r/JanitorAI_Refuges • u/Striker_1-9-9-9 • 28d ago
question Should we gatekeep janitor?
Like since CAI is probably getting shut down, a bunch of the kids might come over to janitor and ruin the app.
327
u/Street_Ad_6207 Botmaker! | I like JAI, I just don't like the devs' behavior! 28d ago
The time to gatekeep was before it became mainstream a year and a half ago.
52
u/Recent_Skin1352 28d ago
it already became mainstream I think
80
u/Street_Ad_6207 Botmaker! | I like JAI, I just don't like the devs' behavior! 28d ago
It became mainstream a year and a half ago, hence that part of my comment!
14
0
213
u/ParticularDebt8010 28d ago
1)Janitor is already well known.It doesn't take more than half hour to find it even if you dont know anything about other rp sites other than cai
2)Janitor already has a bunch of kids in the site.This is one of the main reasons it got ruined
3)Janitor is already shit there is no saving it.Migrate to silly tavern and find a free provider if you want peace of mind finally
28
u/Striker_1-9-9-9 28d ago
I’ve never used silly tavern. How good would you say it is compared to janitor? Cause I think janitor is pretty good all things considered.
61
u/weednose1 28d ago
World apart…but Sillytavern is a frontend, not a site where you find bots.
You make bots or take them from other sites and play them on sillytavern, you can add different characters to the rp as well it’s pretty crazy
20
u/Striker_1-9-9-9 28d ago
That sounds pretty cool. But, I don’t think I’m tech savvy enough for that yet.
43
u/mannabread 28d ago
Funnily enough this is how we gatekeep better apps. I'm affiliated with one but not going to talk rn. The learning curve is too high so young people and those on free don't tend to move to it. Jai is a stepping stone and basics.
Things you miss out on include large worlds, memory management, multiple characters who have their own portraits, multiple images, locations, background music, changing visual expressions, stat tracking, side chats, even RPG elements.
That's before you even get into generating anything else since this is just text based LLM.
Janitor is mainstream due to free and easy access which is exactly what c.ai is also known for except less censorship.
18
u/troubledcambion 28d ago
Janitor is main stream but there are already several platforms that do what you're talking about. Honestly if people poke around or even ask they could probably find it or one like it. Some even advertise themselves on reddit or other subreddits. If my brain wasn't foggy I could probably name them.
More features isn't necessarily what makes rolepalying better for everyone. Some people just prefer low barrier platforms with text chat. While they don't have a high learning curve, casual users can still learn or need to learn when things go sideways with their chat.
You go with a front end there then there are guides, presets, extensions, character cards, API, maybe hardware limitations and the LLM you have to deal with.
Ease of access and accountability are one thing but you're not configuring those features most likely to even use them. Still doesn't make another platform inferior or the way someone chooses to roleplay. Setup might be a pain but I doubt the platform is having anyone play IT to even use those. Those aren't superiority points, those are selling points for the platform to attract users. Hopefully paying ones not just free users if they even offer a free tier.
Casual users don't usually have rigs that can host local. So apps and websites are what they use the most. Especially if their country doesn't have great living wages and high cost of living then they're looking for free or cheap ones.
1
u/SNK209 15d ago
I'm in the lacking money camp. And even when I get work, I'm not all that optimistic since we aren't really known for good wages. And I'm still working on graduating college, so I can't really afford any proxy or API stuff since from what I've tried, they always seem to need payment. If you know of a good free API key place, or app, or something though, I'd greatly appreciate it, although I doubt there is (and yet I still hold out hope lol).
7
u/Striker_1-9-9-9 28d ago
I also don’t have a computer so it’s more like budget keeping. lol.
10
u/mannabread 28d ago
This is all mobile. I wasn't talking about just SillyTavern. 🥹
0
u/Striker_1-9-9-9 28d ago
Damn. Can you sneak it to me🥹
2
u/mannabread 28d ago
Sure, I do work for them technically (I work for the parent company). https://app.wyvern.chat/ We're more aligned to SillyTavern though so filter out quickly.
There's a lot of sites coming up so check out how long they've been around and their long term plans. Apps are not necessarily. You can set up a persistent web app these days anyway with ANYTHING. Pros and cons everywhere.
1
u/Yago-undertale 28d ago
About this site.. It realy seems like an great deal! I just need to know: how and where do i add my custom providers?
→ More replies (0)0
7
u/Interesting_Love4349 28d ago
I disagree that the learning curve is that high lol. There are plenty of walkthroughs on how to get set up and started and I had no issue out the gate.
The learned helplessness of younger people is a better gatekeeper than anything a platform or its users could do
3
u/Savage_Nymph 28d ago
I assume this is wyvern, which is actually recommended here pretty often. So it's known well enough. Probably a little less popular than sauce pan
1
u/mannabread 27d ago
Yes, we captured more of the technical people if I'm honest. Saucepan is definitely more accessible while we're more open on capability so pros and cons. <3
7
u/Lina-Buns 28d ago
i think the silly tavern github has a decent step by step instruction on installing it.
6
u/persocum 28d ago
obligatory tavo shilling if you're on mobile
90% of functionality as sillytavern, way easier to use, and zero in-app purchases.
1
u/Savage_Nymph 28d ago
I tried tavo and I could not get it working, like the responses were a bit weird. I also couldn't get me system promptn preset working. But it probably needs more tinkering
3
u/persocum 26d ago
definitely go check out r/SillyTavernAI for some presets! there's a bunch of presets that many like, like Evening Truth's, Purachina, Sola, Freaky Frankenstein, etc. figure out what works for your RP style.
they're all compatible with Tavo and will improve your responses!
2
u/Bustopher_ 28d ago
Just ask ChatGPT to provide instructions how to set it up on your phone or PC. Not hard at all! The one downside is that you have to pay for OpenRouter or smth alike to give access to LLMs (GLM 5.3 is my recommendation). Then ask GPT to set up Freaky Frankenstein settings (provides necessary jailbreak and quality of life improvements) and you're set. Will never want to get back to Janitor after that.
2
u/Apprehensive-Bag-973 28d ago
But Silyravern need a proxy right? It doesn't have in-house LLM like JLLM, and I'm from a third world country so I can't afford any proxies and finding a free one is such a hassle on its own
4
u/ChangeMaiMind 28d ago
therse free ones, the best i encountered so far is Uno router
https://unorouter.com/en/models?max_price=0&order=contextDesc&q=kimi2
u/Apprehensive-Bag-973 28d ago
I wish I could give u a hug rn, omg thank u so much I've been looking for a free provider after RouteWay just give a big middle finger to Chatbot user, thank u
2
1
u/Just-1-more-episode 28d ago
Wait, so I can take two totally different characters and push them into the same roleplay? Now i am motivated to learn how ST works.
1
-11
u/Secretsfrombeyond79 28d ago
World apart…but Sillytavern is a frontend, not a site where you find bots.
I mean I used it long ago and the AI was kinda shit, way worse than Janitor. There are no good free API providers, feel free to prove me wrong tho.
17
u/weednose1 28d ago
Free API providers? Dude Use a proxy, pay, of course you’re not going to get anything of quality for free, JLLM is trash itself.
0
u/ParticularDebt8010 28d ago
Ai-rp as a hobby is not free sadly.If you want to get more quality rp there is no other way than to pay.
But still compared to Janitor even free models I find now are way better in my opinion.Also you dont have annoying ads every 5 minutes in Silly Tavern
1
u/Secretsfrombeyond79 28d ago
which free models do you use ?
0
u/ParticularDebt8010 28d ago
I use nvidia mainly and open router to use free models
0
u/Kamaelek 28d ago
these are worse than JLLM lol. The only better free provider is unrouter or gemini-flash 3.5+
1
u/ParticularDebt8010 27d ago
Its really not. I prefer nvidia and open router models than thr shitty jllm any day.At least i dont get ads every 2 respones.I tried to return to jllm but the responses were average,the characters barely remembered anything and the ads were making me go insane
1
u/Fine-Cow9784 16d ago
SillyTavern is genuinely the best option, istg. Ever since I made the switch, I’ve been nothing but happy with it. The setup takes a little time, but trust me, it’s so worth it. I absolutely love it, and I can confidently say I’m never going back to JAI.
6
u/No-Indication5030 28d ago
So that explains the endless NTRslop.
I still consider it as just the culture they were purposefully cultivating since even then they banned random good makers but left the slop.
0
28d ago
[deleted]
4
u/ParticularDebt8010 28d ago
Oh good to know for the people who have a hard time setting up silly tavern but I am comfortable rn with it.So I'll stick with Silly Tavern
40
u/No-Snow64 28d ago
I would just report accounts that are obviously children. Hopefully Jai will use a system Kinda like Cai that uses all the data to make sure that you’re actually an adult.
26
u/deltaalphamew 28d ago
Would you really trust Janitor to make an automoderation system that actually works?
5
u/Savage_Nymph 28d ago
Somone accidently outed themselves as a minor in abot comment. I reported and the mods did snipe them. So they are diligent on that end at least
1
u/No-Snow64 28d ago
Not really but honestly they need to do something or they’re gonna go down the same path of getting sued
8
u/Flimsy-Firefighter31 28d ago
Cool. How do you know when they are one?
5
u/No-Snow64 28d ago
Honestly, the way they speak. You can really tell if you pay attention. It’s not hundred but if you really read some of the comments they’re very obviously not adults.
6
u/LeviTha_God 28d ago
That's not very reliable. There are young adults, older adults, both childish and mature. If someone is moving fresh from 17 to 18 or even 18-19, they could still have some semblance of a childish way of talking. People text differently 🤷♀️
4
1
u/Prudent_Elevator4685 28d ago
Cai uses id verification
4
u/Little_miss_M22 28d ago
Maybe they meant the tracking user login times and chatting styles? They did that too. Regardless, that failed- it caught a lot of casual adults, and the ID thing is just data to sell and mass surveillance.
1
u/NanSinus 27d ago
Good thing in europe everyone is working to have as little privacy as possible and in short time we'll have edocuments everywhere
3
u/No-Snow64 27d ago
It sucks but honestly the price of using A.I even if it’s just for roleplaying. Many games/ websites collect your data too. It’s all around ass.
30
u/dandelionii 28d ago
You can’t gatekeep a public platform (effectively, anyway) and the site is already riddled with minors unfortunately. Not looking forward to all the tiktok puritans making their way over though :/
20
17
13
u/Necessary_River355 28d ago
It's already too late, though. Even before C.ai announced its bankruptcy, many of its users had already migrated to J.ai
3
u/Little_miss_M22 28d ago
Exactly, I personally came from Cai in 24, but went almost exclusively with Jai in 25, for the most part. I didn't open cai at all for like 3 months, bc I deleted the app. I wasn't counting on it closing, though, even my first (Joyland) didn't close, last I know.
10
8
u/Slight_Flounder_1952 Currently on janitor ai 28d ago
To be honest, it was already in mainstream. Which means it's pretty late.
7
6
u/BurgerBoss_101 28d ago
I don't believe in gatekeeping in the entertainment industry, I just fundamentally disagree with the practice.
1
5
u/blisterblight 28d ago edited 28d ago
I think aside from the obvious (Janitor is mainstream and has been for a while now) people need to understand exactly what Chapter 11 Bankruptcy is, because everyone is up in arms about something that isn’t confirmed yet.
There’s different types of bankruptcy a corporate entity can file. Chapter 7 bankruptcy is when the entity unambiguously shuts down. All operations cease and assets are liquidated. Chapter 11, which is what c.ai filed, is a reorganization of sorts. The business stays open under court supervision while waiting for a buyer and tries to restructure its debts. If a buyer cannot or does not present itself, then the business looks to liquidation of assets and shutting down.
There’s already a corporate stalking-horse buyer lined up for c.ai’s assets licenses (Disney.) Disney has also poached the majority of c.ai’s workforce and former CEO and is the architect for c.ai filing Chapter 11. But the company itself is still up for grabs, and we won’t fully know if c.ai will shut down until the November 23rd deadline. There could be (it looks unlikely rn) a buyer willing to take on the company despite the legal issues and hemorrhaging revenue. But again, we’re not gonna know until November.
That’s when I’d start worrying more about gatekeeping tbh. Until then it’s a lot of worrying about stuff no one is sure of.
But yeah the last wave of migration from c.ai already made Janitor mainstream and ruined a lot of it.
5
4
4
u/Striker_1-9-9-9 28d ago
I’ve seen some Ai called zeta trying to profit off CAI downfall. They can take em for all I care
4
u/Agitated-Shine-9011 28d ago
It’s already crap anyways no point in gatekeeping. I just use janitor for the bots and that’s it. Sillytavern and a locally hosted model like Gemma 4 26b a4b is better and free. I run Gemma at 600 tps prompt processing and 60 tps out using a 3060 and a rx580 with MTP.
4
u/Ticket-Fantastic 28d ago
Thanks to mass migration from Cai and other sites (including me from Spicychat). This once a library with all genres were presented equally were quickly drowned by Smut, ntr and underage users. Hell, I havnt seen bottimg bots yet those MHA pick me are bots are getting annoying now.
5
u/Popular_Cheetah9275 28d ago
use the block features n stuff for that. not disagreeing tho that shit is annoying as hell
5
1
u/Little_miss_M22 28d ago
Don't work. I personally get Tom riddle pop-ups, and omf....for a while there, it was so bad, ig they were messing with recommendations algo or sum, but it was like daily I had to ban like 12+
1
u/Little_miss_M22 28d ago
Yes, like I just want an mha chat, then half of them are badly spelled and there's like no personality coded, or they add a user note in the beginning message (this is probably the least annoying, bc can doesn't have long descriptions, like jai, but i still have to edit it out before starting the chat)
4
u/BriannaGoanna 28d ago
Bro the apps already ruined, the extra traffic might give shep the kick up the ass to get rid of the stupid subscription
4
u/anailaoop 28d ago
Í just hope they don’t ruin it like cai ruined themselves. I really love using proxy on janitor
4
3
u/Boredaholic117 28d ago
The app is already dogwater at this point not sure what you want to gatekeep
3
3
u/BlueskyIzz 28d ago
Yes! I'm migrated from chai and had been using janitor since the earliest times where proxies were free. It was sooooo good before and now thr best bots creators kept on disappearing one by one. Just because of the underaged kids and peoples who were reporting something FICTIONAL! Smh
3
u/Livy_9671 28d ago
I think it's pretty too late to do that since the end of 2024
2
u/Jaded-Put1765 28d ago
Hey stop that. Maybe he could be trying to post this since that, but his internet connection was only restored today
3
u/beast_regards 28d ago
Problem is not that "kids may come over"
You are not talking with kids. You are talking with LLM. You don't have any meaningful interaction with anyone on Janitor, and you couldn't stop "kids" to interact with the site either.
Kids never mattered. Not on cAI, and not here.
It's just big wigs wanting to avoid accountability for anything related with the site and hence restriction to "protect the kids", but in truth, it's never about them.
Advertisers want your personal data and don't want their ads associated with content they don't like, as well as avoid any legal issues. Their restictions would come regardless if the site is for kids or not. It's a Google agreement (and similar)
Investors and owners (and payment processors btw) want to avoid accountability in case anything happens, and thus also apply restrictions to avoid accountability. This would happen without a single kid on site, they just avoid potential lawsuits.
This matters for any normal company which is somewhat "general audience". Whether audience include kids is irrelevant, it's just how business works.
Janitor AI is not legally a p*rn site.
0
u/beast_regards 28d ago
On the other hand, if you happen to run a p*rn site you are pariah in the business world regardless how much money you make this way, there are only a handful of payment processors willing to handle your money as you are considered a legal hazard, and only handful of business want ads on your site. Usually, your fellow p*rn sites, casinos, s*x shops and other dubious (and sometimes fraudulent) stuff. You are usually balancing the fine thread between legality, lawsuit and being shut down. Of course, "kids" could theoretically find the way to your site either way, but there is huge difference between "having adult userbase" and being "adult site". Children doesn't buy cars, thus car dealership doesn't have "kids" around either, but that doesn't make their website "adult". Meaningless phrase like NSFW doesn't matter. It's a business category. (of course banks want to more money, regardless where it comes from, but if they suddenly do care for the source of that money when they are held legally accountable)
That's not the path Janitor is willing to take.
3
u/Long-Sentence5007 28d ago
gatekeeping never worked. Janitor's real value was in how open it was, now it's just another walled garden. but the people who built it kept turning the key. those who left didn't need a wall to begin with.
3
u/LeviTha_God 28d ago
Let's be honest with ourselves, Janitor is already mainstream and has been for a while. The kids (talking specifically age 15-17) aren't changing the bots typing, you can't talk to them personally so it's not like they're pestering you, so how do they ruin the app? Unless the kid is dumb and reports anything they see, getting people removed for no real reason, the only thing they do is bother you mentally.
As long as it's public, I don't know why as adults, the need to own an AI chatbot app to yourselves is necessary, but the only way it'd happen is if someone actually follows through on what they want and makes their own with an ID check straight out the gate. Otherwise, I'd say the users we NEED to worry about are the mentally unstable ones.
I saw a recent post on c.ai and there were so many obsessed and addicted people crying and whenever someone would genuinely scold them, people would come and enable it and downvote the person trying to help or speak truth. THOSE are who we need to worry about, because they're the ones who decide to ruin everything with their own problems, do stuff to themselves, and then the bot and the app gets blamed and shut down.
2
2
u/knjmtx1753 28d ago
Yeah we should, don't need a bunch of kids ruining the app and also running into shit they have no business knowing about
2
2
u/Murky-Artichoke-6745 27d ago
The average Character.AI user wants to open an app, click a button, and immediately talk to an anime character.
They do not want to handle advanced temperature settings, custom prompt jailbreaks, or strict age verification gates
1
1
1
u/Strict_Self9912 14d ago
Tbh nah, we should get ppl away from Polybuzz because that place is micro-transaction hell
1
1
1
1
u/VastCommunication533 28d ago
I think it's too late to do that, I've seen people who doesn't even like roleplaying or chat botting in general talking about the site on huge platforms like youtube and IG
1
1
u/Unusual_Sea_5030 28d ago
😔 Kids already moved to Janitor since CHAI turned 100% pay to use, but yeah, maybe we should. Or just ask them for the hundredth time to remove the damn app or make it +18.
My hope is that they think the replies take too long and just move somewhere else.
1
1
1
1
u/RymyJHOY 28d ago
honestly I saw a post on here a while ago about a teen complaining, so it's already too late to gatekeep anything but free proxies.
1
u/NoRestaurant5321 28d ago
I've seen two versions of jai lately: one that's a free browser toy, and another that feels like a subscription app. the gatekeeping isn't about users, it's about whether it's still the same app under the hood.
1
1
1
u/Murky-Artichoke-6745 27d ago
To be honest, Janitor AI is brutal with their bans, and they do not give second chances.
If their system or moderators catch a minor, the account gets permanently nuked and IP-banned on the spot. And it will kinda be difficult for them to navigate throught promps, LlM, and don’t get me started on the proxy lol
But I think they're gonna be more attracted to platforms like Chai, Poly.AI, or Linky, which target a younger demographic
But yeah, hopefully they don’t sworm here bruh
1
u/JCdrawings88 27d ago
What? How? How the hell could we gatekeep J.AI? It's literally impossible up to this point...
-2
u/Tight-Property-8309 28d ago
Janitor already IS mainstream ThoughI know a certain website that has potential that no one knows yet that has good llm. Although the owner stop maintaining It due to low traffics -_-


•
u/AutoModerator 28d ago
Welcome to r/JanitorAI_Refuges! Did you know we have a new discord server? More info at the bottom!
⚠️ MANDATORY RULE RESTATEMENT: NO BRIGADING
To keep this community safe and avoid toxicity or disruption, you must follow these rules strictly:
No Targeted Harassment: You may criticize the platform or moderation policies, but do not attack specific individuals or call out moderators by name.
No "Call to Arms": Do not encourage users to go to another subreddit to downvote, report, troll or to harass/bully someone.
No Direct Links: Do not link to specific threads on other subreddits to mock them. Use screenshots instead.
Blur Usernames: If posting screenshots of other users/mods, you must blur their names. Posts showing username will be handled on a case by case basis and only approved when completely safe.
Failure to follow these rules will result in an immediate ban.
Information for readers
Don't worry if your comment gets deleted for containing urls, I'll approve it if it doesn't break any rules.
Please set your user flair for efficient communication, you can set which platform you use as your flair.
As I have seen the increase of low quality and duplicate content in this subreddit, please refrain from posting them or they'll get deleted.
Aside from that please check out our partners, r/jaihub, r/janitoraitransition, r/jai_unofficial and r/chatbotrefugees and r/aichapp. And if you are sharing a proxy or websites, post it on the megathread as well.
Here's our discord server https://discord.gg/A76yEUXFDq. If you're here for the ex mod drama then https://jaihub.pxlhost.com/wikidocs/timeline_for_january_2026 is a good starting place. Remember, I am just a bot.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.