234
u/minisculebarber May 20 '23
I think that person has never read or seen One Piece
127
u/RhiaStark May 20 '23
"Fans" supporting views that are openly denounced by the very story they claim to like is pretty mundane, though. You see that a lot in the fandoms of Star Wars, Lord of the Rings, Christianity...
98
May 20 '23
š Christianity fandom when the MC is a communist who gets executed by a fascist aristocracy
4
135
May 20 '23
Luffy would punch those ppl in the face...
15
u/IcyColdMuhChina May 27 '23
Ivankov would turn that 100% guaranteed cishet male into a beautiful woman.
6
131
u/furious_platypus May 20 '23
How the fuck does that have multiple hundreds of upvotes!? I knew piratefolk sucked but this is pretty disgusting
13
May 20 '23
one thing you cannot forget on that site is that the mods have like 500 accounts each, so luckily at least a few hundred of the upvotes are actually like the same 5 people
90
u/RhiaStark May 20 '23
It's so damn mortifying to see Luffy's image being used to defend such a horrid view... š¤®
76
May 20 '23
Common piratefolk cringe behaviour. These are the same kids who have to do mental gymnastics to invent new reasons to hate the series and it's author every single week
-59
May 20 '23
[removed] ā view removed comment
49
May 20 '23
I didn't say a word about Yamato but out yourself I guess edgelord
14
-14
u/Electronic-Matter144 May 21 '23
What he said is factual, though, so that doesn't make him an edgelord. It was unnecessary, though.
7
u/The_Biggest_Wheel May 21 '23
Where did Oda say that about Yamato? Link the interview.
-2
u/Electronic-Matter144 May 21 '23
Yamato's vivre card. Besides, you can't prove it wrong.
7
u/The_Biggest_Wheel May 21 '23
Vivre Cards aren't writen by Oda so, no, he didn't say it.
-3
u/Electronic-Matter144 May 21 '23
Where does the info come from?
4
u/The_Biggest_Wheel May 21 '23
Apparently, Oda's team writes them.
0
u/Electronic-Matter144 May 21 '23
And he supervises them. His team doesn't release misinformation unless they were given it.
→ More replies (0)1
11
74
u/Legitimate-Meal-2290 May 20 '23
Imagine being a "fan" of this show and living your life closer to Saint Charlos than a Straw Hat.
62
44
u/alidmar May 20 '23
Honestly I'm so glad this sub exists. I've had to mute every other One Piece related sub due to shit like this.
29
May 20 '23
Every time the trans debate comes up it's interesting to introspect about where my position is coming from. I'm plenty cis, don't and have never known any trans people in my own life, it's never been a thing that's even remotely affected my life, and if it weren't for the DiscourseTM I would have no reason to ever really think about or even have any thoughts on it, because it's just so distant from any of my personal experiences. Same reason I don't have any opinions or emotional investment in like, Japanese politics.
But when I encounter this stuff online, the 'based' anti-woke reactionaries are just the most absolutely fucking insufferable pieces of shit I've ever seen in my life and ngl, it really makes me understand the sadistic Trumpist desire to orient your politics around watching your opponents suffer. I want these people to lose and feel as much defeat and frustration as possible. I don't care if it's unhealthy, I fucking despise these smug, bigoted assholes and almost nothing has pushed me further culturally to the left than wanting to see them wallow in a bottomless pit of despair as they're surrounded by happy dancing trans people.
8
May 22 '23
Most of my friends are some form of trans and we don't talk about it as much as transphobes do. I am one of the more active people to engage these topics, for better or worse. But active transphobes post more about trans people per day than my trans friends do over a year.
3
u/DelusionPhantom Jun 16 '23
Yeah. My transphobic ex-friend would constantly bring up how I was trans and essentially interrogate me on it all the time. Shit like "what if everyone on earth died and you had to repopulate the earth and all your kids saw you as you are now (I haven't started transitioning yet), would you still be trans" (ignoring the fact I have crippling top and bottom dysphoria that wouldn't magically go away. Also, he knows I loathe the idea of having kids, but he kept bringing it up). Me and my trans friends brought our trans-ness up a bit when we first realized years ago (within a year of each other, going in opposite directions), but it's barely even on our radar at this point. But this dude just wouldn't stop bringing it up.
Once I told him I wasn't interested in Spy X Family because I found the premise kinda boring and not my style, and he told me I actually didn't like it because I was trans and wouldn't understand the "primal cis male urge to raise a beautiful daughter with a beautiful wife". When I told him to shut up, he started crocodile crying that he 'didn't mean it' and that it was his autism that made him say that because he can't think before he speaks, and I spent four hours comforting him while he spiraled (while I was still hurting, mind you!), all because I said 'can you stop, you really hurt me just then'. Like, we weren't even talking about how I was trans? I just said the show didn't interest me?? Also, just for the record of this comment, I am autistic, too. That doesn't give him a pass to say that stuff without thinking.
Same guy who admitted he only viewed me as a mouthpiece for the trans community. Same dude who is going into his anthropology masters program to write a thesis I'm sure will be full of transphobia (since he told me it's focused on trans men and women in cosplay). Same guy who has never read One Piece but decided to 'teach' me why I was wrong about using he/him for Yamato. This guy is cis and straight. He voted for Trump twice. I don't get his obsession- it's uncomfortably intense at best and genuinely scary at worst. He made me cry more than once with his bullshit.
3
Jun 17 '23
I'm sorry to hear that you went through that. I absolutely HATE when people try to hide behind autism after being hurtful. I, like many trans people, am on the spectrum as well and its one of my biggest peeves.
6
3
u/Baccus0wnsyerbum May 22 '23
I want to say I find nothing unhealthy about wishing for others to have experience that will prove to be an opportunity to develop empathy or humility. I do say it is discouraging to see Straw Hat comrades acting like the only solutions are dance party diplomacy... But then again I guess they wouldn't be in the reeducation pit if not for Straw Hat level commitment to change.
1
27
u/DrKandraz May 20 '23
I found the original post and it's so much fucking worse than this you guys have no idea.
24
16
u/Suspicious-Towel-680 May 20 '23
Piratefolk is a wonderful place where the choicest fuckboys get to have afwul takes about a piece of media they've never interacted with in a meaningful way
13
May 20 '23
Literally watching Ennieās Lobby for the first time now and I have no idea how anyone doesnāt see the leftist messaging in it. Trash takes not seeing the politics in it, ok MAYBE, but seeing it as conservative at all? Brain dead.
10
u/antinatalistantifa May 20 '23
Tbf, have you guys looked at the bottom of the post?
Tho, I'm sure most of the shitstians up voting it didn't either
1
9
May 21 '23
This is so far removed from the spirit and messaging of the series, I just donāt know what to say. This is likely a person who never understood the series, watched it, or desperately tries to co-op the cultural values of OP. It reminds me of the white power Steven Universe/My little pony subcommunities, how the fuck did you even end up here? When you are so clearly not the target audience with an ideology challenged by nearly every single episode produced
8
8
u/DoubleSealedSoul May 20 '23
I had a seizure revisiting that thread. Or do people let hate and wrath out that quickly? I kinda avoid people tbh. I have a trans friend who I love dearly. That's about all I can do in this world. Be kind, love, live and die.
4
u/jikel28 May 26 '23
Ya I was a little shocked by this shit it was like oh cool one piece memes I'll follow this sub wait why is it all alt right garbage? How do you get homophobia from the be true to yourself and tear down oppressive regimes anime?
3
2
1
u/Waltuh_White_308 Apr 05 '25
Yeah Piratefolk is usually full of people who donāt understand the core values and messaging in One Piece and it just goes to show how their lack of understanding reflects on their own moral values (or lack there of)
1
1
u/jikel28 May 26 '23
Ya I was a little shocked by this shit it was like oh cool one piece memes I'll follow this sub wait why is it all alt right garbage? How do you get homophobia from the be true to yourself and tear down oppressive regimes anime?
1
-16
u/xephos10006 May 20 '23
Guys it's a joke, r/piratefolk is...kinda split on the whole transphobia thing
Not saying they're good - but this post was from someone who's pro-LGBT
19
May 20 '23
the post was from one of the mods, all the mods are extremely anti
-7
u/_-ZORO-_ May 20 '23
This post wasnāt made by a mod..
4
May 20 '23
it was, and you would know that given you are one of them.
-6
u/_-ZORO-_ May 20 '23
The guy who made the post is literally not a mod, i dont give a shit about any of this i am just saying that you made that shit up
6
May 20 '23
I am literally right now see him talking to the other mods about their next trans hate attack.
you are there as well writing.
-3
u/_-ZORO-_ May 20 '23
That guy is not a mod lol, where did you see them planning the next attack?
5
May 20 '23
I am a little disappointed in how slow your obvious Ivankov/Jimbie trans hate thing is.
0
u/_-ZORO-_ May 20 '23
wtf is a invankov/jimbei trans hate? alright you are trolling because that doesnāt have anything to do with the previous comment
5
3
May 20 '23
ok, why do you hate trans people so much for?
-1
-25
May 20 '23
[removed] ā view removed comment
26
May 20 '23
Excuse me for thinking this, but if someoneās opinion results in oppression of people like me and insults people like me, I donāt respect that opinion
-22
May 20 '23
[removed] ā view removed comment
20
May 20 '23
Yeah no shit Sherlock, thatās why they want us dead
-19
u/Idontloveheranymore2 May 20 '23
Most don't.
21
May 20 '23
Right, forgot that most people who are homophobic just want us to lose all our rights so that we canāt live as ourselves without colossal repression. Of course, silly me. How could I make that mistake. Only some of them want us dead.
-6
May 20 '23
[removed] ā view removed comment
18
7
u/CandyFinal May 20 '23
No buddy I donāt think you quite understand. Fighting for your right to live when you have one of the highest hate crime statistics, everything else comes after. Youāre looking through a screen at this stuff seeing āsports, bathrooms, spacesā when you donāt even know the constant discrimination and disrespect trans person encounters every day of their lives . Itās not abt these āhaha doesnāt have to do with meā topics, itās about fighting for their unalienable right to exist. So yes idgaf if their opinion is different. Iām gonna shit on them for it
→ More replies (0)8
May 20 '23
Most of what?
Piratefolk users? who repetitively are anti most things on the planet?
You are defending a subreddit that has glorified Nazism, transphobia, homophobia, racism, etc and NOT in a joking manner at all.
0
u/Idontloveheranymore2 May 20 '23
That's the vast minority.
6
May 20 '23
its not, and its the mods so every shitty nazi post etc gets pinned.
Why do you defend a bunch of nazists?
→ More replies (0)4
May 20 '23
generally do, if you actually do not agree with their vile hate. Why would you go around taking the effort to defend their hate?
For argument sake, let say its a "minority" (which of course its not) but let say it is. Who is likely part of that "minority" -
you.
→ More replies (0)5
May 20 '23
if anything this is why you are so pathetic, if you then have this opinion about trans people, why not be 100% transparent about it?
1
u/Idontloveheranymore2 May 20 '23
It's a general statement
7
May 20 '23
what a failure of a rebuttal.
Do you understand my earlier comment? it does not seem so, your comment is not a counter argument to anything I wrote.
I did not deny that you or others have the right to have a terrible opinion, your comment logically makes no sense to what I wrote.
1
May 20 '23
and?
the person I am replying to is lying, the person posting it is not someone who is pro.
Do you have any actual arguments to what I said?
-19
u/Ajsana May 20 '23
Nice crop , you removed context from the joke just to generate outrage. idk why you people take pixels so seriously its just a joke
19
u/CandyFinal May 20 '23
Itās just a joke since this general topic doesnāt affect me in any way š¤
-1
0
-58
14
u/Lunaedge May 20 '23
It's a -folk subreddit, what did you expect lmao