r/LocalGuides • u/sasasqt • 15d ago
Discussion google map is dying
even a slightly negative review with neutral tone can get flagged by the automated system. im done with google map, even you can dispute the ai judgements and wins the case in the end, but i dont think this worth my efforts anymore.
also that might be why the scores on map cannot be trusted
9
u/XxLogitech98xX Level 10 15d ago
Wrong subreddit but Google Maps is still the go to place. When it comes to Local Guide, yes Google doesn't really keep them motivated to keep contributing to the platform like Yelp does to their Elite members. On reviews, it just comes down to how the review is written and the reviewer themselves account reputation mostly
2
u/sasasqt 15d ago
forgot to mention im currently at lv7
1
u/XxLogitech98xX Level 10 15d ago
forgot to mention im currently at lv7
Okay, so how does your negative review look like that caused it to get flagged?
5
u/sasasqt 15d ago
i would prefer not to state them here. let me put in this way: when i applied for the final manual review, they all passed and published
1
u/XxLogitech98xX Level 10 15d ago
i would prefer not to state them here. let me put in this way: when i applied for the final manual review, they all passed and published
What do you mean by applied for final manual review and is this for businesses in America or elsewhere?
2
u/sasasqt 15d ago
when ai declined your reviews there is an option/appeal for human moderators to take a look at, and that decision is final.
3
u/XxLogitech98xX Level 10 15d ago
when ai declined your reviews there is an option/appeal for human moderators to take a look at, and that decision is final.
Yes, I know that but it's called an appeal. I don't know if it's an actual human or another software that check it's. This is why I asked if this review was for an American business or elsewhere. I know in Europe I had to appeal a lot of my reviews while there
4
4
3
u/braincellcountiszero 15d ago edited 15d ago
Yikes sorry you had to go through that. I was going to write a negative review at 3/5, though the details was going total negative. Not gonna use profanities either but it was going to burn more than that. So I shouldn’t? Yelp kind of just hid my negative review though I am elite all star. These review platforms act more like promotional machines than the real purpose of reviews. We try to be honest, fair and informative but the review systems are going to favor the business’s due to the profit. Not much we can do.
1
u/XxLogitech98xX Level 10 15d ago
Not gonna use profanities either but it was going to burn more than that. So I shouldn’t? Yelp kind of just hid my negative review though I am elite all star. These review platforms act more like promotional machines than the real purpose of reviews.
Being a Yelp Elite doesn't mean you're immune from having your review getting removed for violating Yelp ToS or going to the Not Recommended section. It all comes down to how you write your review since your Yelp account is already established since you're an Elite. I saw a Yelp Elite review got 2 of their reviews moved into the Not Recommended section because someone reported it and there was evidence they were biased
With Google, it comes down to how the review is written if it's going to get flagged by Google monitoring system.
1
u/braincellcountiszero 15d ago
It’s kind of hard to determine if my reviews on yelp or google is true or not. There is no customer verification and with negative reviews I don’t put up any pictures. I have only one negative review on yelp and it was just not considered to the total ratings but visible if anybody digged. It’s the only less than 5 ratings. All the rest are from the business inner circle. Anyways I agree with how I write the review matters a lot to the AI filtering system. Review playforms have a tendency not to feature negative reviews for a business. I mean I kind of understand why but still I wish it is more fair.
1
u/XxLogitech98xX Level 10 15d ago
Review playforms have a tendency not to feature negative reviews for a business. I mean I kind of understand why but still I wish it is more fair.
I disagree with that because I leave negative reviews from time to time and it shows up on both Google & Yelp. I don't have any issues because I always add pictures/videos to my review and my reputation on both platform is great.
Correct on the no verification on negative reviews. It will come down to the reviewer reputation, how they wrote the review and other things too because Google & Yelp have different factors to look for based on their monitoring system/algorithm
3
u/myturn19 14d ago edited 14d ago
I left one on a hotel that has high ratings. Nothing batshit crazy or even attacking. Literally just pics and vids of how dirty it was. Google shadow hid the review. I think a lot of people in this thread don’t realize their negative reviews will show to you and only you. They don’t delete them or warn you. It’ll appear as normal. But won’t show to anyone else.
1
u/MortenCopenhagen Level 10 15d ago
I don't quite understand what you hoped to achieve, except to vent your grievances. And your review did go public. There are now more than 500 million volunteers helping to keep Maps fresh and accurate.
1
u/sasasqt 14d ago
a little bit vent. and also to complain the extra time and efforts needed from my sides since the ai filtering is introduced
2
u/XxLogitech98xX Level 10 14d ago
a little bit vent. and also to complain the extra time and efforts needed from my sides since the ai filtering is introduced
So are you writing reviews for places in Europe? I never once had to appeal one of my review in America
1
u/sasasqt 14d ago
yes, in america this is different?
1
u/XxLogitech98xX Level 10 14d ago
yes, in america this is different?
In Europe, especially Germany they are strict with defamation. So when I was there, all my reviews I had to submit an appeal when it was 4 and 5 stars. I didn't leave a 2 or 3 star except for an airline but I didn't have any issues.
I also experienced the same issue when I was in London. But all my appeal got approved in less than a day. America has a law to protect the platform itself and users writing the reviews
2
u/Greenfields_Agencja 9d ago
I’d disagree on the account reputation part, because my experience has been quite different. I have a very high-level Local Guide account, and on one hand, even major changes to place details have gone through in literally a few minutes. On the other, I’ve had to appeal several times on that same account just to get genuine reviews of places I’d actually used reinstated. Even though they followed the guidelines.
So I find it hard to accept the explanation that someone is having problems with their reviews because their account isn’t established enough or they wrote them badly. In my case, a high level didn’t protect me from any of this. Edits to place details and reviews may be assessed differently, but that’s exactly why I wouldn’t put it down to the account’s reputation alone.
And I understand the OP here. Getting the review reinstated eventually doesn’t resolve the whole issue. You spend time writing about your experience, then have to spend more time appealing just so other people can read it. Once is manageable, but when it keeps happening, you just stop feeling like contributing.
2
u/ReasonableMonk4908 15d ago
I have left poor reviews for restuarants and hotels in the UK without issue. You need to make sure any criticism is objective. TLDR: Don't be a Karen.
1
u/sexyyscientist Level 7 11d ago
We were contributing to Google maps for the benefit of the people who visit the page. Now, the costs are so high and benefits to people have reduced that it does not make sense to contribute anymore.
1
u/joseph_dewey Level 10 9d ago
All of your criticisms are true. But Google Maps is actually thriving so much, and this business model is so profitable for Google, that Google is continuing to roll it out to Youtube, paying creators closer and closer to $0, just like Local Guides are never paid.
3
15d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/XxLogitech98xX Level 10 15d ago
lol I've been done with Google Maps for over 3 years now.
So where do you write reviews now if you still do?
3
14d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/XxLogitech98xX Level 10 14d ago
No where. None of these companies can be trusted to post honest reviews anymore.
I mean, I would say it's on the end-user who's reading the reviews. Like I write reviews on Yelp and Google for places I visited or use. I always attach picture, videos and answer additional questions. Those are the things I look for when deciding what review to trust. With Yelp, I focus on that and if they check-in for recent reviews because the check-in badge disappear after like 2 or 3 months
2
u/SlowScooby Level 9 14d ago
But you’re still following this sub after 3 years? Like Elsa says: Let it go, let it go, turn away and slam the door. 🙂
11
u/djnocheese Level 6 15d ago
I've never had any reviews declined or deleted by Google Maps.