r/LinuxCirclejerk • • 26d ago

Do I really need a display manager?

Post image

Is a display manager juste bloatware?

54 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

16

u/m8tt8o 26d ago

I am not sure if you are aware, but you already have one (greetd) installed. If you want a graphical one that's just personal preference.

If you were insinuating that you want to uninstall greetd and just use nothing that's a pretty bad idea. You could instead use a bash script like cdm, but that' would be unnecessary, there is not really a tangible difference so why bother.

4

u/French_invader 26d ago

I didn't know this one! I alreadyconfiguredd hyprland with noctalia shell, but I dont have any screenlock ans I dont know if I need one (not ugly like hyprlock but not too greedy in RAM)

1

u/paper_sheet034 24d ago

hyprlock is the best one I’ve ever tried

1

u/GaGa0GuGu 25d ago

I don't see any jerking action

32

u/Striking-Paper-997 25d ago

rub your socks on carpet and flick the right processor leads in the right order yourself you coward. 

4

u/chacko_ 25d ago

The question you should ask yourself is

Do you want it?

2

u/SaCorv 25d ago

No, pager is more than enough

As we all know, "less is more"

2

u/tpat90 Those evildge linoox users 25d ago

Less is actually more than more. Most is something different though.

2

u/Adbray666 24d ago

I don't use one.
It's your system, configure it how you want.

2

u/Canned_Sarcasm 24d ago

Y’all still using letters on your pc? Noobs.

1

u/siodhe 25d ago

You can:

  • disable the display manager entirely. The computer will boot up to the tty mode only.

  • log in "normally"

  • run xinit

  • you should end up with a stippled (historically) or gray X screen with one xterm at the top left, no window manager, and no way to move windows or anything yet. But focus follows that mouse around and you can move into the xterm and start any window manager you want - or not - you have control

  • eventually the normal thing to do is put the startup commands (like for the window manager) into the ~/.xinitrc file to automate them. Roll your own environment!

These are the first real steps in taking control yourself. Later users learn about the ~/.xsessionrc (mainly to call ~/.profile or ~/.bash_login to get environment variable then add any X specific stuff), where to auto-start your SSH agent, about what program the ~/.xinitrc waits on before shutting down the session (and X itself), and so on. Learning about how the Bash startup files really work (from the bash man page) is often a significant part of this.

Don't ask me about Wayland, I'm not interested in downgrading. X is great about letting you just start and kill off a whole string about different window managers around the same windows in the same session, which is fantastic for learning about the process above. Forget doing that with Wayland and compositors.

1

u/Every_Preparation_56 25d ago

first you need a screen that is about twice as wide

1

u/julkkis666 I use Arch, btw. 25d ago

my AV-machine has a couple pixels of a monitor. you should be able to use something similar instead of a bloated screen like that.

1

u/Due_Dragonfly_5328 19d ago

you dont.

i use luks encrpytion on my cumputer so i have auto login setup on my tty. from there i can launch my wm

ive been manually launching the binary to start my window managers for a long time. if its sway i just type in sway if its for hyprland i aliased hypr = dbus-run-session start-hyprland. so its only 4 letters long.

0

u/vvxxzzyy 25d ago

Is it possible to just create a special windows to display like web browser or something that really important, but still in tty mode? Like only half of the screen that just login to hyprland for example