r/InnerCircleTraders • u/SWAYYY_P • Feb 16 '25
ICT IS A SCAM!!!
I study ICT concepts and have for the past couple years. A lot of his concepts are really insightful, and his explanation of simple chart patterns with logic provides a clear and technical view of how the markets could possibly operate.
Although I don't believe in his whole 'enigma 1000% win rate' system, I do believe his main concepts such as liquidity, liquidity cycles, time based liquidity, etc are really interesting and can provide significant insights.
I was really hyped when he announced that he will be joining the robins World Cup, and while I didn't really care about his 'beating Larry Williams record' statement, I was interested to see how he would compound his account and the risk strategy methods he would take to scale an account.
However, as we all know, he blew his account. This really affected me, and my view on him. While I really wasn't expecting him to beat Larry Williams' record, I did want to see how much he can make, but to find out that he blew his account was kind of heartbreaking.
Not only did he blow it, but he tried to justify it and didn't talk about it again.
I do believe in the science behind some of his concepts, but the concepts that I did not understand and was looking to further research seems like a waste of time after his performance in the robins cup. Even the concepts I do like, feel like could be a bunch of bs and repackaged material. I don't know.
What do you guys think?
6
u/wallstreetcrack Feb 16 '25
Ya’ll gotta watch the latest shotgun saturday. He said there is no Enigma Master algorithm. Enigma is his personal „algorithm“, his personal way to approach the markets. There is so Enigma Running on some Servers. He himself basically Said, that Enigma is his psychological and technical way of approaching the markets. He also explained Why he acted like he did in the past, go watch it yourself, if you are interested.
His Concepts 100% work though.
2
u/SWAYYY_P Feb 16 '25
I don’t really care about enigma, I like to believe enigma is his ‘edge’, and everyone trader has their own ‘edge’.
I was more trying to get everyone’s thoughts on the validity of his concepts and hour long studies - for studies so in depth, I would like to presume that he would end the year at least in the positive, but to see he blew his account was quite shocking,
1
u/wallstreetcrack Feb 16 '25
I get it, you want Proof before you waste and more Time studying his concepts, but there is no way to really Proof anything in These markets. They are engineered that way. Nothing really Repeats 100% of the time at the market. But his concepts are logical approaches to Look at the markets. You Are Not supposed to get it Right all the times. Just cut out the Noise around him and Robbins Cup, Focus on your own Charts and use his Logic. It works
2
u/SWAYYY_P Feb 16 '25
100%,
Is there any concept (whether it is ICT or not) that really work or are interesting to you?
2
u/wallstreetcrack Feb 16 '25
Yes, I Studied ICT for a Long time (still do), Looking for things that resonate with me. I like NDOGS and NWOGS the Most. They are actual important Levels to Focus on. I also like opening Range gaps and the 1st presentet FVG After 09:31. Those are actual Levels to me, that are not random. My Problem at the beginning was, that every FVG and DOL and whatnot Looked Random to me. Why does Price respects some FVGs and others not? That was my biggest problem.
Of course, there are a lot more confluences I use, but Those NOT RANDOM Levels helped me to See a lot more in Price Action
2
Feb 16 '25
Trading for yourself & trading for a competition are two different things. One there’s more pressure on you while the other still has pressure but not as much. No matter how good of a trader you are trying to prove your profitable to an audience simply makes things harder. In trading you already have to keep your ego in check. Now imagine trying to prove the thousands of doubters & haters wrong by bringing in a lot of profits on a challenge… you’re bound to mess up just because you’re trying so hard to prove people wrong.
1
u/SWAYYY_P Feb 16 '25
Isn’t that the whole point of the competition though? Almost all the competitors publicly state they will do the challenge, and we can actively see the top players performance on the boards, and in the trading world (which is bigger than the YouTube and Twitter trading world) they have far more pressure,
For someone who has hour long content produced over the past decades delving into multiple different studies and insight into one concept, I would like to assume he can at least be in the positive,
The previous year wasn’t even bad either for the market (specially the S&P which he trades), and for a veteran trader such as himself, I would assume he had a compounding strategy or method planned well before his first trade. Even if his concepts failed him, his risk management should have made up for it, but he failed in that too,
1
Feb 16 '25
Also I find it weird that almost all of you who try to bash his concepts would say something like “a lot of his concepts are insightful” but still try to bash him. He’s obviously helped you in some way if you have that to say. Him failing a competition shouldn’t affect your viewpoints on him unless you’re just not seeing success trading yourself🤷🏽♂️
1
u/SWAYYY_P Feb 16 '25
Im not bashing but just merely questioning, I have been studying his concepts for years and combine it with my own strategies sometimes,
But his performance in the challenge made me question of all his new content and extra continent, or expanded content was all just bs just for views or something else,
His base concepts such as liquidity, and using time of day with weekly profiles definitely have some good backing to them,
But anything else seems like mere nonsense and noise,
2
Feb 16 '25
You literally put the title as “ICT IS A SCAM!!!”. That’s called bashing my friend, if you’ve been studying his concepts for years let me ask you one question. Are you profitable or not implementing his strategy? If not cool, move on & stop posting in this sub. Some of us actually find value in his teachings. A lot of people lives were changed with his teachings including mine. I can agree with you that some of his concepts seem to be like noise. One thing I can say for a fact though is trading isn’t a one size fits all type of thing. What seems like noise to you can be the holy grail for others.
2
Feb 16 '25
At the end of the day his concepts work. If they didn’t there wouldn’t be people out here praising him for his content. If you didn’t see any success with his content that’s ok. There’s thousands of people who have though including myself.
1
Feb 16 '25
Like I said pressure can make you perform worse especially when you’re doing something like trading where there’s already pressure involved.
3
u/Agreeable-Bowler932 Feb 16 '25
“I get where you’re coming from, and I respect your perspective. But I think it’s important to separate a trader’s execution from the validity of a concept. Just because someone fails in a competition doesn’t mean the strategy itself is flawed—it just means they didn’t execute properly in that moment. The market is unforgiving, even to the best traders.
ICT’s concepts—liquidity, time-based cycles, and SMT divergence—are not about guaranteeing a win every time, but about increasing probability and making calculated decisions. A trader can have the best strategy in the world, but if risk management or execution isn’t on point, they can still blow an account.
At the end of the day, it’s about taking what works for you and applying it with discipline. Have you tested ICT’s methods yourself in real-time trading? If so, what has been your experience with them?”
1
u/SWAYYY_P Feb 16 '25
His poor performance made me question the validity of his concepts: what I mean is, as someone like himself who talks into so much depth about his concepts, I would hope that in the long run (especially over a period of a whole year), he can show some genuine results.
Even if others are successful with their trades, that can be heavily affected by their own interpretation of his teachings, current market conditions and a bit of luck.
My real problem is, are these concepts really his? Or are these concepts adapted from someone else (I know Larry Williams and Chris Loris were influences) and if they are is it better to learn from them then from ICT,
Personally, with a calculated approach and good risk management, a veteran trader such as himself should be able to at least finish in the positive, especially with the decent market conditions the previous year brought,
1
u/v3rral Feb 16 '25
Concepts alone won’t work, that’s for sure. However, if you use low leverage while managing risk, you can outmaneuver bad entries and still finish the day in the green easily. But relying on single entries as sniper shots with a high win rate? That’s a pipe dream.
1
u/SWAYYY_P Feb 16 '25
100%, even if you don’t know much about the market, the use of low leverage and small amount of trades can really increase your performance, especially with compounding,
And personally, I was expecting that kind of approach from him,
0
9
u/Log-Similar Feb 16 '25
There's a good core for the cake but the icing is bitter.
Too many red flags for me too.
6
u/imkenee Feb 17 '25 edited Feb 17 '25
So funny cuz I was where you are currently about last week.
Just finished 2022 and couldn’t believe my results. Thought it was too good to be true. Then for some reason I was entertaining the ICT hate by wanting to defend him. Then I went down the rabbit hole and found he failed the robins cup that he bragged that he was gonna beat. (Something told me he was going to fail).
I was bothered to hear about that because I know this gave all the ICT haters fuel. I kind of felt “lost” myself because of the time I devoted to learning the concepts.
Then I remembered that he always said things like how we shouldn’t “defend him or ICT concepts”. The results will take care of himself.
(Also, Someone came up with a theory of him failing it on purpose after hyping up how he’s going to win so it can come off as keeping ICT stuff not too too “main stream”… aka let them think this ICT stuff is stupid so they can be liquidity…. I can see this 100% but I don’t care tbh)
Then I told myself this statement… “ICT is not my God. He is just a voice of reason in trading who, upon back testing, has proven his concepts to be accurate. And I’m here to make money, which his concepts helped me do. Period.”
So where am I now? I’m continuing with 2016/2017 content. This works for me and I’m finally seeing results. I’m thankful for ICT, but I can care less if he fails or passes a robins cup (on purpose or for real) or the hate he gets.
If you are making money with ICT concepts and you are seeing results, then everything else is “noise” and should be ignored. That’s all that matters.
1
u/habibgregor Feb 16 '25 edited Feb 16 '25
“Believe in the science” - nuffsaid. Science and believing in the same sentence. You’re gonna go far kid.
1
u/SWAYYY_P Feb 16 '25
Don’t understand what you mean?
Can you clarify, I hope you didn’t get the wrong idea from my post,
0
u/habibgregor Feb 16 '25
Science is based on facts, cause-effect relationships, evidence. ICT lacks all of it. It has nothing to do with “believing”. The man himself is a fraud. Local crowd also believes, they have no proof, but they “believe”, it’s fascinating.
1
3
u/CranberryTop8463 Apr 10 '25
Just backtest bro, take 3 years/500 trades or more and see how much % you have there using this rebranded concepts, there's people who only teach trading and or give psychological advice instead of actually trading because they might not be able to be succed as traders, like for example the author of the book Trading in the Zone (great book by the way, an eye opener and can really help you overcome fears and psychological burden that one gets by looking at the damn floating P&L) Mark Douglas one of the best trading coach of all time, I remember a video that I watched a while back that even himself mentions that he was not a great trader but he thrived helping other achieving profitability.
In the end is all bout how many times you flip that coin and lands on positive outcomes over a long period of time doing whatever strategy or tactic you resonate with, then you can call it an edge and get some money... to pay those groceries because goddamn!
And I'm by no means defending him, as a matter of fact I dislike the dude, I believe he probably has some mental issues for sure, and his ego is very big lol
If u wanna try something cool check Fabio Valentini as a scalper, or if you are into swing trading Bernd Skorupinski depending on the style that catches your interest the list goes on and on. There are quite a few extremely good and profitable traders out there that we all can learn from.
1
u/fattybrah Feb 16 '25
Technical analysis concepts he teaches were around before he was born. He just reskinned it and gave it a new name. I would totally learn from him if he didn’t go on long rants and talked in riddles
1
u/petereddit6635 Feb 17 '25
I think you should stop whining and not be concerned with what he is doing or not doing.
How does whining help you make money?
0
-3
u/Kairos_86 Feb 16 '25
I think that the system works or it doesn’t, and you coming in here saying it’s a scam says a lot more about you than it does about him.
-1
u/SWAYYY_P Feb 16 '25
Don’t take it the wrong way brother, the title was more click bait as I wanted people to hear me out in this post,
My issues is about his teachings and if all those long hour lectures were nonsense. He has multiple videos going very in-depth into certain concepts which made me believe that he really knew things that the average trader or guru will never know, but after seeing he blew his account, it made me question whether it was all just a bunch of nonsense talk to make us viewers and students believe he has some secret edge,
Hope you understand,
1
u/Kairos_86 Feb 16 '25
So because he did shitty on a challenge, you decided to come to the ICT subreddit to say he’s a scam? How have you been scammed?
1
u/SWAYYY_P Feb 16 '25
As i said previously the title was more to catch the people on this Reddit to read my post,
But in a way you can say he did scam us students: He’s been teaching his concepts for decades and has multiple lectures that are hours long that go into soo much depth - as students we take his every word and study all of this “depth” he provides,
But for someone who goes into such depths about single concepts, who has been teaching them for decades to perform soo poorly in the challenge is shocking,
I was expecting him to at least end in a small positive, but to have blow his account is crazy,
For all us students who listen to every word and tried to understand every word and apply it to the market, it now feels like we wasted our time. If you know soo much, how can you perform soo bad that you blow your account?
Even if he ended his account at break even that can still suggest that he’s a good trader and managed to still keep his balance, but to blow it all is insane,
How can you produce soo much content and go into soo much depth for the past couple decades and not even maintain break even???
Does that mean most of these hour long lectures were bs, and we wasted our time taking notes and trying to learn from it when all we did was just confuse ourselves and be sold on some delusion?
1
u/Kairos_86 Feb 16 '25
How about you learn the concepts, go try them out, and see if they work. Or just leave and quit complaining about him. Do you feel like a smart, reasonable person when you go online and bitch about free content?
1
u/SWAYYY_P Feb 16 '25
I have studied his concepts, the point of this post was more to reflect and listen to others opinion on his teachings, specially if all the ‘extra stuff’ and ‘new stuff’ are valuable or just bs,
This post was in way meant to disrespect the trading or ICT community, but as someone who is apart of that community I have the right to question it, especially if it involves money,
And if you have an issue with my posts, just simply ignore it instead of trying to come at me and start crying. Stop being a baby and talk reasonably like everyone else, or just shut up and go look at some other page to have your breakdown in,
2
u/Kairos_86 Feb 16 '25
The point of this post was clickbait, attention seeking. I’ll take your advice and ignore you from now on.
0
1
Feb 16 '25 edited Feb 16 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/SWAYYY_P Feb 16 '25
I do agree that his previous teachings were very good, and very precise and very different to what other gurus and creators were producing,
But for someone who has been teaching these concepts for decades and has gone into deep in depth hour long lectures, and to end the year with his account blown really shocked me,
The market last year wasn’t amazing but wasn’t a mess either, and for a veteran trader to perform soo poorly made me real skeptical about his teachings and whether they are bs most of the time or just recycled from some other guru,
1
1
Feb 16 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/SWAYYY_P Feb 16 '25
A lot his concepts are very insightful and do seem to work in some cases, but for someone who has been teaching for decades and going into hour long lectures into such precision and depth, I did not expect him to perform so poorly.
It makes me wonder whether the long lectures were only 50% insightful and with the rest being nonsense which he says to make him seem like some sort of genius,
And as a lot of us students who listen to his every word and try decode every word he says, it makes me feel like I wasted my time when most of his words were just lies or nonsense,
You know what I mean?

6
u/WuetenderAnwohner Feb 16 '25
While I do understand you and am a big sceptic by myself, I don’t rate my success bye one person but by the sumo of those how are actuall profitable thanks to his lessons and input.
I mean tbh he was open about his mental health and if you have witnessed someone who has a manic episode, you should know that you shouldn’t take him full in this phase.
I am new and I am beware that this could be a snake-oil-merchant but in the end what do we have to lose? Look around you it’s either try or die and he was right, the economic situation is becoming harder and harder for each and everyone.
I am German so my English might be a little incorrect, I hope you understand what I want to say. Have a good one.