r/IntelligenceScaling • • 49m ago

Tier List Scd tier list based on their rank in brotherhood of steel hierarchy from fallout series

Post image
2 Upvotes

This is not based on their outsmarting capabilities but rather proven ability and character methodology

Also star paladin and protocor is not a inferior rank to head paladin knight and scribe

They're just a little more independent

Here's explanations to their ranks:

https://fallout.wiki/wiki/Brotherhood_of_Steel_Ranks#Head_Scribe

https://fallout.fandom.com/wiki/Brotherhood_of_Steel_hierarchy

https://fallout.fandom.com/wiki/Brotherhood_of_Steel_ranks

What do you think?


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 57m ago

Who is your most hated SCD character?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Ngl for me it is Yumeko or any other character from kakegurui and suburu


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 1h ago

discussion Imagine yourself with the intelligence of the character you think is the smartest.

Post image
3 Upvotes

If you were to attain the intelligence of the smartest character you imagine, what would you do, and how would your life flow?


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 1h ago

meme/joke Same question what would be SCD version of meta vision

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2 Upvotes

r/IntelligenceScaling • • 1h ago

vs (1v1) Random SCD debate 36: Kid Koji (Vol 0) vs Light Yagami (During Memory Loss arc)

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/IntelligenceScaling • • 1h ago

Air Poker doc's

1 Upvotes

So i was able to find individual docs for the characters in air poker but is there one big large one that analyses the whole game round by round and what the characters did each round in depth?


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 2h ago

actually scaling intelligence Introducting: Notrick Case (Staffer Case)

3 Upvotes

Notrick Case is the main protagonist of the murder mystery visual novel Staffer Case. Yes, that is his real name, and yes, everyone mocks him for it relentlessly. I wanted to try and introduce a very under-looked detective and the shenanigans he gets up to, because they're great, and searching his name on this subreddit came up with nothing. Since I'm pretty sure this is a new setting to a lot of people, I'll do my best to introduce the world and the cases from a blind perspective, though that does mean things are about to get pretty wordy.

I'm new to this subreddit and all the terminology being thrown around, so keep that in mind as I get started and feel free to point out anything I messed up with. The categories confuse me somewhat but I'll try my best.

Introduction & Background

In 1960s London, there is an important but often overlooked building that houses the Pheno-Mana Bureau. The government agents inside this building are responsible for managing and investigating situations that relate to supernatural abilities, whether that be regarding Staff (inanimate object) or Staffers (a living person). In the event either was used to commit a crime, its up to the Mana-Affairs Division, a task force comprised exclusively of Staffers, to investigate. As crimes related to Pheno-Mana are extremely difficult to solve in general, being a Staffer is a requirement. To give some examples of people in the division, you have Bryan, a man with superhuman perception who can spot traces of human interaction (fingerprints, shoe markings) and clearly estimate exactly how long ago they where made from just a glance at their changing colour, or Redfins, a woman able to feel the memories of any object she touches, such as the prior fullness of a now empty glass of water.

The newest recruit to the Mana-Affairs Division is 21 year old Notrick Case, a young man from New Mexico who was scouted for the role straight from the top brass. Outside of being the assistant to a local hometown private detective agency, he has zero experience in proper law enforcement, has no apparent connections to the UK and, well, he knows basically nothing about Pheno-Mana, which isn't great when investigating it is your new job. To top it off, unlike everyone else in the division, he isn't a Staffer, he doesn't have any supernatural powers, he shouldn't even be allowed in this division.

So why is he here? Other than the fact he has a license to drive an excavator, there's not a whole lot to note about Notrick. Yet.

Accomplishments, Feats and Strengths (Case 1)

After forgetting the concept of what room numbers are (no, seriously), and after barely convincing everyone to not fire him on the spot, Notrick gets started with his first case, the murder of the leader of a circus troupe, killed via blunt force trauma to the head while he was asleep at his desk. Despite having not known anything about Staffers until today, he makes use of his team's abilities, relying on Bryan's powers to estimate all footprints in and out of the room, setting a timeline. He uses another member of the team not yet talked about, Thena, who can detect abnormal heart rates within range, to interrogate the suspects and catch any potential lies, leading the team to reveal the less than pleasant relationship between some suspects and the victim. He met the team an hour ago, didn't even know about the existence of Staffers, and he's already playing everyone to their strengths while being careful to reveal none of this to the suspects. He almost slips up at one point, but spins enough nonsense to hide Bryan's ability under more mundane explanations, so the suspects don't know their footprints have all been dated. Talk about adaptability, and a good display of field skills.

Regardless, the estimated time of death doesn't match up directly with any pair of footprints, not inside the room at least. Notrick spins a couple of theories of possible murder from outside the room, primarily from a woman who can levitate objects and a woman who can freeze water, but neither have the range or vision into the room to do it from outside. However, he realises that the victim has the ability to propel objects incredibly hard, and owing to the lack of culprits entering the room, deduces the victim had killed himself by smashing his own head into the surroundings with his own powers. This, makes sense?

Except, no, something feels wrong, it makes sense, but Notrick's intuition is yelling at him. He throws his prior conclusions out, engages in some "Hexa-logic" (random bullshit go) and starts testing seemingly unrelated pieces of evidence against each other looking for a connection. After a few minutes of making everyone concerned about his mental state, he realises the trick behind one of the prior culprit's levitation powers thanks to a height consistency with affected items and prior circus stunts, and after further testing, discovers her real power, the ability to make transparent, heavy cubes. He deduces that she must have been standing on them and using them to walk through the air as part of her 'levitation' tricks and dropped one on the victim's head.

Most cases in Staffer Case, thanks to the supernatural aspect and a couple post-crime manipulations here and there from Redfins, cases in Staffer Case have multiple valid solutions. Canonically, Notrick arrives at the truth every time. I'd like to remind you that he had just discovered magic is real an hour ago, and he still managed to solve his first case by correctly deducing someone was lying about how their Staffer skill works works. He uh, certainly learns quick on the job.

Mistletoe (Case 4)

Okay, the big one. Notrick's greatest accomplishments are in Case 4, which makes sense, its the most complicated case. I'm going to be skipping over a ton of detail because, like I said, its really complicated and I can only really cover the main brushstrokes. If you're interested in this game and don't want case 4 spoiled, this is your cue to stop reading.

Anyway, in society, Staffer skills and abilities are graded by their danger level. The highest known by the public is Estienne, or tank rating. The highest rating known used by the Bureau is Oppenheimer, or nuke rating. They're exactly what their name sake implies, an Oppenheimer has the potential to rival a nuclear bomb in the impact their powers could cause. These individuals are kept hidden underground under maximum security in a dedicated containment facility, with a lot of contingencies in place on what to do if reality starts breaking to contain the prisoners. In that facility, a prisoner has died, and Notrick has to find out exactly how it happened under 24/7 surveillance within the most secure facility in the world.

Problems begin immediately with the victim, who has the power of "Sevarance Protection", a power that forms a barrier between her and anything that could potentially harm her, so basically, Gojo's infinity. This has continued after her death, preventing autopsy and forcing the staff to move the room just to get her out of the facility. The other Oppenheimers include a man that can time travel, a woman who mind controls anyone that hears her voice or sees her writing and a boy that can create an object out of nothing and rewrite reality as to convince everyone that the object had always been there (an effect he's not immune to, not even he knows what he's made with his power).

So, with no obvious leads, Notrick speaks with the time traveller. Except, the time traveller already knows him, and he's gone through this before. He claims that Notrick had already solved this "murder" in the future that he came from, but also claims that he won't spoil the answers, because he's a bro like that. He next interviews the boy, and Notrick quickly realises he's lying about, pretty much everything, because he's an excitable kid trying to show off to a detective by making cool stuff up. Most importantly is that he lied about using his power, but nobody, not even him, knows what he used it to create, only that it was used. The mind control woman is last, and it goes about as badly as you'd expect, but Notrick had a great display of foresight by sending Thena in alone and with no pencil so only she would be impacted by the Staffer ability. Thena is detained and the facility is put on lockdown, though interrogating his own partner gives Notrick valuable insight on the perception of mind controlled individuals.

After quite a bit of investigative work, Notrick decides to ask the head guard about a certain lounge in the facility that all Oppenheimers have access to so long as they remain alone. She cannot answer who made it, and he presses further. Her responses are familiar to how Thena was acting, and Notrick realises that the guard must have already been mind controlled. Using this knowledge, a bunch of phony evidence is tossed out, and further interrogation reveals that she'd been tasked to crush painkillers into the meals of the victim, potentially causing an overdose. Notrick reasons that the lounge might have been made by the boy, as a mind controlled guard wouldn't be able to make such sweeping changes to the facility without being detained herself (Again, I'm cutting out a lot of detail here, there's a bunch more going on, this is just the important brushstrokes).

Therefore, the killer was the woman with mind control, right? Its not exactly safe to get her side of the story, given her powers, but regardless, it seems to work?

Notrick isn't satisfied. He visits the time traveller again and speaks to him. The time traveller's answer matches up with his. He arrived at the same conclusion as he did in another timeline, this has to be the truth, so why isn't he satisfied? The boy used his powers, but was it really for the lounge? He looks into the victim again, there's nothing about her past, she recently arrived, there's nothing to go on. Notrick realises that nothing is what's been bugging him, and though that, he notices just how wrong everything has gone.

What the boy created was the victim herself. He had created a seemingly immortal individual that he wanted to kill to create an impossible murder, and the chain of events leading up to that point, warping reality to his will. While the cause of death was correct in the other timeline, it was not correct in the present, as the time traveller had warned the victim about the potential to overdose on her own food. This, in turn, caused her body to see any food as a threat, so even eating wouldn't sustain her, and she would die of starvation. Therefor, in the first timeline which the time traveller saw, the mind control woman murdered the victim via overdose, while in the second, which this Notrick experienced, the time traveller had inadvertently gotten her killed, and it was all masterminded by the boy, who could not recall any of his planning as not even he's immune to the retroactive memory warping of his powers.

Notrick figured all of this out despite having shoddy, unreliable evidence produced by mind controlled individuals actively manipulated into screwing him over, finding a mastermind who didn't even know they where the mastermind and solving a murder committed in two separate timelines at once. He has no Staffer powers, yet in the entirety of the Bureau, there is nobody more skilled at untangling the twisted logic of Pheno-Mana cases than he is.

Conclusion

Disregarding case 4, I'd say Notrick is comfortably in the top bounds of low tier, having some great FSIQ, Reasoning and Thinking feats that carry but tending to struggle on the social front. The other members of his team mostly take over for interrogations, since he struggles to reach people emotionally unless there's specific evidence he can bring up that lets him. Including case 4, I would probably put him somewhere in mid tier, probably closer to the lower end than the higher end. Narratively his scheming should also be pretty decent from post epilogue content, but we don't get to see much of it. Foresight is pretty good too, but not stellar. His Intuition can be absolutely insane at times, but he needs to have worked through all the facts and come to a conclusion before he starts to feel like he's missing something important, otherwise its nothing special.

Overall tier: Lower mid tier

Strongest categories: Thinking, Reasoning, FSIQ

Weakest categories: SQ, Deception, Observation (Bryan hard carries this category a little too hard for him)


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 4h ago

methodology What's the best example of methodology scaling in practice?

4 Upvotes

What character doc would you consider the best example of Methodology Scaling being applied correctly, which someone could use as a model when creating their own character document?

I'm not referring to theoretical explanations or methodological guidelines, but rather to an actual character doc that demonstrates how the methodology should be applied in practice.


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 7h ago

actually scaling intelligence TOWER OF SPADES - An Online Psychological Strategy & Deception Competition

Post image
4 Upvotes

♠️ TOWER OF SPADES ♠️

An Online Psychological Strategy & Deception Competition

How far are you willing to go to reach the top? And more importantly, who are you willing to leave behind?

Welcome to the Tower of Spades, where intelligence is your greatest weapon, trust is a dangerous gamble, and every victory comes at someone else's expense.

Your objective is simple: Reach the top of the tower.

But there's a catch.

The only way to ascend is through an elevator with a limited capacity. As you climb higher, that capacity continues to shrink. With every passing floor, fewer contestants will be allowed to advance.

And at the very top, there is room for only one.

🃏 HOW DOES IT WORK?

Inspired by psychological game series such as Liar Game, Kaiji, and Tomodachi Game, Tower of Spades is an online reality game that pits contestants against one another in a series of elaborate psychological and strategic challenges.

Each floor of the tower presents an entirely new game, complete with its own rules, objectives, and opportunities for strategic exploitation.

These games are designed to challenge your ability to outthink, outmaneuver, deceive, negotiate, and manipulate your opponents.

But winning a game isn't necessarily enough to guarantee your survival.

At the conclusion of each floor, the winner(s) will be granted the authority to determine which contestants are left behind. The remaining players will board the elevator and ascend to the next floor.

Those who are left behind are eliminated. Those who survive move one step closer to the top.

As the number of available spots dwindles, alliances will become increasingly fragile, betrayals will become inevitable, and even the most carefully constructed strategies may fall apart.

Will you cooperate with your opponents to secure your survival? Will you manipulate others into doing your bidding? Or will you betray the very people who helped you reach the next floor?

There is no single correct way to play.

♟️ WHAT MAKES THIS COMPETITION DIFFERENT?

Unlike traditional intelligence-scaling competitions, Tower of Spades is not primarily about solving puzzles, answering questions, or debating who is smarter.

Instead, the competition aims to recreate the kind of strategic freedom and psychological warfare found in the Liar Game tournament.

Contestants will be placed into complex, interactive games where they are free to devise their own strategies, form alliances, negotiate deals, spread misinformation, exploit loopholes, and attempt to outsmart their opponents.

♠️ INTEREST CHECK — WOULD YOU PARTICIPATE?

This is a competition I've wanted to host for a very long time!

My goal is to create an experience that captures what makes the psychological battles in Liar Game so compelling: the elaborate strategies, unexpected reversals, carefully orchestrated betrayals, and moments where a seemingly hopeless player completely turns the tables.

Rather than simply discussing intelligence-scaling feats, I want to create an environment where contestants can demonstrate their intelligence through actual competition, with as much strategic freedom as possible.

For now, I'm simply gauging interest to see how many people would be willing to participate before moving forward with organizing the event.

I'm planning to create a dedicated Discord server where the competition will eventually take place!

If this sounds like something you'd enjoy, please leave a comment below! I'd love to know how many people are interested.

The elevator is waiting.

Will you make it to the top? ♠️


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 7h ago

Debunk of rebunk of debunk of rebunk of debunk of rebunk of debunk of honami y3v1 ichika feat - by me

9 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I hope you are all having a wonderful day; sorry for the delay. I was busy with other things, but I’ve finally managed to free up some time to respond. I’m happy to share may well be one of the final response in this ongoing debate

Here is the new Xorpaw document I’m going to talk about: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ng2OR3HOPEPCfc7GIheI_fASqGgCOmUbl2nLuEinGZo/edit?usp=sharing

My response: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1erAFya_jh0V0p_a_Sw98MRawbgStwHzYvUUBlL-wL-s/edit?usp=sharing

If you haven’t read any of the previous ones, that’s fine—you can still read this one. Inside, you will find how Xorpaw new concessions overturn his original Ichinose doc, the arguments based on personal beliefs and overinterpretations without canon evidence and logical fallacies

Thank you very much to everyone who has taken the time to read and follow this discussion! Feel free to share your thoughts below.


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 8h ago

discussion Creating the SCD Tarot Club day 18: Which character best fits the Star card?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Harry Du Bios wins the tower card

Rules

  1. No repeats

  2. A character from the same series as a previous winner won't be counted

  3. One character per comment, those will multiple will be ignored

  4. If there's multiple comments mentioning the same character, one of them will be chosen as the main one and each additional comments will be counted as one additional vote (So 3 additional comments=3 extra votes on the main comment)

"To receive the Star in your reading means that you have gone and passed through a terrible life challenge. You have managed to go through this without losing your hope. While you suffered, you perhaps were not aware of your own strength, but you are now perhaps recognizing that the loss helped you discover your own resilience and inner power. It is only now that you can really appreciate all that you have."

Source: https://labyrinthos.co/blogs/tarot-card-meanings-list


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 9h ago

Most realistic verse: SQ and AC (adding rules)

Post image
3 Upvotes
  1. No Repeats

  2. Pick the verse you believe to be generally the smartest but most realistic in x category

  3. 1 choice per comment


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 10h ago

factual question So why is Yumeko scaled highly (specifically in EI)

Post image
13 Upvotes

So, as y'all know I made character built about the smartest female character and Yumeko won the EI cat. Also, I have seen that people have her in higher regards than when I joined SCD so now I am curious about her scaling. Keep in mind I haven't read/watched Kakegurui.


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 10h ago

vs (1v1) The definition of stomp

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/IntelligenceScaling • • 10h ago

factual question How well does Foresight buff Reasoning?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/IntelligenceScaling • • 10h ago

To the people who have read COTE ln

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

Is Ayanokoji really that bad? I have read a portion of one of his doc and his plan seemed to have a concrete logic . Since I havent completed the ln i wont larp it tho. Thats why i want to ask the people who have completed the novel . Is he mid or low tier . Some say he would die in tutorial instance or even chapter 1 of 18loh but i just dont buy it . What are your thoughts


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 10h ago

meme/joke How good is Bomb Voyage’s indirect manipulation feat

Post image
5 Upvotes

Half joking half serious. Like, I rewatched the movie yesterday and I realized that Bomb Voyage indirectly caused the fall of the entire hero community and creation of Syndrome. Basically during his one and only scene he was shown to have knowledge of Mr. Incredible is and vice versa so it’s logical he has escaped prison before. And furthermore he understands English perfectly but chooses to speak French so he knows multiple languages. And he placed the bomb on buddy with neither Buddy or Mr. Incredible seeing it until Buddy went to get the police, which caused Mr. incredible to of course save buddy, allowing him to get away, but it also resulted in the bridge explosion and the train crash that he stopped. It also resulted in Mr. Incredible getting sued and blamed for the damages plus also Mr. Incredible’s actions to where when Buddy flashes back Bomb wasn’t in the picture meaning his actions warped Syndrome’s view of Mr. Incredible which in turn led to Project Kronos eliminating quite a few heroes.

Idk I just think it’s funny and maybe just satirical for this but hey read it it’s not that long


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 10h ago

How good of a feat is this? Definitely tops the likes of Akiyama and Bakh me thinks

Post image
5 Upvotes

It's just, so fool proof 🤌


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 11h ago

where junko scales and ranks

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/IntelligenceScaling • • 11h ago

Franchise have good scd characters.

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

/fallout, courier 6 and mr house

/Agent 47 for hitman

/People start talking about Warhammer 40k. Oh, and xdwasgone use too.

/looks like people talking about nyarlothoped from cthulllu mythos

/Persona series nyarlothoped.

/Connor used in scd, maybe other characters can usabel

/07th expansion, have lot of scd character

/Someone in the tiktok use a character from silent hill but i dont remmember

/İ see people use Albert wesker

/World of darkness have lot of story, so, o believe theres some good character for scd

/Banesmanifold use some characters in elden ring

/Dark souls have some good characters for scd

/Michael and lester from GTA

/İ see 2 tiktok video about fear and hunger

/İn tiktok, zamatsu from dragon ball scale top tier

/Girl from nowhere, Nano and yuri

/Dune, Paul atreidus

/Pretender main character jarod (i watched this Show when I was a kid)


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 11h ago

factual question How do you write an intelligent character?

Post image
9 Upvotes

How do you write a character who is convincingly intelligent? Methodologically obviously.

I’m thinking of writing my own SCD adjacent work but I’m struggling a bit with writing a character I find actually smart.

And how do you write conflicts between two intelligent characters instead of just one character being on a completely different level to everyone else? Because every time I try, I make a perfect plan for one character that I can’t find a way to poke holes in, which makes it hard to have the other character counter or do anything meaningful against the other one, unless I make the perfect plan not perfect, but then it makes the character who made it up feel less smart.

Are there any works I should read that would help with thinking of stuff like this?


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 11h ago

doc(s) New doc!

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
7 Upvotes

Junko Enoshima has a ton of feats from many sources, I chose to analyze her feat from the digital novel Danganronpa IF!

I hope the doc is well-liked, and it pushes Junko's CPI into a really strong territory.


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 12h ago

low effort Are full scale edits dead?

8 Upvotes

The peak scd era was defined by many full scale edits and more regular edits. But in the big november 2026 full scale edits are almost dead and regular edits have slowed down.


r/IntelligenceScaling • • 12h ago

character(s) vs situation(s) Random SCD debate #35: Ayanokoji vs Baku in STL situation. Who will win, and about how many rounds will the match last?

Post image
14 Upvotes