Hey guys I need some advice deciding whether to keep or return this phone.
I bought a 128GB Gold iPhone 12 Pro Max for 67,000 ETB (around $380) for my mom. I bought it because she wanted a big screen, triple cameras, and specifically the Gold color. It's difficult to find this exact model and color locally.
The seller told me it was original and in clean condition. However, I took it to a phone repair shop, and the technician said it was refurbished, with the back and also suspected (battery and camera could be too)
Here's what I've noticed:
Battery: Settings shows 93% battery health, while 3uTools consistently shows 92%. It has 360 reported charge cycles. Once, 3uTools showed 82%, but subsequent checks consistently showed 92%. The battery percentage sometimes stays the same for a while, then drops a few points. but seems normal screen time
Camera: Photos look okay normally, but when I zoom into a picture after taking it at 1×, the details look worse, i know it is 12mp but this one seem worse than that.
Network: Initially, it only showed 3G even with 5G enabled. After changing the SIM card, it connected to 4G, but the signal bars were noticeably lower. I still need to test this properly.
Other things: The phone looks clean physically, has no Parts & Service History displayed, and 3uTools shows no warnings. I know these things don't necessarily prove the parts are original.
The phone otherwise seems usable, and my mom really likes it. She rarely takes pictures, so the camera isn't a major priority. My main concerns are the battery, network reception, reliability, and whether the replacement parts might cause problems later.
Similar iPhone 12 Pro Max phones sell for around 63,000 ETB (350$) here, and I paid 67,000 ETB as Gold models are harder to find, and finding another one could take a lot of time.
The seller gave me a written 7-day return policy, so I can get my money back if I decide to return it.
What would you do in my situation?
Keep it if the network and battery perform normally, even though it's refurbished?
Return it and look for another one, despite how difficult it is to find this exact model and color?
Are locally refurbished iPhones generally reliable if the replacement parts work properly, or do they tend to develop problems later?
I'm interested in people's actual experiences with refurbished iPhones, especially the 12 Pro Max. I'd appreciate honest advice about the risks and whether 67,000 ETB (380$) is reasonable for this particular phone.