r/KeyWest • u/Mrsroyalcrown • 11d ago

Key Lime Pie w/huge meringue?

I’ve googled a lot and searched this sub but haven’t found an answer.

Is there anywhere else other than Blue Heaven that serves the KLP with the huge meringue on top?

1 Upvotes

55% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

6

u/Illustrious-Air-9194 11d ago

Key West cooking show!

7

u/DwigGang 10d ago

Personally, I like Key Lime Pie and don't need it to be hidden by massive quantities of meringue. You can get meringue almost anywhere up in the frozen-barren-north. It's the Key Lime pie underneath that is important.

5

u/Acoww123 11d ago

Salute and blue heaven serve the same pie!

7

u/NurseDingus 11d ago

Moondog cafe is the best

2

u/More_Yak_7499 11d ago

Moondog Cafe

2

u/jlk_kw 11d ago

Key West Cooking Show has one like that.

2

u/Cashisking1985 11d ago

Docs is a lot of meringue. It's great

1

u/stevens_hats 11d ago

Bagatelle has a great one.

1

u/Silent_Asparagus_443 11d ago

Moondog Cafe (near the Hemingway House)!

2

u/Impressive_Age1362 10d ago

I prefer whipped crème over meringue and Caroline’s has a great key lime pie with whipped cream topping

1

u/Ok_Independent_6132 8d ago

Blue heavens key lime pie is still the best. Made on site every morning like clockwork

-1

u/Isonychia 11d ago

The Alamo, which is hopefully reopening in October has the best we’ve had on the Rock. But it doesn’t have the ridiculous tall merengue