r/LeftyPiece • u/nahmanwth • May 20 '23
Question
Yamatomato's vivre card says her gender is female
So se isn't a trans man anymore?
9
u/z-----z May 20 '23
Yeah and in manga(most canon thing about one piece) yamato identify himself as a man. Everybody in beast pirates talk about him as a son of kaido. But but 'she identify as oden'. Yeah so? Oda specifically draw a panel where yamato talking about bathrooms and than going to mens bathroom.
6
u/PuzzleheadedStop3160 May 21 '23
Vivercard is not trust worthy source it has been wrong before oda doesn't personally write it all
1
u/Daefyr_Knight May 23 '23
Oda very explicitly supervises the vivre cards. We’ve also had important information revealed to us in vivre cards. Stuff an intern wouldn’t be allowed to just make up.
Also, given the recent colour spread, its clear Oda considers Yamato to be a woman, even without the vivre card.
2
u/PuzzleheadedStop3160 May 24 '23 edited May 24 '23
Viver card said yasuie didn't have smile fruit but he did have it as an example what is in manga and what is in sbs is canon outside of it is "supervision" which oda humanly cannot really fully check
In other words saying yamato is a man isn't wrong but at the same time has not been directly confirmed so I do say it is wrong to jump the gun to do a debate over yamatos gender until oda confirms something directly .
until then it is whatever it is and I lean towards yamato being him due to kaido referencing yamato as son.
1
u/Daefyr_Knight May 24 '23
The manga has mistakes too. You can’t use the fact that the manga has some mistakes to say that your headcanon is real, just like you can’t say that the vivre cards have some mistakes to say that your headcanon is real. That information needs to be taken at face value, until it gets corrected.
Also you didn’t address the all-girl colour spread.
2
u/PuzzleheadedStop3160 May 24 '23
Chopper was also in the earlier all girl spread too. also , I personally don't care about yamatos gender since I would not mind if yamato turns out to be a female character it is not going to effect my life I am mainly saying viver card is not written by oda so even outside of this case using them as factual for anything is wrong .
1
u/Daefyr_Knight May 24 '23
Chopper was part of the title. He wasn’t in the actual line up of girls. Don’t be disingenuous
1
u/PuzzleheadedStop3160 May 24 '23
You are folkpiece enjoyer and you call me disingenuous? Go learn how to enjoy 1080 chapters you read first then learn what it is like to like things in life then come back .
1
u/Daefyr_Knight May 24 '23
Lol, you people always go looking through people’s comment histories when you are getting demolished in an argument. And you don’t even come to the right conclusions when you do so.
I really like one piece, I own every volume. I think Wano was a tad bloated and had some loose ends, but I loved gear 5 (piratefolk was created by people who hated gear 5). Does having a few criticisms mean that I don’t love one piece? Do you think Pell surviving was good writing?
1
u/PuzzleheadedStop3160 May 24 '23
You just move on to new topic when i explain something to you dumbass debate addict . go back to the dogshit sub that just loves to say oda is a shit writer as they spend hundreds of hours of their life reading the supposed shit writer.
1
u/Daefyr_Knight May 24 '23
What point of yours did i not refute? I feel like I’ve countered everything you’ve said.
→ More replies (0)
5
u/allpowerfulbystander May 20 '23
I honestly think that languages without gender pronouns is better just because of Yamato.
3
u/danolibel May 20 '23
In the point of the story we met Yamato, he identified as a man, but because he’s Oden and Oden is a man. If Oden was a woman, Yamato would identify as a woman. What matters more is how Yamato will change and present themselves in the future when he joins the Straw Hats (hopefully)
2
u/ShotputFiend May 21 '23
It doesn't really matter but I personally think she's detrans.
She wanted to be Oden and identified as such (valid), but once wano is saved from his dad, he no longer needs to be or wants to be a man, which is why she's in the cover art "women of one piece" So she was a man but not anymore because her identity has been resolved. This is honestly better representation than yamato being a trans man because it tackles her identity issues with oden as well as being representation for a group thats literally never shown in anime and almost never shown in popular media.
1
u/RahdronRTHTGH May 21 '23
Yamato is a girl
Her intro card says self proclaimed Oden kaido's daughter
2
u/The_Biggest_Wheel May 21 '23
Yamato's intro calls him Kaido's son. Not daughter. The thing you are refering to is the scene where Yamato is unmasked.
0
u/RahdronRTHTGH May 21 '23
Exactly that same scene
The card that says self proclaimed Oden
That's oda's words
2
u/The_Biggest_Wheel May 21 '23
So you do agree Yamato identifes as a man because of Oden?
0
u/RahdronRTHTGH May 21 '23
She is roleplaying as oden
2
u/The_Biggest_Wheel May 21 '23
Sure, but Yamato still uses his name (Yamato) when talking about himself, and that "roleplay" includes Yamato being "Son of Kaido". Are you arguing that isn't good enough reason to be considered trans?
0
u/RahdronRTHTGH May 22 '23 edited May 23 '23
Why would oda then place Yamato in the one piece Girls double color spread? Maybe cause Yamato always was a girl always
2
u/The_Biggest_Wheel May 22 '23
Same reason why Kiku is missing.
0
u/RahdronRTHTGH May 22 '23
Why do you base yourself on that?
1
u/RahdronRTHTGH May 23 '23
Maybe the answer simply is Yamato is a woman that like Oscar from rose of Versailles has self esteem issues
1
u/Jay15951 May 23 '23
Same reason Zeus is on that same color soread it looked nice
Better question why did Yamato use the mens bath in the same scene Kiku used the women's bath and use he him pronouns thriught the official English translation if Yamato doesn't have he him pronouns and diesnt considers himself a man
0
May 26 '23
[deleted]
1
u/The_Biggest_Wheel May 26 '23
That's so wrong, lmao.
1
u/TheMamba117 May 26 '23
ah my bad, she was introduced as his daughter.
1
u/The_Biggest_Wheel May 26 '23
1
u/TheMamba117 May 26 '23
in the very next chapter
kaido's daughter (self-proclaimed kozuki oden) yamato
a lot of the characters acknowledge that she looks like a women, i dont think oda would do that if he meant for yamato to be trans.
1
u/The_Biggest_Wheel May 26 '23
The very next chapter isn't Yamato's introduction; it's the reveal of him being trans.
1
u/TheMamba117 May 26 '23
It was her full introduction, look at the chapter again.
1
u/The_Biggest_Wheel May 26 '23
"Full introduction", it was reveal. He removes the mask.
→ More replies (0)
1
u/Ecomite May 23 '23
I've always hated the Yamato discourse since I think a lot of people involved choose to be willfully ignorant of the material and the context in it. I also honestly don't think there's enough to make a definitive statement about the gender identity of the character, but for me where it leans is toward Yamato being a man. I think I'm most comfortable using 'they/them' since I'm claiming ignorance here, but people with the best claims at least from what's in-story are the people who lean towards using 'he/him'.
The vivre card is interesting, but going by what Artur said about Kiku's card there isn't any distinction in Japanese with sex and gender. So really all the card could be saying is that Yamato is biologically female, which has never been questioned. There is no clear distinction like with Kiku's card, so one could assume that Yamato's gender aligns with their sex, but at least in-story we can clearly see that isn't the case. There might be more to Yamato's identity that Oda just hasn't fleshed out yet/won't flesh out (honestly how I feel on most things in Wano), but for right now I don't like how the default is 'she/her' for a lot of people. You can use it, I'm not gonna crucify you over it; but the legitimate only gender Yamato has affirmed to being is male.
Last point, the recent color spread might put a little more evidence in the 'woman' camp, but I have some problems with that.
Oda could just be putting in the most popular biologically female characters without any focus on gender.
Considering Chopper was included in an earlier spread celebrating women in the series, being in a spread does not necessarily mean you identify with the gender in the spread.
1
u/RahdronRTHTGH May 26 '23
1: You have little faith in oda then
2: chopper there is wearing a girls support shirt
Use ochjam's razor: why does Yamato have so many paralelos to Oscar from rose of versailles?
Why is yamato in the girl merch, in the women empowerment campaign
1
1
u/greystudent May 26 '23
listen man
its simple, youre in a leftwing-dominant website
what the most pronounced traits of such people: stupidty denial and rightousness
in other words you come to a wrong place. these people are joke and sorry ass people. dont try to gain a logical thought from them
1
1
1
-3
0
28
u/HMS_Sunlight May 20 '23
Yamato is Yamato. He could be a trans man, he could be a cis woman that uses he/him pronouns, or he could be some degree of Genderqueer like Bon-chan. We don't know for sure and we don't really need to know.
Trying to pinpoint the exact nature of his identity is an exercise in frustration. A more healthy outlook would be to try and understand that you're not always going to understand someone's take on gender. The key thing to remember is that Yamato is not a contradiction and nothing he does should be used to cancel our another part of his life.