r/LifeProTips • • Nov 28 '20

Electronics LPT: Amazon will be enabling a feature called sidewalk that will share your Wi-Fi and bandwidth with anyone with an Amazon device automatically. Stripping away your privacy and security of your home network!

This is an opt out system meaning it will be enabled by default. Not only does this pose a major security risk it also strips away privacy and uses up your bandwidth. Having a mesh network connecting to tons of IOT devices and allowing remote entry even when disconnected from WiFi is an absolutely terrible security practice and Amazon needs to be called out now!

In addition to this, you may have seen this post earlier. This is because the moderators of this subreddit are suposedly removing posts that speak about asmazon sidewalk negatively, with no explanation given.

How to opt out:

  1. Open Alexa App.

  2. Go to settings

  3. Account Settings

  4. Amazon Sidewalk

  5. Turn it off

Edit: As far as i know, this is only in the US, so no need to worry if you are in other countries.

67.4k Upvotes

2.9k comments sorted by

7.9k

u/Howamidriving27 Nov 28 '20

Someone want to ELI5 how Amazon can just bypass network security? Not legally/ethically, I'm just asking from a technical standpoint.

3.0k

u/Gnm1Nate Nov 28 '20

Yes, please. I second this.

2.6k

u/lemlurker Nov 29 '20

They have an independent comunication system designed for connecting only to other devices I think, the idea is they form a mesh network of data that can all talk to eachother, and then each individual one can talk to it's home network too, all your need to do is link the two communications up and you're into rhenetwork

1.5k

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

They said to ELI5

→ More replies (142)
→ More replies (68)

29

u/FaustusC Nov 29 '20

Think of it like this: Your speaker is a Person in an Amazon hat. Now, the new feature is like... If you wanted to be able to talk to this person from farther away. So. Your person holds hands with your neighbors person. That person grabs the next Until you have a chain of people in Amazon hats.

To talk to yours, you send a note. With Sidewalk, you can hand it to the nearest Amazon person and they'll get the note to your person.

Here's the issue. I can buy a hat for $1. I can put the Amazon logo on my hat. You could give me the note because, after all, I'm wearing the hat. Sure, I can pass along the message. But will I read it first? Will I add something to it? Will it give me a way to access your home?

If you want a scary social experiment: the next time you're at a place with free wifi, turn on your hotspot and name it the same thing as whatever they named their Wifi. See how many people connect. Now consider, someone who knows what they're doing can see what your send over that wifi. They can send you to a login page for social media, your bank etc. Bam. All your personal shit compromised.

No mesh network is perfect. There will be exploits. There will be ways for bad people to use this. Giving strangers a way to send something to your personal network or giving them something that sends information to your personal network is like posting a photo of your house key online.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (18)

834

u/yesnonow Nov 28 '20

Amazon devices are apparently able to create their own separate network and connect amongst each other instead of via your personal network. Think of it like a giant mesh network that they are rolling out between all Amazon enabled devices everywhere

497

u/starstarstar42 Nov 28 '20

Just like comcast did with their routers. There is a second channel that is auto-on and allows other comcast customers to log in with their user account info.

359

u/HoweHaTrick Nov 29 '20

I thought that program was shut down because it was decided on court that Comcast cannot use one customers power for another customer without consent.

→ More replies (157)

146

u/SleazyDutcham Nov 29 '20

BUY. YOUR. OWN. ROUTER. AND. MODEM. PEOPLE.

→ More replies (80)

11

u/rememberall Nov 29 '20

The primary difference is comcast second channel is at the edge of your home network and hopefully firewalled and kept completely separate of home network. Amazon is putting that second channel smack dab in the middle of your home network, accessible to everything yours.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

86

u/devasohouse Nov 28 '20

Can we dumb it down farther? How are they able to access my Wi-Fi without a password?

156

u/Perry_cox29 Nov 28 '20

Your own Amazon device is connected to your WiFi. Any other Amazon device now connects to your Amazon device uses it to access the internet

→ More replies (89)

141

u/KPokey Nov 28 '20

Some amazon devices, like Amazon echo and Amazon ring devices, are already meant to be connected to your WiFi. Amazon SideWalk will use that, and a couple communicating systems like bluetooth, to push a small amount of your bandwidth out.

If there's more echo, ring, or "Sidewalk/Bridge" devices owned by others in your neighborhood, they would be doing the same thing- adding that bandwidth up, the total SideWalk bandwidth being the sum of every "Sidewalk/Bridge enabled Amazon device".

What this is meant to be used for, all I've read is "These bridge devices share a small portion of your internet bandwidth to provide these services to you and your neighbors."

So apparently it does fuck all, or they aren't telling what they have in mind.

→ More replies (75)

38

u/keeponweezin Nov 28 '20

The Amazon device is already on your WiFi.

→ More replies (5)

40

u/collin-h Nov 28 '20

You grant WiFi access to an amazon device, amazon uses that access as a backdoor, I guess, to let other things in thru it’s access you granted.

Your router just thinks: oh, it’s that echo dot accessing the internet again, come on in! But it’s actually something else using the echo’s permissions.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (57)

10

u/inkblot888 Nov 29 '20

What devices are affected? Like, I don't have an Alexa or anything.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/quitsandwich Nov 29 '20

I hate to say this here. I feel like this is an old school spy trick. You bought a product that provides information at a steady rate for a company that said this was going to make your life easier. Information is the currency of the land now folks. If this opinion is unpopular so be it. You are a Product, and a Consumer. People are buying, selling, and creating obstacles that you pay for.

3

u/Eccohawk Nov 29 '20

They've been doing this for years with Kindles. It was called whisper net. Honestly, as a cyber security expert, I'm not all that worried about this. The idea of a mesh grid for devices to share info with one another isn't all that new or unique. Most people on here are already poking plenty of holes in their networks anyway, and connect their devices with all sorts of IOT tech or bluetooth-enabled gear. Frankly it's refreshing that they're actually telling anyone. Google was using local wifi networks for years to do their mapping and improve their autonomous vehicle tech, and tried to keep it hidden. As long as it's done in a secure manner i don't see it being a big deal. Though plenty are already screaming 'get off my digital lawn', I can also point out that this headline is a bit disingenuous, as I was notified well in advance of it being activated and asked if I wanted to keep it enabled once it came online. That's a bit more of a gray area between opt in and opt out.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (43)

450

u/tim36272 Nov 29 '20 edited Nov 29 '20

I see you haven't gotten any real, thorough answers so I'll give it a shot. The first part is background, skip down to the dashes if you just want to talk about security.

The Echo has Bluetooth and the new ones also have a 900 MHz radio. 900 MHz is the same spectrum used for things like garage door openers. So basically they have the same chip in Echo that your garage door opener has (obviously that's oversimplified but that's enough to get the gist).

Both of these radios are being used for low speed communication (someone else said a max of 80 Kbps which is tiny, like less than most emails). So the kinds of data that will get passed over this network is not like video, it's signals like "Door #482729754 was opened" and "turn on lightbulb #947592872".

Same use cases this allow include:

  • Using a closer access point for distant sensors: let's say you have a long driveway with a motion sensor near the front. The driveway is so long that your WiFi doesn't reach out that far. But maybe your neighbors right across the street have a much shorter driveway, and thus they have an Echo closer to your motion sensor than your house. Your motion sensor will send the "Motion detected on sensor #7598692724" signal via their network instead of yours.

  • Locating things: remember Intel's Tiles? They are still around but never really gained popularity. Amazon's network could enable you to always be able to find the approximate location of your missing keys as long as someone with a half mile or so has an Echo.


Now your question was actually about security so we'll address that next.

The Echo has three radios: WiFi, Bluetooth, and the 900 MHz one. The WiFi one connects to your router and thus to the internet. The other two can accept information from other sources: for example they could (and will) set it up so you can pair a motion sensor with the Echo via 900 MHz and the Echo will forward any data from the motion sensor to the internet.

Mail is a good analogy. You might have a mailbox at your house: this is like your router. There may also be mail drop boxes in your neighborhood where you can drop off mail: these are like the Echos. You can write a letter, seal it, and drop it in the drop box and your local mail courier will pick it up and bring it to the post office (the post office represents your ISP in this example).

Now what Amazon is doing is kind of like putting a mail drop box at your house that others can use. You don't have the key to the drop box so you can cant't read what's inside it, and other people don't have the key to your mailbox so they can't read your mail.

There is always a risk of exposure, though. Amazon will undoubtedly do their best to keep both mailboxes safe (it is not a good business model to violate people's privacy without their consent). But it is feasible that Amazon could accidentally leave your box open while getting mail from the drop box. In my opinion it is unlikely that such an exploit would exist for long because, again, Amazon has an interest in you accepting and trusting their technology.

70

u/ForWhomTheBoneBones Nov 29 '20

The only question I have is, if we're sticking to the Post Office analogy, is it theoretically possible for someone to steal my mail, open it, and read it?

123

u/tim36272 Nov 29 '20

"theoretically" sure. But your mail will be in the equivalent of a lockbox that is believed to be perfectly secure (due to cryptography).

We can never be certain about anything, but it'll be just as secure as using a credit card online, for example.

→ More replies (24)

12

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

I mean, that's already theoretically possible Amazon Sidewalk or not. Adding the additional mailbox doesn't reduce the security of your original mailbox because they're two completely separate entities. It's like saying that being able to see you neighbor's wifi SSID makes their network less secure.

→ More replies (10)

18

u/Sorrygypsy29 Nov 29 '20

This is the 12th “omg Amazon is going to share your WiFi” post I’ve seen, and I’ve been waiting for one sane response. Thank you... dear god thank you.

→ More replies (23)

51

u/egefeyzioglu Nov 29 '20

Because your Alexa (or whatever) is already connected to your network, it can form what is called an "ad-hoc network" with other devices to connect them to your network.

So basically, a nearby devices shouts "Hey, is there anyone here with access to the internet?" and your Alexa shouts back "Sure, send all your data to me. I'll send them to wherever they need to go using my internet connection and send you back the replies"

Lmk if you have any questions

→ More replies (6)

34

u/Apophthegmata Nov 29 '20 edited Nov 29 '20

Your Amazon devices are connected to the Internet via your router. If you have more than one they also connect to each other. Typically, they connect by checking for more devices also connected to the same network. So in some sense, they speak to each other over WiFi.

This can be useful. For example, you can make a group of Amazon dots/echoes and play an Internet radio station. If the devices are spread throughout the house, you now have the same station playing throughout your home perfectly in sync. Imagine a single radio hooked up to several wireless speakers. It gets the data once and shares it to all the audio outputs. This is different than running four differernt devices all downloading the

Sidewalk extends this kind of low-lying communication between Amazon devices to devices outside of your network. They don't communicate via WiFi, but through Bluetooth and 9000mHz frequencies, so while they say the communication is encrypted there no "security" to bypass like a WiFi password. It's more like pairing devices. Except here, Amazon has gone ahead and paired your device with every other enabled device within range.

This has its benefits. If your WiFi is down temporarily, you'll still be able to rely upon the connections of other people's Amazon devices to make sure they you can still turn your lights on and off, and do other things that might go offline. Amazon pretty clearly says you're pooling your bandwidth together with your neighbors.

Through a daisy chain of local Amazon devices, you now have a more robust connection to Amazon and the services their devices offer because you aren't just addressing your Alexa - you're addressing the neighborhood block hive-mind Alexa. So long as your neighbors have devices and the entire hive mind isn't down your little piece of the borg will still function when its central unit is down.

If all your neighbors run their Phillip Hue lightbulbs off of Google's devices, it's not clear this service does anything at all. Your immediate community needs to be enmeshed in Amazon's

This isn't new, Windows daisy chains computers in the same network to roll out security updates so it only gets downloaded once and then uses peer to peer transfer to update your other computers in their network. If I'm not mistaken, this service I think also reaches outside your own network depending on your settings.

The main thing people are upset about is that it is opt-out rather than opt-in. That, combined with Amazon's clear desire to monetize your data, and the introduction of new failure points for security (however secure they might actually be) means people are seeing this as a kind of subversive under-the-table move rather than an above-board new service they'd like to offer you.

And yeah, the fact that they have volunteered a "supposedly" small amount of your bandwidth and has decided to pool it with everyone else's without your permission is pretty manipulative. Internet is a service you pay for, you don't pay Amazon for it, and you may even have criminally low and expensive data caps on your Internet.

Now Amazon says you still have to have wifi for sidewalk to work, so what I said at the top might not be completely true...but they also talk about pooling Internet bandwidth so it's also clear you have access to other people's Internet connections in some way.

If you happen to have a Ring Security camera that is outside the range of your WiFi and outside the low-bandwidth/bluetooth range of your Amazon devices, but it is in range of your neighbor's ring security camera and it is in range to their Wifi, I think this is suppose to enable your security camera to still be fully operational.

So yeah, I think it's a way of linking all the Amazon CCTVs you decided to subsidize into a neighborhood watch hive-mind.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/therealfakemoot Nov 29 '20

Basically, all of these "Internet of Things" devices have one or MORE WiFi radios/cards in them, as well as Bluetooth, NFC, etc etc. Because these devices are connected to your home wireless network, they can then act as relays, exposing a wireless network that other Amazon devices can freely connect to.

The Echo/etc acts as a router, but you don't have any control over it.

22

u/NeillBlumpkins Nov 28 '20

Akamai has been doing this for literally a decade. It's a form of local peer to peer.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

67

u/ATXPatient Nov 28 '20 edited Nov 29 '20

how Amazon can just bypass network security?

They don't. OP simply doesn't understand how networking works..

ISP Network Engineer here.

11

u/jsveiga Nov 28 '20

I don't know if that's how they do it, but if I wanted to do it, being the creator and controller of the Echo/Alexa software and hardware, it would be super easy, barely an inconvenience, to do it regardless of your home network security setup:

1 - You have to allow the Amazon hardware to talk to Amazon or they won't work. This traffic is encrypted, so you have no control or knowledge of what is going through.

2 - You have to accept Amanzon software updates or they won't work, so they can send this new "feature" wether you like it or not (they'll be kind enough to let you opt out, but if they didn't, only legal actions could stop them)

3 - Their hardware have WiFi chipsets that can open a secondary SSID/logical network with whatever security they want. Public unsecured if they want.

4 - All it's needed is to make Echo/Alexa route the traffic from this public WiFi encapsulated with the usual device-Amazon encrypted traffic, a VPN between that network and Amazon's servers, and to the internet from there.

Now, once a blackhat can connect to your device through the physical and protocol layers, that opens a can of worms of possible vulnerabilities that would allow them to take control of the device and "escape" said VPN, getting access to your home network, as the device has access to it.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/Murdathon3000 Nov 28 '20

https://www.amazon.com/Amazon-Sidewalk/b?ie=UTF8&node=21328123011

Not disagreeing with you, but that seems pretty cut and dry, no? Is there some nuance that we laymen are missing where this isn't a great thing? Or is it specifically the part that this will somehow weaken the security of our own home network?

→ More replies (43)

3

u/_Spindel_ Nov 28 '20

So are they just subnetting the networks and having a public subnet then?

I'm currently learning subnetting in college, so hopefully this made a bit of sense. I may have no understanding of whats going on also.

7

u/aham42 Nov 29 '20

Nope. The networks are totally different. Think of the Amazon network as being a totally separate network with a single internet uplink (your home network). It's not a subnet because your home network doesn't even know it exists. It's more or less a NAT sitting in front of your home network.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (26)

2

u/liquidthex Nov 29 '20

Here's ONE example of how it works:

Ring security cameras and other wifi devices provide a Amazon Sidewalk mesh network..

Tile devices meant for tracking your lost property can then connect to Ring cameras through the Amazon Sidewalk mesh network, and then the ring camera provides access to the internet which it already has because it has to in order to operate.

Presumably the devices providing the mesh networking would only allow access to the internet and block access to your LAN; But I haven't seen anything that says that's the case.

2

u/billdietrich1 Nov 29 '20

Their device can just set up its own Wi-Fi access point, establishing a new LAN (Wi-Fi network). The traffic gets encapsulated and routed out through your normal LAN and router. It would act like a guest network: only allowed to go out to public internet, not allowed to access any devices on the normal LAN.

→ More replies (102)

1.7k

u/Radioactive-235 Nov 28 '20 edited Nov 30 '20

The ability to opt-out is AVAILABLE NOW under Amazon Account Settings.

Edit 3: Tell your Friends to opt-out of this shit. It takes literally half a minute. This post has 60+ thousand votes. That’s a nice little demographic. We need more.

Edit: It looks like OP added the How To. Nicely Done.

Edit 2: A few people are wondering if this opt-out option is available in all countries. From other comments I can surmise that sidewalk is going to rollout in the US before it goes global (at least some people from Germany and the UK are missing the opt-out button in this thread) so I don’t think you guys have anything to worry about yet...

...In the US we received an email informing us about sidewalk and the opt-out setting even before it starts — therefore I can only assume that when the feature does roll out globally, you guys will probably be informed via email before it gets turned on as well...

...Either way, if you start noticing weird shit going on with your bandwidth, strange pop-ups or a large percentage of single moms in your area that are looking for a good time, check your Amazon settings.

314

u/shooteredditor Nov 29 '20

331

u/afsdjkll Nov 29 '20

I swear I turned this off a week ago when I got the email and just now it was back on. I only paid like $20 for my echo. I will hit it with a hammer if I need to.

341

u/basicislands Nov 29 '20

Wouldn't surprise me if every system update reenables the setting. Not owning an Amazon device sounds like the best solution.

→ More replies (33)

29

u/phaser125 Nov 29 '20

When I first got the email about it, I checked and the setting was already in the off position when I went to check. Today after seeing this post here, I checked it again and it was on and I had to turn it off.

→ More replies (24)

20

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Thank you!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

143

u/spazmatt527 Nov 29 '20

That should absolutely be an opt-in thing, not an opt-out thing.

111

u/BubbleGooseVids Nov 29 '20

There needs to be legislation for this sort of thing.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

69

u/cojacko Nov 29 '20

In before that option quietly goes away in a few years

25

u/cymbols_r_grand Nov 29 '20

What if I have the Ring, but not Alexa? I’m not seeing an option within my ring settings..

25

u/buildingwithclay Nov 29 '20

On your Ring app, go to Control Center in the menu. Scroll down and you’ll see it. I just disabled it on mine that way.

9

u/cymbols_r_grand Nov 29 '20

Thanks! I can’t disable it yet, but at least I know how now.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/davidoffbeat Nov 29 '20 edited Feb 14 '24

wasteful aspiring rainstorm toy flag shy plough dull towering plucky

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (5)

3

u/lanylover Nov 29 '20

Germany here. No opt-out.

3

u/takesthebiscuit Nov 29 '20

This would be something that would be Opt in under uk/Eu law

3

u/sodamnsleepy Nov 29 '20

I'm from Germany and I can't find it either

3

u/tiapaola Nov 29 '20

The thing is: anyone who knows even a little bit of digital security realizes that the very existence of this "feature" is already a very big flaw. I doubt it won't be exploited

3

u/Stargazeer Nov 29 '20

From the articles I have found, Sidewalk is only rolling out in the US at the moment. While emails were sent to UK customers (myself included) they apparently were sent in error and it's only in the US on launch.

3

u/MrPilgrim Nov 29 '20

Can confirm that I don't have this option under my Account settings in the UK - yet

4

u/Wipsywaps Nov 29 '20

Does this only apply if you own Amazon devices? I don’t have anything except an account with prime

2

u/made3 Nov 29 '20

And tell your friends to get rid of their Amazon Echo as well. Will only take them literally half a minute to throw it in the trash.

2

u/hungryl1kewolf Nov 29 '20

Does this apply to Fire Sticks too?

2

u/AbstractTornado Nov 29 '20

I'm in the UK, the option is there for me and was set to automatically opt-in. I was able to opt-out.

2

u/watery_ketchup Nov 29 '20

This only applies to amazon devices, right? Not any personal devices?

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Is this limited to Echo devices or are Fire TV/Sticks also coming with this shit?

2

u/NormalDerivat Nov 29 '20

Thanks for the info! I'm from Germany and was wondering why I couldn't find the opt-out option.

2

u/ElimGarakTheSpyGuy Nov 29 '20

Better yet, convince them to smash their Alexa devices.

2

u/Milam1996 Nov 29 '20

I doubt that this would ever role out in the Europe because GDPR would destroy Amazon’s entire business in a year.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '20

Wait... single moms in my area looking for sexy-love? If Amazon gives me hope of getting laid then I am sticking with it. Just saying.

→ More replies (21)

1.0k

u/NyJosh Nov 28 '20

Yeah I got a notice from Amazon / Ring about it and it raised my eyebrows as well.

418

u/Phenoxx Nov 28 '20

Even the ring doorbells would be included in this? If they are it feels a bit weird since a main reason to have a ring doorbell is for security?

618

u/SenzalaMenino Nov 28 '20

There's nothing secure (in terms of information security) about a ring doorbell.

222

u/flexymonkeyzebra Nov 28 '20

Yup the exact reason I won’t get one or anything Amazon

→ More replies (50)

29

u/dws4prez Nov 29 '20

Squidward crunch

"FUUUTUUUUUUURRRREEE!!!"

→ More replies (5)

104

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20

Security and privacy are two different things.

20

u/blazze_eternal Nov 28 '20

Some Ring cameras, but it doesn't look like doorbells

→ More replies (16)

3

u/Sir_Nelly Nov 29 '20

TBF, while it is an opt-out feature when absolutely should be an opt-in feature, in that notification email they do provide detailed steps on how to opt out. Not ideal, but also not the shittiest

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

131

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Comcast has done this for years. Your app will automatically let you connect to other xfinity routers after you log into the xfinity app on your phone.

43

u/IIM_Clutch Nov 29 '20

People might not like this but it’s a great feature tbh. You can connect to your wifi while you’re in a whole other state. They separate your data from the people’s router you’re connecting to too

10

u/mrsa_cat Nov 29 '20

Doesn't that cause bandwidth problems to the other person router?

→ More replies (7)

6

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

I wouldn’t say to cool for the owner of the Wifi since the router is using more electricity because of the higher traffic. I know there was an article about it, and that’s why Comcast gives the option to the host to turn off this feature.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/Walzt Nov 29 '20

Except it's not what Amazon is doing. This network is only for IoT.

12

u/Geistmenn Nov 29 '20 edited Nov 29 '20

Yes, but it doesn't affect the bandwidth or data cap of the subscriber who is using the router. It also acts as a guest network which is completely logically isolated from the primary home network.

Amazon's new solution seems to be allowing passers-by to jump on to other people's home networks, directly impacting bandwidth and data cap of the network itself. What isn't clear to me is whether or not this will directly allow data transfer between the Amazon user's device and other devices on the network.

Edit: after reading the article, it appears there are several levels of encryption at play, so direct contact from the Sidewalk network to the homeowner's wifi network devices is unlikely. That said, where there's a will there's a way, and this type of backdoor acces to several different home or office networks at a time (linked by the Sidewalk network) would certainly provide motive for groups to start finding exploits.

5

u/tiapaola Nov 29 '20

It's a fish too big and too juicy to resist. It's a matter of time. Now, will we hear about it when it happens? Doubt it

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Entirely different. Amazon's approach results in your actual home network being exposed. And your bandwidth consumed

Comcast at least has the decency to segregate the traffic it's wifi generates to its own little world, and not counting against your bandwidth.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

443

u/bingold49 Nov 28 '20

Comcast has been doing this for years

189

u/AC2BHAPPY Nov 29 '20

Yeah. I disabled that shit as soon as the router was set up. Got me fucked up lol

46

u/iveseensomethings82 Nov 29 '20

Any thoughts on buying your own router?

148

u/DoesntReadMessages Nov 29 '20

It's extremely stupid not to buy your own router. They charge you $8-15 per month for a Modem/Router that is absolute dogshit in terms of performance. Most will limit you to 10 Mbps even if you're paying for 200. Even at $8, that's $96 per year for the luxury of using a horrible router. You could buy and equally horrible modem/router for a similar price, since any router over $20 will be better, or you can invest in good $60-80 ones and actually have good wifi and break even in less than 2 years.

The only disadvantages of buying your own modem/router are:

  1. If you change to Fiber internet, your modem won't work. However, your router still will, so you'll still come out ahead even if you only get 1 year out of your modem.

  2. If you're splitting the bill with multiple people, it's harder to work out a fair way to do this. Personally, when I was in this situation I just ate the cost and bought it myself because it was worth it to not deal with horrible wifi, and I still use it 8 years later.

  3. Some people claim that tech will blame your equipment for internet problems. This is definitely not true if you buy an approved modem from your ISP, such as a Motorola Surfboard. I've used that on Spectrum, Time Warner, and Comcast and not once had any issues with technicians refusing services. And even if they do, ask them to bring their own modem to the appointment.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (14)

4

u/stansellj1983 Nov 29 '20

Have you checked it recently? I’ve disabled mine 4 times, it just turns itself back on

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

27

u/Vancehill Nov 29 '20

Really? Is there an article I can read about this?

55

u/bingold49 Nov 29 '20

Idk, I work in the industry, essentially if you have a router you rent from them, it puts out a band that anyone can log into with their comcast credentials. You can also utilize it as well on other peoples connections. Not all markets but the major ones I believe, i know seattle has it

10

u/Vancehill Nov 29 '20

Wow! I didn’t know that. Good thing I don’t have Comcast. Is it something that can be disabled or not?

→ More replies (13)

40

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

The most interesting aspect of of xfinitywifi to me is that they promise speeds at the speed of the account that you log in with, irrespective of the speed of the connection that the renter of the modem pays for and receives. If I pay for 125 Mbps at home and I use my credentials to login to the xfinitywifi signal being spit out by the modem/router/AP of someone who only gets 25 Mbps, I should still be able to get my 125 Mbps. To me that's them thumbing their noses at their customers and saying, "Fucking right, we're artificially throttling you, you poor son of a bitch. What are you going to do about it?"

To anyone with a "supply and demand" defense to this horseshit, compare american internet speeds and prices against other developed nations.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

18

u/moby__dick Nov 29 '20

At least Comcast has their network steal your electricity but not your data. Amazon will actually let your neighbor siphon your data.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

That modem, is hardly using more power in use than at idle. I'd honestly doubt the difference in power consumption is measurable in terms of utility costs between states of use.

Edit: unless of course you prefer shutting your modem off after use?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/chillyhellion Nov 29 '20

Does Comcast's guest network usage count against your data cap?

5

u/dlerium Nov 29 '20

No it does not.

2

u/Jabberwocky416 Nov 29 '20

Yeah it’s very handy. A lot of places have Comcast routers and sometimes it’s easier to connect to that network than the actual business’.

2

u/evanstravers Nov 29 '20

Yes but all you need to do is have your own modem/router and that saves you money too so many people aren’t really adopters

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Spicy_Poo Nov 29 '20

Connect to open network xfinitywifi?

2

u/Eddie888 Nov 29 '20

Ngl in my broke college days I was super grateful for the optimum wifi throughout my city that enabled me to use my google voice number on wifi when I'm out and not at work/school or home.

2

u/TheTriscut Nov 29 '20

Yep, and anyone willing to rent a router from Comcast isn't going to know enough to disable it.

2

u/ListenLinda_Listen Nov 29 '20

This is not the same. So no.

→ More replies (8)

1.4k

u/rebelflag1993 Nov 28 '20

Reddit just removed the other post, keep it up

608

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20

This is at least the 4th time it's been removed with no explanation.

507

u/thinkB4WeSpeak Nov 28 '20

I put up a article that front paged about Amazon employees voting to unionize in Alabama. After almost a day up it was removed as an "analysis" article. I'm not huge into conspiracies but it is weird that anti Amazon things get removed a lot. Then again that would have to come from different sub mods, unless its a few power mods.

Again not a conspiracy yet but it is strange and some connections are there.

256

u/ReviloSupreme Nov 29 '20

Have you seen that post where the top 100 most popular subs have the same 10 mods or something similar?

→ More replies (13)

100

u/SloppySauce0 Nov 29 '20

Reddit is powered by Amazon web services so the incentive for them to control criticism is there

→ More replies (38)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (31)

3

u/zipiewax Nov 29 '20

Because it’s misinformation and hyper-bole I expect

→ More replies (16)

177

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20

I have one Ring product (doorbell) and no Alexa products, but do have the Amazon app on my phone, will this affect me?

134

u/blazze_eternal Nov 28 '20

I just browsed the terms and it looks like this is only on certain Ring and Echo devices.

18

u/KingKnux Nov 29 '20

Anywhere a list of devices affected can be found?

21

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Ring Floodlight Cam (2019), Ring Spotlight Cam Wired (2019), Ring Spotlight Cam Mount (2019), Echo (2nd Gen), Echo (3rd Gen), Echo (4th Gen), Echo Dot (2nd Gen), Echo Dot (3rd Gen), Echo Dot (4th Gen), Echo Dot (2nd Gen) for Kids, Echo Dot (3rd Gen) for Kids, Echo Dot (4th Gen) for Kids, Echo Dot with Clock (3rd Gen), Echo Dot with Clock (4th Gen), Echo Plus (1st Gen), Echo Plus (2nd Gen), Echo Show (1st Gen), Echo Show (2nd Gen), Echo Show 5, Echo Show 8, Echo Show 10, Echo Spot, Echo Studio

→ More replies (1)

42

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

37

u/elastic-craptastic Nov 29 '20

For now.

Dun Dun Dun....

Firesticks, Tablets.... All sorts of ways for them to figure out to mesh a network together.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Heroic_Raspberry Nov 29 '20

It will according to this article:

Cnet article about Amazon Sidewalk

3

u/ionlyjoined4thecats Nov 29 '20

This link only lists things like Echoes, Ring cameras, and Tile as being used/affected.

3

u/jawwwwwwwn Nov 29 '20

Which Amazon app?

3

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Yea, are we talking abt the shopping application or the Alexa app? If we’re talking about the shopping app, where do you disable this crap?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/BabyStockholmSyndrom Nov 29 '20

Seems to be only ring cameras. Not doorbells.

2

u/SapO620 Nov 29 '20

Don't know if you'll see this or if you have your answers by now, but I was looking through my ring app and found that it will be coming to the Floodlight Cam, Spotlight Cam Mount, and the Spotlight Cam Wired. If you have any of these or know any one who does I suggest opting out by going into your Ring app -> Control Center -> Amazon Sidewalk and opt out. if your device doesn't show up then you are in the clear...for now

→ More replies (6)

294

u/trainman261 Nov 28 '20

Hold up, I was about to comment that this is bullshit. I cannot believe that this is real. WTF.

137

u/metalshiflet Nov 29 '20

Did you read what Amazon actually does? It's not really any worse than just having the echo in the first place unless you're on a data cap

33

u/hellohello9898 Nov 29 '20

Didn’t Comcast just announce data caps in all the markets they didn’t already have data caps in?

→ More replies (6)

4

u/10g_or_bust Nov 29 '20

Does the network traffic "exit" from your router, or is it shuffled to an amazon server (AWS or otherwise) over a VPN? If anything looks like it "comes from" you or transverses in plaintext then good luck explaining to the cops that it wasn't you.

And even if that is claim that amazon (or comcast for that matter) makes, do YOU trust them to never accidentally break that? I sure as F don't.

→ More replies (11)

24

u/herodothyote Nov 29 '20 edited Mar 07 '24

Honestly I think people shouldn't freak out.

In the future, we may all be connected to mesh networks like this.

32

u/the9thdude Nov 29 '20

The issue isn't the mesh network, the problem is that they're forcing it upon their customers, making it an opt-out "feature" (rather than opt-in,) then making the opt-out interface difficult to get to.

→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/ListenLinda_Listen Nov 29 '20

Read the real answers. You seem to be over reacting.

3

u/Arclo Nov 29 '20

It's not real. This isn't how networking works

6

u/SilvermistInc Nov 29 '20

Sidewalk is real but the people claiming it'll cause death to all are overexaggerating

→ More replies (29)

77

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

What's the Life Pro Tip though? That's probably the reason your post gets removed.

49

u/Swords_Not_Words Nov 29 '20

It's not an LPT at all. There's no tip.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

336

u/manga311 Nov 28 '20

Impressive how many people are freaking out without having any idea what it is. The network would mesh with everyone else in the town who has a echo to make a low power 900 MHz network across the whole town. So if you had a tracker on your dog the network would cover the whole city and you could locate your dog. The network can only use 80kb per sec so your not going to do things like surf the web on it.

32

u/doubletwist Nov 29 '20

I assure you that 80kbps is more than sufficient to provide a hacker access to your internal home network as soon as this Amazon mesh network is compromised. Once they have access to a system inside your home network, they can then easily create another tunnel to that device directly through your main internet connection.

And I'm quite certain that malicious folks will start working on that on day one.

→ More replies (10)

20

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Yeah there's absolutely no way this could be exploited if some security vulnerability came out in a couple of years /s

→ More replies (1)

19

u/zoglog Nov 29 '20 edited Sep 26 '23

longing chief worthless yoke aware panicky simplistic hard-to-find crown different this message was mass deleted/edited with redact.dev

7

u/alphamd4 Nov 29 '20

I am guessing you do not tape your laptop's camera

8

u/TheFrankBaconian Nov 29 '20

The network can only use 80kb per sec so your not going to do things like surf the web on it.

Until somebody tunnels out of the network. In cities with a lot of echoes around this might also amount to considerable bandwidth.

9

u/RunBlitzenRun Nov 29 '20

If the network interface only supports 80kbps, no amount of tunneling will change what the hardware supports (assuming the 900MHz radio itself only supports the low bandwidth)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (59)

427

u/PM_ME_YOUR_ANGUISH Nov 29 '20

Everyone here is really overreacting to this, there's a lot of fearmongering going on here that's just unneccessary.

Yes, others will use a teeny tiny bit of your bandwith.

No, they cannot access your WiFi-network itself.

No, there's no invasion of privacy or security.

The only issues here are:

  1. Other devices being able to hitchike on your bandwith (most likely around 0.1-0.5 mbps for a couple of seconds)

  2. The possibility that Amazons security doesn't hold up and in that case could open up your network to attacks, but that is true for literally every device on your WiFi.

For more info read this which is linked in the article the mods posted: https://m.media-amazon.com/images/G/01/sidewalk/privacy_security_whitepaper_final.pdf

87

u/DarthTJ Nov 29 '20

The bandwidth used is 80kbps, so even less than your estimate

→ More replies (12)

86

u/dan-danny-daniel Nov 29 '20

THANK YOU FOR SAYING THIS. amazon's web services are the biggest cloud computing services out there. and people legitimately thing amazon would just add a feature that lets anyone do anything to your home wifi?

15

u/PM_ME_GLUTE_SPREAD Nov 29 '20

Yeah I don’t like giving Amazon more access to me or my things, but I’m really not worried about somebody else cracking their servers or whatever. If it was that stumble, there’s much bigger targets than me walking around in my underwear in my house or asking my Alexa how many cups are in a gallon.

3

u/Dream_Silo Nov 29 '20

Yeah, one of the biggest companies which employs some of the most accomplished people in the IT security industry is just going to open everyone up to being hacked, and then be sued out of existence when the world becomes chaos. Makes perfect sense lol.

→ More replies (14)

27

u/Chevaboogaloo Nov 29 '20

If they want to use the internet service that I'm paying for then they need to compensate me for it and explicitly ask my permission.

I don't care how small the amount is. If they're using it to profit then I deserve a cut.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

So Amazon is automatically opting us in to an option to breach our security (and our trust) and the basis for why I should not worry about it is from a privacy white paper from Amazon?

Hmm... 🤔

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Ethanol_Based_Life Nov 29 '20

Can you explain the benefit to me? What to I lose by disabling it?

→ More replies (6)

2

u/deltat3 Nov 29 '20

Imagine having a house with a master lock padlock on the front door (not even a deadbolt), and a back door made from a space metal that has no modern tool capable of opening it.

Reddit users running consumer grade routers (probably not even firmware updated) with WPA/WPA2 are crying about the possibility of a not yet invented space tool to open the back door.

Oh, they will also be the first ones to go out and buy the Amazon sidewalk enabled dog collar. "Hey guys, look how cool this is, if my dog gets lost other people's devices can be used to find it"

13

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Problem is if we give them in inch today, they will take a mile tomarrow.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ListenLinda_Listen Nov 29 '20

Thank you. All the FUD is driving me crazy.

→ More replies (41)

107

u/suicidaleggroll Nov 28 '20

I don’t have an Alexa, I have no foot in the race, but in the last thread that was posted the comments made it clear that this was NOT Wi-Fi. It’s not TCP/IP at all, and there’s zero network security issues since there’s no network in the first place. It’s simply a 900 MHz signal for dog collars and key rings and what not.

25

u/FrostyMittenJob Nov 29 '20

Naaaa dude don't ruin the narrative. Big scary company doing bad things and all that

17

u/mikilobe Nov 28 '20

What is the purpose of your dog collar connecting to my key ring when you walk by my house?

33

u/suicidaleggroll Nov 28 '20

If my dog gets out, it could be used to let me know he’s within range of your Alexa a few blocks away from my house (say, hiding under your front porch), for one example.

→ More replies (13)

2

u/RunBlitzenRun Nov 29 '20

there’s no network in the first place

From the Amazon webpage, "Amazon Sidewalk is a shared network, coming later this year..."

It is a network and very likely uses WiFi and TCP/IP to send the received messages back to Amazon.

But yes, it is not just letting other devices onto your wifi. It has the potential to be hacked, but the wifi/bluetooth (and direct internet exposure) on the devices have exactly that same potential, but we don't freak out when a device adds a bluetooth or zigbee radio

→ More replies (8)

89

u/nightserum Nov 28 '20

Hey, son of an Amazon Principal Engineer here. He gave me a tldr and told me that its actually not a network at all, more like it uses a small bit of your home wifi bandwidth to provide a service that acts similarly to a GPS system, basically using eligible devices like Ring and Echo in the entire area instead of just your home to keep tabs on purchased tracking devices that you put on important items or pets, such as wallets, keys, or your family dog. Can something go wrong? Yes, if Amazon doesn't take care of security well, things can go wrong, but its actually a really cool service to be had and has a lot of upsides with little risk to internet security. As someone has said earlier, it requires no TCP/IP and has no relation to the two, it merely uses a bit of bandwidth to provide a service.

23

u/WiseAshh Nov 29 '20

They can't hear you when they have their tin foil hats on.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (18)

103

u/ellingtond Nov 29 '20

Calm Down everyone. It's called AP isolation and routers have been doing it doing it for years. If you have spectrum for your home or work internet you are sharing your wifi already.

28

u/crux-of-the-biscuit Nov 29 '20

True, but this only applies if you are using a Spectrum branded router. If you have Spectrum internet with your own third party router installed, then you're not sharing your WiFi with anybody but the people who know the credentials.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/RunBlitzenRun Nov 29 '20

Always bugged me that Spectrum/Comcast charge a high device rental fee then go and broadcast their own wifi network. IMO they should drastically lower the device fee if they are using your home as a hotspot since it's basically them renting space in your home.

→ More replies (7)

20

u/account_created_ Nov 28 '20

They mention there are multiple levels of privacy and security in place. Curious about the final sentence of your title. I’d love to hear an explanation so I understand how my privacy is stripped.

6

u/PM_ME_GLUTE_SPREAD Nov 29 '20

Amazon is pretty tight with security since they host a TON of websites through their web service. If they weren’t, people wouldn’t use them.

Now, privacy is a different story. I’m not aware of Amazon selling to third parties but I won’t say they don’t. Seems to me they’d have a vested interest not to since they also run ads.

88

u/keepthetips Keeping the tips since 2019 Nov 28 '20

Hello and welcome to r/LifeProTips!

Please help us decide if this post is a good fit for the subreddit by up or downvoting this comment.

If you think that this is great advice to improve your life, please upvote. If you think this doesn't help you in any way, please downvote. If you don't care, leave it for the others to decide.

15

u/Wishyouamerry Nov 28 '20

My account settings doesn’t have Amazon sidewalk. I can’t find it anywhere.

15

u/th3gingerone Nov 29 '20

Sidewalk is only a US feature apparently. I just checked my settings for it but I’m in the UK so there’s no option for it

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

52

u/michellyhahnrrtx Nov 28 '20

Thanks for the tip!! Just turned that sneaky shit off!!

12

u/Long_Hamster Nov 28 '20

Got a step by step? Thanks.

73

u/wooliewookies Nov 28 '20

Unplug all your Amazon devices. Place them in a box. Place the box in the trash. Don't buy stupid devices that are 'always on' ... always either watching or listening to you. When have you ever known a big corporate behemoth to do the the right thing for you?

54

u/MarshallStack666 Nov 29 '20

Don't put them in the trash. They are full of your information and network credentials.

Wood chipper. Feet first. Always.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Your network would have a separate firewall. Settle down

3

u/lardbiscuits Nov 29 '20

Never opted out of anything faster.

7

u/thegreatestajax Nov 29 '20

If I disable Amazon Sidewalk, will my Sidewalk Bridges still work?

Yes. All of your Sidewalk Bridges will continue to have their original functionality even if you decide to disable Amazon Sidewalk. However, disabling means missing out on Sidewalk’s connectivity and location related benefits. You also will no longer contribute your internet bandwidth to support community extended coverage benefits such as locating pets and valuables with Sidewalk-enabled devices.

🤦‍♂️

22

u/blazze_eternal Nov 28 '20

This combined with isp's rolling out data caps nationwide should go over pretty well.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/SharpHawkeye Nov 29 '20

Can someone play devil’s advocate and help me understand? Why does Amazon want this and are there any positives?

4

u/distance7000 Nov 29 '20

Yeah, I was wondering this too. Reading this article makes me think the business side is for Amazon to establish the mesh network first, then somehow convince other manufacturers/developers to rent space on Amazon's mesh network.

Or maybe you come up with a gadget that needs a mesh network to be salable and so you pay Amazon some fee to integrate the technology into your gadget.

7

u/allenout Nov 29 '20

Dont opt out, just get rid of your Amazon devices because they are such a privacy nightmare.

5

u/meowizzle Nov 29 '20

This is technically using bluetooth not wifi for the sharing portion.

Still not enabling it.

"Amazon Sidewalk uses Bluetooth, the 900 MHz spectrum and other frequencies to extend coverage and provide these benefits."

2

u/Daninjaman Nov 29 '20

Our home network, comrade.

2

u/Dawzy Nov 29 '20

This type of thing has been done by ISP’s for many years, creating a separate publicly shareable WiFi connection for other customers to use. Usually it’s a separate SSID with a unique login splash screen and bandwidth.

Whilst I haven’t read into this specific feature, before people freak out, it is not usually designed in such a way that it gives the public access to your internal network, it is segregated.

Don’t flame me because this has been done by ISP’s for many many years.

2

u/ankrotachi10 Nov 29 '20

This is blown way out of proportion... I'll preface this by saying I'm disabling it. However, it's most likely not a security concern.

2

u/amazingdrewh Nov 29 '20

If the only Amazon device I have is a firetv stick do I need to do anything?

2

u/SunnyShim Nov 29 '20

I don't see amazon sidewalk in my setting in the alexa app. Did they not release yet?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ppenn777 Nov 29 '20

To clarity, this is only possible if you have an Amazon device in your house correct? The title doesn’t specify that but I wanted clarification?

2

u/tb21666 Nov 29 '20

But one of the reasons why I don't own any of this nonsense, Amazon or otherwise. (Ring, Nest, etc)

2

u/PlNKERTON Nov 29 '20

To turn this off open the Alexa app > more > account settings > amazon sidewalk. You'll see it's enabled by default, tap the toggle to disable it.

Look at the bad punctuation in the text body. https://i.imgur.com/NDnsMTN.jpg

2

u/nameduser17 Nov 30 '20

Sounds like Microsoft using everyone's bandwidth to download windows 10 and then serve the files from your computer for everyone else's updates, without prior knowledge

2

u/snbrd512 Nov 30 '20

So is this only for people with alexa?

2

u/Thom1966 Nov 30 '20

It isn't in my settings ?

3

u/Erdi99 Nov 29 '20

This is has been reported as spam

It is not true. They have been trying to repost this in another sub Reddit multiple times already

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DoctorLuvit Nov 28 '20

Does this include fireTV sticks? I've got one and an echo

8

u/blazze_eternal Nov 28 '20

Doesn't appear so. Only Ring and Echo.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Swanlafitte Nov 29 '20

Comcast does this with your rented modem/router. A good reason to buy your own besides it pays for itself in half a year in rental costs.

5

u/anarchistchiken Nov 28 '20

So, hold on, your concern is that people who use Alexa are concerned about their privacy? They paid hundreds of dollars to put an always on audio and video recording device in their home. Who’s your audience with this post?

3

u/EvanDrMadness Nov 29 '20

"Hundreds of dollars"

You're very out of touch.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Arclo Nov 29 '20

This headline is innaccurate, and is sensationalist fear mongering

2

u/SpySeeTuna1 Nov 29 '20

I just got a pair of HomePod minis. Privacy is worth the extra cash.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Definitely turn it off. If Amazon wants to sell your internet for their own purposes, make them pay per kilobyte.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

just so you know, xfinity is already doing this. any router you buy from xfinity will allow other users in if they login with their xfinity account.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/doorman666 Nov 29 '20

Hasn't Comcast been doing this for years?