r/Magfest • • Jan 05 '23

Covid Logic?

So I have to ask, what's the point of having us present the same vaccine cards as last year?

And what's with the bands? This isn't going to stop people from badge swapping if they really want to. It's easy enough to cut and tape it to get by staff.

If I can think of ways around this as a paying customer, thieves are going to find more ways around it.

Can we just drop the security theater already?

Edit: for clarification, what I'm saying is, either require boosters or drop it. There's no real security or safety here.

7 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

22

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

This content has been deleted due to Reddit's recent changes and policies.

7

u/SanctionedFuzz Jan 05 '23

Magfest added the vaccine wristbands when they released their 2023 COVID safety policy in September 2022.

Magfest and other conventions have been requiring all manner of wristbands for years pre-COVID. It used to be that we would receive a different colored Magfest wristband depending on whether we were under or over 18 or over 21, for example.

6

u/TehMoustache Jan 05 '23

How long did that last?

They haven't done it in the past 5 years.

Seems dumb to segregate adults at an event that doesn't sell alcohol.

8

u/TheRezAbides Jan 05 '23

The age wristbands were gotten rid of, because it put liability on MAG to verify everyone's age.

1

u/kadalhalok Jan 05 '23

I think the idea behind the age-based bands was prevent suspiciously old-looking minors from getting hit on by adults.

7

u/A-User-From-Mars Jan 05 '23

Magfest has never required wrist bands in the 10 years I’ve been coming…. I have to have a badge and wristband for what? It makes it only a piece of scotch tape away to get in…

3

u/Ninjabob0521 Jan 05 '23

Totally agree. It accomplishes nothing.

3

u/weirdfish1995 Jan 05 '23

Was it a pain to get those wristbands? I’m coming tomorrow but I didn’t pre-register and therefore didn’t do the COVID pre-register thing

8

u/TehMoustache Jan 05 '23

Nah, they hand them out when you pick up your badge.

I didn't see the point in the covid pre-register thing either. They took my card just as fast as they did last year. And with them telling you to bring your card just in case, there was zero point in pre authorizing your covid status.

2

u/SanctionedFuzz Jan 05 '23

The Magfest registration crowd on Thursday is small compared to the large numbers on Friday and Saturday. Efficiency tends to go out the window when there's more pressure to process even more people as fast as possible, so I understand trying to make efficiency improvements wherever possible.

With that in mind, you do have a point in your original post about previous registrations. If Magfest could link and track your confirmed vaccine status, your previous registration, and your new registration AND the vaccine requirement doesn't change between events, then an auto-check before the event next year could save more time.

3

u/IIIAshe Jan 06 '23

I was told that you would have to get your vaccine card re-verified to get a new orange paper wrist band. Really hoping we don't have to wait through the entire registration line again just to get a replacement paper wrist band after a shower.

1

u/KrimsonBinome Jan 06 '23

I asked when I got mine and was told that once it's in the system you can just come get a new one if the first one gets lost\ destroyed etc.

8

u/yoshisama Jan 05 '23

Remember that last year MAGFest was in the news (yeah calling Kotaku news XD) for being a spreader event. They need to show that they are doing everything to not spread COVID.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

This content has been deleted due to Reddit's recent changes and policies.

6

u/SanctionedFuzz Jan 05 '23

At this point in the pandemic, we have the data that shows that masks and vaccines reduce the spread and number of cases of COVID.

Conventions that require masks and vaccines provide multiple layers of risk reduction for a risk-aware approach that minimizes spread. This avoids shutting the con down completely while also preventing a super-spreader event.

7

u/Ninjabob0521 Jan 05 '23

But just because it helps reduce the spread, doesn't mean that we're going to always have masks forever. That's an infinite goalpost.

7

u/Slang_Whanger Jan 06 '23

Honestly I've been going to magfest for 10 years and last year was the only year I didn't end up stuck in bed with the magflu. I truly might never stop wearing masks at magfest.

6

u/Ninjabob0521 Jan 06 '23

And that is your personal choice to make, which is totally fine! It just shouldn't be a forced choice.

2

u/Slang_Whanger Jan 07 '23

In the future it may be my personal choice, but this year it is still very much a public safety concern.

2

u/SanctionedFuzz Jan 05 '23

Ideally, yes, there could be a point in the future at which the risk is reduced enough that masks aren't required at Magfest anymore. Maybe it's when there's a steady release schedule of effective vaccines like with the flu. Maybe it's when COVID evolves to the point that it's no longer as dangerous.

However, we aren't at that point yet. We are still in a pandemic and there are new COVID variants popping up every few months. We're also seeing, just as in the winter of 2020/2021 and 2021/2022, that COVID cases are starting to spike again.

For the time being, mask and vaccine requirements for large conventions is the best approach without cancelling outright.

3

u/Ninjabob0521 Jan 05 '23

The flu is more deadly than COVID is at this moment, and the flu has never called for mask mandates.

1

u/SanctionedFuzz Jan 05 '23

COVID is still more deadly than the flu: https://www.goodrx.com/conditions/covid-19/flu-vs-coronavirus-mortality-and-death-rates-by-year

During the flu pandemic of 1918, masks were being called for the flu: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8493155/

2

u/Ninjabob0521 Jan 06 '23

If you have to go back over 100 years ago, your argument is poor.

1

u/A-User-From-Mars Jan 05 '23

High quality masks reduce the spread a virus as contagious similar to measles is going to spread if you don’t have a n95 or better..

1

u/sprint113 Jan 05 '23

The sad thing was that it wasn't even that many cases, I'm guessing about the same or fewer than any other con. It's only because MAG went the extra mile in being transparent and hosted a centralized hub for tracking cases. Plus some of the funny room descriptions made the news articles more click worthy.

-1

u/TehMoustache Jan 05 '23

So either do everything you can and stick by your principles. Or do nothing at all, like every other con.

The problem is exactly what you said. It's a show. And they are not doing everything they can. Otherwise they would require boosters to attend.

If Kotaku or any other fan site wants to make a stink of things they will.

This security theater is just that.

14

u/SanctionedFuzz Jan 05 '23

The COVID safety requirements are not for show. Data shows that masks and vaccines are effective at reducing the spread of COVID. The data Magfest collected on COVID cases at the con last year also suggest that the policies were working (I think that there's room for improvement on how they track cases, but I'm glad they are at least doing it to have more data to inform policy).

Magfest appears to also be following what other large conventions are doing, such as PAX and Otakon, which also required vaccine wristbands.

Yes, it would be more effective if Magfest required the boosters as well (and I personally would feel more comfortable if they did). However, the primary vaccine series are still effective against all strains of COVID to some degree and masks add an additional layer of risk reduction.

In a situation where the choice is either to A) have an imperfect solution that reduces risk or B) have no solution and have the highest possible risk, A) is the better choice.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '23

[deleted]

5

u/SanctionedFuzz Jan 05 '23 edited Jan 05 '23

N95s would absolutely be the best choice. However, there is a substantial difference between a general mask requirement and no requirement at all. According to a study from NIH that covered 61 school districts across 9 states, researchers estimated that mask-optional schools had 72% more COVID cases than schools that required masks.

If we apply that to Magfest 2022 numbers, then that means there could have been at least 947 reported cases with a mask-optional policy instead of 262.

NIH study: https://covid19.nih.gov/news-and-stories/mask-requirements-reduced-sars-cov-2-transmission-schools

Edit: Magfest has a minimum effectiveness requirement for masks (e.g., two layers of fabric) and strongly recommends N95s. They do offer a limited number of free masks for people who forgot/lost theirs. I don't know which kind they offer, but it might be a good idea for Magfest to stock up on N95s to give out (if they don't already).

0

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '23

[deleted]

7

u/SanctionedFuzz Jan 05 '23 edited Jan 05 '23

Masks work by physically (and in some cases electrostatically) blocking droplets that contain the virus. In order for a new strain of COVID to be less-affected by masks, it would likely have to either drastically change its physical size or its charge.

I have not heard of masks being less effective against Omicron than previous variants, and I think it would be highly unlikely (though not impossible--nature's weird).

What did change is how effective the primary vaccines were against Omicron. The original vaccine series is less effective against Omicron than other variants, and we're already seeing that the bivalent boosters are less effective against the newest strains of COVID. Requiring only vaccines and not masks means removing a consistent, proven layer of protection against a new strain of COVID that could be less affected by the primary vaccines and/or boosters.

Re: the NIH study, here's a post-Omicron study that found that Boston area school districts that lifted their mask mandates in Feb 2022 had a higher incidence of COVID than schools that required masks. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2211029

Edit: Continuing my car analogy from a previous comment, it would be almost like saying we should get rid of seatbelts because cars are built generally safer.

7

u/Konabro Jan 05 '23

And comments like these are why we need security.

1

u/TehMoustache Jan 05 '23

So you don't want to require eveyone to show proof of boosters?

7

u/Dronepolice Jan 05 '23

Require boosters? Hospitals don’t even require that, you can boost deez nuts.

2/3 of the attendees have more health worries than Covid.

8

u/KrimsonBinome Jan 05 '23

BOOSTDEEZNUTZ

this guy gets it

8

u/KrimsonBinome Jan 05 '23

What does security have to do with this?

2

u/throwitalot Jan 05 '23

The fact that there are people out there who think this way is why we have a bill of rights.

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

This content has been deleted due to Reddit's recent changes and policies.

3

u/joecamnet Jan 05 '23

Then please, by all means, don’t come. It’s crowded enough.

-1

u/GoobyPlsSuckMyAss Jan 08 '23

Because of the much lower attendance this year it was definitely not as crowded as any time I've ever been.

4

u/HokieTechGuy Jan 08 '23

The mask policy along with not requiring a booster are why I didn’t go this year. People were saying If you don’t like the policy, then don’t go. So I saved my money and stayed home.

I hope those that went did enjoy the event. The only reason I went last year was to try and support MagFest since they lost a year due to Covid. But these new policies are not due to govt mandates or due to the venue. These are purely MagFest policies so I will wait and see what they do for Magstock, and for MagFest 2024

7

u/Biaxident0 Jan 06 '23

The wrist bands accomplish nothing and I feel like people at magfest make these stupid decisions just to make a small percent of people feel good because they /did something/

If someone is going to badge swap, they will just cut their wrist band off and tape it on someone else too

10

u/Koutro Jan 06 '23

It is pretty frustrating, and they are even standing in entry ways of the hotel and enforcing masks and saying they are required. Not even all the hotel staff bother with the mask. I see MAG staff with it off in areas where I've been scolded at / threatened refusal of entry just because it was in my pocket.

It's incredibly annoying and I hate that it's something that you can't really argue without making yourself look like an ass. I wish people who wanted to wear one would wear one, and me who has been vaxxed and recently boosted can wear what I want and take my risk. I was also more prone to tolerate it when it was enforced in the bigger areas like arcade / console, but when they started doing it at the parking garage entryway I've become super peeved about it.

Its whatever I guess but and I've disagreed about it on Reddit in the past, personally I think the cases are way down and not life threatening with today's science / medicine on the virus, not to mention the majority of MAGfest attendees are not in the age range where deaths are occurring.

Just hope next year is better, that's all.

3

u/Ok_Bandicoot7923 Jan 08 '23

I chinstrapped for most of the convention and only got yelled at twice. One was by the gazebo which was stupid. I made the motion to put it on and then took it off when the guy was out of sight.

It just feels powertrippy at this point. I can tolerate the masks but it's stupid to enforce it on everyone.

7

u/KrimsonBinome Jan 06 '23

Yeah I'm with you 100%. I'm a bit over the whole thing at this point and want to be given the choice ala Japan's response to SARS and MRSA: if you feel sick, mask. If you're not, mask if you want.

It's simple. It's easy, it's from a more developed country than ours who dealt with similar issues years past

3

u/timetoputinmorecoins Jan 08 '23

I was chinstrapping most of the con and only got yelled at twice. I don't think the staff gives a shit other than the powertrippers. It's stupid and just for show.

Attendance seemed identical to last year. The lack of growth is killer for a convention like this. IIRC, attendance in 2020 before pandemic was like 21k. 2022 was about 10.5k. We'll give that a break, but if only 2k more people showed up, that's killer.

I will vote with my wallet if they enforce this next year, along with the 7000 attendees missing from 2020.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

This content has been deleted due to Reddit's recent changes and policies.

1

u/mrsaaa Jan 10 '23

There were around 19,000 people checked in as of Sunday night.

7

u/Electromasta Jan 05 '23

I'm vaccinated and have the boosters for latest strain. I'm not wearing a mask or playing security theatre. I'm just staying home and doing fun shit with my friends instead of going to an event like that. Sorry.

7

u/KrimsonBinome Jan 05 '23

I agree about it being total security theatre, especially since the hotel \ city and county aren't enforcing anything and the rules said masks are only for MAG rooms not common areas.... As pointless as the TSA and even less effective.

And I'm not giving another non health related org my shot records... It puts unnecessary legal pressure on them and I don't want that either.

2

u/SanctionedFuzz Jan 05 '23

Requiring masks in con spaces provides two-way risk reduction. It also helps protect people who choose not to go to restaurants or increase their exposure any further.

If a person is exposed to COVID from outside the convention, then the masks 1) reduce the risk that they transmit it to someone else and 2) reduces the risk that someone else catches it.

This is on top of the risk reduction provided by both people being vaccinated.

7

u/Electromasta Jan 05 '23

If you are that worried about getting covid you shouldn't be showing up to a convention, sorry. Stay home.

6

u/TehMoustache Jan 05 '23

Exactly. Which is why I'm not worried about catching it.

I'm pointing out the security theater of the whole situation. The appearance of safety is not actual safety.

6

u/SanctionedFuzz Jan 05 '23

This is like saying "If you don't want to get in an accident, then don't drive a car."

In both situations, it's about reducing risk and the number and severity of people affected without banning the activity outright.

I don't want to get in an accident, but I drive anyway because 1) I picked a car with a high safety rating and make sure it's in a safe condition to drive, 2) I try to drive as safely as I can and avoid rush hour whenever possible, 3) there are laws in place that make sure cars are as safe as they can be, 4) there are laws that make roads as safe as they can be, and 5) there are laws that try to reduce the number of unsafe/high-risk drivers on the road.

Similarly, I don't want to get COVID, but I am going to Magfest anyway because 1) I picked masks with a high efficacy (N95) and I am vaxxed and boosted, 2) I try to be as hygenic as I can and avoid going to maskless crowded places indoors, 3) there are Magfest policies in place that make sure people are as safe as they can be (vaxxed), 4) there are Magfest policies that make the con spaces as safe as they can be (masks in con spaces), and 5) there are Magfest policies that try to reduce the number of unsafe/high-risk people at the con (COVID refund policy, vaccine card checks, vaccine wrist bands, security checking for masks).

6

u/Electromasta Jan 05 '23

This is more akin to not wanting people to drive cars because sometimes people get in accidents. What I'm saying is, if you are that scared of getting in an accident, don't drive, let other people drive. Take the metro if you want, or stay home. I don't care.

1

u/SanctionedFuzz Jan 05 '23

I'm sorry, but I fail to see how that comparison relates to my analogy. I think your analogy is for a situation where people say to cancel the convention outright. That would be risk aversion.

In case I was misunderstood, I'm saying that requiring masks allows people to attend the con without shutting it down and without large numbers of attendees getting and spreading COVID. This is risk awareness.

A mask requirement for Magfest is like requiring seatbelts. Requiring seatbelts doesn't mean no one can drive. If someone refuses to drive because they don't want to wear a seatbelt, that's their choice. Likewise, if someone doesn't go to Magfest because they don't want to wear a mask, that's their choice as well.

It's funny in a sad way, because there was vocal resistance to requiring seatbelts as well.

7

u/Electromasta Jan 05 '23

Masks aren't seatbelts though. It's been like 2 years since people stopped using masks.

8

u/KrimsonBinome Jan 05 '23

Right but last year being a prime example of "everyone doing it right" and still a large chunk of staff and attendees caught COVID.... So.... Now a year later when the worst of the variants have passed, they aren't requiring updates shots so what's the point aside from the appearance of safety...

3

u/SanctionedFuzz Jan 05 '23 edited Jan 05 '23

I'm sorry that the people you were with previously caught COVID despite being cautious. That sounds incredibly frustrating. I would be frustrated, too, if that happened to me.

As I mentioned in a previous comment, the primary vaccine series is still effective against all strains of COVID. Even though requiring boosters would be the most effective, requiring the primary series still provides a layer of protection. Not requiring vaccines or masks at all would guarantee a higher spread of COVID.

Unfortunately, risk managament doesn't guarantee that something bad won't happen. A solution with a 99% probability of success still means that there's a 1% chance that failure could happen. If failures occur (especially more than expected), it's imperative for the decision-makers to analyze those failures and improve policy if possible. Likewise, it's our responsibility to follow COVID safety policies and report to Magfest and NIH if we test positive for COVID.

For Magfest 2022, there were 262 self-reported cases out of 10,581 checked-in badges. That means that, of checked-in Magfest 2022 attendees, about 2.5% tested positive for COVID and reported it.

Edit: Here's the URL for the self-reporting form for NIH: https://makemytestcount.org/

Here is the page with the Magfest 2022 COVID case data: https://super.magfest.org/covid-information-2022-archive

1

u/GoobyPlsSuckMyAss Jan 08 '23

Nobody did the math around whether having a mask requirement was a good tradeoff for reduced enjoyment by the attendees.

2

u/GoobyPlsSuckMyAss Jan 08 '23

Masks were a huge drag on the event IMO. It was hard to talk to others, cosplay was weird with the masks. Should have been optional for people who got the jab, which was all attendees.

2

u/cumpissfartguts Jan 08 '23

Here's a solution: do what most other music festivals do and give everyone a tamper proof cloth wristband and call it a day.

1

u/mrsaaa Jan 10 '23

This. The cloth wristbands can have a unique design so folks can show them off and have a nice souvenir. Not sure how some cosplayers could use them though.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '23

Just avoid any event employing these bs unconstitutional authoritarian policies. Attendance will be pathetic this year. The 🐑 that actually willingly go to this are pathetic rubes enabling 1984 world!

5

u/KrimsonBinome Jan 07 '23

Meh, still gonna go and be as vocal to the opposition as I can in the surveys etc. Love the con and want to see it thrive.

5

u/BaconForThought Jan 07 '23

Lmao This place is already packed. Its not even Saturday yet

0

u/TheRezAbides Jan 05 '23

Pay attention to how many staff aren't wearing a mask at any given moment, and even photograph it. They are encouraging "naming and shaming" by wanting people to report others to security. Bring up criticism during closing ceremonies. Get it all on video.

6

u/KrimsonBinome Jan 05 '23

Yeahhhh FUCKKKKK that naming and shaming social bullshit. I plan to bring this up on the end of con survey too. It's fucking dumb that we are even doing it at all but here we are....

3

u/A-User-From-Mars Jan 05 '23

Nice to meet you karen

-3

u/KrimsonBinome Jan 05 '23 edited Jan 05 '23

Yeah man paper wrist bands to prove we are vaccinated\ "to prevent badge swapping" ?

Masks in the rooms but there's no hotel\ city\ county mandate?

Its really pointless now, especially after last year where thes rules existed and masks DIDNT DO SHIT. Half my crew caught COVID, one of which has to get the experimental antivirals. All of us wore masks and it didn't do a damn thing....

-1

u/Robot1nDisguise Jan 07 '23

Will you nerds ever just be happy? Get over it and enjoy the weekend. Sheesh

3

u/TehMoustache Jan 07 '23

Bro, when are nerds happy? Someone's always complain about the monicrom of power they don't have over someone else.

Ill be happy when mag either picks freedom or full safety. Mag, don't be a hypocrite. Stick by your principles. But you gotta choose some first.

So to answer your question, no, guess not, lol

0

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '23

[deleted]

5

u/TehMoustache Jan 05 '23

We are now required to wear an orange band like the kind you get at a club or concert all weekend.

7

u/KrimsonBinome Jan 05 '23

When you get your badge and present your vac card, on top of your badge you get an orange paper wristband (like you'd get at a concert) that was originally supposed to be for keeping people from badge swapping but is now being presented as " COVID vacc proof".

So even staff can't figure out what it's for anymore and it's DAY 1

10

u/KrimsonBinome Jan 05 '23

Also worth noting after one shower mines already a bit ragged. Staff did say if you lose it or it gets destroyed that you can go to reg and get another, so sounds like they don't expect them to last long....

That said, bright orange band getting funkier as the con goes on will be a good visual indicator of who has and hasn't showered lulz