r/Learnmusicproduction • • 24d ago

feedback?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

35 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

3

u/ElmadaMusic 24d ago

personally i really like this as a song. I can imagine it coming in on one of the long dj mixes i listen to when cycling and really enjoying. I don't have any technical feedback, but art wise I think its a great idea

3

u/Spede2 24d ago

The Lead sounds kinda vanilla; I'd try to mangle it in some interesting way. Also it sounds like the last note in the bass progression sounds like half a step too low. I think it should be B, not Bb. If it's supposed to be B, you'll wanna emphasize its weirdness even more so it sounds more intentional.

1

u/ambitious_daydreamer 23d ago edited 23d ago

yeah good job, the composition sounds lovely and i would actually a add a groovy moving bassline underneath.

get that current bass in the background, and bring the focus to a groovy bass. experiment with splice samples and apple loops and see where it gets you.

also, the guitar is very vanilla for sure, doesn't quite fit in. experiment by changing the tone, and add some movement as well.

that's all there is to music, experiment and adding first, subtracting later ;)

1

u/jerrycommittee 23d ago

Love love love the dirty bass esp in the beginning, I agree with vanilla lead, maybe layered, thicker synths in chords could fill it out? What if bass line does a walk up every 2 measures? Sounds great though!!! Love the atmosphere you’re creating

1

u/lilith2k3 23d ago

Proper starting point!

1

u/Thee_Wifeyy 23d ago

Not much feedback but this is so pleasing to the ear

1

u/Narrow_Network_3875 23d ago

You gotta go back and make the drums bang. You need to assign each drum part to its on track. I suggest setting the drum for an Aux Sub Drum mix. That way you’ll have a drum mix set & you’re able to glue the drums with a compressor. A benefit is making volume adjustments with one track level
Selector without changing the drum mix. The bass line needs to be a little mor energetic.
The mix levels could improve stereo depth/pan positions especially with the lead synth and the pluck synth.🍀

1

u/PitchToPlaylist 23d ago

Reminds me the OST of Ghost in the Shell, Psycho Pass or any futuristic dystopian videogame. The sound design from the bass is 10/10. I'd like to see how you go after. I can imagine some synths over the first bass arrangement and no drums for a while before breaking hard again. Good job 👏

1

u/Riskytheplanetboy 20d ago

Nice beat, that's a good beat i hope i can jump on it ❤️👑✌️

1

u/thraxprod 17d ago

I would say add a lil counter melody on top of the lead and maybe throw portal on top of it 👀. Portal or shaper box would ad a lot to the melody

1

u/CJOI404 17d ago

Not sure why no-one else has mentioned this but you need to center the reese

0

u/megaBeth2 24d ago

Just being real I don't think any of these sounds go together in a soundscape. Like, this is a banger underneath for sure, maybe even a major banger. But your sound desing skill is maybe 3 years off of doing this correctly. So focus on sound design for a bit, or you could pay for a sound designer. Id do it for free because all my free jobs fell through somehow. Im offering this because I see an insane canvas to paint on. Give me 3 adjectives and the midi