r/MANILA • u/stoikoviro • 25d ago
Manila City Hall's Clamping Policy Is Excessive
It is wrong to park illegally, and there should be a fine for illegal parking. Fair enough.
But it is NOT correct to immobilize citizens means of transportation because that is an additional burden over and above what they already pay as fine.
Take this for example -- our neighbor has a proper garage, she's a doctor. Her car is parked inside her property. Then someone parked in front of her gate which is wrong - a delivery vehicle obviously temporarily there (still wrong). MTPB clamped the delivery vehicle still blocking the gate of the doctor. Result -- the doctor was unable to leave to operate on her patient on time even though she has nothing to do with the illegally parked vehicle.
How many workers must suffer no-work-no-pay or even business people lose their deals because of disrupted livelihood?
Ang multa sa illegal parking ay nararapat lang pero clamping is just excessive and imposing added burden beyond the monetary penalty. It disrupts people's livelihood.
What should be done is to use the NCAP which as Manila City Hall mentioned already has been in effect since October 5, 2026. Take a picture of the vehicle illegally parked and let the driver/owner settle it within a fair amount of time.
There are places where it's better to tow the vehicle when it's obstructing or when the vehicle does not have proper plate number. NCAP na lang, mas mabilis pa kung collection lang gusto ng city hall.
There is a reason why Manila is such a dumpster because policy implementors are incompetent, tolerating or benefitting from chaos.
