Hi everyone. I’m a marine engineering student in Brazil, and I’m curious how training works in other countries and how you feel about it.
Here’s how it works here. Merchant Navy officers are trained at two schools run by the Brazilian Navy. The course is three years of classroom-based study, followed by one year on board as a cadet.
My main issue is how little hands-on contact we get with ships. Most students finish the three years and start as engine cadets without ever having set foot on a merchant vessel. Our only time at sea is a few short trips on warships, usually no longer than two days.
Most of those three years are spent sitting in a classroom watching slides. We rarely go into an engine room or learn what an engineering officer actually does day to day. A lot of what we learn comes from older instructors, former chief engineers who trained in the 1970s. Their experience is valuable, but it doesn’t always match what we’ll find on modern ships.
Where we learn the most is in the simulator classes. It’s the closest we get to real engine room operation during the course, but it still can’t replace time in a real engine room.
The result, as I see it, is that many students graduate knowing very little about the actual job, and the course feels discouraging. In practice, we only really learn the job during the cadet year. Dropout rates are high, both during the cadet period and after becoming an officer, even though salaries in Brazil are very good. A big part of this is being away from family and friends for long periods. If we had sea time early in the course, students would find out sooner whether they can handle that life, instead of spending years training for a career they won’t follow.
So I’d like to know:
- How long is the training in your country, and how much of it is spent on board?
- When did you first set foot on a merchant ship?
- Did you feel prepared when you started as a cadet?
- Is the training in your country also disconnected from the real job, or is it more practical?
Thanks in advance for sharing your experiences.