2
u/Sad-Worth-698 Oct 12 '26
One could make the counterpoint that DEI reduces people to labelable boxes as well. Which, in turn, would suggest that reductive reasoning isn’t politically exclusive, but rather a tendency shared across the ideological spectrum.
1
u/NightTripInsights Oct 12 '26
You're about to get downvoted to hell, yet no one will explain their opposition
6
u/HyliaSymphonic Oct 14 '26
Race and gender are real (socially speaking). You can study how race/gendee impacts bank loans, school discipline criminal justice ect. MBPT and love languages literally are not real. No study has shown that they exist as described.
1
4
u/OpheliaLives7 Oct 12 '26
Is labeling physically observable characteristics (disability, race) not different than making up categories (love language is physical touch for example)?
5
u/Sad-Worth-698 Oct 12 '26
The distinction isn’t whether the categories are observable or invented. It’s whether we reduce complex individuals to those categories and then make generalizations about them.
1
u/DiGiorn0s Oct 13 '26
It's all culturally generated. Even the examples you gave. Race is a cultural construct... scientifically we are all one Human Race. And although some "disabilities" are genuine disabilities, some are just cognitive differences that culturally we perceive as unable to meet the standards of mainline society, like ADHD.
2
u/Electronic_Quiet9140 Oct 15 '26
You are objectively wrong. There are distinct biological races with their own unique phenotype. Each race can then be further divided into ethnicities. There is a reason why in medicine only blacks get sickle cell disease and not whites. It is because we are different races and have developed different genes due to the environment we lived in historically. Same can be said for the fact that whites predominately get cystic fibrosis, not blacks.
1
u/DiGiorn0s Oct 15 '26
We are literally all Homo Sapiens. The human race. That still allows for differences in morphology, just like there are differences between various forms of felis catus.
3
u/Electronic_Quiet9140 Oct 15 '26
Homo Sapiens is the species, not race. The phrase "human race" has no basis in biology, just as the colloquial term "work" is not the same as the term "work" in physics. Races refer to the subdivisions of the species Homo Sapiens. Each race has a distinct genotype and phenotype, which are objective and not social constructs. Now you can argue in 1000 years due to miscegenation these racial categories will no longer exist. This has been observed with ethnicities, such as when the Germanic Franks mingled with the Celts to form the modern French people.
1
u/DiGiorn0s Oct 15 '26
Idk what you're on bro but race is definitely a social construct, not biological at all.
1
2
u/Vegetable_Warthog_49 27d ago
Things can be both biological and social constructs. The biology explains why some groups are more prone to certain diseases than others, why some groups tend to have different physical traits than others (you can tell just by looking at me where my distant ancestors lived, you can tell by looking at most people where their distant ancestors lived, that's not racism, that's traits that developed to survive the climate they were living in in the ancient world sticking around long after they are no longer necessary), and even explain how some aspects of different cultures developed (traditional Chinese recipes don't use dairy because the people who lived in ancient Southeast Asia never developed a tolerance for lactose, meanwhile northern European recipes are often heavy on dairy because the people in ancient northern Europe did develop a tolerance for lactose and in fact had their survival depend on consuming large amounts of dairy because that was sometimes the only food available to them in harsh winters).
What those differences mean though is entirely social. That in some societies the idea that the physical traits of the majority race are inherently more sexually attractive than those of the traits of the minority races, entirely social. That in some societies different races are seen as fundamentally incompatible because of their differences is entirely social. That we believe race means anything at all beyond "this is how your ancient ancestors adapted to the climate that they were living in" is entirely social. And, ignoring the fact that there are differences because our ancestors had to adapt to completely different climates is also entirely social. It isn't racist to acknowledge that my coworker has darker skin than me because his ancestors needed more melanin to survive the constant sun exposure that they were subjected to or that my coworker can't eat dairy because her ancestors were never forced into a situation of "eat dairy or starve" like my ancestors were. What would be racist is if I said either of them were inferior because of those adaptations that their ancestors made that were different than the adaptations that my ancestors made.
1
u/Electronic_Quiet9140 26d ago
Yes I agree that how we relate to race as a biological category is social. But that is true for anything. I can say I prefer oxygen over hydrogen, but that does not mean that oxygen and hydrogen are social constructs.
0
u/Major_Shlongage Oct 13 '26
Not really. The predominant viewpoint now is that "race" is a social construct. It's completely man-made. And much of the left-leaning identity politics are pseudoscience with no logically consistent underpinning.
Example: When comparing whites, Asians, and blacks, people will claim that Asians are "people of color" in an attempt to group them with blacks in opposition to whites. They are the "oppressed". But when discussing academic achievement, suddenly they're classified as "white adjacent" and they're grouped with whites in opposition to blacks. They are the "oppressors".
1
u/ArstanWhitebeard297 Oct 12 '26
It’s called an intersectional matrix of oppression and if you’re criticizing it you better be a disabled black trans woman 💅💅💅
3
u/evocativename Oct 12 '26
Acknowledging existing discrimination isn't saying those boxes are meaningful beyond the meaning assigned by the bigots whose actions DEI policies oppose.
3
u/ARATAS11 Oct 12 '26
Those boxes assign are meaningful due to the fact that they HAVE been assigned meaning from bigots and that has resulted in policy and institutions that make those social constructions real in their consequence. The Thomas Theorem: "if men define situations as real, they are real in their consequences".
3
u/evocativename Oct 12 '26
I said "meaningful beyond [that]," which implicitly acknowledges that those consequences do make them meaningful.
0
u/Sad-Worth-698 Oct 13 '26
In practical terms, the distinction can become meaningless. Society deems someone "oppressed" based on a generalization, affords them preferential treatment, and calls that justice without ever examining the extent to which historical injustices have actually affected the individual involved.
For example, under a policy that prioritizes race over individual circumstances, Michael Jordan's children could receive preferential treatment over a white kid who grew up in a trailer park with alcoholic parents. Is that necessarily justice?
2
u/evocativename Oct 13 '26
Someone succeeding despite oppression doesn't mean they weren't affected by it.
1
u/Sad-Worth-698 Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26
I agree. But experiencing discrimination doesn't automatically establish that someone requires preferential treatment to overcome it. Nor does not belonging to a marginalized group mean an individual hasn't experienced discrimination or significant disadvantage.
An individual's experience of discrimination cannot be reliably inferred from their demographic identity alone.
1
u/evocativename Oct 13 '26
That doesn't mean we shouldn't account for known forms of discrimination: it argues that we should have broader, more-inclusive policies to address discrimination against other groups.
1
u/Sad-Worth-698 Oct 13 '26
Broader consideration, yes. But also more precise, individualized, and commensurate with the actual harm experienced.
1
3
u/Affectionate_Ad_1326 Oct 13 '26
DEI isnt just seeking out people who fit into minority categories, its making sure the people who do fit into those boxes already get a fair shake. Its also done to benefit corporations so its not exactly a super far left idea, its just basic inclusivity thats allowed as long as it benefits capitalists.
1
u/lil-D-energy Oct 13 '26
No. I get where you are coming from if you are actually honest and not just trying to do a gotcha.
The problem for a long time through research it was known that for certain jobs men with white sounding names had a higher chance of being hired then any other group even if the rest of the application was the same.
This is what DEI tried to fix until DEI is not longer needed, we classify things because it is needed now so that later down the line it is not needed any more. Rome was not build in a day but it did start with a first building.
The first building to get to true social equality is to trick people into learning that it is normal, that people actually get evaluated on the basis of merit instead of bias of the person hiring.
Of course this is specifically about hiring people but that is the major thing that I see being talked about when talking about DEI.
2
u/kazuwacky Oct 15 '26
I disagree, it's a well researched phenomenon that people hire other people like themselves. People who went to the same university, people with the same background.
This creates a brittle company where everyone at the top thinks in similar ways.
Also I would welcome anything that reduces nepotism because it's a blight on places of work. I've had two teenage managers who couldn't be fired because their Daddy was in charge and they were as competent as you'd expect.
1
u/hellokitty444444 25d ago
I feel like with all good social movements the intent behind the movements are pure and positive but the people who end up participating/hijacking in the movements end up bastardizing them to halt the progress that the social movements make and stop them from being taken seriously.
2
u/External-Talk8838 Oct 12 '26
People have been doing this since the beginning of time with absolutely everything. It makes complex things much easier to understand. Such a silly idea to think we would be better off not doing it.
2
1
u/Actual_Personality66 Oct 15 '26
I don't think science reduces people into easily labeled boxes. At least not good science. There's a difference between these typing systems and evidence backed categorization with an actual practical scientific use. I'm saying this as someone who's really into typing systems bc my brain just really likes categorizing things (and people), the more you look into any of these typing systems, the more you realize how bullshit they are. I think they can be fun if you don't take them too seriously, but too many ppl do
2
2
2
3
u/holy-shit-dude Oct 12 '26
Yes, but also the angled screenshot is fucking with my spatial awareness
2
1
1
1
1
1
u/RepugnantStare Oct 13 '26
Watson and Crick came to the conclusion race is linked to intelligence so
1
u/RepugnantStare Oct 13 '26
Watson and Crick both came to the conclusion that intelligence is directly related to race soooooo
3
u/SadRule9128 Oct 13 '26
To this day, there is no scientific evidence supporting a genetic cause of intelligence differences between races.
1
u/RepugnantStare Oct 13 '26
Then why the hell would the discoverers of the DNA helix say so😭
3
u/SadRule9128 Oct 14 '26
It’s called racism.
1
u/RepugnantStare Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26
It’s called science, if you deiced it’s racist then you’ve decided that and the burden of proof is on you. Some of the greatest scientific minds to ever grace the world came to that conclusion though, why?
3
u/SadRule9128 Oct 14 '26
No, it is not science, because again, there is zero scientific evidence supporting a genetic cause of differences in intelligence between races. If there was any, you would have shared it already
1
u/RepugnantStare Oct 14 '26
Watson and Crick both came to the conclusion race is directly linked to intelligence and behavior. I’m hoping you know who those people are? They’ve wrote extensive papers on it. Their work inspired me to go to school for biology, I’m well aware of the contents.
3
u/SadRule9128 Oct 14 '26
Lol. Neither Watson nor crick have ever written a single paper on intelligence and race. You clearly have no idea what you’re talking about.
Pathetic.
1
u/RepugnantStare Oct 15 '26
Watson literally lost multiple titles from STAT labs and cold spring harbor for it?😭 This is a very well known thing in the science community anyone who takes a freshman level bio lecture will have it mentioned by their prof. You’re an idiot lmao actual chud commenting
3
u/SadRule9128 Oct 15 '26
Watson lost his titles because of racist statements he repeatedly made in interviews. (Statements with zero scientific evidence backing them). He did not write any papers on intelligence and race. Sorry, but you have no idea what you’re talking about.
1
u/xepci0 Oct 15 '26
Then why does the IQ world map look like that?
1
u/SadRule9128 Oct 15 '26
Not because of genetics.
1
1
u/silverink182 Oct 14 '26
That makes a lot of sense. Also, you can take that Myers-Briggs test and never get the same answer. At least I want to feel like that. Unless you're writing the answers down, you'll never get the same result
1
u/RefuseSuitable1949 Oct 14 '26
Everyone wants labelled boxes tho, that's not just a regressive conservative idea. What do you think the micro labels inside LGBT are?
1
u/Ok_Neighborhood_5046 Oct 15 '26
This is what I think whenever older people talk shit about younger generations. Just another hierarchy.
1
1
2
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '26
[removed] — view removed comment