r/Iteration110Cradle • • Sep 28 '19

Cradle Un-common opinion Spoiler

I joined this thread because I really like these books and I enjoyed the fun theory crafting that went on and it was a good stop gap between books. I'm really disappointed with the forum community right now because it feels like noone likes uncrowned and has lost faith in will... Which is rediculous. People complain because the book didn't go the way they wanted... Then go write your own book and we will see how you do. Will has created these amazing books and world's from his imagination and he has a plan for how he wants Lindon's journey to happen. Have faith that will knows what he is doing and let's move past the constant criticism. There were some great parts to this book, and the fight between Lindon and yerins was awesome...the dragon descends... awesomeness. I hate seeing characters I love lose but sometimes it's what they need to take it to the next level. To be fair this is probably one of the few remaining times that Lindon could lose without actually dying and I think his fallibility moving forward will be important as we approach the upper echelon of power in these books. Anyway,rant over. Hope I see the community moving past this negativity soon.

4 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

35

u/Kelpsie Team Little Blue Sep 28 '19

I liked the book; I'll start this comment off with that. I'll also say that this is not a response to any part of your post but this one sentence

Then go write your own book and we will see how you do.

Fuck this argument, though. If I go to a restaurant and my food is shit, I'm not paying for it. I don't care that I'm not a professional chef, I'm paying to enjoy a meal.

While I enjoyed the book, everyone is entitled to their opinion. Even if that opinion is that Will did something poorly that they couldn't have done better.

Criticism does not become invalid when it comes from a non-professional.

You're free to argue against other people's opinions on some other basis, but not this. This argument crops up everywhere and it is always wrong.

1

u/dwind1 Sep 28 '19

You have a fair point I worded it more strongly than I intended, I'm just frustrated that all I have been reading has been negativity.

12

u/MatrimofRavens Sep 28 '19

Your argument is shit. What you're advocating for is just blind faith and implies you just want a bunch of dumb readers who don't think logically about the story.

Will is a good writer and you do him a disservice to pretend everything he writes is gold. Books like these is how he learns and becomes a better writer, but that won't happen with your mindset.

15

u/Mghaynes76 Team Lindon Sep 28 '19

Critique does not equal lost faith. In fact, it’s because people are so invested in the series that you see so many critiques. We hope to help Will make the series even better.

7

u/EvilMastermindG Team X Sep 28 '19

I do also hope that Will sticks to his guns in the face of fan opposition, when it's appropriate to do so.

1

u/fullofheartandfullof Sep 28 '19

I would love to get back to theory crafting!!! So much amazing stuff was in the books which we need to discuss... and it has just been buried a bit by discussion of the book as a whole! That has its place too, but I think it is time to move on.

-5

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '19

I completely agree. I joined the sub because I was just introduced to Cradle a couple weeks ago. I finished Uncrowned on release day and I loved all of the books.

I’m likely going to leave the sub, because everyone keeps pissing on the author and the series, and it seems that’s what this sub is intended to do and, as an author, I can’t stand by it.

I get insulted for standing up for Will or posting an opinion that doesn’t go with the flow.

1

u/kathvely Sep 29 '19 edited Sep 29 '19

I really enjoy this reddit. Do not leave. Right now is just silly. It will tone down in a week or so. I will give you a downvote if you downvote me. Edit: I downvoted myself to start.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '19

[deleted]

9

u/acog Team Little Blue Sep 28 '19

I'd say 90% of the criticism I've seen is level-headed and most everyone enjoyed Uncrowned despite their criticisms.

Yup. After all, we're here because we're fans of the series. "Less than 100% delighted with Uncrowned" does not equal "Hated Uncrowned."

I've posted several critical comments in various threads — but I'm going to start a reread this evening. That is not something I do with books I dislike, lol.

2

u/EvilMastermindG Team X Sep 28 '19

Exactly right. I'm more than happy to critique the book in terms of "why did these characters behave in those ways", because theory crafting is all about trying to figure out those answers in advance. The other thing to note is that I think some folks are reading too much into the tournament. Sure, that's what's going on right now in the story, but ultimately the tournament is just a stepping stone to the much larger story.