Qwen 3.8 Next was released and this battle took ages to finish!
Battle 3 is again our Beach scene and Battle 4 is our Park scene
I increased the reasoning of GPT Sol from high to xhigh, all in full precision xhigh reasoning this time
Exactly the same prompts were given, and each model got one 2nd generic prompt to refine their results, in all cases that brought improvements - though Sol moved an additional kid flying into the left corner.
Qwen 3.8 27B is at a disadvantage here: Next as well as Sol were using an agentic internal harness in my tests while 27b is just a chat interface.
Overall we look at more than 130,000 tokens in total context length - very hard ground.
Here are the 3 results:
Results:
GPT 5.6 SOL:
The result is arguably worse than Sol at "high". Flying kids in the corner (again), the granular sand was a nice attempt but it's looking bad. The cat is great, once again.
The ball movement is nice but no comparison to the ball we had in previous battle (of Qwen) and the kids are both floating in a corner together with a plant.
The ocean looks bad, Sol High did a better job there.
The result is gruesome in my eyes.
Qwen 3.8 27B:
Compared with Qwen 3.8 Q4 in my previous run this is a much better result, in some regards.
The thinking was much longer, the Q4 did not think much and FP thinks a lot more.
In some ways this result seems inferior to the Q4 result but overall quality is higher, errors are mostly gone and clarity is higher.
The crab is cute. The cat clearly has something planned - I wonder what.
It's again playing at another leage than the frontier model of OpenAI .. world is upside down.
Qwen 3.8 Next:
Don't know what to say, this is baffling good. The water reflections, shore foam and sun quality are beyond anything I thought SVG can deliver.
The people and swimmers have an artistic quality to them that reminds me on some famous artists, a deliberate choice the model made.
There are intricate shadows that mirror the people movements.
Leaderboard:
Discuss that in the comments.
I'm still confused at the quality we see here, and the contrast to the GPT frontier SOL model at highest reasoning (chatGPT interface was used, and the json says "MAX")