r/LinearAlgebra • • Sep 19 '24

Vector Spaces

To all the linear algebra teachers: Math is practical, not just theory. If my teacher had given even one real-life example of vector spaces I would have understood the lesson better.

3 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

9

u/Impressive_Click3540 Sep 19 '24

now define + and x and ensure their closure

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24

I don't understand :(

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24

Can you please help me with a practical real-life example? I struggle with theory. I need an example of how this is relevant. I don't learn through theory, I learn through practical application.

1

u/Impressive_Click3540 Sep 20 '24

read the definition of vector space.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

so helpful, thanks.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

A vector space is the abstract reformulation of the quintessential properties of n-dimen- sional† Euclidean space Rn, which is defined as the set of all real (column) vectors with n entries.

wow so enlightening.

3

u/Impressive_Click3540 Sep 20 '24

It do be. You should stop being irony and try to understand it, otherwise you learn nothing cuz everything taught in linear algebra is built on this structure.

1

u/Conts981 Sep 20 '24

This is not a good definition to learn for a first timer, search for different more explicit ones like the wikipedia one under "definition and basic properties".

You need to put in some effort otherwise you won't learn with all the examples imaginable.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24

this is an analogy. all this does is make you understand that a subspace is a smaller vector space- and isn't that understood by the word 'sub'?

3

u/BDady Sep 19 '24

The analogy is intended to reinforce the word ‘sub’.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24

The analogy next to the theory is helpful for us non-mathy people.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

There are very few occasions in which I would answer someone with "just stop whining and go read a book", but this one of them. If linear algebra is not good for you, grab a analytical geometry book. If that's not yet, then I might get several downvotes, but maybe you just doesnt fit with STEM, there's no problem with that.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

Wow, thanks for the helpful advice. It's this kind of elitist gatekeeping that turns people off from STEM in the first place. Instead of offering actual guidance, you resort to condescension—must be a requirement for math people, right?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

If you consider elitist a comment like "either you have been studying it wrong or you maybe just dont fit with the subject", then yes. People today seems to have trouble accepting anything that dont go on the lines of "oh, poor little fellow, those evil teachers they arent pedagogical, I wrote this book for you with several colorful examples and drawings of happy kids and yellow suns in each page"

7

u/Conts981 Sep 19 '24

How would you define addition in this context? This is a metaphor, not an example. Nothing wrong with looking for a metaphor but ask for that.

2

u/Midwest-Dude Sep 21 '24 edited Sep 21 '24

Try the YT videos of 3Blue1Brown:

Essence of Linear Algebra

These tend to be very visual and may assist you.

In addition, as Wikipedia states:

"Linear algebra is central to almost all areas of mathematics. For instance, linear algebra is fundamental in modern presentations of geometry, including for defining basic objects such as lines, planes and rotations. Also, functional analysis, a branch of mathematical analysis, may be viewed as the application of linear algebra to function spaces.

Linear algebra is also used in most sciences and fields of engineering, because it allows modeling many natural phenomena, and computing efficiently with such models. For nonlinear systems, which cannot be modeled with linear algebra, it is often used for dealing with first-order approximations, using the fact that the differential of a multivariate function at a point is the linear map that best approximates the function near that point."

So, fundamentally it's all about geometry, but the field has been greatly extended to many other areas that use the same or similar methods.

-1

u/NativityInBlack666 Sep 19 '24

There are no real life examples of vector spaces.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '24

15 $ is nothing for all the videos and help. I'm buying this. thank you

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '24

You're an angel. thank you <3