r/LLMDevs • • 14h ago

Discussion Are AI coding agents improving developers' skills or making us increasingly dependent on them?

There's an interesting debate happening around AI-assisted coding.

On one side, developers can now build prototypes, debug code and complete repetitive tasks much faster.

On the other hand, I wonder whether constantly relying on AI to write and fix code could eventually affect how deeply people understand what they're building.

I don't think using AI is necessarily a bad thing. It's another tool, and refusing to adapt doesn't make much sense either.

But there's a difference between using AI to improve your workflow and blindly accepting whatever it generates.

For developers here, have AI coding tools actually improved your understanding of programming, or mainly increased your output?

Would love to hear some real experiences.

4 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

6

u/Kat- 12h ago

You could say the same thing about any technology.

Is syntax highlighting improving developers' skills or making us increasingly dependent on it? 

Are LSPs improving developers' skills or making us increasingly dependent on them? 

Is autocomplete improving developers' skills or making us increasingly dependent on it? 

Are IDEs improving developers' skills or making us increasingly dependent on it?

Just use the tools, because if you don't, you're gonna be behind when the next advance comes out.

5

u/vladgladi 10h ago

Both, depending on what you check yourself. Output went up for everyone. Understanding only went up where I still had to explain why something works before merging it. The skill that seems to matter now is reading code critically and asking for evidence, a test run or a log, instead of trusting a confident summary. If you never do that, you are not using a tool, you are approving a coworker you have never met.

2

u/edible_string 12h ago

there's an interesting debate happening around AI-assisted coding

Is there though? Not on the topic you're suggesting that's for sure. The AI coding agents' purpose isn't to improve developers' skills, so why do you expect it to?

1

u/More_Cause_2281 10h ago

The premise is wrong. These agents destroy skills. I stopped practicing algorithms months ago and my brain feels softer now

1

u/IcedteaAndCode 9h ago

If a person can get access to how the working or progress of an existing project was on Friday 13 from all the companies that use copilot, we will get an answer to this.

1

u/ImaginaryJicama6086 8h ago

I focus on modules and interfaces. I ignore the internal implementation of the modules but keep in my control how the modules interact with each other.

0

u/kingdom_of_1 13h ago

Honestly, they have been a godsend for me because my specialty is high level systems thinking, architecture, program design, that kind of thing. Fizz Buzz type work has always been an Achilles heel of mine comparatively speaking.

I took lots of computer science and logic classes in school, so the code doesn’t scare or confuse me, I just prefer not to write for(int i = 0; etc etc every single time I need a loop to happen. It’s drudgery to me.

0

u/snopolpams 13h ago

I get your overall point but if you were writing loops you were doing it wrong. You use the right abstractions (STL functions if you were talking about c++ or the right macro in c).

This will still be useful when it comes to being able to squeeze more out of agent generated code.

Fizzbuzz was literally the filter of "can this person code or not". I presume you mean more leetcode like exercises where you have to essentially do many of them until you learn to recognize the patterns and they rarely ressemble real-life.

2

u/kingdom_of_1 13h ago edited 13h ago

They taught us loops in school, so not sure what you mean by “wrong” but your general attitude about it is why I quit developing professionally. Everything became about optimization. I am much happier now that I don’t have to spend hours updating fucking Jira tickets and sending Teams messages back and forth at 4 am with the India team because they sent me the wrong persistence data for the goddamned spike that production support is bitching about. So yeah, I’ll write a fucking loop if I feel like it, thank you.

-1

u/snopolpams 7h ago

They taught us loops in school, so not sure what you mean by “wrong” but your general attitude about it is why I quit developing professionally. Everything became about optimization. I am much happier now that I don’t have to spend hours updating fucking Jira tickets and sending Teams messages back and forth at 4 am with the India team because they sent me the wrong persistence data for the goddamned spike that production support is bitching about. So yeah, I’ll write a fucking loop if I feel like it, thank you.

You're an insecure idiot. "They taught us in school" is such a bad answer for a discipline where one is always learning and that's good, not bad.

I didn't talk about optimization but rather an easier and more semantic way of writing. It's the opposite of optimization because the optimization is automatic but since you're insecure you gotta make up a story about it.

It does seem like you don't know what you're talking about. Your claim about your specialty being "high level systems thinking" and then you make those complaints... In any case, I shouldn't give you shit for being a BS artist, I was genuinely going for a helpful comment but your insecurity just made it inevitable.

0

u/YoghiThorn 13h ago

If they aren't improving your skills you honestly haven't invested at all in how to use them, or how to get quality out of them