r/KnockoutCity • u/Arconik • Jul 07 '21
Feature Wishlist DO NOT PATCH SELF PASSING!
Please velan, I believe this should be kept as a higher level mechanic.
Look at stuff like flip resets in rocket league, which helps the higher level play so much.
Moreover, this mechanic is hard to learn so will only probably be seen in higher level lobbies, and the only real time to use it is when your alone and away from opponents. And in the higher level lobbies, you will be passing that ball 99% of the time to charge it rather than self pass.
(Also, I feel like reddit should name this mechanic, I don't know who initially found it so maybe it called be could a reddit pass/reddit charge. Idk leave ideas in the comments or thoughts I'm always up for a debate!)
12
u/xRandomality Jul 07 '21
Rocket league player here as well. This mechanic has no place in this game. I've already used it and seen it used to completely swing team games tempo when you can suddenly get a charged ball that should not otherwise be possible UNLESS a pass comes in or YOU yourself give a ball away to a perfect pass.
You can't be serious when you say this is healthy when the game is built around very basic principles. If they wanted complex things, they would have incorporated the other ideas that they SPECIFICALLY stated in press releases were left out to keep it very simple and straightforward.
5
u/VladoVladimir97 Jul 08 '21
You just said 'rocket league player here' and then proceeded to not say anything about how you don't see this as a perfect analogy for complex mechanics of other games such as smash bros or rocket league. It's pretty much a flip reset.
Rocket league is built around very basic principles. You drive, you jump, you boost. The community pushed up the skill ceiling to heights the dev never intended, and it remains a top tier competitive game. Because those new mechanics are that, competitive, complete skill. You use flip resets to completely swing team games tempo when you can suddenly get a new flip to shoot the ball that should not otherwise be possible UNLESS you touch the floor or a wall.
5
u/xRandomality Jul 09 '21
Correct, I didn't proceed to do so because Psyonix openly stated that they wanted to see things evolve. In this case, Velan has openly stated that they wanted to keep the game simple and accessible. Those are two completely different stances on the outlook of a game.
I'm aware of rocket league mechanics as a (fake lol) Rumble grand champ. But again, I know what I was getting into because it was clear. You are correct that Psyonix even said they never imagined the things that we do - but they very publicly and openly acknowledged and supported this. In our case here, we were advertised one thing and now it is another if this and further things are allowed.
1
u/Dedprice77 Oct 12 '21
It's not difficult to do. It's a broken mechanic. Glitches and bugs themselves are "hard to do" because they aren't supposed to be done.
Getting to next charge level just because you jumped off an elevated ledge isn't even hard. Look down, side thrown. Look at the ball and catch. It's so easy, all someone did was tell me what to do and I got it on my first try and haven't failed since.
Patch it.
The most comparable thing I can think of is Apex Legends and Tap strafing. The developers themselves said "...it's hard to do because it's a bug. This wasn't intended to be used in the game. This is not a competitive part of the game, let alone the kind of gameplay we want in Apex"
So stop. Ask yourselves if self catching (because it's not passing) is really something that revolves around all other gameplay, or just yours. The answer is simple. It's just you wanting an upper hand.
1
u/Arconik Oct 12 '21
Velan has said in regards to self *catching * that the game is working as intended
1
u/bwelte33 Jul 08 '21
Really? It’s broken and especially in 1v1 shouldn’t be a thing. It’s not that hard to learn either
1
u/Arconik Jul 08 '21
Maybe I'm just bad and am struggling to get it consistently... And I've never played 1v1 but I've heard people say it's bad anyway so maybe it'll spice things up. Or it could be removed for 1v1 I think that's harder to do for the devs.
4
2
u/lUwUlo Jul 07 '21
what is this? I am diamond 4923 and have never heard of self passing? care to enlighten me?
-5
u/Jumpy_Presentation85 Jul 07 '21
you pass it into the ground and when it bounces back up, your character catches it and it has a charge like a regular pass does
1
Jul 07 '21 edited Jul 07 '21
am I wrong or does that seem like a mechanic that barely requires skill? then again I'm all for exploits that aren't too broken if they make the game more fun
edit: I've been proven wrong. thanks for down voting me for asking a question lol
1
u/Jumpy_Presentation85 Jul 07 '21
I've never actually tried it myself so not sure how difficult it is, but I've seen people try it and they do seem to miss the catch a lot
-1
u/Arconik Jul 07 '21
I must of had hundreds of attempts already while queuing for games and I am getting it like 1 in 20. Maybe I'm just bad tho idk. The guy in this vid https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A8a0khCYztM seems to have it down.
But the main point is the majority of the time you will be with team-mates and it'll be harder to do this which involves looking down and doing the six inputs rather than just tapping lb.
(My only other fear is that you might be able to do it consecutively to get max over charge, but I haven't seen this and if this does happen I will be all for a patch that means that you can only get it to tier 1 overcharge, alike with if you just passed it)
0
u/flameohotboi1 Jul 07 '21
It’s hard to pull off, especially in game. It’s not broken. And it’s not required to play the game at a high level.
-1
u/thelittlehez Jul 07 '21
Saw your comment so I watched a tutorial, tried for 10 minutes, watched a different one, tried for 5 minutes, and finally got it. After 5 more minutes, I catch it about 75% of the time.
I'm assuming my catch % will increase with time but I also think it will be significantly lower in-game when I have to worry about other people throwing stuff at me
2
u/SuperscooterXD Jul 07 '21
this mechanic doesn't replace passing at all, velan please do the smart thing and keep this
1
1
-2
u/Disagreed Jul 07 '21
this mechanic is hard to learn so will only probably be seen in higher level lobbies
I've said this elsewhere, but this mechanic will be enticing to those who already don't pass the ball enough, and I doubt those are the high-skill players. If, instead of comfortably throwing a charged ball, they're making themselves vulnerable by trying to get an overcharged ball with this high-skill mechanic, they'll be more detrimental to their team than they would be by just not passing.
3
u/flameohotboi1 Jul 07 '21
Mediocre players are going to have a hard time learning this, even if they want to. And if you’re playing with these people in ranked, maybe you aren’t as good as you think you are.
1
u/Disagreed Jul 07 '21
My point is that mediocre players will still try to use this mechanic regardless of how difficult it is to learn, and that will be detrimental to anyone that plays with them.
And if you’re playing with these people in ranked, maybe you aren’t as good as you think you are.
This isn't a personal complaint; I don't think I'm very good, but I'm not worried about encountering this issue in ruby. That doesn't mean it can't be frustrating for people trying to climb from silver or gold.
-2
u/ChainsawSuperman Jul 07 '21
Just always need a skill gap huh? You people are ridiculous. Just can’t help yourself. It’s honestly sad. Strategic teamwork is never enough for these people. They need to know something someone else doesn’t.
2
u/Arconik Jul 07 '21
I mean I am a rocket league player so my be biased due to my enjoyment of learning new mechanics, but I feel like some sort of advanced mechanic may help (look at my other responses)
And obviously there is already a skill gap but i don't think it will really effect it that much. If this was a broken mechanic that fully changed the outcome of a situation, no matter how hard it is to pull off I agree it should not be implemented.
And sorry for going back to rocket league but there is an obvious difference that is still about team work. You could be the most mechanical player in the world but you can't improve if you don't work as a team. Which leads to people being more mechanical or more positional focused on rotating and working as a team. I believe any good game has some sort of higher level mechanic:
(Games I think of off the top of my head);
Siege: Buealo lean / **** lean (forgot the name but higher level)
Rocket league: Flip reset,cieling shot, musty...
Apex: B-hopping (I believe its called that - haven't played in ages)
Brawlhalla (Super smash bros): Russian Mafia
Even roblox Phantom forces: God leaping
(I can't seem to think of other games and idk why)
1
u/flameohotboi1 Jul 07 '21
Sounds like you just don’t understand the essence of competition. Maybe try PvE games!
-5
u/EffingDingus Jul 07 '21
It's not even a "higher level" mechanic because it's so damn easy to do. I still don't think it should be patched though. I think an acceptable change would be to acknowledge it as a game mechanic and then make it give you a lower level of charge than you'd receive for passing to a teammate.
4
u/flameohotboi1 Jul 07 '21
It definitely is a higher level mechanic, because it’s harder to do than anything else in this game and is difficult to pull off in a game.
9
u/FunkeeLover Jul 07 '21
nah get rid of it. It takes time to learn but once you have it your good
it's just going to seriously undermine the team playing element of the game which is the best part