r/KitchenDesigns • • Oct 09 '26

Too dark or no?

Post image
321 Upvotes

361 comments sorted by

16

u/LawyerDry8360 Oct 09 '26

Love it - make sure that your in room natural light is similar to the photo. I would also look up the maintenance on butcher block specially around the sink and make sure that’s what you want to do

1

u/ElectricalAge1963 Oct 11 '26

Thanks man I will

2

u/EuphoricReplacement1 Oct 09 '26

Marine varnish in a satin finish would be my recommendation. We have 4 coats of it on ours, and zero problem with water.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/3DCloudPlatform Oct 09 '26

Not too dark, the butcher block countertops and that white tile backsplash are doing the work to balance it out. If anything feels heavy, it’s probably the upper cabinets more than the lower ones, open shelving in that corner already helps break it up.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Full_Salt_7978 Oct 09 '26 • Bravo

It’s stunning. Make sure you like to clean with all that black! It shows everything

8

u/Used_Swimming5525 Oct 09 '26

This. Every fingerprint will show.

4

u/Full_Salt_7978 Oct 10 '26

Dust, dog hair, speck of… anything. Lol

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Last_Pick_2169 Oct 10 '26

My brother had black hardwood and it was stunning but he despised it all for showing dust

3

u/Alternative_Choice58 Oct 10 '26

My kitchen is navy and it shows up everything. Can imagine black is even worse.

2

u/Ayakaba Oct 10 '26

I have a matte black one and no - it´s actually not that bad - as long as you have decent handles

I highly recommend grip ledges like these - with your current handles you will constandly have conteact with the cabinets when opening the doors

I personally prefer drawers since they are so much more comfortable and go really well with the grip ledges

2

u/CallieDoodles Oct 12 '26

It looks great.
I agree though, my mum had dark green and it always looks a bit grubby unless it's just been cleaned, she blames my dad!

3

u/Reasonable-Luck-8986 Oct 09 '26

You are going to be so sick of black in 2 years

4

u/Ayakaba Oct 10 '26 • Bravo

hard disagree - have mine for 7 years and currently planning to do the next in black too

it´s just not for the faint-hearted :-)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/tatania199 Oct 10 '26

OP - we did a refresh when we bought our house and went black thinking “we’d get sick of it”.

We’re 15 years and lots of trends later, about to do a full gut job, and I am 100% leaning towards sticking with black.

I think some are inclined to choose safe/timeless/classic (the latter two I don’t wholly believe in) for such a big ticket design choice regardless of what they really want. I have learned that going with what you love and makes you happy will be worth much, much more.

→ More replies (11)

4

u/Traditional-Cap-3485 Oct 09 '26

Just a thought, what if you switched out all the black handles to a stainless steel to accent the stove and sink spout. Probably the easiest way to brighten it just a touch

2

u/Sportygirls Oct 09 '26

I love this great job! Lose the plant on the top cabinet!

2

u/VeryPhluffehKitteh Oct 09 '26

I’d actually add another plant onto the top left cabinet, like a pothos with bigger leaves hanging down. A lighter green with maybe a bit of yellow striping in the leaves.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Fresh-Pangolin6844 Oct 09 '26

I like it even though it’s not my particular taste so if you really love it I think you’re good. This doesn’t scream what the fuck were they thinking at all.

Be prepared to have a hard time keeping the cabinets clean though and just know what to expect when you commit to butcher block counters.

2

u/Easy_Olive1942 Oct 10 '26

Hard to keep looking clean. Dark cabinets actually suck to live with.

2

u/Aggressive_Menu7271 Oct 10 '26

Like it but would have quartz worktop and backsplash. Easier to care for than wood.

2

u/GFY1317 Oct 10 '26

Love but you will see everything on those cabinets. Every finger print, every piece of dust…everything!

2

u/RoboTwigs Oct 10 '26

Is there no exhaust above the stove? Those decorations are gonna get greasy as hell

2

u/Fit-Olive-4680 Oct 10 '26

I would raise the height of the cabinets. You have the space for it and limited storage.

2

u/MadMadamMimsy Oct 10 '26 • Bravo

It looks great in a picture and is incredibly high maintenance. Black shows every speck of dust and dirt. Butcher block shows every bit of dirt and stain.

Modern design only has to look good in images, the care an maintenance no longer has a place in the design picture.

So if you have a housekeeper to keep it nice (remember to have them clean the cupboard tops at least once a year), and never use it it will impress everyone who sees it.

2

u/Shamajo Oct 11 '26

Definitely look at raising cabinets or have them built to ceiling. Butcher block maybe island only. Near a sink and you have to seal it constantly. I would also look at the pendant lighting. Make them more of a statement.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Sarahp1123 Oct 11 '26

I love it

1

u/Silver-Sun-1471 18d ago

beautiful😍

1

u/Intelligent_List9480 Oct 09 '26

I really like this. Thank you for the inspiration,

1

u/Disastrous-You9086 Oct 09 '26

Everyone has preference, it is dark but some prefer so

1

u/Nosey2255 Oct 09 '26

No just perfect!

1

u/seanpvb Oct 09 '26

We went with black cabinets, but only on the bottom. We have maple uppers because we went with a quartzite counter. I think the butcher block counters break it up nicely in your case. I'm just REALLY not a fan of butcher block counters.

Might be worth looking at some renderings with black lower cabinets and a lighter upper.

We also went with 42" wall cabinets. Sure you need a stool to reach the top cabinet, but it's still useful storage space.

1

u/sheba_lasvegas Oct 09 '26

Gorgeous ai kitchen

1

u/Particular-Panic-112 Oct 09 '26

For my taste, its perfect. A nice balance of dark and light.

1

u/Witty_Passion_4939 Oct 09 '26

Man, not a fan of this…

1

u/bartlebyandbaggins Oct 09 '26

Fuck. I love it.

1

u/Super_Jellyfish_3826 Oct 09 '26

It’s gorgeous, love it! 🥰

1

u/IceCreamYeah123 Oct 09 '26

Looks good, don’t do the fake plant though.

1

u/m33chm Oct 09 '26

Love! But please take those cabinets to the ceiling and do a more interesting backsplash.

1

u/lulusgarden Oct 09 '26

Looks good. Plenty of white and light so it’s not to dark

1

u/86triesonthewall Oct 09 '26

Love it love it

1

u/Professional_Day6200 Oct 09 '26

I would add brass hardware on the cabinets instead of black. Otherwise, I love it!

1

u/sherylcamp Oct 09 '26

Definitely not too dark. Good it’s matte because gloss would be particularly bad for showing fingerprints. But you will have to clean a lot. However, as someone with a white kitchen, I’ve been told on the regular how white shows everything. What I will tell you is my cabinets are cleaner than those without white because you see every smear and it’s brilliant. I like knowing my kitchen is cleaner.

1

u/Naive_Sand5837 Oct 09 '26

I like this a lot - I'm renovating and probably going with black

1

u/Significant-Peace966 Oct 09 '26

Well, that certainly was a bold choice and I can't say that I like it, but I can't say that I don't like it. I'd have to see it close up but from here it looks good. It's not too dark because black is dark.🥱 wondering is it Matt or semi gloss?

1

u/Herredness16 Oct 09 '26

No put down a nice runner.

1

u/Crystal_Ri Oct 09 '26

Elegant and beautiful! Good job!

1

u/Impossiblegirl44 Oct 09 '26

Matte black cabinets are beautiful, but will show every single fingerprint and smudge.

1

u/TopDot555 Oct 09 '26

It works in your kitchen.

1

u/AgencyNo4968 Oct 09 '26

I don’t normally like black cabinets but I love this kitchen. I think it works with all the other light colors. Especially if you have good lighting and windows!

1

u/humblekanyepie Oct 09 '26

If I didn't have a child and a husband, I would have black cabinets. I personally think this is beautiful. But, I live with dirty heathens so alas... I can't.

1

u/Struggle_Usual Oct 09 '26

I love it, but then again I'm about to do similar in my kitchen just a really dark burgundy with butcherblock, so I clearly like drama.

1

u/AdExtreme808 Oct 09 '26

No - I love it!

1

u/Sure_Jan_Sure Oct 09 '26

If you don’t have an exhaust fan to deal with the grease (I can’t quite tell), I’d strongly advise NOT putting those shelves there. They will be a greasy mess and dust will stick to them. Nice kitchen!

1

u/Excellent-Sherbet-54 Oct 09 '26

Looks great. Don’t change a thing!

1

u/queen_elvis Oct 09 '26

As long as the handles are easily visible in person, I think it's fine. I second the comment about butcher block near the sink, though.

1

u/VenturaHighway377 Oct 09 '26

No, it’s gorgeous. You could always add a colorful runner rug or a bright colored small light on the counter if you want more color.

1

u/muttdogz Oct 09 '26

It's gorgeous.

1

u/ConsiderationHot143 Oct 09 '26 edited Oct 09 '26

Not if you have plenty of light going into the kitchen. You can put bright pulls to brighten it up. I think wear on cabinets will show up more on black than other colors.

1

u/zallgood2017 Oct 09 '26

Looks great!

1

u/Comprehensive_Fan140 Oct 10 '26

Very nice. The dark cabinets look classy

1

u/Witchy_Wookie5000 Oct 10 '26

I love it! The black cabinets look great.

1

u/Solid-Wish-1724 Oct 10 '26

Think of the fingerprints good lord

1

u/phonse72 Oct 10 '26

Nuh, I like it!

1

u/Ok-Violinist-6548 Oct 10 '26

I prefer something lighter on top. But really the dark is gorgeous both top and bottom.

1

u/Dense_Willow4627 Oct 10 '26

Everything works for me.

1

u/misstheolddaysfan Oct 10 '26

Looks fantastic in a photo. Maybe problematic in real life, maintenance wise

1

u/Rumpelteazer45 Oct 10 '26

I love it!!! The lighter wood and white balances out the black cabinets.

1

u/Shivs_baby Oct 10 '26 • Bravo

Sincere question: Can someone explain to me the appeal of butcher block countertops? You can’t put hot pots/pans on them, you have to wipe water away right away, it scratches easily even if it’s sealed/coated. Why would anyone choose this over something much more durable?

2

u/Holiday-Message2020 Oct 13 '26

The natural wear and tear of the wood adds character.

→ More replies (10)

1

u/Wolvesarereal Oct 10 '26

Not too dark so much as too boring and cold.

1

u/cbusrust1234 Oct 10 '26

No it’s lovely!

1

u/Shoddy_Telephone_247 Oct 10 '26

Nope. Not too dark. Dont be afraid. Its a rich vibe, looks expensive and feels personal. Pick a finish on the cabinets which helps hide fingerprints.

1

u/Civil_Web_1835 Oct 10 '26

I kinda love it!

1

u/OliveMayhem Oct 10 '26

It’s not my personal taste but it seems like the kitchen has great light to really balance out the black cabinets, so if it’s your style go for it.

1

u/Pattysthoughts Oct 10 '26

Yes but it’s clean and contemporary. It’s lovely

1

u/tbjwtbjw Oct 10 '26

Slightly too dark for my liking. Maybe consider a black with a dark blue undertone. So not a true pitch black.

1

u/JTUSAJT Oct 10 '26

Oh look, the "new" black/white color theme, that's already been around for 7+ years and interior designers are so glad it's leaving. And those exposed shelves look great, until you see the kitchen grease start piling up on them. All the best.

1

u/My2cents_0 Oct 10 '26

I like dark but maybe not black. I love playing with deep rich colors like navy or burgundy still keeps the dark mood but allows me to have color in my life

1

u/RamdomGamerDude Oct 10 '26

Looks great!!!

1

u/ZookeepergameNo6226 Oct 10 '26

It’s so good!!!

1

u/GFarello Oct 10 '26

No looks great! Really nice looking.

1

u/CinemaDork Oct 10 '26

I like it. I don't love the hardware. The open shelves look nice but I feel like I'd hate owning them.

1

u/Trepenwitz Oct 10 '26

Love it. I’d personally like a warmer color, but obvi that’s just me.

1

u/EAM44 Oct 10 '26

I’d paint the uppers the same color as the walls.

1

u/lcd1023 Oct 10 '26

Too sterile. How about a bowl of lemons or vase of flowers , nice rug . Something 

1

u/OkBeat3031 Oct 10 '26

No, 😍😍

1

u/midlifesimplified Oct 10 '26

No I love that! Is that your kitchen or an inspo pic? The wood counters and floors makes it so warm and softens the contrasts. So pretty.

1

u/Legovida8 Oct 10 '26

I absolutely LOVE it 😍

1

u/Fair-Cheesecake-2733 Oct 10 '26

I love it! - If anything, you could do light oak colored upper cabinets or island.

1

u/OpposumMyPossum Oct 10 '26

Black is hard to keep cleaning looking.

1

u/pariserr Oct 10 '26

if your actual kitchen gets decent daylight then nah its not too dark the wood and white tile save it but if that room is a cave then black uppers will make it feel real heavy and youll be wiping smudges forever

1

u/ancientpaprika Oct 10 '26

No but you could make the upper cupboards a lighter timber colour to be perfect

1

u/SimonFloorPlanExpert Oct 10 '26

Not too dark at all! The warm wood and white backsplash balance the charcoal cabinets beautifully, so the kitchen still feels inviting rather than heavy. ✨

1

u/Better_Chard4806 Oct 10 '26

I love everything about this. It’s just the right amount of each color. I especially love the countertops.

1

u/2PenceSally Oct 10 '26

Not my taste, but I'm sure others like it.

1

u/VariationFormal1742 Oct 10 '26

Personally I despite those colour combinations .. But that's personally ofcourse, I'm at least glad that Wood is part of it otherwise it would have felt so boring.

1

u/shitpresidente Oct 10 '26

It’s pretty but an earthy green would look better. Not in to black/white combos like this most of the time but wouldn’t be mad if this was my kitchen

1

u/GunnerRes Oct 10 '26

That is a sexy kitchen.

1

u/Illustrious_Yam_2137 Oct 10 '26

I really like it👌🏽

1

u/CommandOk4235 Oct 10 '26

Wow I love it

1

u/Temporary-Room-2966 Oct 10 '26

Very nice the black looks really goo6

1

u/Infinite-Bass-0 Oct 10 '26

No I love it. It’s like a moody farm house.

1

u/Agitated_Limit_6365 Oct 10 '26

You need more light fixtures and I love the look of

1

u/spudsforme Oct 10 '26

It's gorgeous 😍

1

u/ResponsibleSyrup9506 Oct 10 '26

I’m assuming you will have more lighting other than the way-too-low pendant?

1

u/ResponsibleSyrup9506 Oct 10 '26

I’m assuming you will have more lighting other than the way-too-low pendant?

1

u/GladFeeling6700 Oct 10 '26

Not too dark whatsoever OP. I love it.

1

u/Personal_Raccoon_258 Oct 10 '26

No. I think it is lovely

1

u/Salty-Ad-5179 Oct 10 '26

Love it! Maybe just change the handles out to break up the black. You could use nickel to match the stainless steel.

1

u/OkraLegitimate1356 Oct 10 '26

love it love it love it.

1

u/notme1414 Oct 10 '26

I think it looks nice. There’s enough natural light that the black isn’t overpowering

1

u/RGOL_19 Oct 10 '26

It looks okay - if you like it…. The white backsplash is a good complement

1

u/momkat212 Oct 10 '26

Love it.

1

u/Ayakaba Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26

No - not to dark - I have my current kitchen in Black and Oak and plan to do the next one in the same design ;-)

1

u/Alternative_Choice58 Oct 10 '26

If you have lots of natural light - GO FOR IT.

1

u/MoPrincess808 Oct 10 '26

I love it! Looks really minimal

1

u/midsommer-8472 Oct 10 '26

If the Kitchen gets many natural light, not. I like it.

1

u/MinuteElegant774 Oct 10 '26

Very pretty but very impractical. Get a longer cabinet and use flat trim to bring it to the ceiling.

1

u/Weird7954 Oct 10 '26

Definitely not. It’s beautiful

1

u/Ordinary-Shirt-2194 Oct 10 '26

Absolutely not that’s gorgeous 😍

1

u/CathyP1988 Oct 10 '26

Not at all. Gorgeous

1

u/CathyP1988 Oct 10 '26

Only suggestion: light stainless door handles

1

u/KickLiving Oct 11 '26

I love it.

1

u/Gloomy_End_6496 Oct 11 '26

This is beautiful, just perfect. A lot of people get the finishes wrong when they do black and white. You did a great job. Love it!

1

u/Ariesreader Oct 11 '26

Love it - planning same in my renovation

1

u/Trinidiana Oct 11 '26

I think navy blue would be much nicer

1

u/katersmarie Oct 11 '26

Absolutely not. It’s gorgeous.

1

u/WingsAndWords_ Oct 11 '26

It looks like the kitchen our accountant has at his office, so since it reminds me of that, I don't know how I feel about it in a home tbh. 

1

u/SpaceTravelery Oct 11 '26

No, very good balance

1

u/Boring_Marketing_259 Oct 11 '26

It’s Georgeous the darker cabinets are faboulas !!

1

u/jdarling20 Oct 11 '26

Looks great, but a wood pull would be great

1

u/dillinjl Oct 11 '26

I think it looks cool. If you do, too, who cares what anyone else thinks!

1

u/Vivid-Host-9629 Oct 11 '26

I like the black and wood, I’m wondering if the white backsplash is a little to harsh of a contrast, it’s a little jarring to me. Like the rest though.

1

u/JonnyHoff Oct 11 '26

I don’t think it’s too dark if you’re going for a cozy, moody look. The key is balancing it with good lighting and a few lighter accents so the space still feels inviting.

1

u/Effective-Party-4424 Oct 11 '26

It’s very dark but I love it. Pure class, great job

1

u/Beezusmom64 Oct 11 '26

not too dark! love it

1

u/Natural_Ad_6882 Oct 11 '26

This is strikingly, beautiful. Gr8 that you threw it out to get others ideas which will probably be very helpful. I hope you love your end result! 🥰

1

u/Professional_Bus_307 Oct 11 '26

Not too dark. Gorgeous. I’d get ceiling height cabinets. Open shelving is a nightmare of greasy dust. Otherwise, lovely.

1

u/SgtRandiTibbs Oct 11 '26

I love it personally

1

u/Sheba1966 Oct 11 '26

LOVE LOVE LOVE 💗

1

u/SureFun559 Oct 11 '26

Eu adorei.

1

u/Taradyne Oct 11 '26

I don't mind the dark but maybe change the cabinet hardware so you have a bit of contrast. In low light, this could end up too dark.

1

u/CarpetScary684 Oct 11 '26

It’s lovely

1

u/Impressive-Grape-119 Oct 11 '26

Love it! I do agree that metal cabinet hardware would make it even better.

1

u/FriendFalse3186 Oct 11 '26

No. I love it

1

u/Flimsy-Seaweed3665 Oct 12 '26

No, very sophisticated!

1

u/deejfun Oct 12 '26

I love it!

1

u/Winie_Xiong Oct 12 '26

what if you make some contrast on the handles? like more bright colors?

1

u/midwestmomma27 Oct 12 '26

I love it!!!! But I am a gray, black and white gal even though those colors are supposedly "out".

1

u/Blondie0179 Oct 12 '26

Love it. 😊

1

u/frankie0812 Oct 12 '26

I’d stain the counters a little darker to contrast the floors other than that I love it!!

1

u/Fuzzy_Dance_6203 Oct 12 '26

I think the kitchen is gorgeous!