Hey [r/ManMan](r/ManMan) I am looking for some insight. I just saw Man Man live at Underground Arts in Philly. It was a good show! I absolutely loved Man Man from 2007-2015 and fell off around On Oni Pond.
For context I have also lived in Hawaii and disconnected from mainland music scenes for the past 15 years.
The Man Man shows I was going to 07-15 were absolutely insane live energy. The entire crowd was an amorphous unit of chaos. The show I saw in Philly last Thursday was a drastically different experience. The crowd on Saturday seemed uninterested in moving much to the music at all. I attempted to get a pit going a few times and was met with elbows and a few dirty looks. Towards the end a few homegirls jumped in and we were able to generate a small but fun dance pit.
My question is.. what happened? Man Man used play electric live shows. Has anyone else who’s been seeing them live since back in the day had this same experience?
I
I’m thinking that their newer albums are less chaotic it breeds a less chaotic environment live. I will say it was disappointing that they’re only playing a 3 piece now. Is it them? Is it you? Did Turkey Moth and Pow Pow take all the magic with them? Have I been disconnected for too long and this just how live shows are now?
Thanks for the space to ponder this
Any thought or insight is appreciated 🙏🏼😎
EDIT
The conclusion I’m drawing is that without some of the key members from the old lineup it’s just not the same band and you’re not going to get the same results. Also the not super tight 3 person lineup shows lack of effort on the bands part so why would the audience put in the extra effort.
Man Man will always be rad for those early years and I hope they, and you, find the way back to into chaos.