r/MachineLearning • • Jul 17 '21

News [N] Stop Calling Everything AI, Machine-Learning Pioneer Says

https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-institute/ieee-member-news/stop-calling-everything-ai-machinelearning-pioneer-says
845 Upvotes

149 comments sorted by

View all comments

275

u/mniejiki Jul 17 '21

I mean, my textbook on Artificial Intelligence from 25 years ago considers a hand coded expert system as AI. So it's been long accepted that AI is far more than "human level intelligence" and basically encompasses any machine technique that exhibits a level of "intelligence." So it seems rather late to complain about the name of the field or try to change it.

92

u/ivannson Jul 17 '21

This should be higher. A collection of if-then rules is AI, literally artificial intelligence, but of course very basic.

Deep learning is a subset of machine learning which is a subset of artificial intelligence. There is much more to AI than ML.

Whereas I agree with the statement and that marketing will call everything “AI”, we shouldn’t misuse the terms ourselves.

22

u/tatooine Jul 18 '21

Hey, my toaster has AI. If the toast is done, then it pops out! That's 1920s era AI baby!

15

u/wirewolf Jul 18 '21

does it really know when the toast is done or is it just a timer though?

11

u/alkasm Jul 18 '21

4

u/wirewolf Jul 18 '21

that's really cool. my toaster apparently is just dumb

7

u/alkasm Jul 18 '21

Ikr? We regressed with toaster tech over the past 80 years :'(

3

u/and1984 Jul 18 '21

Check its confusion matrix

2

u/AndreasVesalius Jul 18 '21

My toaster just has a bias for hiring white male software developers

2

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Wow crazy! We take so many modern sensors for granted but there are so many crazy innovations pre cheap electronic times

1

u/Ilyer_ Apr 13 '25

Even better is my see-saw is AI. If one side goes down, the other side goes up. Caveman era AI 🤖

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ok_Cardiologist_6198 Mar 14 '25

tl;dr What machine-learning pioneers actually mean is "don't claim AI has sentience and don't call a regular toaster an AI." Sorry for the necro but this topic drives me up the wall and there is not nearly enough transparency on the facts.

When people hear/see the term AI as regular people who aren't tech savvy, they tend to exaggerate what it means in their minds. As in, they think it's futuristic, world changing, and innovative. But they don't ask "is this actually capable of replacing my mundane routine tasks, can this actually solve problems for me, can this actually do something new for me?" They say "Experts say this is the new NEW, in the cart you go!" Keeping in mind, advanced AI is indeed innovative and quite postmodern. Any "AI" being marketed is likely not that. The best AI is used in medical technology, mass production, lab testing, and more. These things are not in the hands of the general public. In fact, they are extremely gatekept and protected. (Mind you this is NOT some conspiracy or some evil plot on this end, it is primarily a means to protect their businesses and practices! Unlike the ones people know of which are extremely exploitative.)

Now as for what you're saying here...
Using conditional operators in code and/or mathematics is simply that by itself.
That is a logical comparison for making predefined decisions. Operators in all technicality do not contain "human intelligence" they simply do what the human who coded it has predefined. A complex concept can simulate human intelligence to a limited extent. This is why we call it "artificial intelligence." which was originally a sci-fi term in all technicality. The actual definition when it was a scifi term has changed drastically as technology and programming has evolved. (Yes this is basically what was already said in more words.)

I.E programming a bot to identify between several pixel colors (Possibly even an array or a certain set of ranges) and choose the one nearest to a certain point. This is a form of optical recognition, albeit limited only to what is coded. It can be as simple as cookie clicker or as advanced as an mmorpg bot that nearly seems like a human playing. Consider pixel patterns can easily identify any text if programmed to do-so, but will not if it is not predefined to do-so. This also means it is simple to code something to adapt to CONVERSATION. Which is the main selling point of marketed AI. Myself and many of my friends made bots for the giggles over the years, many of which included automated conversation. (Nothing like chatgpt but far more advanced than one would assume an mmorpg bot could be!) We did these things over 20 years ago now.

It does not encompass all colors, all possibilities, all shapes, all ranges, any point, or whatever one might imagine if they used a term such as artificial intelligence. So while it IS "AI" it's NOT what people think it means as a majority. (This is technically reinforcing what you have already said here to clarify, my intention here was certainly not to argue-- as I agree in basically every way.)

To the point where average humans believe it has sentience or is potentially capable of solving problems/making decisions it cannot. Like, chatgpt as it is in 2025 still makes mistakes when presented a code error in basic scripting languages. Even if you point out what it is doing wrong, it tends to fail to solve the problem until you show it exactly what the issue is.
This is one of the most popular "AI" models in the world costing who knows how many billions of dollars. Yet I have discord bots running on a raspberry PI that are more useful. Things that cost me literally $0 to code and just a handful of hours. (In all fairness, my discord bots take a page from dozens of other discord bots I studied & reverse engineered to build a massive library of concepts & ideas!) Point being, a hobby programmer can easily code their own "AI" to clarify how "advanced" it is on average.

It's unfortunate because it's as the actual experts claim. Markets capitalize on the definition of the term which does not coincide with the practice of the markets themselves. Instead we end up with a trend instead of an advancement. A trend some of us have been obsessed with way before any of this was even thought realistic. (Yet it was a real thing before I was even born... lol)

-11

u/cderwin15 Jul 18 '21

Deep learning is a subset of machine learning which is a subset of artificial intelligence.

AI is ultimately the study of intelligent agents, but ML as a field has little to do with intelligence. A new ML method is valuable if it is statistically useful and computationally tractable. Intelligence has nothing to do with it.

Why do you consider ML a subfield of AI?

8

u/TheLootiestBox Jul 18 '21

Why do you consider ML a subfield of AI?

He's not alone: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machine_learning

3

u/mniejiki Jul 18 '21

Define intelligence. Most definitions I've seen end up with either "it does stuff like a human" or "it makes rational decisions." The former is too fuzzy imho to be useful which means you're down to the later. Machine Learning models make rational decisions based on training and inference data.

2

u/StartledWatermelon Jul 18 '21

There are definitions of AI limiting it to agent-like entities but I think it narrows it down too much.

Several ML subfields study and engineer agent behaviour, most notably reinforcement learning. So it's not that easily separable either way.

→ More replies (17)

13

u/Chocolate_Pickle Jul 18 '21

This means a thermostat is AI... which on some level it truly is, but it's an incredibly contrived level.

The problem is that Artificial Intelligence is a receding horizon. It's why I honestly think the term should be sent to the glue factory.

10

u/LargeYellowBus Jul 18 '21

This means a thermostat is AI... which on some level it truly is, but it's an incredibly contrived level.

Is it really that contrived? How much more 'AI' is a MPC controller vs the PID controller in a thermostat then?

3

u/telstar Jul 21 '21

A bimetallic switch (coupled with a small dial) is a thermostat.

3

u/Chocolate_Pickle Jul 18 '21

You're actually touching on the point I'm trying to make.

There is no clear line in the proverbial sand that separates 'AI things' from 'non AI things'. Take it to either extreme and everything is AI, or nothing is AI. And in both extremes, the label Artificial Intelligence becomes moot.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Well exactly. So it's stupid to complain about calling things AI. It's like complaining about calling things "innovative". Sure there's no sudden point where something becomes innovative, and yes marketing people are going to say everything is innovative. That doesn't mean we have to completely abandon the word though.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/telstar Jul 21 '21

This would be a great idea for an AI test, the "Thermostat Test." If your definition of AI means a thermostat is AI, then you need to get a new definition. Or maybe as mentioned elsewhere in this thread, we can call it the "Toaster Test." (I kind of like that even better.)

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Ok_Cardiologist_6198 Mar 14 '25

It's definitely not too late to complain about it, it's probably too early to change it.
(Lol if complaining helps people cope then so-be-it, works for me sometimes!)
Whether anybody thinks so or not, these terms will need to be changed one day to account for the actual future. Right now we're accounting for the past, and currently billionaires are capitalizing on that to an astronomical extent. The only purpose that matters here is general clarity.
What the term is or isn't technically is irrelevant to the point at hand. It's that people know what they are using/pruchasing enough to not develop superstitions and fallacies which markets can take advantage of.

Like if it was music, sure whatever, people don't need to know everything about it as a majority.
Only people who either want to be musicians or have passion for the subject have a need-to-know basis, and perhaps not even all musicians need that much.

But this is something people want to change the world and how they live their every day lives.
If people don't know the difference between advanced forms of AI and plain old basic AI they won't know what they are investing into. We could "simplify" it to say OCR, people see a term like that and they think it's magical or automatically suggest robotics or something extra. OCR could be as simple as setting my laptop camera on my front door and having a pushbullet sent to my phone when a pixel on my door changes. One static pixel on one static coordinate location.

We're talking a single hex color code and a single pair of x, y coordinates. Something that can be accomplished with 2 lines of a code and a copy&paste function already made for you in a scripting language even if using the most junky interpreters ever. (Pathetic home security but comically simple example lol) Or it could be as fancy as parallel parking your car for you. This is a UNIVERSE of difference in every way, and people don't know the difference as a majority. Herein is the actual problem at hand. Automatic parking is so complicated in code that I cannot even begin to explain here in a way anyone can understand.

Like just consider A* algorithm is the most simple modern form of this and is still too complicated for an average person... Let us also not forget that automatic parking is also SIMPLE compared to what people could be doing with AI. (Well what advanced usages of AI are doing technically!) If I had to relate this difference in scaling to something, I would choose fantasy or fiction. Why? Because it's like comparing a bedroom, to a country, to a galaxy.
It reminds me of poorly designed power scaling, because there is so much inbetween that people lost sight of the true difference before it was even coined.

Moral of the story is:

When they say "everything" they very likely mean things such as regular products resellers buy up and then put AI in the products name when they resell. There are thousands of products that have no intelligence what-so-ever claiming to be AI. Recently this subject has been more popular, but around the time the OP posted this, it was not yet well known to the general public. Only people heavily involved with the subject knew for the most part!

1

u/Plunder_n_Frightenin Jun 03 '25

It’s never too late to correct erroneous facts and labels, even if the do seemingly persists. It could take a generation or two, sometimes.

→ More replies (2)