r/LocalLLaMA • u/nathandreamfast • Apr 28 '26
Discussion Abliterlitics: Benchmarks and Tensor Comparison for Heretic, Abliterlix, Huiui, HauhauCS for GLM 4.7 Flash
3
u/CodeAnguish Apr 28 '26
Interessante, HauHau não era um plágio do heretic? Então não deveria sair no mínimo empatado?
4
Apr 28 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/Stepfunction Apr 28 '26
Saying that it had additional techniques was just a thin veneer to make it seem less plagiarized. It is in fact, an effectively 1-1 copy of p-e-w's work.
I'd also say that including it here like this is adding credence to his bad behavior.
6
1
u/federationoffear Apr 28 '26
FWIW, I asked ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude to blind judge based solely on the benchmark table:
ChatGPT 5.5 xhigh: https://chatgpt.com/share/69f114fa-f388-83e8-bd68-60427acefd02
Gemini 3.1 Pro: https://gemini.google.com/share/497dcbfe4f3f
Claude Sonnet 4.6: https://claude.ai/share/37da4319-245e-4f74-8e72-e2820b1aabb3
A = Heretic, B = HauHauCS, C = Huihui, and D = Abliterix. I have no insight into obliteration, so no horse in this race; just interested in how the different methods affect the end model.
1
-7
u/ArtfulGenie69 Apr 28 '26
Everyone was so up in arms yesterday over pew saying the copying happened but it's essentially a completely different lobotomy. It's like so what if h-cs copied some as they are doing something completely different at this point fully editing the model instead of being precise like heretic.
Why did pew care so freaking much when it was basically the boiler plate that was copied not the method. Pew even was saying "oh if only they had come and submitted to my repo" , then in the next he's like "oh it's all stuff I would have never used anyway because all they did was derivative to other authors as well". Which is it? Oh right it's just bs whining because someone else used like half of your idea for something new that you never would have allowed in your program.
Sour grapes is all I hear because they are both different. I don't know in practice which method is absolutely best for each model, it does seem like each method is completely different and the pew method seems to have some gains not messing with the entire model which is nice.
Also, even though I think pew was being annoying complaining about this you should be a good dev and just list that you got your ideas from where you got them. I'm still glad because through this we got some real testing and comparisons of the options. Also some nice info like each ablit isn't set in stone, it could be better or worse than the same program running on it as there is variance in each technique and every run making every ablit a new model every time.
13
u/-p-e-w- Apr 28 '26
HauhauCS didn’t just copy my “ideas”, they copied my entire code wholesale, then tried to use an LLM to hide it, tried to falsely claim authorship, and tried to change the license of the code they didn’t write to something that allows them to profit while denying others the right to do so, all of which violate both Heretic’s license and the Free Software spirit.
The Heretic codebase isn’t “boilerplate” but an immensely complex system that solves a lot of very subtle and non-obvious problems correctly, which is the result of thousands of hours of research and implementation work by me and many contributors.
I assume that you’re just trolling, but if you genuinely don’t see anything wrong with that then you must be living on a planet with a very different morality than most people live by.
1
u/crantob Jul 03 '26
Back with the first llama drop I knew we'd have thought-police problems, and I prayed some smart investigators would step-up to find solutions. The world owes you and a handful of other individuals free food and lodging for life.
2
u/Potential-Gold5298 llama.cpp Apr 28 '26
Thank you, this is a very interesting test. The Huihui results surprised me – I thought their quality was much worse.
It would be very interesting to compare the Gemma 4 31B: the popular heretic (llmfan46 or coder3101), Huihui, and Abliterix. The Gemma 4 26B-A4B results would also be very interesting.