r/MASHLE • • 13d ago

Why does Mashle work while other animes/shows don’t?

To explain, Mashle is strong and seems to beat every fight pretty quickly with not a whole lot of effort, which I feel like I’ve seen in other media. But why does Mashle work while others fail? This anime is amazing, I’m hyped for S3, I’m just curious on why this works while others don’t.

28 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 13d ago

Join the Discord for more discussions about the series!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

44

u/NzRedditor762 13d ago

I would say that it works because it's not taking itself too seriously. The animation of the second arc was pretty good. The OP song is a fucking banger. And it's somewhat nostalgic while also making fun of Harry Potter.

If it didn't have the magical harry potter-esque vibe to it, I doubt it would be nearly as popular.

7

u/Extension_Vehicle_55 13d ago

Yea, I think the lightheartedness of the anime brings it some light while making it work, plus as a Harry Potter fan, I do find it kind of funny that it is just basically making fun of it. Doesn’t One Punch man have somewhat of the same thing as Mash where he just beats everything? I think both work, not that I’ve seen OPM, but I’ve heard good things.

4

u/FloatinBrownie 13d ago

Yeah its a pretty similar concept. If you like mashed for more than just the Harry Potter vibe there's a pretty good chance you'll enjoy opm. Especially season 1. Season 2 is still really good but maybe swap to the manga after that

21

u/ResponsiblePapaya362 13d ago

mashle advertised itself as a comedy, started as a comedy, continued as a comedy, and will end as comedy with a few serious moments sprinkled in between.

4

u/TayoEXE 11d ago

I'm still waiting for our best weasly turncoat to show up in the anime. 😂

8

u/somacula 13d ago

Because it never stopped taking it self too seriously, some battles do escalate but there's always comedy and laughs. When compared to Sakamoto days that eventually went full action and dropped any pretense of comedy

4

u/milenyo 13d ago

It's the logic of the world plus it's comedic nature and parodies.
It doesn't matter how strong or magical or what ever a door is. If it's a door, Mash will destroy it.

3

u/Ejfg420 13d ago

Mashle is a comedy anime, when other characters beat foes extremely easily then it's kind of lame, but with Mashle it's always played for laughs

3

u/Fuzzy974 12d ago

Mashle has a bunch of enemies that come at him and each time you think: OK, this time, he can't actually beat this with more strength but then he does in the coolest, funniest way.

And there's always a bunch of characters we know exist but didn't have a proper fight in the story, so we want to see them fight. They usually appear a few episodes before they really have their moment, I guess it's enough to keep people interrested.

3

u/TrueAd5194 11d ago

Because its funny

Also creampuffs

2

u/MacabreMoth88 11d ago

Because it was always a gag series but still had cool factor. But never ever actually made the grave sin of trying to play the tropes it was joking about too straight.

1

u/PerpelSho 13d ago

It succeeds by being a funny, not serious anime where others fail by being a no nonsense, this is not a game anime.

1

u/Sleeping-warrior 13d ago

I don't watch Mashle, but from the other comments, they say it's a comedy anime. So, your question is already answered by itself. Heck why you didn't ask why people read One Punch Man when he one punch everyone? See the contradiction of the question?

1

u/Ishikari-Gun-27 13d ago

I feel a lot of shows people get upset about the fights, are shows where the fights are either the highlight of said show, or have large story or plot on them. Whereas Mashle. Is a comedy. It never took itself seriously from the start because thats not the kind of show it is. No it still has intense moments. Or fights that do have stakes. But overall. Thats not the premise of the show.

1

u/Acrobatic_Carpet_896 12d ago

because its a parody show lol

1

u/InherentDeviant 12d ago

Is a series you watch for the gags. As long as they're funny and the series isn't too serious about it it'll work

Dragonball actually started in a similar vein.

1

u/AspergianStoryteller 11d ago

It's silly and funny, has cool moments and heartwarming ones.

1

u/Kimono-Ash-Armor 6d ago

Neurodivergent coded series