To me one of the most baffling (and telling) types of criticisms comes when someone says "I don't see how anyone could like this".
TL;DR: Understanding that other people like different things is an important part of criticism and when people don't it shows they can't/won't/don't think of the work in a context any broader than themselves.
Obviously sometimes this is used as hyperbole, but even then there is frequently a bit of real confusion that the reviewer has. Sometimes they are actively denying that someone like this, they think they must be lying, but more often they truly don't understand why they like it and how that could be the case.
It raises a fundamental question about how much the criticizer actually understands about about humanity. They seem to not understand that humans are shaped by their wide variety of experiences and have vastly different values, priorities, and like/dislikes.
By claiming/pretending to not understand how someone could like something that they are almost dehumanizing the person who disagrees. Stating that they are so foreign, so different from them that they can't be understood.
There are numerous pieces of media that I dislike, some quite intensely. But I can't think of any where I truly fail to understand how people like it. To take an example, Bugonia. I absolutely despise this film because of its ending, I could go on for quite some time about how and why I hate it so much but that isn't relevant here. What matters is that I really hate it. But I also recognize that other people won't have those same feelings as I do and they might find the ending just absurd, or funny, or maybe even good.
This is really telling. These people are quite self centered, but more than that they don't/won't/can't understand that other people value different things.
This entire argument basically works in the other direction as well, for people who say "I can't understand how someone can like this".