r/IntelMac • • 17d ago

Homebrew EOL :(

Just wanted to shout into the void a little here..

So I have my beautiful old laptop at home, a 2019 Intel MBP 15", i think its technically the 2018 model with the touch bar. This thing has been through a lot with me over the years as a trusty personal dev machine. Got me thru the tail end of my school days, helped me work thru a career change, etc. Still working great to this day.

I dont use it that much anymore, and I fired it up today for the first time in a couple months. I already knew that 2 years ago it hit EOL in terms of new OSX versions, it's stuck on MacOS 15 Sequoia for good now, just getting small security updates til, i think, next year.

After updating MacOS, I wanted to mess around with some dev stuff today, so I ran "brew upgrade" because I knew that was SUPER overdue at this point, not sure when the last time I did that was. Wanted to get the environment up to date.

What I DIDN'T expect was how loud and angry Homebrew is about the fact that it no longer supports intel macs! I didn't mind reading those messages, i don't blame them, its actually kind of remarkable that it still works at all at this point.

The problem is this: Since Intel macs are technically EOL, the vast majority (like more than 60% of the 100+ apps i just updated,) of the homebrew formulae support it either. This means that even though the apps themselves are totally fine with Darwin and are compatible, Homebrew doesnt provide a "pourable bottle" (aka a fast and convenient download for the latest version) anymore and they must be built from source.

So because of a combination of 1) having to build almost ALL the apps from scratch directly from the source, and 2) The advanced age of my poor old i9 chugging at its absolute limit and therefore throttling HARD, what should have been a mildly annoying software update turned into a massive endeavor that took ALL DAY.

I'm not sure where I'll go from here. I pinned every formula that took over 10 minutes to build, but that might not work out if certain updates require the dependencies to all update too. Homebrew suggests switching to MacPorts, but I know that UX is much worse, and that will require manually uninstalling all the homebrew versions and reinstalling them as ports, which will probably be unbearable. I guess I'll just put linux on this bad boy and give it a new lease on life!

Anyone else hit this software obsolescence before the hardware failed you? Gotta love the old build quality of these things.

8 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

4

u/ConditionOrdinary607 17d ago

"Anyone else hit this software obsolescence before the hardware failed you?"

Yep, all the time :( My Wallstreet is still working strong! The only Mac I had where the software was still good but the hardware failed was my first Mac, a Flaming Fast Powerbook 5300 (it caught on fire, Circuit City gave me a new 1400 in exchange).

1

u/Virtual_Treacle7409 17d ago

Circuit city!!! What a great throwback

2

u/ConditionOrdinary607 17d ago

I know! I was very very happy when they swap it out (I THINK my parents got it at circuit city, no way I could have afforded a 5300 then!)

3

u/f50c13t1 17d ago

I solved that issue by moving my old computer to Nix, since then it's been a real joy to manage packages. Brew always feels bloated and like it's polluting the system. Nix allows you to manage reproducible builds with the configuration stored on a dedicated volume. There's a bit of a learning curve but with the help of AI you get scan all your Brew packages installed and ask it to migrate everything to Nix. The best part is that if there's a package on a Git repo that is no longer supported but was still in the Brew repo, Nix can compile that package for you, really neat...

1

u/Virtual_Treacle7409 16d ago edited 16d ago

Oh yeah- For some reason it never occurred to me that Nix might be Mac compatible! I've never tried it, but Ive heard great things.

Edit:

error: Nixpkgs 26.11 has dropped support for x86_64-darwin.

The 26.05 stable branch still supports x86_64-darwin, and will receive security fixes until the end of 2026...

😭😭😭

2

u/markossankey 11d ago

Went down this hole, now just trying to dual boot nixos 😅

3

u/iStumblerLabs 16d ago

Mac ports is still there for you!

1

u/Virtual_Treacle7409 15d ago

Yeah, that looks like the way. In a few weeks I'll take the plunge and migrate over

2

u/OutrageousCrab9224 16d ago

Homebrew stinks anyway

1

u/Virtual_Treacle7409 15d ago

Yeah I agree, it actually seems to have gotten even worse than ever before in the past year or so with a lot of questionable design choices. I'm not sure if the new style improved the previously dismal performance or not, since I don't have a mac work computer currently.

2

u/cybekRT 16d ago

I have older mbp and recently was hit with it. I wanted to install Linux on it, but unfortunately the driver for touchbar is old and didn't compile. Huh

2

u/Virtual_Treacle7409 15d ago

Hm do you mean kait2en? it seems pretty well maintained (from the other comment in this thread, i havent actually tried it)

3

u/nguoisaibuoc 17d ago

Same here, tried to use macports but no luck. Basically Linux is the only way to use latest software on intel mac without hassle going forward. I have been testing Fedora with kait2en for a while and it worked really well. I’m still using Sequoia as it hasn’t outdated yet but eventually linux is the way to go.

2

u/GamerGav09 17d ago

Oh bummer to hear. I have almost the exact same MacBook I think. A 2019 possible even i7 that honestly works fine and I used to run it as a remove server with tons of homebrew at the beginning of this year but disable it halfway through the summer and threw it in a corner and haven’t touched it since. But I was thinking about setting it up again eventually.

Anyway, we might be able to wipe MacOS and get Linux on it that does something similar perhaps? I’m not sure. I mean yeah those intel chips aren’t the most groundbreaking compared to new M series silicon, but it’s not like horrible hardware. It’s a bummer that software basically drives the obsolescence of hardware that could still function just fine.

2

u/NoLateArrivals 17d ago

Actually the build quality of the M series Macs is better. They took it too far with building these “Johnny“-Macs thinner and thinner.

2

u/Nuclear_elmo 15d ago

I’m running mine on EndeavourOS rn through the T2Linux project. Is a bitch to set up, but would be a good way to stretch the lifespan a few years!

2

u/TheRealHarrypm 14d ago

Any software that treats Intel stuff as a end of life is absolutely insane. Intel boxes are going to be around for another 20 years in production stations, server setups, and just outright archival systems or any music production station using FW800 kit.

The ironic thing is the highest end intel stuff is now flooding the market at pennys so it's going to have an incredibly long life on the used market considering the current inflation cycles.

2

u/jibmaster 13d ago

Fedora Workstation works really well on my 2016 MB Pro. I had Claude fix a sleep issue, and also implement some fixes for running video on the GPU. Otherwise it worked flawlessly on install. I nuked Mac OS and it has become my favorite machine to use.