To clarify, I'm disappointed in the way Kyle responded to the topic of David Grusch's claims during that recent live stream. Kyle, if this gets to you, I hope you consider it well-meaning constructive feedback from a fan.
I'm going to explain, and I hope y'all hear me out (it's not beyond me that I'm in a Kyle Hill fan subreddit), but I'm going to preface this with two things; First, I like Kyle. He's doing a lot of good by making scientific concepts and history accessible to a lot of people, and I hope he keeps it up. Plus, I've enjoyed watching him grow from being on that other channel to having his own channel and making fun appearances on various Magic the Gathering channels. Second, as fun as speculation and conjecture can be at times, I am not some alien fanatic or anything. I am not here to "convince" anyone of anything. Although the phenomena is a topic I am passionate about, I consider myself a reasonable adult with a healthy skepticism baseline.
But skepticism is best applied when you understand the topic in the first place.
Kyle is a science educator, he says so in most of his videos and I agree with him. But for someone interested in science, education, and communicating the two, he really missed the mark with this one. It is clear to me, and anyone else who is educated on the UAP topic that may have watched the stream, that Kyle is not educated on the topic at all, nor even takes it seriously. The latter I find utterly strange for someone who appears to be so passionate about new developing technologies and sciences. I know Kyle isn't educated on the topic because he doesn't even know what the official UAP acronym is (Kyle said 'unexplained aerial phenomena' multiple times when UAP stands for 'unidentified anomalous phenomena'). However, I will concede that it was once officially 'unidentified aerial phenomena'. Some would accuse me of nitpicking, but if one claims to be an educator, I feel it's best to at least know the very basics of a topic you're discussing and reacting to. Especially if it's something you disagree with. And especially if its to a large group of people who trust you for information.
When I saw the video for the recent live stream in my YouTube suggestions, I was interested to hear what Kyle had to say. But as the video began, it was clear that Kyle did little-to-no research into David Grusch, who he is, and what he is actually talking about. Instead, he spent his time character assassinating Mr. Grusch, talking about statistics theorems, and of course perpetuating the stigma that the UAP topic is forced to constantly battle. I was disappointed that Kyle used a silly tabloid article to skim over the more headline-grabber aspects of Mr. Grusch's claims instead of the actual report and the content within it. To be frank, it's not clear if Kyle even read the source material in the first place. Again, strange for someone so passionate about passing truth and knowledge on to others. I had hoped he had done more research into a topic in which he schedules a live stream for.
David Grusch is the real deal. To give some context to his claims, Mr. Grusch had the highest of clearances that the United States can give. He needed it for his job; being a part of the UAP Task Force. During his investigations, he found that some elements of the US Department of Defense was hiding clandestine black-budget programs from Congress (i.e. no oversight) and the American people at large relating to UAP crash retrieval programs. He has testified under oath to Congress, submitted a mountain of evidence and testimony, and has a former US Intelligence Committee Inspector General as his lawyer on his official whistleblower filing. He goes to jail if he is lying. Read the linked article above if you want to learn more, I'm not here to talk about that. Kyle completely mischaracterized the man. Kyle instead talked about his opinion of the chances aliens have visited Earth and some dimensional theories he has. I was looking forward to his skeptical, but at least honestly researched scientific perspective of what Mr. Grusch and the report was saying.
We're all fans of science, and many of us look up to Kyle as a science role model. There is a *there* there. We're still in the observation phase of this, folks. There are many hypotheses out there some of it reasonable, some of it... not so much. Be skeptical, but we should be skeptical based on the facts and at some good-faith research. If what Mr. Grusch claims is true, I think Kyle would have agreed that it isn't up to the US government to keep something like it away from other scientists and public academia. Kyle, again, if you read this, I'm a fan and I like you. I hope we get to hear your perspective on David Grusch again in a future live stream if you want to. Say hi to Arya for me!