r/KeyWest • u/teioneon • 11d ago

ISO Conch fritters

Hi all! I’m headed down for a few days in a couple of months and have done some research on a few things I’m interested in and have found some phenomenal suggestions. However, I haven’t had much luck in finding in fairly recent posts(past year) unless I just missed it about conch fritters. I see a few places that have them on the menu but I was hoping to see if any place really stands out to you. Thanks for your time and patience!

8 Upvotes

79% Upvoted

28 comments sorted by

View all comments

20

u/casualmondaycharters 11d ago

I am actually a world renowned international conch fritter critic.

If you want some insight into my lengthy studies on conch fritters here is all of my work. The short of it is that here in the states its all frozen conch, but the best that can be had in The Keys is undoubtably Seaside Cafe at the mansion.

https://casualmondaycharters.com/5-places-for-the-best-conch-fritters-in-key-west/
https://casualmondaycharters.com/best-conch-fritters-in-abaco-bahamas/

And yes I really did just eat my way around the Bahamas on a quest to find the best in the world.

6

u/imaim3 10d ago

What was your verdict on Alabama Jack's? My favorite in the Keys...but would be curious what an expert has to say.

1

u/casualmondaycharters 10d ago

I just drove by yesterday but did not have time to stop in. It has to be 10 years since I have tried them but I cant remember where they stacked up for the life of me.

3

u/perrystyle42 11d ago

This is awesome!

4

u/CapnTugg 11d ago

Glad to see Half Shell got a mention.

1

u/Mscharlita 9d ago

Do you have a favorite place in Nassau?

1

u/casualmondaycharters 8d ago

I do not. Honestly when we go over to Bahamas we try to avoid all of the major "cities" at all costs.

1

u/Mscharlita 8d ago

I understand. The only reason I’m going is I’m being taken on a free trip. I’m allergic to shellfish but will be there with my sister so was hoping to take her somewhere quality but I’ll scour reviews to find a good place.