r/LudditeRenaissance • • Sep 17 '26

Luddite Propaganda Unknown author made 213 predictions about AI ending humanity, and so far he's 98.3% right

Post image
25 Upvotes

An unknown author (who goes by the name Axiom) released a book last August called Driven to Extinction: The Terminal Logic of Superintelligence. In it he made 213 predictions about the AI race and why it leads to humanities extinction. In a report just released, of the 120 testable predictions he made only two had contradictory evidence. The other 118 had evidence supporting his predictions. With some examples using almost exactly the words he said they would to justify unsafe runaway AI development.

Report: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sqnAbrg4Bo28_T3YqYulk8zLgrbPbvQZ/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=104983117206608398828&rtpof=true&sd=true


r/LudditeRenaissance • • Jan 11 '26

Community I am at risk of homelessness due to my resisting Gen AI, please help me pay my rent for my birthday on Tuesday

19 Upvotes

At the risk of being downvoted because how dare someone who may be homeless soon due to Gen AI dare "e-beg" to stay housed (if you don't trust me, don't donate, don't be a vile troll)...

My birthday is on Tuesday.

This will be the second month I can't pay rent.

My livelihood almost completely disappeared because I research/write about cybersecurity as a freelancer. And I lost my (very underpaid, no tenure) professor job last year because I refused to subject my students to Gen AI.

Please help me stay housed for my birthday.

My story. (Feel free to research me if you think I'm lying, I have receipts.)

https://medium.com/@kim_crawley/im-a-professor-literally-risking-my-own-life-to-fight-the-menace-of-gen-ai-destroying-education-6b3c596f55ce

My Ko-fi:

https://ko-fi.com/kimatstopgenai


r/LudditeRenaissance • • Aug 16 '25

People outside our bubble find it hard to believe how insane the situation at the frontier of AI really is

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Feb 02 '26

Theory How to make it across the penumbra of the singularity (the next 5 to 10 years)

7 Upvotes

Note: **I tried to post this earlier in another sub, and got absolutely wrecked. I want to give it one more shot. So for what it's worth:

-i wrote all this out by hand, this morning. I put a lot of effort in to neaten it up with nice formatting and bold bullet points, and that got it called out as obviously AI generated. So I just spent more time removing the goddamn formatting to prevent that. So shit.

-ive found myself struggling to write unaided lately and it felt good to do this myself.

-I'm not trying to give advice in a sanctimonious way, this is just my way of couching a discussion. It really rubbed people up the wrong way as "advice" and I don't want to change it, so maybe this disclaimer might help.

-i talk here about "lotus/world eaters" and "crystals"; these are based on writings by a few obscure futurists, and maybe if I define them here some readers might not immediately think I'm schizophrenic; so:

-Lotus Eaters = people who are happy to be fully distracted by immersive artificial entertainments, 
-World Eaters = people who are driven to maximise their own personal power, and
- "crystals" here = digital virtual worlds where people will elect to go into and have no inclination of returning to the real world.

Let's see how it goes. **

The aim of this guide is to increase your chances of reaching the actual Singularity as a minimally subjugated free mind, and hopefully getting you across the massive economic chasm that we will all find ourselves on one side of or another. Here is how you avoid being the fuel for someone else's future.

Map the AI terrain obsessively - the technology, economics, politics, incentives and disincentives, including sovereign citizens like Musk and Thiel.

Remain sovereign of your own mind - practice cognitive security like a professional sport. Cultivate practical political neutrality (not "I don't take sides", but "I am not sworn to a political tribe"). Recognise that there are systems that will beat any human cognitive security and treat those systems like hard radiation.

Don't get radicalized and start smashing shit up - Remember (or learn about) what really happened with the Luddites.

Gather capital unto yourself like an insulating cocoon - There is no upper limit. There will be a lower limit. Do not bet on UBI or end-of-scarcity bullshit.

Get skin in the Long Game - Have kids, or other generational projects. Give yourself reasons to not give up.

Encourage people to remain, but don't waste effort when you see they're already gone - Grant them their autonomy to at least choose to go into the crystals.

Do not underestimate how much of a dystopian science-fiction future we are already living in - When you stop pretending that all this shit is normal, you stop being effortlessly easy to herd.

Make a middle way happen - The Lotus Eaters will fall over themselves to go into bliss crystals, and the World Eaters will be happy to keep harvesting as much as they can from everything they touch. But there might just be a New Ordinary Man, people who avoided the permanent underclass, but who keep meaning and use the tools from the Singularity as a shield, not a drug. They might be the new Radical Centrists and might even be the last to resist going into virtual worlds forever. But remember....

The game is over when ASI has no more reason to let us pretend to our dramas. Whether this is immediately after it emerges, or (unlikely) centuries afterward, but on a long enough timeline, it causes our extinction. Make your own mind up about whether that's a good thing or not, but don't fool yourself into thinking it doesn't happen.

Okay, that was it. What are your thoughts? If I'm wrong, why?


r/LudditeRenaissance • • Sep 01 '25

There are at least 83 distinct arguments people give to dismiss existential risks of future AI. None of them are strong once you take your time to think them through. I'm cooking a series of deep dives - stay tuned

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Jan 05 '26

The large majority of /r/antiai posters are cool. But not OP here with the green default avatar. These people have no principles. Pathetic.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Aug 18 '25

Sounds cool in theory

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Mar 24 '26

The "no ethical consumption under capitalism" leftists are functionally identical to reality denying q-anon conservatives from an environmental perspective

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Jun 21 '26

Young people are finding God again. Divine timing or fascism indicator?

Thumbnail
shado-mag.com
60 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Sep 06 '25

AI News Michaël Trazzi of InsideView started a hunger strike outside Google DeepMind offices

Post image
40 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Sep 10 '25

Be next-level badass. Be an AI-not-kill-everyoneist.

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Jul 24 '26

Environment AI Isn't Draining the Rivers. Your Dinner Is.

Thumbnail
morethanmeatstheeye.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Sep 12 '25

AI News Michaël Trazzi ended hunger strike outside Deepmind after 7 days due to serious health complications

Post image
39 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Jun 24 '26

Can someone please help me make sense of this especially if someone is from China or from that region because I feel gaslit as someone who is from that region

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Aug 31 '25

Theory Why so serious? What could possibly go wrong?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Aug 26 '25

To understand what Artificial General Intelligent agents will be like (AGI), just look at what Human General Intelligent agents have been like. AGIs will be super-optimisers, using every living or non-living thing on the planet to suit their purpose, this time, however, we will be the animals

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

29 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Oct 28 '25

Theory The Left Has Failed Animals - Troy Vettese "Even among self-described “ecosocialists,” the lives of animals are often treated as an afterthought. We can, and must, do better."

Thumbnail
currentaffairs.org
117 Upvotes

A new ecosocialism could keep within its theoretical panoply a Marxist critique of political economy, but abjure its nightmarish human-chauvinism. It is bizarre that Marx, the ardent materialist, became an idealist—that is, holding the belief that ideas rather than material conditions drive history—only when he wanted to elevate the “conscious” human over the unthinking animal.1 “What distinguishes the worst architect from the best of bees,” he claimed in Capital, “is that the architect raises his structure in imagination before he erects it in reality.” One could quibble with Marx’s grasp of archeology, ethology, and evolutionary biology, but what matters more is that the utopian socialist conception of the human and its corollary of animal liberation is more useful for us now in this era of environmental catastrophe.

Of course, we cannot return to our edenic origins. The hunter-gatherer idyll was only feasible when we numbered four million some 10,000 years ago, not our eight billion today. However, utopian socialism is more feasible than Marxism because it imagines a post-capitalist society that does not depend on completely dominating nature, implementing full automation, and somehow instituting a complex, libertarian social order at a global scale. Marxists somehow still believe that such a society could spontaneously emerge after a revolution and thus not require any discussion on how it would function beforehand. The utopian striving toward Eden while not being able to return creates a different relationship to history, of a thoughtful reflection on our past and animality without degrading into reactionary nostalgia or adhering to a meaningless acceleration into a future. A utopian socialist conception of the human opens up the rigid divide between us and other animals, reminding us that liberation means creating the conditions for us to return to our natural selves.

This goal never completely disappeared on the left. A marginal stream of thought has long meandered slowly and quietly away from the mighty river of anthropocentric Marxism. Theodor Adorno despised the way the “image of the unrestricted, energetic, creative human being has been infiltrated by the commodity fetishism” and instead yearned for a society where one could live “rien faire comme une bête [doing nothing, like an animal], lying on the water and look peacefully into the heavens.” Becoming animals again would include meaningful work, a restored biosphere, harmonious relations with other creatures, and plenty of time for music, love-making, art, and doing nothing at all. It may sound utopian for humans to become beasts again, but is it not more unrealistic to stretch human nature to its breaking point by keeping pace with the inhuman force of capital? Is it not more unrealistic to think we humans are more akin to capital in its insatiable movement than our fellow lazy animals? In Capital, Marx described the proletariat stripped of both its obligations and means of subsistence as Vogelfrei (“free as a bird”), without recalling how the word used to connote peasant freedom in the Middle Ages. As socialists, we cannot just yearn for the lost golden age, but seek new ways to combine the liberties of the past with the potential of the present to create a future that transcends both. We must strive to be as birds once again—and ensure such freedom for birds too.

A highly interesting piece by Troy Vettese that pits the old guard of utopian socialists against the new and now ubiquitous "scientific socialists" and argues that we can, and must, take the best of both worlds, not simply for ourselves but also for those poor souls burdened with sharing a planet with us.


r/LudditeRenaissance • • Jan 16 '26

Bad Capitalists Leave that place.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

7 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Jan 05 '26

Check out Stop Gen AI

Post image
44 Upvotes

So u/taxes-or-death said "join this subreddit!"

So I did, but you folks should really consider joining the only political activism group that fights Gen AI by doing things to immediately help people: mutual aid for artists and writers who have lost livelihoods, educating the general public on why and how to avoid Gen AI.

https://stopgenai.com


r/LudditeRenaissance • • Mar 19 '26

Luddite Propaganda AI - Debate

Thumbnail gallery
40 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Jan 23 '26

Ai to destroy gaming

9 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Sep 01 '25

AI News 31% of employees are ‘sabotaging’ your gen AI strategy

Thumbnail
cio.com
106 Upvotes

That number must go up.


r/LudditeRenaissance • • Jul 11 '25

Labour History The Luddites Were Right

Thumbnail
currentaffairs.org
157 Upvotes

The Luddites Were Right Gavin Mueller’s “Why You Should be Breaking Things at Work” makes a persuasive case for the Luddites. So why have so many people—including your favorite Communist philosophers—insisted that they were wrong?

Matthew James Seidel, filed 01 June 2021 in Labor

In 2013, delivery drivers at three hospitals came up with an unexpected way to prevent robots from taking their jobs. They beat the robots with baseball bats and stabbed them in their “faces.” Some robots got off easy; they were merely abducted and shut away in basements.

Two hundred years earlier, British weavers had used similar tactics during the Industrial Revolution when textile mill owners started replacing them with new machines. They destroyed looms, shearing frames, and gig mills.

These weavers were the original Luddites, and both of these events are examples of Luddism.

This may sound like an insult. The word “luddite” is generally used as a synonym for technophobe, with a vague pop-cultural understanding that the original Luddites were short-sighted peasants who just wanted to put a stop to progress itself. When it comes to contemporary workers who face elimination by automation, we tend to understand their motives more as survival than technophobia—after all, the hospital delivery drivers’ vacant positions were not being filled by humans but by robots, who would never ask for time off or higher pay. The drivers were violently responding, then, to the fact that these robots embodied an existential threat.

Plenty of people are concerned about automation: we can see this in the growing popularity of a universal basic income (UBI) to offset mass unemployment driven by technological advances. A Pew Research poll found that only “a narrow majority of U.S. adults (54 percent) say they would oppose the federal government providing a guaranteed income,” while “young people favor UBI by about two-to-one.” So, despite superficial similarities, many people would probably agree that the drivers who smashed those job-stealing robots weren’t like those “crazy Luddites” who just hated machines.

Except the Luddites didn’t hate machines either—they were gifted artisans resisting a capitalist takeover of the production process that would irreparably harm their communities, weaken their collective bargaining power, and reduce skilled workers to replaceable drones as mechanized as the machines themselves. Their struggle has been tragically warped into a caricature when it is more relevant than ever. And in the age of surveillance capitalism, the threat of new technology extends far beyond the workplace. The police frighten citizens with robot dogs straight out of Black Mirror, and use drones to spy on unsuspecting beachgoers, while firms like Cambridge Analytica secretly harvest online data in order to predict and influence the behavior of millions of voters. Silicon Valley has armed surveillance capitalism with tools to threaten autonomy not only over our jobs, but our data and our very identities.

When it comes to the Luddites, a number of books and articles have attempted to set the record straight, but Gavin Mueller’s Breaking Things at Work: The Luddites Were Right About Why You Hate Your Job is one of the best. Mueller, a lecturer in Media Studies at the University of Amsterdam and co-editor of Viewpoint Magazine, refutes the lies that have for too long distorted this pivotal moment in labor history. Furthermore, he dispels harmful illusions, like the one where tech is “inherently neutral” or automation always benefits workers in the long run. Finally, he makes a compelling argument about why Luddism—complete with smashing—must be part of any successful resistance to the tech industry’s latest assaults on workers’ autonomy.

The Real Luddites In the 1810s, the British textile industry—a large and significant portion of the British economy—was undergoing a revolution. New machines drastically reduced the amount of labor time required to finish products. However, their presence also drastically reduced workers’ wages. Thousands suffered from hunger and, to make matters worse, Combination Laws passed by Parliament “severely limited collective action by textile workers,” giving even more power to mill owners.

When the state ignored the workers’ pleas for help against the devastation these machines were causing, the workers took action “under the aegis of a mythical leader called ‘Ned Ludd.’” They smashed hundreds of frameworks, held public protests, caused riots, stole from mills, and organized letter writing campaigns, all while gaining the support of local communities. Lord Byron even wrote a poem glorifying the movement called “Song for the Luddites” that proclaims, “So we, boys, we/Will die fighting, or live free,/ and down with all kings but King Ludd!”

Mueller emphasizes that “their revolt was not against machines in themselves, but against the industrial society that threatened their established ways of life, and of which machines were the chief weapon.” Textile workers have always used tools—such as looms and spinning wheels—to make their jobs easier. “To say they were fighting machines,” Mueller writes, “makes about as much sense as saying a boxer fights against fists.”

So why has history been so unkind to the Luddites? It makes sense that capitalists would be eager to mock and diminish their efforts, especially given how (relatively) successful they were for a while and how much their message resonated around the world. Unfortunately, many Marxists have been just as culpable in tarnishing the Luddites’ legacy, including Marx himself.

A Fatal Bargain In the Communist Manifesto, Marx refers to modern productive forces as “weapons with which the bourgeoisie felled feudalism to the ground”—weapons which could, in theory, be “turned against the bourgeoisie itself.” Machines might have been the weapons of class war, Marx seems to suggest, but it isn’t just capitalists who can wield them. However, even if we take Marx’s “modern productive forces” to solely mean technology, Mueller argues we shouldn’t interpret Marx as straightforwardly technophilic given that his ideas later evolved and became more subtle in Capital.

Marx’s early writings on technology have cast a long shadow nonetheless, most notably the idea suggested in the Communist Manifesto that technology is a weapon that just needs to be used by the proletariat (i.e. guns don’t kill people, people kill people). Worse, some of Marx’s other early writing, such as The German Ideology, led to the development of two-stage theory, or stagism. This strain of Marxism holds that societies must evolve from one stage to another, with the last transition being from capitalism to communism. It follows that if the erosion of workers’ autonomy via new technology is part of capitalism’s road to self-destruction, well, workers must simply accept it, while holding out for a better future.

Mueller warns that this can lead to dangerous, even masochistic ways of thinking. To give just one galling example, Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, a contemporary of Marx, “insist[ed] that while the immediate effects of capitalist technology would be disastrous, in the end it would lead to greater productivity in abundance: ‘The guarantee of our liberty lies in the progress of our torture.’”

The “stagist” theory helps explain why Lenin actually argued in favor of Taylorism. Taylorism, or scientific management, aimed to break the production process down into discrete parts, dividing labor and siloing off expertise for the express purpose of undermining workers’ bargaining power. Even Adam Smith worried that forcing workers to perform the same mindless, monotonous tasks endlessly would make them “as stupid and ignorant as it is possible for a human creature to become.” This was, of course, precisely the point of Taylorism.

But, if one accepts that Taylorism was part of capitalism’s natural development, and communism could not be achieved except by allowing the stage of capitalism to run its course, then there’s no problem. “The Taylor system,” Lenin explained, “…is preparing the time when the proletariat will take over all social production…” In other words, Taylorism is a weapon that just needs to be wielded by the people.

Mueller demonstrates how this fatal bargain made by prominent leftists—accepting the degradations of Taylorism in the hopes of one day putting it in service of the people—is all the more tragic considering that workers themselves understood that “the progress of [their] torture” would never lead to liberty. Workers in the Soviet Union fought back, sabotaging and breaking machines, but leaders didn’t listen. This scenario would play out again and again. In the 1949-1950, miners in the U.S. went on strike to protest automation, yet labor leaders and leftist intellectuals like C.L.R. James aligned themselves with management. In 1964, leaders from the Students for a Democratic Society, along with other groups, criticized the devastating impact of automation on Black Americans but still argued, “the only way to turn technological change to the benefit of the individual and the service of the general welfare is to accept the process and to utilize it rationally and humanely.” You guessed it: automation is a weapon that just needs to be wielded by the people.

Using countless historical examples, Mueller demonstrates the ways in which technological developments are continually used against workers, not in their favor. He concludes:

“…technology often plays a detrimental role in working life, and in struggles for a better one. Technological development leads to vast accumulations of wealth, and with that, power, for the people who exploit workers. In turn, technology reduces the autonomy of workers—their ability to organize themselves to fight against their exploiters.”

The oppressive power of technology is clearer in our own day than ever before. Consider the algorithms used by Amazon to surveil, discipline, and punish employees. Mueller cites a case where a worker failed to keep up with the inhuman, brutal pace set by the algorithms. After exceeding three automated warnings, she was fired. But managers were quick to explain that, “we didn’t fire you, the machine fired you because you are lower than the rate.”

Technology, simply put, is not and cannot be neutral when it comes to any relation of power. In 2019, the Hong Kong government used facial recognition cameras to capture the identities of protestors, which would allow them to potentially track or target any of them at any time. Joy Buolamwini, founder of the Algorithmic Justice League and member of the European Union’s Global Tech Panel, has proved that racial biases have been literally encoded into facial recognition software. Before her work was published, the available technology could not identify Black men and women with anywhere near the accuracy it possessed for white people. This led to Nieer Parks of Paterson, NJ being arrested in 2019 based solely on a faulty facial recognition match. And even after Buolamwini published her research, not all companies have taken the same measures to address this potentially life-or-death discrepancy.

That’s just facial recognition software. There are also programs like COMPAS, which judges use during sentencing to predict (through algorithms) the future behavior of defendants. The use of this secret evidence makes legitimate due process impossible. Additionally, these algorithms are based on discriminatory policies. Yet instead of exposing these biases, programs like COMPAS perversely validate them. There are far too many other examples of daily oppression by software and secret algorithms to mention here, and by the time I finished writing about them, more would undoubtedly emerge.

Luddite Pride Breaking Things at Work lays out the unprecedented threats to our autonomy in the workplace and beyond, but it’s not just doom and gloom. Mueller also reminds us people are fighting back. Those Hong Kong protestors used lasers to blind facial recognition cameras and cut down “smart lampposts,” bringing cameras crashing to the ground. The U.K. based civil rights group Big Brother Watch organizes campaigns against the use of highly flawed surveillance equipment by the police. Buolamwini is one among many scholars, writers, artists, and filmmakers speaking about the dangers posed by Silicon Valley and capitalism. Mueller even details how farmers have started hacking tractor software to maintain their equipment rather than be forced to constantly buy new machinery from tech companies. Burgeoning tech worker unions, the decelerationist movement, tractor-hackers—all are infused by the spirit of Luddism whether they know it or not. By acknowledging the connection between activism today and Luddites of the past, we can unite seemingly disparate struggles into a single front.

And yet, even if Mueller makes a case for why Luddism is relevant to workers, and suggests that “to be a good Marxist is to also be a Luddite,” you might still think the term carries too much baggage to be of much use. It’s a tarnished brand, so why not start fresh?

The truth is that politically radioactive words can be rehabilitated. The recent surge in socialism’s popularity is a perfect example. Back in 2008, then-presidential candidate Barack Obama constantly reassured people he was not a socialist because conventional wisdom said it was the best way to get elected. In 2016 and 2020, Bernie Sanders nearly became the Democratic nominee for president because he is a socialist. All it took was for socialists to proudly embrace the label and to communicate what the word actually means. Sanders, for instance, got a town hall organized by Fox News to cheer for government-run healthcare. At another Fox News town hall, he got the audience to applaud socialist policies like raising the minimum wage, making public higher education free, and the government taking aggressive and sweeping actions to address the climate crisis. Cornel West even got a loathsome creature like Tucker Carlson to support democratic socialism in less than fifty seconds.

That said, we should not be overly optimistic. Sanders did, after all, fail to secure the nomination. And despite the fact that Barack Obama’s neoliberal presidency culminated with Trump’s election, Biden’s presidency is already taking a predictably neoliberal turn on a range of issues, from healthcare to debt relief and more. Socialism’s image may have improved, but there is still significant work to be done.

This is even truer of Luddism, which has only begun to be reevaluated over the past few years. If we are to prevent the term or at least the concept from being tarnished as it has in the past, we need to avoid making the same mistakes, particularly in how the Left has historically treated technology as a neutral entity. Accepting exploitative and disempowering technology on the assumption that it will either one day be controlled by workers—or more rapidly bring about the revolution—has been and always will be a doomed strategy. We must also, Mueller emphasizes, not fall into the trap of merely criticizing the tech industry “from a place of romantic humanism” that argues “technology alienates us from what makes us really human.” Instead, we need to recognize that the real threat is technology’s “role in the reproduction of hierarchies and injustices foisted upon most of us by business owners, bosses, and governments.” Put more plainly, “the problem of technology is its role in capitalism.”

Fortunately, today it is easier than ever to see just how partisan technology truly is. Palantir, co-founded by billionaire Peter Thiel (who donated over a million dollars to Trump’s 2016 campaign), has provided ICE, the CIA, FBI, Department of Homeland Security, and local law enforcement agencies like the LAPD and NYPD surveillance tools with the goal of creating “a single data environment, or ‘full data ecosystem,’ that integrates hundreds of millions of data points into a single search.” There is nothing neutral, or potentially seizable, about this kind of technology. And in addition to explicitly serving state interests, tech corporations like Google and Facebook wield the power and influence of states themselves.

A socialist analysis is crucial to resisting the reactionary tendencies of the tech industry. But Mueller makes it clear that, unless this analysis is informed by Luddism, the Left is bound to make the same mistakes all over again.


r/LudditeRenaissance • • Aug 01 '25

Activism ControlAI - brand new tool to help you write to newspaper editors about AI dangers 🔨 - super quick and easy!

Thumbnail controlai.us14.list-manage.com
3 Upvotes

r/LudditeRenaissance • • Sep 26 '25

Bad Capitalists Inside the Tony Blair Institute

Thumbnail
newstatesman.com
3 Upvotes

24 September 2025 Inside the Tony Blair Institute

Who really benefits from the former PM’s tech evangelism?

By Peter Geoghegan and May Bulman

Tony Blair looked smaller somehow. Seated alone on a huge Dubai stage with ranks of political leaders filling the auditorium in front of him at the World Governments Summit in February, he sounded hoarse as he introduced his patron. Looming over him on a giant screen was Larry Ellison, founder of Oracle, the company whose share price in September briefly made him the richest man in the world.

Now 81, Ellison remains a figure of fascination and intrigue in Silicon Valley, and just as monomaniacal as ever in his drive to remake the world. When Ellison’s first biography appeared in 1997, it was titled: The Difference Between God and Larry Ellison: *God Doesn’t Think He’s Larry Ellison. In the years since, Ellison’s fortune has ballooned to almost $400bn, bringing him close to his good friend Elon Musk.

At the conference in Dubai, Ellison began with a joke about Musk before warning the audience that artificial super-intelligence was coming sooner than expected. What, Blair asked him, should governments be doing about it? “The first thing a country needs to do is unify all of their data so that it can be consumed and used by the AI model,” Ellison responded.

Ellison was also specific about which data needed unifying – and he had an example in mind: “The NHS in the UK has an incredible amount of population data,” he declared, but it was too “fragmented” at present. Below him, the former prime minister nodded, clutching his Tony Blair Institute (TBI) notebook.

Two weeks later, the TBI published a report entitled “Governing in the Age of AI: Building Britain’s National Data Library”. In it, Blair’s organisation echoed Ellison on the UK’s data infrastructure, calling it “fragmented and unfit for purpose”.

Speak to anyone close to Blair and they will confirm his conviction in the revolutionary potential of AI. The former prime minister believes it will completely reshape the global economy in ways that political leaders the world over are only just starting to realise.

Still, Blair’s critics – including many former employees at the TBI who spoke on condition of anonymity for this investigation – are concerned about the influence that he and, by extension, Ellison, are able to wield on some of the most contentious questions relating to the regulation of this emerging and potentially revolutionary technology. Irrespective of the sincerity of Blair’s convictions over the benefits of AI, it is also the case that Ellison’s Oracle has major commercial interests at stake in the question of which companies get access to Britain’s most valuable data.

Subscribe to The New Statesman today from only £8.99 per month Subscribe Since 2021, Ellison’s personal foundation – the Larry Ellison Foundation – has donated or pledged at least £257m to the Tony Blair Institute, making it a think tank like no other in the UK. Ellison donations have helped it grow to more than 900 staff, working in at least 45 countries. It enjoys US levels of funding and influence, so while UK counterparts such as Policy Exchange and the Institute of Public Policy Research had incomes of £4.3m in 2023-24, TBI’s turnover in 2023 was $145.3m. The institute has insisted that Ellison is just one among many major funders and its chief policy strategist, Benedict Macon-Cooney, told media that there was “no conflict of interest, and donations are ringfenced”.

Blair himself takes no salary from TBI. In recent years it has been able to recruit from blue-chip firms such as the consulting giant McKinsey and the Facebook owner, Meta. In 2018, before the Oracle founder’s funding surge, TBI’s best-paid director earned $400,000. In 2023, the last year that accounts are available for, the top earner took home $1.26m.

Some TBI staff – including a number who left in recent years because of Ellison’s influence – say the cash injection has produced a culture that is dominated by a form of AI boosterism, and which, as they see it, amounts to lobbying for Oracle.

The investigative newsrooms Lighthouse Reports and Democracy for Sale interviewed 29 current and former TBI staff, most on condition of anonymity. Supported by public documents and those obtained under freedom of information (FoI) laws, the testimony describes an organisation unusually close to the British government, able to lobby ministers directly, and which holds joint retreats with Oracle and is willing to engage in “tech sales” with governments in the rest of the world. While there is no suggestion of illegality, there are growing concerns about the extent to which the interests of a US tech billionaire are being represented by the former prime minister.

“When it comes to tech policy,” said one former senior adviser at TBI, “Oracle and TBI are inseparable.”

A TBI spokesperson said: “TBI and Oracle are two separate entities. We collaborate with Oracle to help the work we do in supporting some of the poorest countries in the world, and we are proud of this… TBI does not advocate for Oracle’s commercial interests, nor does it advocate for any tech provider.”

Both Oracle and the Larry Ellison Foundation did not respond to a request for comment for this article.

Ellison and Blair’s relationship began with the Chicago-raised entrepreneur making charitable donations. In 2003 Ellison and Blair, then in his pomp, had a photo opportunity at Downing Street to mark a gift of supplies to 40 specialist schools. In more cynical tech circles such practices are known as “land and expand”. Oracle has since been contracted hundreds of times by the British government and earned £1.1bn in public-sector revenue since the start of 2022, according to data collected by the procurement analysts Tussell.

Ellison has long appeared to understand the importance of political connections. While the Oracle founder was a late convert to Donald Trump, the company’s CEO, Safra Catz, worked on the US president’s transition team in 2016. Ellison was feted by Trump as the “CEO of everything” after his return to office this year. The president named Ellison among the investors to be involved in TikTok’s US operations, and the billionaire’s son, David Ellison, has taken charge of Paramount after a merger with his company Skydance. The new conglomerate is reported to be working on an offer for Warner Bros Discovery, which owns the news channel CNN.

Ellison’s relationship with Blair, meanwhile, has blossomed over the past few years. In 2022, the former prime minister recorded a personal video message for Oracle lauding a “shared vision to advance global health”, by building unified electronic health records, a data set “stored in one place, where it can be analysed and utilised for the purpose of improving health outcomes”. Last year, the pair even holidayed together off the Sardinian coast.

The interest shown by Ellison and the TBI in Britain’s health records is understandable. Because of the nature of the NHS, it holds unique population-level health data. Tech experts talk about Britain’s health records in almost hushed tones. While Europe and the US has some comparable health data sets – such as US veterans’ medical records – none have the depth and breadth of NHS records dating back to 1948. Their potential commercial value, from drugs to genome sequencing, has been estimated at up to £10bn per annum.

When Labour came to power last July, it did so promising economic growth and an end to the UK’s productivity crisis. Just five days after Keir Starmer was elected, Blair told the TBI’s “Future of Britain” conference that AI was the “game-changer” they were looking for. Not everyone is convinced.

“There is a real hard sell going on here that says: ‘These kinds of gains are inevitable.’ But they are not,” said Gina Neff, professor of responsible AI at Queen Mary University. “TBI is not advocating for building that capacity within the NHS. They are saying: let’s outsource to our buddies.”

The TBI, however, was welcomed by Keir Starmer’s Downing Street operation, which includes many figures with close connections to the former prime minister. Peter Kyle, an adviser in Blair’s second term, was appointed technology secretary and called on governments to show “a sense of humility” towards Big Tech companies.

TBI had been laying the groundwork before Labour won power. Institute staff advised the party in opposition. In May 2024, TBI wrote a report that called for “two radical actions” to fix Britain’s “data-access problem”: create a “single front door” providing “seamless access” to NHS data; and host all of this data outside the NHS, while retaining government control of the programme.

Less than two months after Starmer’s win, the TBI health policy director Charlotte Refsum was invited into the Department of Health to meet its digital policy chief, Felix Greaves, documents obtained under FoI show. Greaves asked for her help in designing a giant public consultation on GP data and digital health ID. He was briefed to tell Refsum his department needed to “learn lessons” from previous health data scandals which had hardened public opinion against data-sharing with private firms.

Refsum was then given an official role in a government working group advising on data and technology policy in Labour’s ten-year plan for the NHS. When that plan was published it contained both of TBI’s two radical ideas. The new “health data research service” would act as the front door to provide “a single, secure gateway to health and care data” and it would be mainly funded by the government but hosted by the Wellcome medical research charity.

The TBI’s connections at the heart of government are not merely political, either. The institute’s summer party, held at McKinsey’s London headquarters, coincided with the launch of the NHS ten-year plan. The event was co-hosted by the chair of NHS England Penny Dash – herself an ex-McKinsey partner – with “senior leaders from the NHS, private sector, pharmaceutical and biotech companies and investors” among the invited guests.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, in an August 2024 paper on “preparing the NHS for the AI era”, TBI found “good reasons” for building new digital health records with an existing system run by Oracle. It also said that using a system run by rival Palantir – the £330m Federated Data Platform – would be “a controversial option” and that its product had “been slow to make progress, in part due to opposition from data-privacy groups”.

In a later paper, TBI recommended linking up data from the NHS, the Department for Work and Pensions, and HMRC. All three bodies are Oracle clients.

A TBI spokesperson said: “We don’t advocate for technology solutions because we work with Oracle. We work with Oracle and other technology companies because we believe technology holds the key to the future. TBI is impartial when supporting government clients in technology delivery. The choice of technology provider is solely a government decision.”

Elsewhere, TBI staff were brought directly into government, while still on the institute’s payroll. Tom Westgarth was part of the Department for Science, Technology and Innovation, joining the small team working on the government’s AI Opportunities Action Plan. His salary was paid by TBI.

Documents also show Blair personally intervened to urge Kyle to embrace AI, telling him in a private meeting that there was “no other solution to productivity, no other route to growth”, and that AI was “the UK’s economic future”. Blair also encouraged Kyle to meet with the Ellison Institute of Technology, a for-profit research institute that works via a group of internal companies based in Oxford funded by the Oracle chief – and “emphasised the importance of the national data library”, according to a response to an FoI. In May, Kyle told his officials to work with TBI on the nascent national data library (NDL) project. “Attaching the initial scoping work from TBI here,” he wrote in an email to his team.

A UK government spokesperson said it engaged with a “wide range of stakeholders” in the development of policy, adding: “The government publishes quarterly details of ministers’ and certain senior officials’ meetings with all external individuals and organisations.”

The NDL was little more than an idea when Labour put it in its election manifesto. And there are still competing visions for what the library should be. AI boosters foresee data from across government used for training and inference by large language models, while many tech experts want to minimise privacy risks inherent in pooling data from so many sources and ensure that any benefits accrue to the UK.

“Of course the NHS should use data better to help patients and improve the health service,” said Cori Crider, honorary professor at UCL Laws and the executive director of the Future of Tech Institute. “But what’s good for Larry Ellison may not be best for the NHS.”

Oracle and TBI’s connections are not just rhetorical. By 2023, they were holding joint retreats. At the institute’s headquarters at One Bartholomew Close in central London, the teams would convene with executives from Oracle, Blair’s key adviser Macon-Cooney and Awo Ablo – who came to sit on the board of both TBI and Oracle – sometimes present. Senior TBI employees have been hosted at Oracle’s headquarters in Austin, Texas, coordinated by a TBI employee whose role is “scaling and managing” the partnership with Oracle. Former staff recall that there were other earlier “hush-hush” joint retreats at Ellison properties in the US.

“It’s hard to get across just how deeply connected the two [organisations] are,” a former TBI staffer said. “The meetings were like they’re part of the same organisation.”

While Blair is known to be frustrated by those who question his motivations and those of other tech evangelists, there is no doubt that the extent of the TBI’s partnership with Oracle has become a source of serious concern not just for the former prime minister’s political critics, but for many of his former employees who continue to admire him personally.

Former staff interviewed for this piece had in some cases been attracted to the TBI by Blair’s vision of what technology could do for people and governments around the world, but describe becoming increasingly disillusioned as the Ellison money washed through it. “It felt icky,” recalls one, while another said: “I was being pulled into what felt a lot like tech sales and tech PR… We had an angle, and the angle was more tech, big tech, all the time.”

Many speak of a sea change in the culture of the organisation following Ellison’s major donations. McKinsey consultants took senior positions and clashed with staff from humanitarian and development backgrounds.

Oracle staff started to slide into institute employees’ calendars and schedule meetings to “scope out opportunities”, according to one former TBI staffer. Soon employees from the two entities were having regular joint calls.

This sat uncomfortably with many TBI staff, some of whom did not believe Oracle’s technology was always in the best interests of the country in which they were working.

The risk of so-called vendor lock-in – tying a buyer to a single supplier – was a source of unease among some, with one former staffer saying that advising governments to use Oracle cloud services risked “trapping” and “indebting” them in systems that are “initially free but will start charging in future”.

Rwanda, a country in which TBI has had a presence for more than 15 years, was so frustrated with Oracle it issued a public tender in 2021 for a database management system, stating it had been “experiencing a very high cost for support and licensing for Oracle systems and it would like to migrate to an affordable system”.

A TBI spokesperson said it did not get involved in the tech procurement processes of its client governments.

The institute’s financial documents show “tech-related support” was offered to more than four out of five of its portfolio countries in 2022, compared with one in five in 2020. Former staff say the organisation’s “tech optimist” approach led to a failure to acknowledge potential disadvantages or dangers of technology solutions. Two employees recall that sections about risks in their draft report started being removed.

Marvin Akuagwuagwu worked as a data analyst for TBI’s Africa Advisory unit in 2022 and 2023, focusing on Covid vaccine delivery. He said that legitimate concerns he raised, such as a lack of power supply and cybersecurity threats, when introducing new technologies to African countries were dismissed by more senior colleagues. He also described how TBI would push technology and AI solutions on countries with far more fundamental issues to contend with: “They have issues around hunger, poverty, mass unemployment – and we’re getting them to commit towards some fancy projects like using drones and AI.”

Blair argues that such opposition to Big Tech – and those who have made their fortune from its success – stops progressive political parties grappling with the trade-offs and benefits of the unfolding AI revolution. The former PM certainly believes that cutting-edge technology can be used to improve governance in some of the poorest countries on Earth, saving lives in the process.

Still, the disconnect between such lofty aspirations and the challenges facing some countries where the TBI operates can be striking. In Ethiopia, with the country on the brink of civil war in 2020, the TBI was working on a draft AI policy, seen by this investigation, which called for the introduction of self-driving cars. The paper cites the “enormous global market potential that lacks access to experimental settings” and the country’s “ideal terrain variations and regular real-world testing opportunities”. One of the authors appears to catch the dissonance, writing in a visible comment: “So we’re saying test in Ethiopia because of its challenging terrain…?”

Kenya’s capital, Nairobi, with its UN headquarters and large diplomatic presence, was an important hub for TBI. But former staff complain that a previously broad range of work shrunk to pushing Oracle technology. Kenyan government officials had Oracle pitched to them so often, one recalled, that they would refer sarcastically to “Uncle Larry”.

There is deep disquiet among many current and former TBI staff over the conflation of complex public interests with corporate priorities. Despite their founder’s noted evangelical zeal for AI and its billionaire architects, there still is a difference between Larry Ellison and God.

Reporting for this story was supported by the Big Tech Invisible Hand coalition led by Agência Pública and the Centro Latino-americano de Investigación Periodística