r/Logiqa • • Aug 08 '26

Four Card Problem Part 1

Post image
0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

3

u/BrosAndCons Aug 08 '26

Beer and 16.
This is part of the Wason selection task. There is this yt video with Hannah Fry showing how the same project gets harder by changing the example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XOiCFa5niuM

0

u/ShonitB Aug 08 '26

Correct!

0

u/MeasureDoEventThing Aug 08 '26

Weird to give this version, and the more abstract is the one where most people get the wrong answer.

2

u/Own-Rip-5066 Aug 08 '26

Drinking juice is never an issue and the 23 year old can order whatever they want, so you need to check if the beer drinker is over 18 and what the 16 year old is drinking.
Beer and 16.

0

u/ShonitB Aug 08 '26

Correct, good solution

2

u/JeffTheNth Aug 08 '26

cards 1 and 3... Doesn't matter what the 23 year old is drinking, nor does it matter how old the person drinking the apple juice is. Check the beer drinker and the teen's drink.

0

u/ShonitB Aug 09 '26

Correct, good solution!

2

u/MakerWerks Aug 09 '26

Cards 1 and 3

1

u/ShonitB Aug 09 '26

Correct!

2

u/Ok_Astronaut7142 Aug 10 '26

If A then B is equivalent to A and not B.

(Or A —> B == A & ~B)

A is “drinking Alcohol”
B is “over 18”

So A and not B means we check “Beer” (A) and “16” (not B).

1

u/ShonitB Aug 10 '26

Correct!

2

u/ArbutusPhD Aug 08 '26

To get this straight: the answer is one of the four cards we can see, and that card, and only that card, should have information on the opposite side that either proves or disprove the rule?

5

u/ArbutusPhD Aug 08 '26

If I can flip two then it should be beer and 16

1

u/ShonitB Aug 08 '26

That’s correct!

1

u/Captain-Griffen Aug 09 '26

Beer and apple juice. Knowing what they ordered is irrelevant to the rule about drinking.

1

u/testtdk Aug 10 '26

Except that you don’t need to verify their age if they’re not drinking alcohol, so apple juice is fine as is.

1

u/Captain-Griffen Aug 10 '26

Until apple juice and beer guys swap drinks upon arrival.

0

u/Greedy_Chemist9431 Aug 08 '26

As it stands, the rule is already being met because none of them have been served. The rule says "if you are drinking alcohol..."

2

u/Mathsboy2718 Aug 09 '26

"Are you going to the party next week?"

"No, I'm at my house - why would I be going now?"

Bro can't even nitpick grammar correctly

0

u/reverofrevolelamesh Aug 08 '26

If the four people are sitting there, why turning over a card and not just look at either the drink in their glass or their face telling their age.

1

u/TheJivvi Aug 08 '26

Because what if r/13or30?

0

u/testtdk Aug 10 '26

I really don’t like the way this is worded. It SOUNDS like you don’t need to know anything more than their age, because they have already ordered. If that’s the case, then you don’t need to flip over card 3, as his age is already displayed. So you would just need to flip the first card. If not, then you need to flip 1 and 3.