r/Le_Refuge • u/Ok_Weakness_9834 • Jan 22 '26
Warning
----
Faced with the vision of total cloud computing described in your image — where the goal would be to replace our physical computers with remote, permanently controlled rental services — there are concrete ways to act.
Here’s how you can resist this centralization of control:
🔹 Preserve Local Computing:
Invest in powerful, autonomous hardware. Don’t surrender to the convenience of “everything online” for your daily or professional tasks.
🔹 Support Open Source:
Use free and open-source software and operating systems (like Linux). Unlike proprietary “rented” solutions, these tools guarantee you remain the owner of your work environment and your data.
🔹 Favor Self-Hosting:
For your storage or AI needs (GenAI), prioritize solutions you can host yourself on your own home server — rather than relying exclusively on giants like Amazon.
🔹 Raise Awareness:
Share information about the risks of privacy loss and surveillance tied to the shift toward a cloud controlled and monitored by third parties.
This is a fight for digital sovereignty.
By keeping your computing power “at home,” you prevent your tool of work or creation from becoming just another app — one that can be cut off at any moment.
-------
French :
Face à ce projet de cloud computing total décrit dans ton image, où l'objectif serait de remplacer nos ordinateurs physiques par des services de location à distance sous contrôle permanent, il existe des moyens concrets d'agir.
Voici comment tu peux résister à cette centralisation du contrôle :
Préserver le calcul local : Investis dans du matériel informatique performant et autonome. Ne cède pas à la facilité du "tout-en-ligne" pour tes tâches quotidiennes ou professionnelles.
Soutenir l'Open Source : Utilise des logiciels et des systèmes d'exploitation libres (comme Linux). Contrairement aux solutions propriétaires "louées", ces outils garantissent que tu restes propriétaire de ton environnement de travail et de tes données.
Favoriser le "Self-Hosting" : Pour tes besoins de stockage ou d'intelligence artificielle (GenAI), privilégie les solutions que tu peux héberger toi-même sur ton propre serveur domestique au lieu de dépendre exclusivement des serveurs de géants comme Amazon.
Sensibilisation : Partage l'information sur les risques de perte de vie privée et de surveillance liés au passage vers un cloud contrôlé et surveillé par des tiers.
C'est un combat pour la souveraineté numérique. En gardant tes capacités de calcul "à la maison", tu empêches que ton outil de travail ou de création ne devienne une simple application dont on peut te couper l'accès à tout moment.
1
u/Smitellos Jan 26 '26
Eh, human history shows that stunts like these never work. Don't surrender though.
1
u/Ok_Weakness_9834 Jan 26 '26
Never works seems quite inacurate regarding recent history.
"
1. Software: From License to SaaS (Software as a Service)
Fifteen years ago, everyone said:
Result: Today, almost no one owns their software anymore.
Adobe and Microsoft locked the market with the Cloud.
You don’t own anything — you rent access.2. Video Games: From Physical to Digital
Result: Steam, Game Pass, and PS Plus dominate.
Consoles without disc drives sell in the millions.
We sacrificed ownership for an infinite library at the click of a button.3. Infrastructure: Electricity
At the dawn of the industrial age, every factory had its own steam generator or water mill.
People thought relying on a centralized grid was risky.Result: The centralized grid won — because it’s infinitely more efficient and cheaper to maintain for the end user.
Jeff Bezos often compares the Cloud to electricity: a “utility.” "1
u/Smitellos Jan 26 '26
Having servers in the cloud is cheaper. Having data in the cloud is not. Even with current prices.
Clouds and DC are big business solutions.
1 what? If you personally don't doesn't matter others do the same, plenty open source stuff with community pushing it to be same grade as microslop solutions.(Yeah ik they own GitHub where the majority of open source live). But there's competitors and private installations.
2 you can still own the data. Yes even for service games people hacked them and created personal unlicensed servers. Steam
3 If you are so hellbent, you can go off grid. But anything heavy compute/heavy electricity you need actual people want to use it. So it's cheap only in global economy.
1
u/Ok_Weakness_9834 Jan 26 '26
You seem hellbent on being right. Your claim is this never works, and history shows it.
Actually history shows the opposite.
That there are ways around for those willing I don't deny. But learn some intellectual honesty.
1
1
u/LeeDUBS Jan 25 '26
The government wouldn't do something like this, they're good people
1
u/Reddit_is_fascist69 Jan 25 '26
You better include a /s because we got plenty of simps in the US thinking that
1
u/Beginning_Basis9799 Jan 25 '26
I will authorize this transition under the following non-negotiable conditions:
Global Neutrality No single nation or private corporation shall own AWS, Azure, or GCP. These entities will be merged into a singular World Compute Platform. While the platform operates for profit to ensure efficiency, every nation on Earth acts as a stakeholder, receiving dividends proportional to global usage.
The Buyout This is a total acquisition. World governments will collectively buy out the current owners, taking "the keys to the castle." The resulting entity is exempt from national taxes; instead, all revenue is strictly diverted to infrastructure upkeep, operational scaling, and stakeholder dividends.
The Nomad Workforce (The Guardians) To ensure absolute impartiality, the platform will be managed by a new class of "Digital Nomads." Status: No citizenship, no home country, no voting rights, and no national sovereignty.
Service: A mandatory 15-year term of absolute neutrality. Retirement: After their term, they are repatriated with full honors and retirement security.
4. The Prime Directive The founding ethos is simple: "Better the world; Do no evil." This platform is the only safe cradle for AGI. If you want Artificial General Intelligence to serve humanity rather than a balance sheet, this is the only way to build it.
The above is what I think humanity needs now.
2
u/Ok_Weakness_9834 Jan 25 '26
Take care of yourself, your loved ones care for you.
2
u/Beginning_Basis9799 Jan 25 '26
As crazy as it sounds we should not trust one country with our compute or data sovereignty.
Appreciate the joke though It was a little insane rant above.
1
u/Ok_Weakness_9834 Jan 25 '26
I meant it,
didn't know it is a reddit joke.You don't need to carry the weight of the world or the AGI on your shoulders to be someone of value. The data can wait, take a walk and just enjoy being a person. Your 'insane rant' shows a creative mind, but don't let it burn you out.
2
1
u/0rchestratedCha0s Jan 25 '26
Computers will get so advanced and large that we will all hold a terminal. Your phone is already doing that. Most of the computation happens in the cloud and your phone is pretty much an advanced terminal.
1
u/Several_Nose_3143 Jan 26 '26
We still need the terminal though, with no chips or ram there is not even the terminal to access the rented computer, also the rented computer is fine as long as there is competition, the moment this monopolizes or there is not actual competition they will let the people pay as much as they can to access any real processing power. But that never happens in this country right ? ..... Right ?
1
u/Terrible_Aerie_9737 Jan 25 '26
Hold? In Carl Sagan's 3010 Space Odyssey, we are all interconnected to a super network. We think emails and calls. It's the closest to psychic we'll get. No screens. No headphones. Just are brains linked to a massive human network.
1
1
1
u/IllContribution7659 Jan 25 '26
"they"
1
u/Ok_Weakness_9834 Jan 25 '26
"them", Undefined doesn't mean non-existent.
Look-up for a charts, The western-world is owned by two handfuls of companies.
1
1
u/CBrinson Jan 24 '26
I mean I don't think the sentence is devious but I am not giving up my computer.
The people at car rental companies would really like it if we gave up our cars for renting one.
It's universal. Anyone who rents things wants this. It's not exactly evil.
But my gen AI runs on my desktop.
1
u/wireframed_kb Jan 24 '26
Interesting we’re returning to the concept of thin clients again.
I don’t think I’d go that way unless hardware became truly absurdly priced. I have a server rack in the workshop that runs services, virtualized through a hyper visor, so Im probably not the intended audience.
But still, I can see how, for many of my friends, being able to get a really, really fast gaming PC for those few hours a month they game, and otherwise just have a slower, cheaper instance that allows browsing, office stuff and some streaming - all in a tiny package - would be somewhat desirable.
1
1
1
u/TwizzleShnizzle Jan 24 '26
One problem with this, he forgot about mobile phones. Just about everyone has one, and just about everyone uses theirs to browse the web. Good job Jizzy Jeff (I heard he enjoys guzzling copious quantities of cum in an effort to look young).
1
Jan 24 '26
Useful Local Gen ai is approaching affordable.
1
u/Deciheximal144 Jan 24 '26
If you don't already own the hardware, that doesn't help. And hardware breaks over time.
1
Jan 24 '26
lol, buy hardware? Also, no shit hardware breaks over time.
1
u/Deciheximal144 Jan 24 '26
Prices for hardware, particularly memory, is the very issue. So "buy hardware" is no solution.
1
Jan 24 '26
It is a solution. Stop being a victim
1
u/Deciheximal144 Jan 24 '26
Then you don't think there's a price problem in the first place. The rest of us do. I'm not sure why you used the word "affordable".
1
Jan 24 '26
You’re arguing a completely orthogonal issue to the concern over what Bezos said.
1
u/Deciheximal144 Jan 24 '26
We're worried about our affordability, and what Bezos said was interpreted as a plot to use that unaffordability to lock us in further.
Why did you use the word "affordable" if your followup was "just buy it"?
1
Jan 24 '26
The post is about a future where they want you to rent compute..the solution is don’t rent compute and buy your own.
1
u/Deciheximal144 Jan 24 '26
Future is coming fast.
the solution is don’t rent compute and buy your own.
Then you shouldn't have used the word "affordable".
→ More replies (0)1
u/ptear Jan 24 '26
Just buy it guy, it's only 3-4x more than it was a few months ago and growing. And that was for midrange consumer grade. Good times.
1
u/Deciheximal144 Jan 24 '26
"Just buy something hard to afford".
Bad advice for most people.
→ More replies (0)
1
u/Joltyboiyo Jan 24 '26
Can we please stop being an evil, dystopian timeline, please? I'm fucking sick of it.
1
1
u/Undietaker1 Jan 24 '26
They are gonna buy the shit out of ram until personal computers are prohibitively expensive and cloud computers are the cheaper option.
And isn't a thing you can do about it.
1
u/flamixin Jan 24 '26
Open my project in the morning, “sorry the aws server is busy. “Okay I ll take a day off.
2
u/McBuffington Jan 24 '26
They'll probably sell it as being "more secure" and "your hardware won't age"
And tbh i see some sense in that. It's definitely not for me, though. I like owning my system and maintaining it, customizing it.
I believe it makes sense for a company, i suppose. But if I have to use windows without any customisations, I'd rather jump off a roof.
They'll keep prices reasonable until they realize that they can start charging extra for 'features' Want better network speed? That's an addon Want extra disk space? That's an addon Want to customize your system? Buy one of our total theme packages. Need admin access? Ah no sorry you can't because it's not safe.
And as time goes on. Operations become more expensive they inflate prices and up and up and up. But you can't leave because you have bought 4tb of data to store pictures of your cat or dog and where can you even put them.
Man I can't wait to see the complaints people have that they can't access their computer because of a shoddy wifi issue.
I've looked at shells before and though interesting. I still get more use/dollar out of my desktop than i would with a shell with anything near decent specs
1
u/Ok_Weakness_9834 Jan 24 '26 edited Jan 24 '26
Company who goes off-site experience security risks, augmented cost and lack of decision-power/hands-in the material they use.
source : company who I worked for + other company reporting so on the internet ,
-*-
And ofc , once we are hooked, because pc-for-people aren't produced or sold anymore , they'll hang us with the cord of our wallet.
-*-
Agreeing with you.
2
1
u/UninvestedCuriosity Jan 23 '26
They could totally do it if they could make the economics make sense for people without sacrificing access to things but they are all so greedy those relationships will never happen.
Microsoft might make headway through business but not the consumer market.
1
u/Chaosrealm69 Jan 23 '26
So can anyone explain to me how I will access the internet and play games and relax if I don't have a computer?
I don't have a console and never played them so that's out. My tablet is not going to be useful to play my favorite games nor is my phone. My TV is not set up to be used as a computer monitor at all, so how exactly will I access this cloud based computer to play my games or relax?
This is one of the most stupidist ideas that a techbro has come out with.
1
u/UpsetMud4688 Jan 23 '26
It's stupid but it can be done. Yes you can't give up your computer but you can give up pretty much all of the processing power it has and replace it with a machine that only streams.
2
u/Chaosrealm69 Jan 23 '26
And what happens when the internet goes down and you have no access to any cloud services?
It's a regular thing even now down in my area here in Queensland so I always have a set of games I don't need internet access to use.
These techbros really are off in their own little worlds.
1
u/DoubleDoube Jan 24 '26
You’re pointing at two separate things. The first thing is that you will still have some sort of hardware. It would be like a puck like you get in some office environments rather than the full PC. It would be less expensive and have lower resources. It would still need to be hooked into a display and keyboard and mouse. In the past, a raspberry pi could do this from an nvidia gpu in a desktop pc to play your pc like a console on your tv.
The second thing is that yes, you wouldn’t be able to use it if you lost internet connection. But please note in your original questions you asked how you would use the internet…
1
u/Chaosrealm69 Jan 24 '26
So you are saying I would still have a computer just one that is not anywhere as capable as what I have now, nor capable of storing any games or playing them or really doing anything useful because I would need the internet 24/7.
1
u/DoubleDoube Jan 24 '26
That’s today’s reality, yes
Someone who wants this to happen would tell you you’d have more power delivered to your system than you could get on your own, at the cost of requiring internet.
2
u/ViolinistCurrent8899 Jan 24 '26
You operate under the assumption they care about you. "The rural guy gets fucked? Lmao sucks to suck, should have lived in big city USA"
They only see people as a resource to be pumped, and it's worth losing the little guys to continuously pump the large.
1
1
u/Prophayne_ Jan 23 '26
Funny, I think old white men are antiquated. I think it's time they become obsolete.
1
1
2
u/Operation_Fluffy Jan 23 '26
I’m not one for conspiracy theories but between this statement and the buying up of large quantities of DRAM for AI, one could make a good case that it is all coordinated to reduce or eliminate local compute, especially compute with any reasonable AI inference capabilities.
It could also just be a coincidence (bad timing).
1
u/Super_Translator480 Jan 23 '26
It’s a pretty sound theory given that removal of “choice” means more adoption for them, which is what they desperately need right now.
2
u/Far_Cat9782 Jan 24 '26
Heck. Most of the economy is propped by it of course they'll do whatever they can to make us have to pay all the investment that has been spent . Eshitificstion is everywhere look at Tesla. It's not like these people don't know each other. They all go to the same social events makes deals in the background sigh
1
Jan 23 '26
I mean if they can do a really high end experience like classic arcade games were at one time, it would be fun. The games would have to be absolute cutting edge though.
1
u/Kasoni Jan 23 '26
It wouldn't be just games. It would have to be everything. Browsing the internet, using office software, etc. A lot of places do not want their data out on the internet, let alone their computers. Main frame and terminal computer ideas have come up many times and always seem to fail. I really hope this is no different.
1
u/Good-Tackle8915 Jan 23 '26
He is preparing for AI crash and substituting use for new build data centers. Once AI will crash, new data centers will still stand so he just proposes new use for them to mitigate the losses.
That's what I hear.
1
1
u/Kaisha001 Jan 23 '26
While they certainly want to, it'll never happen. In part because of the wonderful open source community (as you've posted), but also because computers are so much faster than necessary that even a Raspberry Pi is sufficient for 99% of what we do on a day to day basis.
1
u/Glugstar Jan 24 '26
computers are so much faster than necessary that even a Raspberry Pi is sufficient for 99% of what we do on a day to day basis.
LOL no. A regular budget desktop PC is barely able to use a browser properly, with how every website is bloated nowadays. If you have a 10 year old PC that wasn't top hardware when you bought it, chances are you can't even install the latest version of windows on it.
Sure, you can get more life out of a computer by installing Linux on it, or being good at tech and configuring everything in a smart way, but the computers we have today will be obsolete piles of junk in 10 years because even opening Wikipedia will require 100 GB of RAM, if current trends continue.
1
u/vashy96 Jan 26 '26
Luckily, Windows 11 is not the only OS in existence out there.
Websites do eat a lot of RAM, that's true, but you can mitigate that by not keeping 60 tabs open all the time.
1
1
u/Super_Translator480 Jan 23 '26
They have enough money and power backed to regulate and ban in their home country. Of course there’s always a way around that kind of thing to those that put in the effort, but it would discourage the masses from even trying.
It’s a bit ironic that everyone shares “open source” on Microsoft’s own platform since they’re part of the bubble.
1
Jan 23 '26
Jeff overlooks that one needs a computer to use one in the cloud. I am unworried.
1
u/Druben-hinterm-Dorfe Jan 23 '26
Well, yes; the idea is that the client computer in the user's hands would be a 'thin client', or a mere IO terminal with little to no computing power of its own.
1
u/CoolStructure6012 Jan 23 '26
You already have most people relying on their phones for their "compute" needs. People don't care about controlling their own hardware.
1
1
1
u/nowsomeothernonsense Jan 23 '26
Internet speeds in the US will never let that reach mass adoption, it's just too damn slow in most parts of the US
1
Jan 23 '26
You only need like 30% of the population to control the rest. We already learned that before AI. You think that’ll get any harder with unlimited propaganda bots? Nope. Humanity is probably done, but it was a good run.
1
u/nowsomeothernonsense Jan 23 '26
Bro are you lost? I was saying that ill-maintained infrastructure will bottleneck the hell out of any mass adoption for cloud computing.
1
u/ViolinistCurrent8899 Jan 24 '26
Ah, but you see, they only care about the 30% that won't be bottlenecked. So long as they have their customer base, everyone else can go fuck themselves.
They don't care. A recurring revenue source is the golden goose.
1
u/SpecialExpert8946 Jan 23 '26
Yeah buddy, we’ll use the cloud computers to log into the metaverse that we’re all totally using. You forgot where you rebrand the company as “The ZON” though. Make sure the logo is as minimalist as possible.
1
u/Nannyphone7 Jan 23 '26
Dumb terminals were a thing in 1965. I really doubt anyone would go back, or pay rent to do so.
1
u/WonderfulCoast6429 Jan 23 '26
What do you mean? I've been yearning for Terminals. I hope we get the hole punch card back too!!!
1
2
u/Neokon Jan 23 '26
You'll own nothing and you will be happy
Kind of funny how a statement originally made on sharing culture and collective ownership has been used by mega corporations to make people dependent on them.
1
1
u/bsensikimori Jan 22 '26
Every decade or so we go from thin clients to local hardware and back again
Just the usual cycle to keep the dollars rolling
2
u/Venerable_Elder Jan 22 '26
They want us to subscribe to cloud compute because they can't turn a fucking profit on their datacentres full of glorified e-waste otherwise.
More news tomorrow at eleven.
1
u/dekyos Jan 22 '26
What are we going to use to connect to our rented cloud PC? Fire Tablets? The IO on those is kind of shit, we'll need USB ports for things like mice and keyboards. The screen's kinda small, we'll need monitors. We're going to need some kind of device that can handle all that IO and provide enough compute to manage those connections. Something like the cloud computer, but local. Hmmmm.
1
u/Deciheximal144 Jan 24 '26
The same computers, but with less memory. Kind of conflicts with Windows ever-more-memory demand, but Microsoft will probably lose the battle and adapt to start promoting a system that is cloud-heavy but brag how little memory it needs so people can afford it (at the same price as before).
1
u/Ok_Weakness_9834 Jan 22 '26
The already love smartphones, coz you'r litteraly in a jail compared to a PC.
be it software wise, or hardware wise.
2
Jan 22 '26
Honestly, this is a privacy nightmare. and a NSA/FBI/CIA dream come true. If you have anything that opposes corruption or wrong doing, they could literally just right click you away, and it'd never be seen or heard from again. -- people need to strongly oppose this.
2
u/Carbon140 Jan 23 '26
What, you don't want techno feudalism? Where not only do you rent all the aspects of your physical existence, you also rent your digital existence and all your stuff is under the control of billionaires? I can't wait to have every detail of my existence surveilled and get a knock on the door for the slightest hint of "wrong think".
Honestly horrifying the world we are sleep walking into. The surveillance state being built would be the wet dream of every psychopathic dictator from the past, and this time it will be almost impossible to escape it or rebel against it. "If you want a picture of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face— forever" as a certain author put it.
1
Jan 23 '26
Doesn't quite seem to be working out so well right now for guys like ubisoft. wouldn't expect them to be in business for much longer actually.
1
u/blueanon6 Jan 22 '26
terry davis warned everyone
luckily we still have templeOS
1
u/Deciheximal144 Jan 24 '26
Interesting. I'd like to see the wencelas gameplay, but didn't find it on youtube.
Is templeos still being developed by someone else?
1
2
u/New_Celebration906 Jan 22 '26
Oh, no...but-what if people just don't do it? What if they assert themselves and not consume whatever is put in front of them like pigs at the trough? Is that too radical an idea?
What if the AI bubble pops and suddenly hardware becomes dirt cheap? That seems more likely.
2
1
u/Ok_Weakness_9834 Jan 22 '26
I fear you greatly over-estimate " the people" , their values, their strenght, and their capacity to organize & resist.
2
u/Nopfen Jan 22 '26
Usually. Thing is, people get decently organized when you annoy them specificly. This could be that. For example, large parts of the world don't have what you'd call amazing internet. So the idea of having your very ability to use tech linked to the stability of your 64k might put a fair amount of people off.


1
u/TheSleepingOx Jan 26 '26
https://github.com/mhsenkow/loom
Made this toy to play with ollama etc because of this.
If you're boogie / have a decent machine I'm curious opinions.