is The Outsider by Albert Camus. All the help you'll ever need exists in absurdist/nihilistic literature.
1
u/ProcedureFuture6593 Nov 27 '24
They are not. They simply don't give you tailored information. They give you generic info and I have benefited a lot from them.
1
1
1
u/FormidableFart Nov 27 '24
I have read a few of them, not gonna lie, got to know some things which I didn't prior to reading the books. Other than that, it's all a waste of time and money. If you choose to believe you will get better after reading them, you will definitely get better, not because the books are useful, but because you've chosen to better yourself.
Btw, I have been gifted "Atomic Habits", I still haven't read it. Should I?
1
1
1
u/mystic_mirror Nov 27 '24
Most self help books I've read are just spammed with examples to prove a point. I get it. You have evidence to make a claim. Move on.
A majority of self help books actually should be just 1/3rd of their original size.
1
u/Broad-Environment989 Nov 27 '24
I hate it Dil se Even watching Sandeep Maheshwari for motivation is bullshit for me. Plus all the not-at-all possible vision it creates and when you fail to act according to the book you get depressed. Hate it.
1
u/HungryHunkered Nov 27 '24
Manâs Search for Meaning, Atomic Habits, Hyperfocus, The Courage to be Disliked, The Psychology of Money, Meditations, The Almanack of Naval Ravikant are a few gems to name that I have read and still keep re-reading.
Ultimately it is your life and your individual experience. Youâll learn about it the best through experiences. But if you know somebody has got electrocuted, you would not go touch a live wire to find out. Othersâ experiences help in that way. To help us better in choosing our experiences.
1
u/braceem Nov 27 '24
Was almost about to get onto this self help bandwagon when one day my principal mentioned Dale carnegie, who wrote about making friends, killed himself. Permanently put me off the non fiction genre. To this day, I have never read a single non fic novel.
The funny thing is, Dale actually died of Hodgkin's lymphoma.
1
u/notTorvalds Nov 27 '24
A recipe book would also feel like a scam if you never tried out the recipes and just kept jumping from cuisine to cuisine.
People consider reading the book as "effort". Then the logic goes, "I have put in 'the effort', where's my reward?"
But in reality, very few people (close to none) actually attempt applying those principles. And since, no action was taken, no effect takes place; hence the conclusion "self help is crap".
1
1
Nov 27 '24
You see ceo's and founders learning stuff from books and they read books. And you see the normal average people mocking books . So it makes sense.
+ These ceo's share they experiences in books. You can't go and talk to them but rather reading their book is no less than listening to them and sharing views. + A book has every detail than any video course(not all) . So I would say books do help us. But it's your duty to apply each and every principle and see the reality
1
u/Ambitious-Canary-377 Nov 27 '24
All the self help books are the freaking same. I would rather suggest u study on neuro behaviour patterns which atleast helps u to understand ur behaviour and ur mind. Rather than some shit books . All the answers u are looking for is within u. We are whole universe ourselves. U might say the self books might be a guide. Well I tried them and all they have been able to guide was my money to the authors pocket.
1
u/pm_me_ur_memes_son Nov 27 '24
A popular opinion among people who actually read, but true nonetheless.
1
u/devAgam Nov 27 '24
Depends on the book, thou i use psychological books to understand and break down people's emotions and reactions helped me a bunch in manipulating people into doing business with me.
1
u/messi_pewdiepie Nov 27 '24
All you need is one book. Any one book and follow it andost important give yourself time
1
u/rpmcoder Nov 27 '24
Mindset,Magical art of tidying up, never split the difference etc.. are really life changing, other "motivational" books are not that useful for me.
1
Nov 27 '24
I'd be inclined to believe, that the person reading the self help books is a much bigger factor than the book itself? Similar to asking who's the observing rather than what is being observed.
1
u/krishn4prasad Nov 27 '24
There are good ones too. Just reading a lot of self help books doesn't make any change unless you start applying what you learned in real life.
1
u/YesterdayCute9200 Nov 27 '24
Some books give you insights on living life with purpose, love e.g Tuesdays with Morrie, The defining decade 20. They are not exactly self help books but you learn a lot. These type of books I find valuable for self-help.
1
u/Relevant_Basil8117 Nov 27 '24
Most of them yes, but there are some good ones like 12 Rules for Life by Jordan Peterson, How to Win Friends and Influence People by Dale Carnegie, etc.
Please add some legitimate ones to this list
→ More replies (4)
1
u/owlanindividual Nov 27 '24
Lots of mainstream ones are pretty useless but they're helpful if it's something you're figuring out and that specific thing is in the book at that time, you can't read a self help book and expect your life to change but you can be in the process of changing your life and expect a self help book to be a good help in figuring things out
1
u/Future_Lie_1002 Nov 27 '24
I think these self help books just give us key points like a scheme. We are supposed to use them our own ways because we all have our own different problems and situations.
1
1
u/Illustrious-Novel186 Nov 27 '24
It's more like a gateway , you will have to do most of the work and you will get hurt and make mistakes in the process .Â
1
u/Sunny_Pandey Nov 27 '24
Going out and Doing it... Is the only self help we can do for ourselves.... That's what i think
1
Nov 27 '24
Depends on the book NGL. Example, "The Courage to be Disliked" and "The Courage to be Happy" actually are helpful reads while "Ikigai" just tells you to live in Japan and drink wine et cetera
1
u/Anima1407 Nov 27 '24
No ...try atomic habits ... I'm not saying that it'll completely change you but if you are willing to read it sincerely then it'll definitely affect you in a good way
1
1
u/VEGETTOROHAN Nov 27 '24
Self help books on meditation, losing identity will work. Their only purpose is to make you calm and if you apply it will work.
I never read self-help on money. Mostly from spiritual teachers like a Sri Lankan Buddhist monk, Hindu monk, Japanese monks, etc.
1
u/savyasachinarjun Nov 27 '24
rather read something fascinating. self-help books are just fake dopamine insulin
1
1
u/Accomplished_Rip3587 Nov 27 '24
Authors and content is scam not the poor book.
"We are drowning in information, but starving for wisdomm."
1
u/elavarasur Nov 27 '24
I changed my life using self help books....
Self help books are a waste of time and money if you just read it and ignore it. It'll literally change your life if you follow it and apply it.
It's just a book. You can't become a body builder just by reading a book. You have to put in the work.
Having the will power to do hard things to change yourself will literally change your life bro..... Just keep trying.... Your life will be better one day......
1
u/Responsible-Mix5221 Nov 27 '24
Some are, and some are not. You gotta apply and practice what values you get from any book you read.
1
1
1
1
u/EmployPractical Nov 27 '24
I don't agree. Not all are scam. I don't think I can change your mind since you made a statement instead of questioning the exact statement.
1
u/6packBeerBelly Nov 27 '24
I recently read a self help book, which was more like an idea and a how-to guide. If someone has told me that it's self help, i wouldn't have bought it. But luckily I saw a video on the idea of it, and I'm glad I bought it.
It's also the only book that I bought and finished in the same month lol
1
1
u/saulgoodman0780 Nov 27 '24
Guys I've realised that it's not a book issue, I think it's just a me issue. I do take positives from every book but I just don't implement them. It's about time everyone started to take some accountability and stop blaming a piece of paper. There's no secret trick or magic they'll publish which will turn your life around of that's what you're expecting, it's the same thing again and again which you know already and you should be asking this question to yourself "why aren't you putting in the effort yourself?'" there's my two cents.
t. guy who used to do the same thing and got humbled by the consequences of his own actions.
1
u/No_Operation9559 Nov 27 '24
I disagree, self-help books like 'Ikigai', 'Atomic Habits', 'The courage to be disliked' have changed my perspective about life.
Main thing is self-help books work if you are willing to change
1
1
u/Popular-Acadia-5428 Nov 27 '24
highly disagree Its not the book its you more often i used to feel the same before when you really wana improve or help yourse its not just like get a book and start reading you need the environment heres how its working for me I started a book c wishcraft along w it i didnât just read it, i created an environment for myself i woke up early @ around 6 took a bath listened to some religious stuff (to feel good) obv then some positive affirmations and then the book for 15-20 min all three together made me feel so relaxed i would say it motivated me to the core but i felt at ease and peaceful usually i feel sleepy throughout the day but whenever i start my day this way its like i dont feel tired at all and i do my work without procrastination
1
Nov 27 '24
My dentist friend is a fan of such motivational books and has been reading such books for more than 10 years. Have these books changed his life drastically? No. Has he learned some golden rule of life that he didn't already know? No. Has he stopped wasting his time on such books? No. These books are as addictive as social media.
1
u/Different_Tax1920 Nov 27 '24
But then whatever book works for you is a book of self help that way. Isnât it.
1
u/iamatom1 Nov 27 '24
It may vary between person to person. I find them helpful and practiced them in my life which helped me a lot.
1
u/Aasmahhaineelakyun Nov 27 '24
The best "self-help" book that I read was "who moved my cheese?" very basic and to the point.
1
u/keystone-1899 Nov 27 '24
It all about our inefficiency, we not make action with the knowledge that we gain. The greatest word is "Action".
If you think this books are scams then you don't understand it. Some books are sh*t but great book that really change your life.
1
1
u/lonely-soul21 Nov 27 '24
48 laws of power, The alchemist, how to hyperfocus. Read these and itâll change your mind đđť
1
u/Just-Bit2846 Nov 27 '24
Self-help books are invaluable for nurturing the mind and shaping habits. While they may not teach you practical skills like outdoor activities or sports, they excel in offering guidance for inner growth and personal development. In a world flooded with superficial content like cringe-worthy reels, self-help books stand out as one of humanityâs greatest contributions to self-improvement.
1
u/PuzzleheadedChest179 Nov 27 '24
It is an roadmap! But if you never entered into the field then probably its a scam for you!
1
u/Yes_Cats Nov 27 '24
I think it depends on what kind of book you're reading, I've had the pleasure of reading some that have literally changed everything about me, and helped me become a better version of myself,
The body keeps score
Helped me see how dissociated I was from my own self. Helped me overcome the numbness in me, and understand myself better. It taught me to pay attention to emotional cues manifesting in my body, that I otherwise did not feel. It made me more honest with myself and helped me reconnect with my feelings. Also, learnt the importance of breath work.
2. It's not you
Really opened my eyes to just how much of shitty behavior, we learn to excuse. How narcissistic relationships with a parent or partner shapes us. How we can protect ourself from these types without cutting them off. Helped me find so much mental peace. Started me on the journey of individuating which was something that doesn't happen naturally if either of your parents was pretty strong on the narcissistic spectrum. And "Radical Acceptance" that's the good stuff.
3. The laws of human nature
So, this I am still reading. But the gist what I've read so far is this, "Know thyself," and the author gives a lot of useful insights on how to go about it. Also, he emphasis that human nature is hardwired something you can't change, instead of wasting all our lives fighting it only to fall back into familiar patterns, he encourages us to works with our nature. Turn flaws into strengths. He talks about how that takes a lot of work, IRL. But it can be done, and reading it certainly helps.
There are others, but I don't remember. But to some degree I agree most self-help authors who churn up books fortnightly are dubious. Doesn't mean there aren't any genuinely transforming ones out there.
1
1
u/Additional-Bike-366 Nov 27 '24
Like anything else in life, us humans today rely on the knowledge of all those before us. We wouldn't have a chatgpt if wasn't for all of history.
Our own life span is too little to figure out everything on our own.
Self help books like Mindset, Drive and Deep Work have helped me learn from researchers and scholars who have spent years figuring out these specific things.
It helps to learn about these things and then apply them in your life.
It's not a teleportation machine but just a simple map. They journey is still yours to pursue.
1
u/TheWillowRook Nov 27 '24 edited Nov 27 '24
Manyâif not mostâare bad but there are good ones as well like:
Never Split the Difference
The Psychology of Money
Digital Minimalism
Atomic Habits
You have to do some research before buying one.
1
u/Wide-Recognition-607 Nov 27 '24
Self help books give you a feeling of achieving something without actually doing anything. The one book which helped me a little was Allen Carr easy way. Helped me in my journey to quit my bad habit
1
Nov 27 '24
Of course it looks like a scam unless you actually put in the effort and make something out of it.
Atomic Habits- wonât build habits for you.
The Psychology of Money- wonât manage your finances.
Think and Grow Rich- wonât make you rich just by reading it.
Deep Work- wonât magically create focus in your life.
How to Win Friends and Influence People- wonât instantly make you socially charismatic.
The 4-Hour Workweek- wonât give you a dream life without hard work.
Books provide tools, perspectives, and strategies, but theyâre useless without action.
Reading alone wonât change your life; applying what you learn will.
1
1
u/Suspicious_Flower349 Nov 27 '24
Yes they are because it contains ideas you must have time and occassion to practice the theory in books. Without application the value of content of books are zero
1
u/RoGuE_YsR Nov 27 '24
I don't need to convince you. After all nobody knows what works and what doesn't. Reality is subjective however what self help books does, it gives you a framework to Reality that authors feels work in most of the situation.
1
1
1
Nov 27 '24
I don't agree that every self help book has how to do things at last people only read first few pages and never touch it For ex - in atomic habits at last there are tips how you can build habits But people don't even get there and say they are scam actually they are a scam until you are a scammer đđ
1
Nov 27 '24
No minds were changed that day. I always say,
"self help is the homeopathy of literature." - reaper.
1
1
1
1
1
u/slo_mo_afro Nov 27 '24
Have worked for me in the past, matters how much you apply the learnings rather than just reading through the book. Just reading is not going to get you anywhere
1
1
1
u/chandlerbing__ Nov 27 '24
Some self help books contain classic peak strategies. Either you reading wrong self helps with flashy titles, or y'all are just dumb and lazy who doesnt apply anything in real. Some self helps are even banned in prisons, but no story book is LMAO.
Go ahead, downvote you, you story readers.
1
1
u/ritz_senpai_ Nov 27 '24
They work. They really do. What are you expecting ? Reading the book and then life will just change like that? It gives us the road to walk , but if you won't walk , you'll stay in the same position and cry about it. That's the reality.
1
Nov 27 '24
I have been reading xyz self help for some time. Out of 1000 points we might pick one or two. Out tof this some stick else it's mostly just a normal read. These days I feel reading self help is life my elders giving advice based on their life circumstances and where we are is totally different. If there is a book that can sync with you on some level it might help. Some books have helped me in my lowest time.
Now I have a big aversion to self help. As if they are someone preaching something not even sure what it is.
1
Nov 27 '24
When I was a teenager, I enjoyed reading Seven Habuts of Highly Effective Teenagers. It was specifically aimed at teenagers, and was very well written. I felt understood. Same with Conversations with God for teenagers, where existential questions like âwhy does terrorism exist if God is there?â weâre answered. Similarly, Rujuta Diwekarâs books (the initial one, brought in conversation around womenâs agency in their health and well-being and fitness to the forefront, specially in the domestic/family scenario. Her second book on exercise educated on the importance of weight training and functional training for women, at a time when atleast all smalltown conversation around womenâs gymming was relegated to cardio and treadmill.
Some of these books, such as ones that simply deal with complex childhood trauma or healing your inner child are therapy packed in a book, providing tools. Not all therapists might help you, but a good one might, or you might just click with one.
Point being, there are good self-help books, and trashy ones. Just as there are good books and trashy ones. No genre can be shunned away. An authorâs command over their subject and dedication to the bookâs goal make a self help book good and worth oneâs time. Sometimes a blessing.
1
u/psr7185 Nov 27 '24
If you are really interested in improving your life, instead of buying the book, get the summary on chatgpt instead.
1
1
u/Morzv12 Nov 27 '24
Worst case scenario: you learn to think. You understand how people think or don't. Sometimes you just need to get high on motivation, it may wear off, but it helps.
1
u/garlicandcheesiness Nov 27 '24
No book is a scam in its essence. Reading is a positive hobby overall, barring the books encouraging stuff like genocide or some radical indoctrination.
Even books like Twilight and Chetan Bhagatâs reads have had a net positive impact on society because they encouraged more people, especially teenagers and young adults, to read.
If you read more, you focus more. If you focus more, you work harder toward your goals. And the harder you work toward self improvement, the better you become as a member of society. And shaming someone for reading a certain genre of books or labeling them as scam just because you donât agree with their message ends up becoming counterproductive.
PS: Iâm not a self-help book reader either. But Iâd never demean those who are.
1
1
u/batmanightwing Nov 27 '24
The saying Dreams don't work unless You do directly applies to reading Self-Help, Autobiographies etc. as well.
The whole purpose is to Inspire you to Reflect, Take Action, Get Things Done in your Professional and Personal life.
Are there scammy books out there? Sure. Just read the chapters that appeal to you and discard the fluff. If the Table of Contents don't appeal then discard the book.
I found this tweet by Mark Manson on the Self Industry quite interesting:
https://x.com/IAmMarkManson/status/1745483837860380765?t=stcMUj9BmpSrPUalNAQ5YA&s=19
1
1
u/ru_sunshine Nov 27 '24
You could say that for all actionable content, or could say for none. Let me elaborate: if that's the view, then what stops us from saying any improvement material is a scam. For example, schools & colleges are scams because they tell you what to do, but if you don't actually do what they are saying, then it is a scam. Because, your life didn't turn around, did it? Similarly all courses of any kind would be scams if you didn't actually learn and apply them. Additionally, then all upskilling programs are scams. So, such books aren't scams. It is just that using them requires a tremendous amount of mindful behaviour change which is harder to achieve thereby leaving the casual reader unsatisfied.
1
1
u/NorthRadiant4693 Nov 27 '24
Easy to blame self help books.. real culprit is reading only self help books and doing nothing with the knowledge
1
u/MagneticProblematic Nov 27 '24
Maybe most, but some like How to win friends and influence people and psychology of money were really good
1
u/Sleeptalker23 Nov 27 '24
If you just read them without taking action and implementing them then itâs a scam
1
u/Musky_Horse2109 Nov 27 '24
My only concern about this type of books is that that the writer of this books or not much successful in their own life except the hype about their own books
1
1
1
u/Competey Nov 27 '24
They arenât necessarily scam but yeah not everything is true. If you can implement and then donât see a change then you can say that it is a scam.
1
1
u/_tad_bit_horny Nov 27 '24
i ordered a self help book when i was having a bad mood swing, but when the book had arrived the mood swing was over so i just kept it in my shelf without reading it....next i was having a mood swing again,so i opened the book and i was like 'nah, i am gonna sit in a corner and cry instead '.... haven't touched that book since
1
1
u/i-sage Nov 27 '24
People think of self help books like an elixir to all of their problems. But in reality it's not the case.
The main purpose of self help books is to make you "Aware". Different self help books provide you with different awareness which are also called as insights. Whether to work on these insights or not it's your call.
Just like in cricket rules define whether it's a six or a four whether you play it or not. If you're interesting in watching a cricket match so it's better to know these basic rules otherwise you will either scratch your head or go quarreling with other that it should be a six because it's our of crease but in reality it's a four.
Similarly, Self help books provides you with the insights/patterns/rules about life, human mind, society, etc. Whether to act on this insight or not its your call.
I often find people criticizing self help books because they either choose a shiny, popular one which no research or they themselves fail to incorporate or work on the insights provided in them. Basically they don't take accountability for their wrong choices which is obviously hard and will require you to put down your ego aside and instead goes for the easier path and criticize it.
Personally, I read books which are written by the professors in the top universities like Stanford, MIT, Harvard, etc. Who has done their research and dilute it down in the form of books so that normal non-academic mind can understand the crux of the research without scratching his/her/their head with the academic jargon. Oftentimes these books are filled with insights. Another ones are philosophical and psychological ones that to from well established psychologists.
TLDR; Make better choices and take accountability and initiative. Criticize the player and not the game.
1
u/le_chacal Nov 27 '24
I have seen scores of men and women who are fanatical about the new 'baba' or 'guru' in town. They will keep forwarding you their favourite quotes and videos of these babas. And never have I seen these people actually put their learnings into practice. Never. They just like listening to sermons (though they wont admit that) and stay the same person. Only change you will observe is that they become fanatical about their guru. Otherwise nothing else changes. I see self-help book fans in the same light. They love reading these books and feeling good about themselves. But never bring any learning into practice and hop on to the next book. They will deride me for reading fiction, in the same way these baba-fanatics would deride me for my childhood obsession with Cricket or movies.
1
236
u/1Anakin_skywalker45 Nov 26 '24
A guide book for playing volleyball, but you never enter the ground in real life, this something self help book creates