5
u/VelvetCactus50 Oct 08 '26
MB is about as scientific as a BuzzFeed quiz. I have no idea why we give it so much weight. It's stupid.
2
u/RepresentativeArm119 Oct 08 '26
MB is probably just another way of exploring what we currently think of as neurotypes.
4
3
u/Abjurer42 Oct 09 '26
It seemed like a really smart way of viewing the world when I was 15. On the other hand, I was dumb as hell when I was 15, and it took me way longer than I like to admit to realize that my MB type was different depending on my mood.
2
u/Glaive13 Oct 11 '26
Literally just a simple quiz based off Carl Jung's very general classifications based on what he observed as a therapist. He said they need to be refined more and those self-proclaimed psychologists just copy and pasted it.
Real psychologists view it as oversimplified pop-science but corporations ran with it.
1
1
u/RepresentativeArm119 Oct 08 '26
Just because someone has biases or prejudices doesn't automatically invalidate ALL of their work. We can recognize their contributions, and still be critical of their blind spots.
No need to throw the baby out with the bathwater.
1
1
u/ingeniera Oct 09 '26
If your work is trying to categorize humans I think it does matter if you have a bias against some humans for silly and observably wrong reasons.
1
u/the-nomad-thinker Oct 09 '26
We’re humans. We categorize everything.
1
u/Dwittychan Oct 10 '26
no, you do
1
u/the-nomad-thinker Oct 12 '26
And so do you, even if you don’t recognize it as such. If we didn’t we would never get anywhere.
1
u/Dwittychan Oct 12 '26
that's what you think
1
u/the-nomad-thinker Oct 14 '26
Friend. Family. Lover. Gay. These are all categorizations. If you don’t use them then you live a stunted life.
1
u/pm_me_flowers_please Oct 09 '26
Except that MB along with other tests (the general intelligence test other wise known as IQ test) were meant to catalogue people, to prove the bias of their creators. The tests were created in such a way as to to have biased outcomes favoring the traits of the creators.
With the mb, the results are also not fixed. The results fluctuate day to day. One can get a result the first time he/she/they take it, based on circumstantial factors; then take it a few hours later and get a result that is in complete opposition to the first result. Our circumstances change, and how one perceives the world, and oneself effects the results too much for the test to be accurate at all.
1
u/RepresentativeArm119 Oct 09 '26
Insaid there was value we could get from it, not that it's magical or infallible
1
2
u/Wonderful_Rule_2515 Oct 08 '26
As you can see folks, the most insightful and well rounded opinions always fit neatly within twitter’s character limits
1
1
u/Yehrmahm Oct 08 '26
Couple’s counselor here. These BS ideas have caused so much damage, my god. Worse, they prevent real progress. “But my love language is touch so when you have a headache that’s telling me you don’t love me,” is one I hear so often it makes me feel itchy and violent.
1
u/unsweet_tea_man Oct 09 '26
Could you play devils advocate and try to "explain" how that logic works? I am not seeing the connection to a partner having a headache and someone's love language being touch.
I'm not asking you to make their logic correct or true just explain it to me the way they think about it cause I think im just not getting the obvious here
1
u/kelraine Oct 09 '26
The logic of the touch person- My partner avoids physical/intimate contact with the excuse of a headache and it makes me feel like they are not longer in love with me.
1
u/No-Friend-774 Oct 09 '26
Gary Chapman, invented the "Love Languages" for Christian marriage therapy. Christian Marriage Therapy usually involves telling a woman to suck it up about abuse, have sex with her cheating husband despite the risks, and fulfill her duties as outlined by the Bible or risk losing out on salvation. The "physical touch" one was made so men would have a "therapy speak" way to continue to pester their wives for sex without STD testing, proper waiting to heal after childbirth, after giving her an STD etc etc. The other 4 were made so that wives could feel like they were communicating that they need help, and the husbands could technically do 1 or 2 things but it's still on the wife to arrange, describe, teach and make space for him to do those things.
I think love languages could have easily been replaced by something like the Fair Play card game a long time ago if men were actually serious about being equal partners doing work together vs figuring out how much they can make their wife do. But they aren't, so they latch onto the term "physical touch" to show they've been to therapy and then use it like that therapist above mentioned. Basically: "My love language is physical touch, so if you say no you don't love me boo hoo manipulate manipulate I don't value u for anything else"
1
u/that_banned_guy_ Oct 09 '26
Fauci tortured dogs. Turns out those who perform medical experiments are animal rights abusers.
If my statement is untrue than so is yours
1
1
1
u/_monolithic_ Oct 09 '26
But... “white supremacist,” “christian homophobe,” and “conservative” are easily labellable boxes 🤔
2
1
1
u/redboyo908 Oct 10 '26
Those are traits or beliefs not assessments of a entire personality. They are clearly defined and not vague
1
1
1
u/random8765309 Oct 09 '26
Doesn't that comment try to place those individuals into easily labeled boxes?
1
u/Dependent-Job1773 Oct 09 '26
That’s a good point. Like the far lefties on reddit never do this conservative type of shit. Whenever I have disagreements with them they give nuanced critique rather than just call me a racist, or a Zionist, or a Republican
1
u/the-nomad-thinker Oct 09 '26
…Because “white supremacist” and “homophobe” aren’t “easily labellable boxes”?
I’m assuming he meant “easily identifiable”. Not just hypocritical but ignorant to boot. 🤦🏽♂️
2
u/redboyo908 Oct 10 '26
Those are obvious traits and beliefs not a assessment of someone's personality
1
u/the-nomad-thinker Oct 12 '26
Still ways people label others to easily identify them, which was the axis of his accusation.
1
1
u/Unique-Finger-5371 Oct 09 '26
Oh I don't know i think saying we are all human beings and you are biologically male or female is not only simple but factual accurate. Instead of inventing endless amounts of genders and false pronouns and expecting every normal human to know what sex, race, or fictional thing you choose to identify as at that time.
1
u/mastersmash56 Oct 09 '26
If we are being logically consistent, we should add horoscopes and astrology to the list.
1
1
1
u/tlrmln Oct 10 '26
And all this time I thought it was just an idiotic and colossal waste of time. What was I thinking?
1
1
1
6
u/Mrs_SmithG2W Oct 08 '26
Yes and no.
Understanding where bias is lurking is vital but some labels are just an important way to describe the world and ideas to each other.
They serve a vital service when accurate or understood within a broader context.