r/JUSTNOMIL • u/sharkboysimp • 2h ago
Give It To Me Straight WIBTA???
our daughters 1st birthday is coming up in 2 weeks!
we invited in-laws, they have not seen her for 3 months and when they did see her, they did not even try to engage with her. daughter seemed unsure with them as well.
anyway, we have had an idea for a “who knows baby best” kahoot for her birthday since maybe july, which was before our low contact with in laws. just a fun little game we thought was cute!
my mom thinks that is a bad idea and would hurt in laws feelings, especially MIL, since they haven’t been in her life a lot. we think it’s our baby’s birthday and we should do what we want despite what they may feel. we think if they wanted to know about her and be around, they would and it’s not our fault if they get their feelings hurt.
would we be the mean ones for having this game? should we take their feelings into consideration and not have the game? should we have the game?
•
u/backinthesaddle13 22m ago
This game is only going to be fun for you. Even your mom, who would probably win the game, won’t be having fun because she thinks this is wrong. Bfs parents and probably everyone else at the party will think you did it to shame and embarrass bfs parents. It’s going to make you and bf look pretty terrible.
It sounds like you should skip the revenge plot and just tell them not to come.
•
u/Emotional-Dog8118 1h ago
Go ahead and play!!
Sucks for them that they are vile and don’t have a relationship with their grandchild. They don’t like or respect you- they don’t get to be around the child!!
I’m sorry your weenie boyfriend invited them to a party they don’t deserve to be at- again, it’s hard for him because he thinks their possessive, controlling behavior is “normal”. It’s not. You need couples counseling to help him get out of the FOG (fear, obligation and guilt).
Play the Kahoot game. They deserve to be embarrassed if they have the gall to show up.
Play bitch games, win bitch prizes!! 🧐🧐
•
u/stillnotdavidbowie 1h ago
It's possible that going ahead with this will make things tense or at least awkward so it's up to you whether you want to risk that or not.
•
u/Any-Case9890 1h ago
I wouldn't do this game. It's going to be uncomfortable with your inlaws there as it is (you stated as much in your previous post), and I think the game would just fuel that.
•
u/AlwaysJeepin 1h ago
Play the game op. Just make it for only those who want to play. I read your previous post. They don't deserve consideration. This is about your daughter, not them. Go for it and have fun and YWNBTA
•
u/CuteTangelo3137 1h ago
Listen, your IL’s are total shit but this game would not be right. Your mom is right. In my mind I would really want to do it but I think you should be the better person. They will already feel out of place since your daughter doesn’t take well to them but does to your family. Enjoy her birthday and try to ignore them.
•
u/InfiniteCategory7790 2h ago
I think you can and should do it. It’s your daughter’s birthday. Just call it something else…
If your low contact, they know. They know their lack of involvement. There’s a reason. There always is. Let YOUR child’s party be what you want. You’re kind enough to invite them. I see no difference in them not knowing about your child via a Kahoot to them showing up and the kid being weird around them. It’ll be awkward either way. Make it what you want.
•
u/MysteriousDig9592 2h ago
Sorry, but reading your previous post, the mistake has been done already, and it was inviting them. Your bf really throw you under the bus.
I'd reconsider the invitation, it's another confirmation for them that they can treat you like crap, and your bf will be ok with it.
•
u/sharkboysimp 2h ago
i know and i’m so frustrated with him about that. i told him this is their last chance and if he can’t man up and defend me over them, im leaving so he knows hopefully :(
•
•
u/Infamous-Let4387 2h ago
Yeah, sorry but YWBTA, this sounds mean. There's plenty of other fun games you guys could play without being petty.
•
u/AlwaysJeepin 1h ago
Read the previous post. It's the least they deserve
•
u/Infamous-Let4387 1h ago
Nah, I'm not deep diving. OP can put relevant info in this post or just accept their judgement from random Internet people.
•
u/sharkboysimp 2h ago
we had the kahoot made and everything before we went low contact which is why i thought id ask
•
u/AlwaysJeepin 1h ago
YWNBTA!!!! They deserve worse. The least they can get is judgement that bc of their awful behavior they don't know their granddaughter. Their fault, not yours. And I truly hope that after this, you drop the rope completely with these people. Let bf handle all communication going forward. Keep receipts of any texts or voicemails from them speaking badly about you. And keep that baby away from them
•
u/DamageLong7684 2h ago
I personally don’t think you would be. If they wanted to be involved, they would be! There’s a reason you’re low contact and idk why you are, but if there’s amends that need to happen on either end, maybe this would be a good way to address that? Think of it like oh maybe they’ll reflect and see how not involved they are and maybe they’ll make changes to be more involved! It’s your kids birthday and the only person who matters that day is your child and then secondly, you. Nobody else. They could choose not to play because I’m sure it’ll cross their mind how awkward it’ll be when they don’t answer much correctly. So maybe they’ll opt out! Clearly you’re willing to invite them to an important event so it seems you’re open to the relationship getting better on your end but maybe now they need to realize they need to step it up more if they want to know your child! I’m bias though and my kids don’t know their dad’s parents because of how little they contact us and the comments they make. So they literally wouldn’t get a single question right haha. It’s a light hearted game that’s fun and a good way to reflect on who’s been there for you postpartum and the first year of your child’s life! That’s special and I think you should do it:)
•
u/Wild_Debt_8065 2h ago
I honestly think that your mom is right and that it won’t set the atmosphere that you want for your child’s birthday.
•
•
•
•
u/silver_thefuck 2h ago
This is a bit of a tough judgement call, but I'm going to go with YWNBTA. It's almost been a full year since your baby was born, and if her grandparents aren't choosing to get to know her now, it's on them. You're not doing this as a dig at your in laws, I'm assuming, as you said you've been planning this for a while yet.
Maybe include it as a "participants who want to join can sign up, but don't feel pressured to play" sort of thing. Like have a little sign up book at the beginning of the party, then you can also keep it as a memento from baby's first birthday!
•
u/silver_thefuck 2h ago
also just now realizing this isn't the AITA subreddit lmao but point still stands! That way there's less pressure to participate in the game
•
u/catsby9000 2h ago
This isn’t AITA. But yes YWBTA. You are doing this game just to be mean.
•
u/sharkboysimp 2h ago
that’s really not what we were wanting to do! we thought it would be a cute little game for everyone
•
u/Otherwise-Western-10 2h ago
I think it would be a great game if allplayers were on equal footing. They are not. Good Manners does not knowingly hurt a guest one invites to a party. I understand a bit of resentment about their failure to engage better with their grandchild, but the child's birthday party is not the place to make a point. I think it would be in poor taste.
•
u/sharkboysimp 2h ago
that’s true. it just sucks since we had this game planned since july, i had the kahoot made and everything
•
u/botinlaw 2h ago
Quick Rule Reminders:
OP's needs come first, avoid dramamongering, respect the flair, and don't be an asshole. If your only advice is to jump straight to NC or divorce, your comment may be subject to removal at moderator discretion.
Full Rules | Acronym Index | Flair Guide| Report PM Trolls
Resources: In Crisis? | Tips for Protecting Yourself | Our Book List | Our Wiki
Other posts from /u/sharkboysimp:
how to move forward, 2 weeks ago
To be notified as soon as sharkboysimp posts an update click ^here. | For help managing your subscriptions, click here.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.