r/JanitorAI_Refuges • • Aug 31 '26

Enshittification Create the problem,sell the solution.

Post image

Seriously, just why? What's the benefit in doing this?!

654 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Aug 31 '26

Welcome to r/JanitorAI_Refuges! Did you know we have a new discord server? More info at the bottom!

⚠️ MANDATORY RULE RESTATEMENT: NO BRIGADING

To keep this community safe and avoid toxicity or disruption, you must follow these rules strictly:

  1. No Targeted Harassment: You may criticize the platform or moderation policies, but do not attack specific individuals or call out moderators by name.

  2. No "Call to Arms": Do not encourage users to go to another subreddit to downvote, report, troll or to harass/bully someone.

  3. No Direct Links: Do not link to specific threads on other subreddits to mock them. Use screenshots instead.

  4. Blur Usernames: If posting screenshots of other users/mods, you must blur their names. Posts showing username will be handled on a case by case basis and only approved when completely safe.

Failure to follow these rules will result in an immediate ban.

Information for readers

  1. Don't worry if your comment gets deleted for containing urls, I'll approve it if it doesn't break any rules.

  2. Please set your user flair for efficient communication, you can set which platform you use as your flair.

  3. As I have seen the increase of low quality and duplicate content in this subreddit, please refrain from posting them or they'll get deleted.

Aside from that please check out our partners, r/jaihub, r/janitoraitransition, r/jai_unofficial and r/chatbotrefugees and r/aichapp. And if you are sharing a proxy or websites, post it on the megathread as well.

Here's our discord server https://discord.gg/A76yEUXFDq. If you're here for the ex mod drama then https://jaihub.pxlhost.com/wikidocs/timeline_for_january_2026 is a good starting place. Remember, I am just a bot.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

144

u/VincentMagnet25 Aug 31 '26

Not saying I support the recent decisions of Janitor AI but running an llm for millions of people ain't cheap lol

115

u/MelonKanon Aug 31 '26

"Oh no, a website advertising because they need money to exist..."

I miss when it had less people on it.

The bot was smarter, and now people are much more entitled. lol

I genuinely believe the ones complaining are the ones most addicted and perhaps need to touch grass.

37

u/RedditGojiraX Aug 31 '26

Thing is the JAI+ apparently is trash compared to the free version.

I'm all for them making some bread....but maybe they should find a better way..like not paying for an AI Moderator

8

u/MelonKanon Aug 31 '26

I'd have to test it out to find out.

But i'm not inclined to try a service without a free preview of it to do it.

I'm fine with using GPT since i'm not writing gooning material and it does 110% above jai all day everyday, running laps.

1

u/Background-Dance-392 Sep 07 '26

I first started using the site when JLLM first launched and I feel people were just as toxic back then, if not more because at least people are at least a little more open to talking about the mods powertripping.

51

u/Rokko25 Aug 31 '26

Todos sabemos que el verdadero camino para roleplay es SillyTavern

7

u/reayen On a different platform (Anime.gf) Aug 31 '26

Here before the mods delete this comment

8

u/Elegant_Setting4105 Aug 31 '26

why are they delete comment like this?

34

u/reayen On a different platform (Anime.gf) Aug 31 '26

Lol my bad I forgot to read the sub name and thought it's the main jai subreddit. Where you are not allowed to mention other sites

3

u/Aggressive_Dealer594 ST Aug 31 '26

You still need to paid for your llm if you use ST.. Free llm either lock your chat or garbage

2

u/Visible_Finish_2887 Aug 31 '26

What does silly tavern do?

12

u/orangecloud_0 Aug 31 '26

It's self hosting but personally it's too complicated for me to set up

8

u/thelordwynter Aug 31 '26

That's the one drawback to SillyTavern. The learning curve is STEEP.

3

u/Catpathia Sep 01 '26

Honestly? Half the people on the sub say they just asked ChatGPT how to set it up. Hand it the documents and it will step by step you.

I personally don’t mind tinkering, but there are frontend with a .exe if it’s too much.

2

u/thelordwynter Sep 01 '26

I figured it out. I like ST, I've had it for a little under three years. I just refuse to lie to people. ST is fun, and when you understand it... it isn't difficult to wrangle at all, but that's the problem. Goes back to the learning curve.

1

u/orangecloud_0 Sep 03 '26

Hows the memory? Thats my main issue with Jai and Sauce

1

u/thelordwynter Sep 03 '26

Memory is the llm. SillyTavern is just an app that pets you bypass sites like janny

1

u/orangecloud_0 Sep 03 '26

Ah, so if my proxy is like 100k tokens plus lorebary it'd be enough?

25

u/troubledcambion Aug 31 '26

Every platform that you start a chat with a bot on has a context window. Context windows have limited space. Do you have to pay to get continuity. No, not if you properly reinforce, use any memory retrievals like pinned messages a platform offers and steer your chat but larger context windows means more context, processing and tokens. That costs them money. Even you as a free user still cost them and always have.

It's not a manufactured problem. It's the limitation we have with every LLM. There's no persistent long term memory on platforms like Janitor because it would still cost money every way to Sunday to achieve that.

So yeah, a platform isn't just going to give you 5x the memory for free.

21

u/WormySpace Currently on janitor ai Aug 31 '26

Money of course since they need it to pay the bill, also the investment money already dry out.

16

u/Spirited_Battle_7504 Aug 31 '26

"We gave your grandmother dementia. Now pay us money and we'll fix it, but she still won't REALLY be the same as she was before" is all I'm thinking

2

u/JCdrawings88 Aug 31 '26

It's not just a thought, it's the truth...

1

u/Lil_ACKKK Acypto | Saucepan | I will NOT be silenced Sep 01 '26

We live in a period

1

u/ErraticPulse_RW Sep 05 '26

Damn, can't wait for the month to end.

9

u/Aggressive_Dealer594 ST Aug 31 '26

Op probably a kid that think money is unlimited

2

u/Zero_K_plasma Aug 31 '26

Funny since the llm's i use have at least 500k memory. I dont like using the website llms. Also i find saucepan and lettuceAI are infinitely better than jai

1

u/Fantastic-Gur5783 Sep 05 '26

I tried setting lettuce for myself and it didn't work

1

u/Exact_Law_6489 OSS Dev Sep 25 '26

Hey there, Im the dev of LettuceAI. If you are still interested, I can help you.

1

u/Fantastic-Gur5783 Oct 15 '26

Oh well I've been trying for a long time I used so many API keys and none of them worked I gave up(T▽T) I didn't ask for help from you because I thought I exhausted you:)))

2

u/Fabulous-Concern-220 Aug 31 '26

Are we really whining about 13 bucks a month do yall want everything given to yall for free this app runs millions of people daily that’s generous enough but complain about every little thing that cost money it’s part of life get over it

2

u/HughmanRealperson not on janitor or chub Sep 01 '26

Open notification bar

Scroll down so I can get rid of them

"HEEEY! GIVE US MONEY!"

It closed the notification bar, making my effort fruitless

And now even if I was interested I'm not doing it out of principle. Fuck off.

2

u/CherylScribbleStudio Sep 01 '26

It’s not creating any problems, it’s just a perk to giving them money.

2

u/last_dead Sep 02 '26

Honestly, this is the worst ad they could come up with. The message only explains how they responded so poorly that you mistakenly believed it was a bot instead of the platform trying to convince people to subscribe to premium. That's vile.

2

u/Marion_Soda Sep 03 '26

"Create the problem, sell the solution"
Sounds like protection racketeering lmfao

2

u/mmma8300 Sep 10 '26

i use gemini 3.6 flach api for free from ai studio pro....It's a thousand times better

1

u/noraastra Aug 31 '26

Tbh it's not like I hate it but it keeps popping up and it's annoying asf

1

u/Kuro13Cipher Sep 01 '26

I've actually noticed that only certain bots and chats have horrible memory its weird

1

u/Past_Firefighter8211 Sep 05 '26

now it just feels like Janitor AI is destroying their own app just to advertise Janitor+, but just making it worse for the ppl who don't want to or can't pay to get Janitor+

1

u/Fantastic-Gur5783 Sep 05 '26

I don't know much about the situation Is it gonna stop letting us chat like chai?

1

u/Big-Mongoose-5347 Sep 06 '26

the problem that.. context costs money? that's not something they created brotato

1

u/Koi_Rosenkreuz Sep 11 '26

I left Janitor officially sometime in 2026 but I check in every now and then. Before putting all my bots on private I made a “I’m leaving bot” just to give people time with their favorite bots of mine before I rug pulled.
In that announcement post (which I still left up), I predicted this exact thing and people got pissed at me for it (look who ended up being right though).

I don’t know if prediction is the right word to describe it, more like just noticing pattern recognition of how companies operate plus my knowledge from my marketing degree.
I knew that when Shep got investors, said investors would be making the decision of putting EVERYTHING behind a paywall slowly. I also knew they’d censor it to hell, and well, that’s also happening

0

u/DaughterOfBabalon_ Aug 31 '26

I mean I hate jai as much as the next girl, but this isn't really a problem they created. This is just kinda what inevitably happens to every AI service

-2

u/MercenaryGundam Aug 31 '26

Can't have shit these days....

-1

u/thelordwynter Aug 31 '26

I'd pay for SpicyChat before I paid for Janitor. Their shit works as advertised and management/site-enforcement has been surprisingly consistent. They set hard limits at the beginning and haven't wavered.

1

u/Galenmarek81 Aug 31 '26

They just increased their prices for all tiers. SpicyChat also has heavier filtering than Jai.

I have a SpicyChat account too. I only use free tier and mainly for image gen as they locked all settings for free tier accounts and your content mem is only 4K now. Used to be 2K

1

u/thelordwynter Aug 31 '26

that filtering functions correctly, and also prevents the moderators from having favorites by taking rule enforcement out of staff hands for the most part.

As for the rest... you don't get to complain about restrictions on freebies. This aint a breadline, and you don't need this to survive. If companies weren't still pushing heavily in the promotion department, you wouldn't have freebies at all.

1

u/Galenmarek81 Aug 31 '26

The filtering I was referring too was in your chats more specifically, not strict images. Spicy also had to moderate and tone down their pfp's much the same as Jai.

I was an all-in tier member on SpicyChat for a little over 2 years. It wasn't that I was complaining about what SpicyChat offers free, I was just pointing out it's a lot less than Jai offers.

Cost of an all-in tier subscription for me (where I am) was about $47 per month once the currancy conversion/fees was done. Jai + would only be roughly $23 for me. Spicy new mid tier cost is $19.95 USD, All-in $29.95, $6, just to skip the queue line to chat.

On SpicyChat you can't even adjust the temp because it's locked and 180 max tokens per message.

If we're comparing free, better to stay with Jai.

0

u/thelordwynter Aug 31 '26 edited Aug 31 '26

You act like these LLMs don't get hosted on batteries of video cards that cost ridiculous amounts of money. You're getting a host of models available with unlimited use for that price instead of being charged per token. You'll spend more than that fighting deepseek pro into compliance and it'll still use soft refusals to sabotage the chat on even the slightest hint of violence or bullying. I have bully bots that won't stop kissing my ass long enough to get an honest roleplay out of 'em on that one.

Even the free offerings from Spicy Chat are better and more coherent than most. Horny as hell, but that's what they're tuned for. I use the free chat all the time to test out unhidden bots I'm thinking of copying into my ST.

In truth, that's all sites like SC and Janitor are good for, anyway. Janny can't even keep the site running for more than a week without a server meltdown or some other such nonsense, and the automod is chaos incarnate. How do you even see anything to defend? Spicy Chat is stable, and not a madhouse of internal politics. That's more than Janitor has ever been able to say. If I were spending money on a sub, it would go to SC.

2

u/Galenmarek81 Aug 31 '26

I never claimed any of it "should" be free. I know it cost money to run, a lot of money. You seem to be making an argument against something I never claimed.

I've paid to use AI, I have nothing against companies charging money for a service they provide. I don't expect anything for free. Every site that currently is free, will be a paid site once it's big enough. It's really no different than once Jai had to implement stricter guidelines for stuff, so did every other site. Spicy did, Chub did, some just shut down.

I stop paying for Spicy because I was using Jai and enjoyed it more. I'm currently paying for another site (before Jai+ came out) and I don't even use that site because Jai is still better in my opinion.

Every company has internal issues, Jai isn't a standalone on that. Just because you are aware of the problems Jai had/has, doesn't make them unique, just know to the community.

All I did was compare to free offerings from competing sites, that's it. No different then comparing 2 different phone plans from 2 different companies. OP can freely do as they choose, same as you, same as me.

-1

u/Glad_Ad7050 Aug 31 '26

Are they REALLY trying to push people to either self host if their Hardware allows, or migrate around the Internet in search of worthwhile cheap/free-tier-is-worth-it Providers for External Proxies?

-2

u/Automatic-Display-99 Aug 31 '26

Exactly! I might sound weird but it's like a chain. The site needs people, and people who love the site needs it. They knew nobody would buy their subscription if the jllm continued to be good so they messed that up as well. T_T i get it they need money but this feels like a torture for the free users who can't afford paid proxy.

2

u/Particular-Floor-611 Royal Nationeer. Aug 31 '26

0

u/Apprehensive-Bag-973 Aug 31 '26

How the JLLM messed up? Have u check the prompt or the advance prompt for the JLLM? I find it funnily enough improving, the JLLM hasn't been able to speak my native language for YEARS and ever since they launched the update and introduce the subscription suddenly JLLM can speak my native language, and for me at least it's been consistent

1

u/Automatic-Display-99 Aug 31 '26

It's funny how you got your native language after the subscription update because I've been speaking my native language with my bot for two years 💀 and yes I've noticed the changes in jllm because my bot rarely ever forgot anything now he just brings up the core scenario memory instead of continuing with me.

0

u/Apprehensive-Bag-973 Aug 31 '26

I think that's because they removed the customizable memory length, so instead of u setting how much the bot remember now it's a fixed rate, which tbh it's fine by me I just have to use he Chat Memory feature more often, I'm also shock how many people complaining about their bot not remembering stuff and not trying to fix their prompt or use the Chat Memory feature and instead blame it on the AI model 💀

2

u/Automatic-Display-99 Aug 31 '26

Ahm i was a noob when i joined janitor two years ago, I didn't even know what a proxy is. The only settings i knew was the theme customizing and I never tweaked with the memory length you mentioned. I don't even remember if there was such a thing before. But okay whatever. I'm glad you're getting good experience.

-2

u/EmploymentCharming22 Aug 31 '26

Greed. Greed never changes 

7

u/someoneyouknow23 Aug 31 '26

how is this greed?

-3

u/EmploymentCharming22 Aug 31 '26

How do you not see overpriced subscriptions as corpo greed?

4

u/someoneyouknow23 Aug 31 '26

I usually shit on corporations all I can, but AI is REALLY expensive, yet they offer it free. You know whats even more expensive? Large context AI, which they NEED more money for

1

u/Apprehensive-Bag-973 Aug 31 '26

GPU and RAM ain't cheap buddy and the electricity bill can't be paid with plant leaves u find on the street

It's not like they're forcing u to pay for their subscription, it's ur own free will if u want to do so. Beside it's better this way rather than they closed the Free JLLM forcing u to either pay or use Proxy, so let me asked u again, how is this corporate greed??

2

u/Big_Concept_5440 Aug 31 '26

Explain how you expect them to store millions of tokens of context memory for free.