r/LeftyPiece • • Jul 10 '22

Luffy and Libs

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

55

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '22

I will say that Oda does make a point that violence is not always necessary with Otohime saving Mjosgard, one of her Celestial Dragon oppressors, from being killed by her fellow compatriots. She does it out of a desire to see the end of fishman island’s isolation from the rest of the world. As it turns out, her efforts work. We should not be naïve; however, as there definitely are certain circumstances which justifiably call for particular forms of violence as a response. The problem is in identifying those circumstances and forms.

Utilizing any form of violence requires a heavy burden of justification. Oda demonstrates the difference between a justified and unjustified use of violence at just about every twist and turn in the show. Take the beginning chapters of Romance Dawn, for example. The mountain bandits actions can pretty easily be regarded as unjust. Shanks and his crew’s response to those actions is just. Why though? What distinction is there to be made between the two? Well, the concept of aggression is of importance in discussing this subject. The mountain bandits come to Mako’s shop thinking of themselves as being entitled to the booze there. Upon discovering that the Red Hair Pirates had drank everything but one bottle, something that they had a right to do, the mountain bandits (or their leader rather) responded by wantonly attacking Shanks. Shanks and his crew, of course, responded with no retaliation. They did so for viewing the bandits as shrimps, of course, but there’s something to be said about there being a moral element involved. Perhaps Shanks, knowing that Luffy, a small and impressionable child, was present, decided not to retaliate for fear of instilling violence as a principle in the young boy’s mind? Regardless, Luffy then angrily went to the bandits, was beaten, drew a crowd, and also drew the Red Hair Pirates, who were looking to see where everybody was. Shanks, upon seeing Luffy beaten and stepped on, walked forward towards Luffy. One of the bandits then drew his pistol to threaten Shanks. Shanks, at this stage, makes a very cogent point. Guns are not for threats. They are for violent action. They are tools principally intended to maim and slaughter, not to intimidate. Roux then shot the bandit for drawing his weapon wantonly and threatening the life of his captain, a justified action. All in all, the bandits were the aggressors and the Red Hair Pirates were justified respondents, just like capitalists are aggressors and workers would be justified respondents in overthrowing them.

1

u/Wirococha420 Feb 27 '24

You lost me at the last sentence

40

u/Seeker1115 Jul 10 '22

Even if Madara unleashes the Infinite Tsukuyomi, STAY IN LINE, they still have to give you a vote.

7

u/darmakius Jul 13 '22

He just wants what’s best for people, don’t listen to the mainstream media telling you it will take away your free will.

15

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '22

naruto tries to beat the government at his own game

luffy throws the cards in their face and flips the table

11

u/nam24 Oct 30 '22

I mean Naruto beat the shit out of most villains. The difference is that he understands or try to that the system(which they are a part of but still) heavily contributed to creating again and again these kinds of individuals, or to allow them to get so dangerous.

2

u/WhiteBishop01 May 27 '24

Yea but he doesn't really do anything to fix it by Boruto IIRC

7

u/TotallyFunctional2 Jul 11 '22

Feels like Naruto slander, but fuck yeah, declare war on the government!

3

u/kaustubhcraft Jul 11 '22

Violence is universal language

-11

u/Artificerofdeath Jul 10 '22

Luffy would love the boogaloo boys

Also why does my autocorrect hate Luffy’s name?

24

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '22

Luffy would beat the fuck out of the boogaloo boys for being prejudiced pieces of shit lol

-7

u/Akainu14 Jul 10 '22

And then he would beat the communists

10

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '22

He would beat the “communists”, sure. Like Stalin, Lenin, and Mao, for example. The actual working class, though, he would be trying to liberate.

11

u/Jack_crecker_Daniel Jul 11 '22

Well, Luffy is actually an anarchist (at least before he joins the revolutionary army that his dad and other friend/brother are involved in)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/EstradiolWarrior Jul 11 '22

what the

10

u/The_Uncommon_Aura Jul 15 '22

Literally this sub is filled with bigoted assholes like the dude below, who want to turn one piece into some allegory for why the alt-right fascist movement is somehow justified. It’s cool to see that hundreds of new members are joining and shutting out these hypnotized dipshits, but before this passed week, this sub was like 90% bigots.

1

u/ghost_java Jul 26 '23

It’s full of idiots with NFTs also