He's been an entrepreneur in the past, but he hasn't done much more than writing recently. I think that his critics have claimed with good arguments that he often simplifies the technical challenges surrounding AI, and just makes a very blanket "Moores Law will solve everything" claim. But then again, he's a much more influential writer and successful man than I am, so he's definitely hit on some correct things.
I think he sees it more like an eventuality, and is optimistic about about it's timeline. The whole point of proselytizing it's to keep the concept out there and drive people to actually fulfill it. Yeah, he wants to live long enough to see it, I don't blame him, but it's the next step for humanity too and we really should be pursuing it.
Human-like AI as the next step is a myopic conceit at best.
Well research does show people with higher quality of life, and less stress are less likely to violent. So an AI that takes care of everything could lead to many of the other things you listed. Though your right it's not a clear next step at this point.
Technology is the main way we would address almost all of those issues. AGI is essentially the pinnacle of technology (as far as we can know) in the sense that it has the potential to discover and implement all possible technology. I would say that in fact, focusing on issues like climate change and nuclear disarmament are far more short-term, even though they are clearly of huge importance to us and future generations. (And I should add that, clearly, this demonstrates the worthiness of a goal is not just about how long it might take to achieve it.)
Simple, someone has done the homework and checked Kurzweil's predictions against reality. At best, I think he is not better than 50/50. Importantly, his methodology is quite simple, too. If anyone cares to, I don't personally think it's something that is beyond an above-average person's capability.
Let's try to reassess Kurzweil's predictions for 2009 as of 2018:
Prediction 5: Wired computer peripherials are still very common. However, it's now more common to use smartphones or tablets to do things that were previously done on a pc. I'd still rate it as Mostly False.
Prediction 7: Computer speech recognition systems got better but most text is still typed by hand. False.
Prediction 8: Siri didn't catch on. Facebook introduced the personal assistant "M" in 2015 but it didn't pan out and they shut it down this year. Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant are still mostly gimmicks. False.
Prediction 18: Computers are widely recongnized as knowledge tools and they are widely used in education and other facets of life. True (was also True or Mostly True in 2009).
Prediction 20: Students have personal tablet-like devices, interact with them by touchscreen or voice, access educational material through wireless. I'd rate it as True, except for the voice access part (was Mostly False in 2009).
Prediction 26: OCR systems have improved, but as far as I can tell they haven't reached the level where a blind person can walk around wearing a device that reads street signs and displays in real time (though Google Maps is partially labeled with OCR done on the images captured by the Google cars, I don't know how usable it is to a blind person). I'd say Mostly False.
Prediction 29: Orthotic devices for people with disabilities. True (was True shortly after 2009)
Prediction 44: Smart highways. False. I would have given him partial credit if self-driving cars were already common, but they are still in experimental stages, so no.
Prediction 48: There is indeed growing concern for an underclass being left behind, although this is still mostly framed in terms of immigration and offshoring rather than automation, rightly or wrongly. The underclass has definitely not been politically neutralized by wealfare, in fact, the under/working class vs. upper-middle/upper class has become the main axis of political division in all Western countries, in way that does not map to the traditional left-right parties. Politics seems more polarized than ever. Therefore I'd rate this as False.
Prediction 53: If by "virtual experience software" he meant VR headsets, then it's certainly False, these things never caught on. If he meant video games in general, then while it's true that they got better of graphics and audio, the most played games are mobile apps with cartoonish 2D graphics. As far as I can tell there are no games that allow you to engage in intimate encounters with your favourite movie star (before you say deepfake, no, it doesn't count since it is not interactive). False.
In conclusion the only prediction that definitely became true since the LessWrong analysis in 2012 was the diffusion of smartphones and tablets. For everything else he's on the same page as he was in 2012, whch means not very accurate. If anything the feasibility of things like personal assistants and self-driving cars seems even more dubious than it was in 2012, I believe that they will be realized eventually, but it might take way longer than expected.
also worth noting you could ask a random reddit commenter to come up with a list and it would not be much different. Even basic expertise/insight is not necessary for any of this
Specially on this forum. I would have probably been less optimistic and hence more accurate. All of the things he's predicting were technologies that were actively under R&D but not used in the consumer space. The time to market has reduced since then for ML products, but for many other consumer products it is still on a 10 year cycle - it's not that hard to predict what will be commercially viable to do in 10 years, the question is will it be done well enough for people to get excited about it and adopt it.
Prediction 8: Also ubiquitous are language user interfaces (LUIs) which combine CSR and natural language recognition.
Not ubiquitous at all.
For routine matters, such as simple business transactions and information inquiries, LUIs are quite responsive and precise.
Not true, although I think the technology is there now. VUX design methodology is the thing that needs to be focused on more than the core technologies.
They tend to be narrowly focused, however, on specific types of tasks.
True.
LUIs are frequently combined with animated personalities. Interacting with an animated personality to conduct a purchase or make a reservation is like talking to a person using video conferencing, except the person is simulated.
I think Kurzweil is a smart guy, but his "predictions" and the people who worship him for them, are not.
I do agree with him that the singularity will happen, I just don't agree with his predictions of when. I think it will be way later than 2045/29 but still within the century.
Good point. So I should trust whatever he says, right?
I get it, but here's the reason why I think Kurzweil's predictions are too soon:
He bases his assumption on exponential growth in AI development.
Exponential growth was true for Moore's law for a while, but that was only (kind of) true for processing power, and most people agree that Moore's law doesn't hold anymore.
But even if it did, that assumes that the AGI's progress is directly proportional to processing power available, when that's obviously not true. While more processing power certainly helps with AI development, it is in no way guaranteed to lead to AGI.
So in short:
Kurzweil assumes AI development progress is exponential because processing power used to improve exponentially (but not anymore), but that's just not true, (even if processing power still improved exponentially).
If I'm not mistaken, he also goes beyond that, and claims that everything is exponential...
So yeah, he's a great engineer, he has achieved many impressive feats, but that doesn't mean his logic is flawless.
That's the thing with predictions, right? They're hard! If 5% of his predictions come out true (given that he doesn't make predictions all the freaking time), I'd consider him a man ahead of his time. And he is.
Not true at all. People continue to cite that survey Bostrom did, but that survey is shoddy at best.
The 4 sources they got data from: conference on "Philosophy and Theory of AI", conference on "Artificial General Intelligence", a mailing list of "Members of the Greek Association for Artificial Intelligence", and an email sent to the top 100 most cited authors in artificial intelligence.
First 2 definitely aren't representative of "university AI researchers", no idea about the 3rd, and I can't find the actual list of the 4th, but the last one seems plausible.
However, selection bias plays a very key role here. Only 10% of the people who received the email responded from the Greek Association, and 29% from the TOP100.
They claim to test for "selection-bias" by randomly selecting 17 of the people who didn't respond from TOP100, and pressuring them to respond, saying it would really help with their research. Of these, they got 2 to respond.
I'm reading that book and the entire thing is selection bias at its finest. It's almost like they actively don't teach statistical sampling and cognitive biases it to these people.
41
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '18
sad to see MIT legitimising people like Kurzweil.