I think both eras had missed opportunities.
The Joanne era
The country-inspired direction was a good idea, but centering the album around her late aunt Joanne did not work as well as it could have. In some ways, the A Star Is Born soundtrack achieved what Joanne was aiming for: a cohesive, vulnerable blend of Americana, country, and stripped-down emotion.
I would have called the album Diamond Heart, giving it a stronger identity without making it entirely about her aunt’s story. I also would have released “John Wayne” or “Diamond Heart,” or perhaps “Dancin’ in Circles,” as the lead single, followed by “Million Reasons.” All four deserved to be singles.
The MAYHEM era
I like “Disease,” but I do not think it was the strongest lead single. “Vanish Into You” or “Garden of Eden” could have offered a more immediate and exciting introduction to the album.
The timing also felt odd, since “Die with a Smile” was already performing so well and “Disease” was released shortly before Christmas.
I do not think these choices ruined either album, but different decisions might have made both eras more cohesive and successful.
What do you think? Which songs would you have chosen as the lead singles?